Naresh Kumar Jain And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others
2023:PHHC:116022 1
!"# #$%&%'(
)( *+) , -,)
! "
# $!% &&&& -,) . + ' ( # # )
"#
* +
, -.-./-/- 0!
1 2'34 ) ! $ " ! # 5 !
"6 5 #) "5
) # "
" /70/4 ,8 * 9 "
: !"+ ) 5 !" /-'30
;/-'3!"<4) "5
/ ( 5
, 5
55,2 %
$ "
, # , ) "+
" /=-'/--/ " 7: !"+ !" '=>7 0
;'=>7 !"<4 55# ) " /3-'/--3 " ?!# " ''#
" /--'/--@ 3 !,, 5 " " '= '=>7 !" #
" # #
2023:PHHC:116022 2 3--./--> 55,, 5, 58 !5 /3=/-'7# "" )55# -@-'/-'@
" " #5
'7-@/-'@ 7
" /--'/-/- )
!
, "
" /70/4/-'3!" "5
, " /-'3!"8"
,
" 6
,
5 5 # )
) )+ 5 "5
# "
-.-./-/-# 55#
,) ;
!"#
$
$
%& ' ( ) '
$* @ $ " "
)
, 5 55# ) )
" ?70'4 /-'3 !" ) : !"+ *55" ) #5"5
-@-'/-// A ,
, -@-'/-//
6
2023:PHHC:116022 3 # " * ) # *B =@7= /-// # 55#
,2 +(
%&' ,
Issue a writ of Certiorari setting aside the order bearing no.43 dated 05.01.2022 (Annexure P-5) passed by respondent no.3/Land Acquisition Collector vide which, the Application filed by petitioners under Section 64(1) of Right to Fair Compensation and transparency in Land Acquisition, rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013; has been dismissed on merits, by observing is baseless; being illegal, without jurisdiction and contrary to the provisions of Section 64(1) of Right to Fair Compensation and transparency in Land Acquisition, rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013; law settled by Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Indore Development Authority versus Manoharlal and Ors., as well as by Division Bench Hon'ble Allahabad High Court in 2018(3) ALL WC 2776 Ayub Hasan and others Vs. State of UP. And others and;
Issue a writ in the nature of Mandamus for directing the respondents to refer the matter to the Authority Constituted under Section 51 of - . ' /
- - 0!12 Issue any other appropriate writ, order of direction, which this Hon'ble Court deems fit and proper in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present case; Call the records of the case;
Filing of the certified copies of Annexures be dispensed with; Cost of the petition be allowed in favor of the Petitioners and against the respondents." ? 9 # "
,
2023:PHHC:116022 4 /?-7/-//#
55#
,# ;
!$
$
$ 3 $* .
, 5 # ) 5# 55#
,2
4
,
4
04$04$ 0
)
%56 67 %
- . '
/
- -
0!1 %& '
!
"
# $- 0 " ''!
#
- . ' /
- - 0!1 ,
4
%& ' 2
4 8
8
, 4 8
2023:PHHC:116022 5 - 2
4
$* =
,
" # "
, 5
# 5 " 5 )
, # -.-./-/-#
,
#
)" , #5
"A
# )
# #5
# # 5 ")
,#
,
, A 5"5 " /#0#'12! 2!"!3!2!%'
!%,4!25!0,"!"# ""!2 2!1#&46'>?/!A0*4'337 /5!2,%'740)!' 486'>>'0'4:?7@ /%25!8!0 !2%,%'746/--'074*0*
543-= " "
# # "
" 5)C 0/4 5/# 5 ")5+
, # 5
"
5 # "" "+ 5
, ! "5 3--! * A )
,"
," " # #5
# " 5 ))
, =0 4 5 " 5
# 5 , # "
/-'3!" 5"5 " "
D)5 *
'12##0#835#'"9"42%": ;& )!'4!28!8 !'1 2& , < #55
)2 " / " /7 /-'3 !" "
"
2023:PHHC:116022 6 "
" 5 5
, ,
"+ #
"" ) "
E5 # ) 55) "
# 5, "
"" "#
/-'3!"" /70/4 /-'3!" # " 5" " %9 :
!
/
!"# !!"# !!
7
;
, 6
/
$* =0
4 B 5
,
'/-3/-/-0!
1 2''4 5 " 5 5 )
"+ #55 " #
"" ) "
# 5 )
5 " /-'3!"95 1" '/-3/-/- # " ) 5 ) 5 " 5 " 2
2023:PHHC:116022 7 ;
7
$
< & / = 6 >
????$* > A 5 " 5 , , 2)6A )5
) "
)
)5 )
) #55 "5
%&$9&&%''5#2%"& "4#8!%5 '- 9 "5
)
)2" 0/4 " /7/-'3!"!
, 5
,#
" 5 "+ "
, )
'=>7!" # ) F) "
" 5 5
,
"" ) "
5 "
"" "# /-'3!"!"
, )2" 0/4 " /7 5 ,#
6 "5 ) "
# 5) 5 # " /-'3 !" 5
" 2 "
"" ) "
" 5 5
, "
" /-'3 !" -'-'/-'7 # " " ) 5F )5 ") '' 95 "5" )5 " 5 '/-3/-/- ) #55
5" 5
5
,#
2023:PHHC:116022 8
" '''=>7!"!" ) #
6""5 5 ,
" 2 +=
,: ! !! /
!"# !$0!$ 00@ $$
@ -.'
0!1 $$0!$0!$ 0!
$
' %; ;A B8 /
!"# "$0!$ C$#
D 0$0!$ 00@
$4C 7
$D E=6 E
7
$
7
$
E E / = 6 >
$ .
,: ! !!/
!"#
@ -.' 0!1
0!$0!$ 0!
$
7
$* ! )
, 1" "
) # " ) "55# # # " "
,# " '''=>7!"
/--@ 5 55 )
)
# /-'3!"# 5 ")50#-'-'/-'74 "
" 5 5
, )
"" ) "
"+ "
,"
"
/--/G "
6
) ) ,
2023:PHHC:116022 9 " )
# A ) " 5 " 5"
" /70/4 /-'3 !" #55
" "
5"!)
,
# 5 # # 5 ) 5 "
/-'3 !" 5
" "
" 5 5
, )
"" ) "
)
/-'3 " "
" -'-'/-'7 # 5
'3-@/-'@ "" #
8!@-=3/-->#
"" '/ " !# " '''=>7!" # /--'/--@ "*
1"
# " '=!# 3--./-->55#)
" ) *
8! /3= /-'7
, -@-'/-'@: " 5 ) )5
,5 "
" # #
" 5 " '=!" , 5 5 " @7'=>7!" #"
" 5 5
,
, "+ "
, #
"" ) "
9 5#
5/-3/-/- @ "
) *
8!/3=/-'7 -@-'/-'@ , 5 '@
, !# ) : !"+ *55" /--'/--@ # )
5 ) ) 5 6
, )5 #
, 5 5
2023:PHHC:116022 10 '3 B 5 5" 1
5 "
&"0 4 #
, D)5 !1 *
)2 > " "5
, 3?3 #5 , # " ")5# F1C1$GGGG #$
0!1
$
0!1 $$!$!$ 0!
$(
:
7
$F Detailed discussion for this finding is in para 242 which categorically holds that c + " ,"
" /70/4 /-'3!"# 555# 5 ) # : !"+ *55"
* # " 5 5
,#
# 555#
, " 37 !"'=>75 ")5# +
$
0!1 '
$(
$ (
/
'
0!1$ B
1 !"# $
@ $ 6
@
$$ 7
$(
0!1
2023:PHHC:116022 11
0!1
$GGG* '7
5 $
( " * # 5"
, ) " 05")
,
= "%"8#1!&,#41#0 ,%'74!'1"4#2&0,"!"# !2:!'!!'1"4#2&4 ''''/-/- 5 # 55#
,"2 +1 $GGGGGGGGGGGGGGG H
0!1 %E '
0!1
!"# $-
/
' '
1 !"# $* ! 5
, ", "55 # "5
" 55
" "
)
"
, 5##55'12##0#835#'"9"42%":>&"0 4 %&$9&&%''"4#%&&9# 5!%'"!%'!?%8%": '@
) # # "55 , ) 5 -.-./-/-#) "5
" ) " " #" "5
G
,-.-./-/-
6
" ?70'4 /-'3 !"
5 5 ) )
, -3-3/-/' ) :
2023:PHHC:116022 12 !"+ *55" # " # "5
-@-'/-//
,
-.-./-/- ) ! 5$ "! A )
5 5-@-'/-//)#*B=@7= /-//9 "
,) * /?-7/-// ## # # 5 ) 55 ! "
, -.-./-/- -@-'/-// #"5
)
" /70/4 /-'3 !" # "
55 " # 5 " " ?70'4/-'3!" )
" ) " ) # # " 5 )
5 ,
# -.-./-/-# "55 , '? 9 *B =@7= /-// # # # ) 55 ))5
, * #
#
,1"
"
# #
, 5
# ) 5 # "
"
#55 "55
) " " " A "55 , -.-./-/-# 5,
# 5 ) 5 " ) ) 6
,
,
F) " " # # " 5 # , ) 6 5)/?-7/-//) * '.
, # #
#
55
, # "55 ,
,
2023:PHHC:116022 13 -.-./-/-# " ) 55" 5 "5
-@-'/-// 5
" 5# !, )5 " 5 "
," " ,6" "" "+ 5 ! "5 3--2! * A 5 " ) "B 5 ! "5'>04* A ,) " 5 , #
5" 5 ,
#6! "53--2! * A # "
5" )
) 5# A " "+ "
,) #" "
, 5
'=>7!" which has duly been availed by the petitioners and even released in their favour and thus by any stretch of imagination, these facts cannot be termed to provide any recurring cause of action to the petitioners.When there are specific provisions in 1894 Act as well as in 2013 Act governing the time frame within which application for enhancement/redetermination can be made, learned counsel for the petitioners has not been able to point out any law to this Court, showing that the right to claim compensation, enhancement or redetermination vests recurring cause of action in favor of land owners. Situation may be different in a case of blatant violation of article 300-A of the Constitution of India, which no doubt is missing in this case.
'=
# "
)
,
# )
'> 9 * "
) )5
" -.-./-/-# 5)5
,
# ) # "55 , ) * #
,
2023:PHHC:116022 14 # #
# # 5 ) 55 #
, # ) 5 1
, -.-./-/- ) "
,
5 )5
" *
, ) ) "5# "@- ---E2
5 ) " " # # $ " %A G B58 "'/ * , ),
3-''/-/3), " 5 " 5
EE -,)
5 B6
,E E B)5 E