Harcharan Singh Gill v. Panchayat Samiti, U.T., Chandigarh
"#$ %$&'(')* "+&,"+")-')., '// $#'#')$+ (!
0$+(1( ")&,"2"#-"3'#'")%#,$+( $(4)%$)# (!
* 56 - 7 6- +$($)#*8 +77 14#"9%:&"#$9 +#,$4$#'#')$+ +7-,"+3"9%:&"#$9 ++$(4)%$)# +"+;$(, ")1<"9%:&"#$9 ++$(4)%$)#(#=
,$#,$+#,$ $4+#$+( /&"/)$>(4"4$+3"2?$"//>$%# ($$#,$<1%.3$)#@ ?$+$ $++$%##,$ $4+#$++)# ,$#,$+#,$<1%.3$)#(,1/%?$+$4+#$%')#,$%'.$(#@ 88 88 6-
6!
,$4$#'#')$+9>,>"(')'#'"//2"44')#$%')")&,"2"#-"3'#' ') <')# -#"#$ 1)<"?9 #'// ,'( "//&"#') # #,$ )') $++'#+2
,")%'."+,) ,$4$#'#')$++$#'+$%"(-14$+')#$)%$)# +3 ($+:'&$ +$(4)%$)#))"##"')').#,$".$ (14$+"))1"#') ,$1)<"?")&,"2"#-"3'#'")%A'/""+'(,"%(34/2$$($)(')")% +:'%$)#1)% 1/$(99 ')(,+#5$)(') 1/$( 5!>$+$)#'
'$% ?2 #,$ :$+)3$)# 1)<"?9 $4"+#3$)# 1+"/ $:$/43$)# ")% ")&,"2"#(9:'%$#'
'&"#')%"#$% = ))$B1+$88!")%#,$("3$ >$+$ "%4#$% ?2 #,$ ,")%'."+, %3')'(#+"#')9 $4"+#3$)# 1+"/ $:$/43$)#")%")&,"2"#(9:'%$#'
'&"#')%"#$%C ))$B1+$8 8!,$.+1($ #,$4$#'#')$+'(#,"#,$>"(4"'%4$)(')" #$+,'( +$#'+$3$)#9?1#(1%%$)/2>'#,$
$&# +3 "+&,99,'(4$)(')>"( (#44$%,$4$#'#')$+3"%$:"+'1(+$4+$($)#"#')(##,$+$(4)%$)#(
88 ')#,$2$"+ ))$B1+$88C!")%1/#'3"#$/2($+:$%"/$."/)#'&$)
C ))$B1+$88D!")%#,$+$"
#$+9#,$4+$($)#4$#'#')>"( '/$%9 31&,/"#$+')#,$2$"+
)?$,"/ +$(4)%$)#(9'#'()#%$)'$%#,"##,$("'%$)(')
1/$( 9>$+$"%4#$%#'("/()#%$)'$%#,"##,$4$)(')4"4$+(
#,$ 4$#'#')$+ >$+$ )# &34/$#$% ")% ($)# ?2 #,$ B$&1#':$
'&$+9 ")&,"2"#-"3'#'9##,$ 34#+//$+ +:$+'
'&"#')#'(4/$"%$%#,"##,$ 4$)(') +1/$( >$+$ "%4#$% >'#,1# 4+4$+ ")"/2('( ")% ')")&'"/ '34/'&"#')( '):/:$% #,$+$') ,$ (&,$3$ '( ')")&'"//2 1):'"?/$ ,$+$ +$9#,$+$>"("4+4("/#$)% #,$(&,$3$?2 ,$ 4$#'#')$+,"(?$$)4"'%4$)(')"31)##'//D#'( 1+#,$+4/$"%$% #,"#1)%$+ 1/$ ! #,$("'%$)(') 1/$( 9#,$4$)(') 1)% >"(+$E1'+$%#?$$(#"?/'(,$% ,$ ,")%'."+,%3')'(#+"#'),"(#";$)#,$(#")%#,"##,$ ("'%4$)(')+1/$(>$+$)#.#"44+:$% +3#,$3")%#,"##,$&34/'")&$ 1/$ ! #,$("'%$)(') 1/$( >"()#3"%$#&+$"#$"
4$)(') 1)% ,":$,$"+%#,$/$"+)$%&1)($/ +#,$4$#'#')$+9#,$/$"+)$% &1)($/ ++$(4)%$)# 9#,$/$"+)$%&1)($/ ++$(4)%$)#(#= ")%,":$"/(&"+$ 1//2.)$#,+1.,#,$ '/$ ,$ #'
'&"#') %"#$% C ))$B1+$88! ?$/'$( #,$ (#")% #,$ ,")%'."+,%3')'(#+"#')#,"##,$("'%")&,"2"#-"3'#'")% A'/""+'(,"%(34/2$$($)(')")%+:'%$)#1)% 1/$(99"( )#'
'$%?2#,$ :$+)3$)#9>$+$)#"%4#$%?2#,$3,$ "&#+$3"')( #,"#>,$#,$+#,$($+1/$("+$:'"?/$+1):'"?/$9#,$($>$+$"%4#$%?2#,$ +$(4)%$)#(>9#,$2"+$#.?2#,$("'%+1/$(,$("'%+1/$(,":$)#
88 ?$$)+$4$"/$%( "+ +$:$+9$:$)'
#,$($+1/$("+$+$4$"/$%9#,$($&") ?$+$4$"/$%)/2>'#,4+(4$&#':$$
$&#")%>'//)#"
$&##,$$34/2$$(9 >,"+$"/+$"%2$)#'#/$%##,$?$)$ '# #,$("3$")%+$#'+$%?$ +$#,$ %"#$ '#(+$4$"/').%3'##$%/29#,$4$#'#')$+>"(4"'%4$)(')#'// "+&,9 9")%#,$+$"
#$+9#,$("3$>"((#44$%#'("/()#"%$)2'). "&##,"# #,$4$#'#')$+,'3($/ '(.1'/#2 /"#&,$($3"%$:"+'1(+$4+$($)#"#')( ##,$+$(4)%$)#(')#,$2$"+")%#,$+$" #$+;$4#313 +)$"+/2"?1#
1+2$"+(")%($+:$%"/$."/)#'&$)/2) C")%#,$+$"
#$+9 '/$% #,$4+$($)#>+'#4$#'#')"
#$+ ':$2$"+(>$:$+9#,$+$&$'4# 4$)(')'( "+$&1++').&"1($ "&#')")% +%$/"2")%/"#&,$(9#,$')#$+$(#&")?$ %$)'$%##,$4$#'#')$+#?$').(9#,$4+$($)#>+'#4$#'#')'("//>$% ,$+$(4)%$)#("+$%'+$&#$%#4"2#,$"++$"+( 4$)(') +3 "+&,9 9#'//%"#$##,$4$#'#')$+>$:$+9)')#$+$(#(,"//?$4"2"?/$#'// #,$4+$($)#>+'#4$#'#')>"(""//2 '/$%?$ +$#,'( 1+#)= #
//>(#,"#')#$+$(#"##,$+"#$ F4$+"))13'(4"2"?/$ +3#,$%"#$
'/').#,$4+$($)#>+'#4$#'#'))= #'//4"23$)#,$+$(4)%$)#( "+$ 1+#,$+%'+$&#$%#&)#')1$4"2#,$3)#,/24$)('))%1$%"#$
6- !
(<;( ,$#,$+(4$";').+$"()$% * $( ,$#,$+ $4+#"?/$ * $(