High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/348/2008allowed

M/S Singh Steel Sales v. M/S Manjit Machinery Works

2018-05-01Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry7 pages

!"" ##"" $%& '! %()%* #

%-,& . %+/0!

%,,& .+/ %!0 1&2%3!#%. %+/0!

%*!3!&+!%(.+/ %!%#

% &2 !##"0%!%+" !4!##"0 ""0+0! .

/+%+%++

4!3&%

0#%+%%+% ,"

##"" !% &"% +##" ! '&+ 2 #+ 5( ! "% + 6% ##"" 3&% %/% ! '&+ 2 #+5(!"% +%"3&% "( ! %& +!!&

%%/%(05%%+5("2 ,"

&+& %%/%(

.7.

8 ! 5 % &"% 5& +" 50 ! #"

+!+ + !5 5* 90 #"++!!:&&+5(!+ %+!% #% +5 #(5" % &2 .

!/ 5 +! &%+

;% +%"3&%0"""% +6%##""3&% !/ & +!!#"

!& &""(#%/+ +2 ( +& +#(5"5(!+ ! +%+# !3&%.!:& "0

0!!% !

" !&52+!#% 5* <=,6." %(++

0! +5 %( 02+ %/ 2 !!!:&&+5(!+

%+!% #% +5!/5 +! &%+;% " % !##"" ""( ++!02&&"# +&%% & +.!% %.%" !!+&"!;2 0&"+##"( +!20&"+5 %& %2!" ! "

(% 0!!"2 !5* %+ !!%! +.

"% " %!%# # +&!0 2&&"

& 5&0 "( 0!!2 +5(!#"

!5*0!% " !2%"05 %+ 5(2* +5 %( +#(2 %/+05 %+ 5( / %+ %(.! .

5+2&&"# +&%% & %" !!+&"!;2 .7>+"

0!& 0!%%/%( %!5" +& !5 2&&". # + &%% & . 0!% !% !/ 5 %#%"

+2 +50 !#%9 0=2 !& #%+&+5(!

5+!&!& 02&&" +!%!/5

%#%"+2 +50 !#% 0%+ %"

! = !#% %2&&"0!%!%!/5 %#%"

+2 +50 !#%,"

"" % 2%! +! %# !&##"( 2%! + %222 #(2 %/+ 9 #%/+ %2! "! ( !+&%#"&5" ? .&!&

+5 /%+5(%" !!+&" " !"% /&52+ ! # %" !!+&"!+!;2 .

7>##"5"! !0&"+5 /% +5(%+&%(%" %" ! !% ! +. "% + & " % ! %# &52+!%" 0&"+ /% !#% &5& #% ! +"+& !5%/%+ % &"%+ %" !!+&"!+! ;2 .7>0&"+5"!!! %+%"+ +"

0!& 0!%!%%% % " + %" "(+"0!& 0! " + "(5( " % .0!! !#% "" &%!%.%" +

+"0!& 0!%!:&. / %+!% #% +5.!/5 +! &%+ #%%" !!+&"!;2 .7>.

!"2 0&"+5 %& %2!+0! !& %

" !&%&9 !.& %% !&%& 0! !#"

%/+ 2 % %+ +! &% !!:&

+! .!& &+

00! 2%"

!!+&";2 =%+& +% ,%@& %0!!!% #%%5+#%+ %# & ,%+ "2

42 %20!!#%+ 5 %&

(& %0!! #%+ "2 #%/++ "0!%

!!+&" 4!%(% )! ! % ! & %& 6%2%+ ! %+#%/ .##% !! "% +6%##""3&%%%+ !:& "2 + & " % ! %# ! &52+ ! +! &% !!:& 0&"+ = + !"2 + !:& 0% ! ++ /% ! #"

##"" > .

!% %.!2!"2 0&"+% %2!+ !:&.

! .&5( +2? &%!%&52+!!#"

5 #%2+% & (! 5( +#"+ ?! &%!%+%0 !3&%!%+%++

+! .&52+ !!# %#"

5#%2+% &5( +0!! 5 ++.%%++ !%+%++

4!%+%#+5(!3&%

=%+ & +%

$%&'(() !

* %+ !%+%+ !0!!#"

!+/% %%+!"2!2& %#% +5( /!:&4!0 "% "0! !0! #%"2 %( !% ? .! %##"# %% &2 4!% &2 "% "!!"2 0&"+ 5 %& %2!+ !!:&"0!& (&5 !#% &0 "+ !5 5* +% &"% 5& +" ,"

!+# +%&

+ &&&

! 2 + 5* 9 ! %+5*

& 0! !+ !+&+!:&.!2& !:& 0%% "+ !& +%+0 / !+ %2 5&0! 2 0%/+0!% %++! &% !!:& !2& 0#& +5"&2 +/ !5 *!% 0%#&

!"&2 +5 =% &2 "% "!!#"

5 ""0+%/"5( +!#"+ 4!% &2 ! &5 ,"

!+ "+& %%/%( !2& ,"

!+#"++ !& *# %& %222 +!+"#"++ !& %&+!20! 2 % %+ !!:&

> !/ 5 +! &%+0%/+4!"2 0&"+5 %&

%2!20! % !&%&,"

"(%:&%+#"+

+ !/+ % % &2 ,"

! "+ & % %/%(,"

0%:&%+#"+ "( 9 %!3&% =2 0!!%" !;2 .7>0&"+##"( " %!%# ! +&52+! !% & +! &% !!:&.!#"

! #+#%"#(2 .!% %.! %5 !&!2 + " !#%+&+#!#

!%+%#+5(!3&% 3%2 "/ > . > . > +

% &"%+ !%+%#+5(!3&%+ 5"!!!#"

!+ / &#!% !%/%!%2

2& !/"&#% / !+ %20 /+ !#%+ & +% ! 5"9 %&2 4! %+% 0 &#!"+ 5( ! "% + 6% ##"" 3&% )!" +% ! #%(% % 5" 5( ! 3&%. "% + & " % ! #"

%+%/8 A !!:&2& 0!&#%'&+ !% !;% ""%%/+!% !"2 % + " =# 9 &!& .% &2 "% " %! %# ! % 4!"!& !"% +%"3&%!++%+!& %&2 .7.

8 .!0/%. #%&" ! " +5* #%/!!5"

0 .8 . ? .! 2& #% #" .8 . 4! & "+ 5( ! #"

8 ##"" !"" ++%+!= .8 . " 0!

%B7A %2

""%"C 4!2& #+ #%+ & +% 5" 9 %&2 0&"+ 5 "5" 5 +'&+4!% %!5 +%2 +.*# /0!! #%0% 5& +2& "2+% %2!22%"

% ##"""0+0! .

)!!%#* +

D )!!%#%5"