← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1895/2018disposed of

Maan Singh v. Authority Under The Minimum Wages Act And Assistant Labour Commissioner Patiala And ORS

2024-11-04Mr. Justice Jagmohan Bansal5 pages

-1-

         

   



 !

"# $!%&'&"()

*++ * ,

-



.+    /'+      ,

,, - 0 *  

-- -  1 ,, --    1   -

+++-  -

-2+

'!

"'+

3!

"# 42 &!'

 

               

 

    !  "     #           

 

         #           

 

    $  $

!   ##           

 

   

  $

    #           

 

    "  $

"   %            

 

      $

   %          

 

 

-2-  

  $

                

 

      $    #            

 

     ,)  51 ,+ -  ,

 -1 &'(')*+

&''&,-.,&/,0123,*' 42&*.'5'*6*62)'&7(8

&/,).6&9)-,:  ;;;;  ,

 -10 

1  By this common order, a bunch of 10 petitions is hereby disposed of since issues involved and prayer sought in the captioned petitions are common. With the consent of parties and for the sake of brevity, facts are borrowed from  $  .

 .'5'*6*62)'&*.&29<.6)(*,)*5'*6*62)9)0'&&*63='( "24*.' 2)(*6*9*62) 24 )06, 6( (''>6)< ('**6)< ,(60' 24 2&0'& 0,*'0   " " 7))'?9&'$8@.'&':A9*.2&6*A9)0'& 6)6/9/,<'(3* 742&(.2&* B 3*C8.,(&'-'3*'0.6(3=,6/ ! .' 5'*6*62)'& 3=,6/( *.,* .' @2&>'0 4&2/ ,&3.C 

 *2 ! $ ! @6*. &'(52)0')*)6/,= 9(:,)0&A '5,&*/')* 24 *.' *,*' 24 9)-,:'@,(5,60='(('&,/29)*24(,=,&A*.,)5&'(3&6:'09)0'& 3*' 5&'4'&&'0,),55=63,*62)2)!   :'42&'((6(*,)*,:29&2//6((62)'& 9)0'& 3*(''>6)<0644'&')*6,=,/29)*24@,<'(6'@,<'(,3*9,==A5,60

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

9(=6/6*,*62) 5'&620 @,( 6),55=63,:=' ( 5'& -90</')*( 24 2)C:=' 95&'/' 29&* ,) '/5=2A''6(')*6*='0*23=,6/(24=,(*! /2)*.( $ '&32)*&, &/,).6&9)-,:(9:/6*(*.,*3=,6/24*.' 5'*6*62)'&,(5'&'3*62) 24 3*@,(*6/':,&&'0')'&,=5&6)365='(24 =6/6*,*62)3,))2*:',55=6'0@.')*.'&'6(,(5'364635&216(62).'&'(52)0')* '/5=2A'& .,( /,0' 5,A/')* *2 32)*&,3*2& @.2 6) *9&) /,0' 5,A/')* *2 5'*6*62)'& 4 *.'&' 6( (.2&* 5,A/')* 6* @,( 2) *.' 5,&* 24 32)*&,3*2& ,)0 &'(52)0')*(3,))2*:'.'

 .,1' .',&0 *.' ,&<9/')*( 24 :2*. (60'( ,)0 @6*. *.' ,:=' ,((6(*,)3'24=',&)'0329)('=5'&9('0*.'&'32&0 "  .' 5'*6*62)'& @,( 32)3'0'0=A ')<,<'0 *.&29<. , 32)*&,3*2& '6*.'&5'*6*62)'&)2&&'(52)0')*.,(06(3=2('0),/'24*.'32)*&,3*2&*.29<. &'(52)0')*'/5=2A'&6(3=,6/6)<*.,*5,A/')*@,(/,0'*232)*&,3*2&@.2.,0 /,0'5,A/')**25'*6*62)'&.'9*.2&6*A.,(&'-'3*'03=,6/24*.'5'*6*62)'&2) *.'<&29)0*.,*32)*&,3*2&@,()2*/,0',5,&*A(5'&'3*62)7 824

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

5'*6*62)'&060)2* 46=' ,55=63,*62) (''>6)< 32)02),*62) 24 0'=,A *.9( *.'&' @,( )2 233,(62) *2 6)12>'('32)05&216(2*2'3*62) 7824 3*.2@'1'&')*6&'3=,6/329=0 )2* :' &'-'3*'0 :'3,9(' *.'&' @,( 5,&* 24 3=,6/ @.63. @,( @6*.6)  /2)*.

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

    6,

 -17 /,)2-



.'*.'&(5',>6)<&',(2)'0

'(2 .'*.'&&'52&*,:='

'(2