High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1119/2021dismissed

Prem Rattan Sood v. M/S Arora Agro Chemical And Anrs

2021-10-01Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl12 pages

!"!

#$%%

!" "

# $% # & ' "

( ) *+ *, ,*-. (/ ' ) *.

*0 ,*,- ( / ) *+ *, ,*-.

/ ' # -1. #2 (' -..- $ 3 3& (

-1. # #

# 4 -1 0* 0,.5 "# # % # # 4 " ) *.

*0 ,*,-

# # $

&4 4 $ &

4 " 6 4

' ( 7

*----8 ,9 -, ,*-9# # -1 0* 0,.5 #"

4 # 4':

'( 6 % 7 4

" *0 *- ,*-; ## # -- *- ,*-;4" 7 ( 4 -9 ( 6

-1. #4# (

< =5- / ':

' 6 4

7 7 4 # 4 7 >< 9 # 4 6 7 >< ; ( ( 6 >< , %

# < ( ## " >< =, =, 7 7 4 ( # # 7>< - *0 *- ,*-;>< , -- *- ,*-;>< 1 >< 8 " % # 1-1 4 4 " 4 4 % # < :=5- : 2"6 4 # 7(6#

44 " (6 % #< :=5,4

7 7 4 7 % 6

# ( 4 % / ' (" 7 7

# ( ( % # # ## # ( ) ( 5< :=5- 4 4 " ( '4# (" " 7 ( 6 (6 % / ' # 4 " (" ( (" 4 4 ( 4 4 6 4 4 " 6 5 7(6 >"

# ( 4

4 4 ( < 46 # % ## 7 7 47 4 ) # (>< : >< :44

( 5< ( ( 4 4 (

(4 ,*-92 "(,*-9 # ( 4 4 ( 4 ( 4

(" 7 7 ( 7 ( ,9 -, ,*-9 # " (

#( " ( '4 (4

" ( ? ) #

( #

"" #" $ %"

# ' ()*+(,+-4 4

(" " 47 " 4

7 ( " ) 6 4 #( # 47 # # ( % # ## 4 #

% # "( 4 ) ( (" :=5, 5< 4 #

% 7 ( # ( ( " ( 4 ) # 3( .

%$$

/$%

0#" 123# 4 ()*-+

-6+ ' 4 # (" -1+ # #"

# ( ( 4 " -1. # 4 4 ( ( %# ( 4 ( / % / 5 " '4 # # # ( " #4

% %(>< : >< :4 # (4 4# (

4 7 ( # # # (

( '4# (" 4 " ( ( " " # 4 " ,* *** 1* *** 4 6

" (4

% # ( " ( -1 # ) # / " # 4

( 4 5

!" "" "# !

$# %&

'( "" " ")&&"" )* "" "& ()&& +!, '

$#+!% ,,, $#+!-

$#+!

$# +!+ , / $# +!0 1/

$# +!2 1 /

$# +!3 '1'

$# +!4 /, 5.$#+!61 1

$#+!7

$# +!8

$# +!9 '/

$# && )&& " ) "" " )&& "& !) " ") "" )&&) "&)* "" " & )&* )&& 9&*

& " & )&* "": # 4) 4 4 ( 4

4 " ( #

@ # 4 %# # # 44#

% ( # (

( # 7 7 47 # # ( 5< #=5, 24 4 A' 4 6 7B C ( # 4 # ( " " ( 4

% # (

' # ) ( /'4 / " " ( ( " ( )

' =5- / ':

' 6

7 7 4 ( ( 6 >< , "

=5, 2# 7>< - >< , -- *- ,*-;>< 1 >< 8 %# 7 4 ( 4

(

% # ( ( ## (

# # # :=5-: 2"6 5< 4 #6 #

746 (6( ' ( (" ( 4 4 4 7 #"

4 ( 4 (>< : >< : 67(6 % # # # ###

% ( # )

' # :=5,

" # # #

% ' # 7 7 ( ( # % 3(

%$$

/$%

0 "$& 5 ( &)*" &&

)& ; /

1 )* 3 - 6"

%) * - & &"

,5,

, )*3- &

& ; ( & -

&& !!! !!! !!!

( "& &)* && )* 9& 9

- % && <9) '

' -- '

/5$

9& 9

"= (

"= & - * 9$ & 4 "< 8 "" "" & "

"*("="&)

) " & & )&*)"

!"& )&*0 ) & )& * 9$ & 4 "< 8 !!! !!! !!! ,(& )*& "& - 9& 9

- % && <9) - * ) """

" 4 " " " "

. - * * "

" " )& - * "" ) - * &&- * &&)& )&4"&

9$ & 4 "< 8 "" 0

"" " )& - *4 "

"" " 4 "

"">;

* & "" &"

"* !!! !!! !!!

)& )&*"

. 4" "= )*&* && " * & "" )" && #" * " && # " * " "

) & )& "

.( ) ) "

& & )&* & - *

" )& & )&* (&"

& "& & )&

!!! !!! !!!

(& " "

& ) & )&"

. 4" - * ) " "& ( "* && " " *)* &( & >;

* & & )& " "

. 4" !!! !!! !!!

'""&* & && )*3- & )* 9& 9

- % && < 9) " && ) "* ": #( ") 4 44 ( 3( " 4 # 7 # #

4 7 4 ((

# 7 '4#

4 6 ## " # ( 7 # (

#( 4 ( 3( % # (#

# ( " ( 3( '

% # ( (# ( (

(# ' # # # "

( 7 7 # % 4 ("( # )

" 4 4 ("( 4 #

" 7 ( ( # 4 ((# ## -1. #7 7 4

# # ## 7 7 4 7 ( " )

' # ( 7 4 7 ? #(>< : >< : # 4 " ( # -1 # ) /

4 (

( 4 4 4 4

# " 4 ( % ( 4

# ,*-92 "(,*-9 -, # /' 4 4 ( # % #7 ,9 -, ,*-9 44#

# ( " ( ( 7 7 # # ( ( >" " # :=5- 2"6 ,* *** 1* ***4 "(

4 4

" # 6 # " 4 4

#( (

% ( ( # " #:=5,

# # ( # ( A' 46 7B %

" 746 # % ( 7 7 4 7 " " # 6 # 4 7

4 # ( ( ) # #

" $& ( 7 7 47 % " # )

( 4 5 3 && "= " "

" &&* "*"= " & )&* & )*" "= !!! !!! !!! && "* "= "

& )&* )&4" & "" )&( "

)) " "*"= & "" &" ) < $-& ( "* "= &*

" &")"

& )& &&*

&&*&? " & )&* 4"

)* *") "* "= " *" & )&*(& & & "* "= 4

" - "* "=

" && )&* "= & * "* "=

& " $ & )&* (

& "& "* "= " )& "

. )&4" : # ( " ) 4 4 (

(" " #77

# # 4

# ( 4

( # 4 '# 4 #4 #7 2 ) ( ( # 4 "4 " # #(><: >< : 7 4 7 7 4 #

# ( ( (

%) (/ ' 4 ( / " " # 4 -1 0* 0,.54 "

) 4

( "

&' () *+ , -.

7 =6 D2 = ( D2