High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20645/2017dismissed

Punjab State Cooperative Supply And Marketing Federation Chd v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2017-11-01Mr. Justice Amit Rawal4 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'()#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#, - - - - .# /'0!+ "!"# 1#,!"%)# /1123 !'4 5!,6#"%'7 #4#,!"%'- .!'4%7!,. #"%"%'#, 8& "!"# /'0!+!'4".#,& #&1'4#'"& 5( 5( 5( 5(9 :5 ;;5 9 :5 ;;5 9 :5 ;;5 9 :5 ;;5 ,#&#'"( 5,;!,!'0%"%'7.-4)$!"#-

,".#1#"%"%'#, ;;5 - <:= ;;5 - <:= ;;5 - <:= ;;5 - <:= .# 1#"%"%'#, .!& $.!22#'7#4 ".# )!2%4%"3 ".# ,4#,& 4!"#4

<''#>/,# ?= 1!&&#4 +3 ,#&1'4#'" - ? @ <''#>/,#=1!&&#4+3,#&1'4#'"!'4 <''#>/,#?= 1!&&#4+3,#&1'4#'"? .# +,%# !$"& !,# ".!" ,#&1'4#'" B#,# 1&"#4 !"

,!'$.

%$#- !7,!'!&&&%&"!'",#*!'!'44/,%'7".#3#!,@@ @"".!""%*#1!443B!&1/,$.!&#4!'4&",#4+3,#&1'4#'" !'4 '# !.%!- ".# ".#' !'4

? +!7& $**' )!,%#"3 !'4

? +!7& %'# )!,%#"3 1!443 B#,# &",#4 %' ".#%, $/&"43 !'4 %'&",/$"%'& B#,# %&&/#4 " ".#* " 7#" ".# 1!443 *%22#4 23%'7 %' ".#%, $/&"43B%".".#&"$6 0%'"$/&"43B.%$.".#3 !%2#4"7#"*%22#4%' "%*#/+&#C/#'"23-".#&!%41!443B!&*%22#4'!$"/!2B#%7."+!&%&!'4! &.,"!7# @?D

C/%'"!2&%'$**')!,%#"3!'4 C/%'"!2& %'# )!,%#"3 1!443 B!& /'4 ". ,#&1'4#'"& $'

%,*#4 ".# &.,"!7#+3&%7'%'7".#5!'48,#1,"!'4!&&/$.".#3.!4$!/&#4

2&&"".#1#"%"%'#,E5!,6 #4"%&!22#7#4".!"".#3B#,#$.!,7#&.##"#4 , $!/&%'7 ".# &!%4 2&& !'4 %' !' #'C/%,3 ".#3 B#,# %'4%$"#4- B.%$. B!& !$$#1"#4+3".#5 5!,6 #4!'4+".,#&1'4#'"& A B#,#*!4# 2%!+2#"1!3@- - @E< -?- D?E!&1,%'$%1!2!*/'"!'4?-D- E !&%'"#,#&"FG1#,!''/*='!$$/'" 2&&&/

#,#4+3".#5!,6 #4 .# 1#"%"%'#, ".#' %2#4 !,+%",!"%' $!&# /'4#, #$"%'&

".# /'0!+ 1#,!"%)# $%#"%#& $"- @ H , &.," I".# $"9J +# ,# ".#

#1/"3 #7%&",!,- 1#,!"%)# $%#"%#&- :/4.%!'! , ".# 1/,1&# ,#$)#,%'7".#!*/'"B#)#,-".#&!%4!,+%",!"%'$!&#B!&4%&*%&&#4' @ .# &!%4 ,4#, B!& /,".#, $.!22#'7#4 %' !11#!2 %2#4 /'4#, #$"%' D ".# $" +# ,# ".# %'" #7%&",!,- 1#,!"%)# $%#"%#&- !"%!2! %)%&%'- !"%!2! !

"#, ! 4#2!3 "B 3#!,& !& %" B!& %2#4 ' @ .# &!%4 !11#!2 B!& 4%&*%&&#4 , ''!11#!,!'$# ".# 1#"%"%'#,' .#1#"%"%'#, %2#4!'!112%$!"%' ,,#&",!"%' ".#!11#!2!22#7#423+37%)%'7B,'7 !$"&' ?.#&!%4!112%$!"%' B!&,#"/,'#4'".#&!*#4!3+/"%"B!&!7!%' %2#4' ? .#&!%4 !112%$!"%'B!&4%&*%&&#4'?@ !&!,#&/2"".#,# -".#!11#!2B!& !2&4%&*%&&#4.#1#"%"%'#,".#' %2#4,#)%&%'/'4#,#$"%' @ ".# $"+# ,#".##7%&",!,<5!'!7#*#'"=-1#,!"%)#$%#"%#&-/'0!+! "#, !1#,%4 "B3#!,&.#&!%4,#)%&%'B!&!2&4%&*%&&#4)%4#,4#,4!"#4

:#!,'#4$/'&#2 ,".#1#"%"%'#,.!& !%2#4"*!6#/"!$!&# %',4#,"#>12!%'".#2!1&#'".#1!," 5!,6 #4!"#)#,3&"!7#!

"#,".# ,4#, B!& 1!&&#4 +3 ".# #1/"3 #7%&",!, ' %' !)/, ,#&1'4#'"& - B. .!11#' " +# ".# ,*#, #*123##& ".# 5!,6 #4!'4B#,#*!4#2%!+2#"1!3!'!*/'" @- - @E

? "#,.#!,%'72#!,'#4$/'&#2 ,".#1#"%"%'#,!'4#>!*%'%'7 ".#,#$,4-4'" %'4!'3*#,%"%'".#1,#&#'"1#"%"%'!&'$!&#.!&+##' *!4#/"B#)#,-%"%&!$!&#B.#,#".#5!'!7%'7 %,#$", ".#5!,6 #4 %&,#C/%,#4""!6#&*#!$"%'!7!%'&"".#:!B

%$#,&-B.B#,#"1/,&/# !'4.!41/,&/#4".#!11#!2!'4,#)%&%'+# ,#".#!/".,%"%#&/'4#,".#$"- ".#1#,&'&B.B#,#!2&$'$#,'#4%'".#4,! "%'7!'4 %2%'7 ".#!11#!2 !'4,#)%&%'%'"%*#!'4!7!%'&"".#1#,&'B.4%4'"!11#!,!"".#"%*# .#!,%'7%'".#!11#!2B.#'%"B!&4%&*%&&#4%'4# !/2" ./24".#/,"'""!6#!'%*1,#&&%'".!"".#&!%4

%$%!2& B#,#.!'4%'72)#B%".,#&1'4#'"& A %'B.&# !)/,".# #1/"3 #7%&",!,.!41!&&#4".#,4#,' @4%&$.!,7%'7".#* ,*".#%, 2%!+%2%"3"1!3@- - @E.#,#%&'#>12!'!"%'7%)#'!&"B.3".# &!%4,4#,B!&$.!22#'7#4+3".#5!,6 #4!

"#,!1#,%4 "B3#!,&+3B!3 !'!11#!2.#,#%&',#!&'7%)#'+3".#1#"%"%'#,!&"B.3".#!11#!2 B!&!22B#4"+#4%&*%&&#4'!$$/'" ''!11#!,!'$# ".#$/'&#2

,".#5!,6 #4.#,#%&',#!&' ,'" %2%'7".#,#)%&%'%'"%*#B.%$. B!&!2& %2#4!

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

"#,.24%'7!".,/7.#'C/%,3 ,".#2&&$!/&#4"5!,6 #4

.#1,#&#'"1#"%"%'%&"./&4%&*%&&#4+#%'7B%"./"!'3*#,%" +/" 4%,#$"%' %& %&&/#4 " ".# 5 5!,6 #4 " .24 ".,/7. #'C/%,3 %' "#,*& ".# +&#,)!"%'& *!4# !+)# !'4 !2& #'&/,# +3 %&&/%'7

%$# $%,$/2!,&E7/%4#2%'#&B.!"&#)#, ".!" ".#!11#!2&E,#)%&%'& !,# %2#4 %'"%*# !'4 !2& #'&/,# ".!" ".# $!&#& &./24 '" +# 4%&*%&&#4 %' 4# !/2" .# #'C/%,3&.!22+#$*12#"#4B%".%'!1#,%4 ".,##*'".& ,*".#4!"# ,#$#%1" $#,"% %#4$13 ".%&,4#,!'4,#1," ".##'C/%,3&./24+# 12!$#4+# ,#".%&/," <;;5 = <;;5 = <;;5 = <;;5 = )#*+#, - )#*+#, - )#*+#, - )#*+#, - .#".#,&1#!6%'7E,#!&'#4 #&E .#".#,,#1,"!+2# #&E