Krishan Singh v. State Of Haryana & ORS
CWP No. 20704 of 2017 -1-
!"!#$%& '(!") #*!#+) ,
- ("." *
(/ # (" ,
"0# 1$ 231 * -*' 4 * 231 *
33
$5 1(1 #!
6- (6 4 7
4 1(")!
(*!#+)4 7
4 (
( 1( #8.( 1!
94 9 7
94 (/ 4:!
) 1( * .( ;) 1 +4 ""
7
9 (/ 4 1"'.")
0'
.(1 # ) 4 7
<< 0
( ) 00( )!" .( )(.+) )!" 0
0( /!#+(=.
")!#+ #
!#"
>&%> # ?&% =.
# 99!#+.# ('!99 %@AA>B%5C4AB5>C4B5C4 ?B5C"!
.
:!
)!# #.
-!99 )!:
#!3) (4#
+(.#
!#0(
!#+") 0"
.# (*
!#BC !+)
!(60
# ( #"0 # /!#3 # =.!"!
;!9!
4@B(")( 4D @EC # ( F. !
.0#
) # 4 !
!" #
""
(/ #
!#
9
"0!#
.
;/1(#8.(1!
949
(# !
9 7
94 (/ 4 (
0(
!#+"7!
:)! ) #
(:
) *
(/ !"".
#
!# .# ( *
!# %& #
CWP No. 20704 of 2017 -2- >&%> ;/4 (!#+!
"!#
@>@& "9 "!
.
!# -!99 )!:
#! 3)
9:
" ( 0.;9! 0.(0"
4 9/4 906
"!
9 # 66 ( !
9*
(!#)!:
#! "0( " (!;
4 # :# (" # (!#
("#" !9 ;F
!#".# (*
!#? %&4:)! ):
.9/
( 3 # =.!"!
!#99
(0( 0( #!# !7! .
9 ;F
!#"4:)! ):
""
7 (#6 ( !# 9 !"!# @ "0 ( ( 7 (#6 4@ "9 # :
"9 .
(6 !# 60(!"
!#') "( %AA>4?4&AA?44&44?4 %A@4 @A -!99 )!:
#! 3) ( ( !#+9/4 7 (#6 !"".
!#.# (*
!#> %&#?&%(
=.!(!#+ 9 # 6
".(!#+ @> " -!99 )!:
#! 3)
9:
" !6
9/4 :
( :
##.# # &% (
=.!(!#+ 9 # 6
".(!#+ @ " ( 906 *
( @4 )!:
#! :
(
@@&%% :
##.# (
=.!(!#+ 9 # 6
".(!#+ %@ " ( 906 *
( @4 )!:
#! "0 0.
( );/
(4)!"
9#+:!
)
(*!#+) # *.")!9'.6 (:
:# ("!#0""
""!#
".(!#+'
9%6 (9 !#') "( %@AA>B%5C4AB5>C4 B5C4? B5C"!
.
:!
)!# ( #.
7!99 )!:
#! 3) ( ) 0
( ) " ;
6 :# ( # ;/ :
/ !#) (!
) # !#=.
9#+:!
) (9 # :
;/
*
(/ 7!
! #
!#" ) 0(
!#+" :
) #+ ;/ 0(
""(5!#5!#
9#+:!
) (:# (";/!9!#+ @%&%
CWP No. 20704 of 2017 -3-
" ) #:
(*!#+) # (7*
(/ # (") !"0""
""!# :
" "
/ 7!
(
?%&% ! ;
##.# :
( ) ! 0
!#:
" !"6!""
;/ .( 7!
(
%=.
0(
""(
# !# =.
9!+#6 ( ) "
! ( ( :
#+ *.0( .( ;/!9!#+*3 :)! ):
" !"6!""
":!
) ( :#7!
(
&%:!
)9!;
/ 00( ) 7 (#6 ( ! !#+ ( 0(
!#4 !#
(6" 9!;
/ +(
;/ )!".( 7!
(
@
("!#
# ( :(!
0
(!"!#+ .
"
!# 0(
!#+"
(4 ( 0(
!# :
" !9 ;/ 0
(4 :)! ) !" /
#
: 0
( ) 00( )!" .( "
8!#+
!# 0(
!#+" ) 0"
.# (*
@ "# 0""
""!# # ) ";
##( 60
!#) ";
#0 ! ? 1(#8.(1!
949
(# !
9 7
94
(!#+ ( *
(/ 4 ( .
#
!#" ;
!#+ ( !"
;/
# ".;6!
!#"
!#!"# 6 !#
!#
!#"
(;
."
() 9(
/9"
(9!
(.# 9!
!+
!#:) !# !#0(
!#+":
.0) 9 ;/ "0 99/;"
(7!#+
# !#=.
9!+#6 ( )."4 9 !6 0
( !" "
## ;
( 7!7 .# +.!"
*
@ .( (".;6!
!#
(!6( (:
"!#0
!#(6?%&% !99%
G 9. !#+". )0 (! 4
(! ?/
(" "(
CWP No. 20704 of 2017 -4- .# (*
@!"# .9!99 4 )."4*
!# BC @ ## !#78 > ".;6!
*
!##
>&%>:
"!"".
( =.!(!#+ # 6
".(!#+@>@& "-!99 )!:
#!3)
9:
"
( )
(!#+ ;F
!#" .# ( *
!# ? %&4
6
".(!#+@ ":
"9 (6 !# 60(!"
!# ') "( %AA>4 ?4 &AA?4 4 &4 4 ?4 %A@4 @A -!99 )!:
#! 3) # .9 !6
9/4 #
!# .# ( *
!# >
?&% :
" !"".
( =.!(!#+ @> " 9 # "!
.
!# 7!99 )!:
#! 3)
9:
" .(".
4 :
( :
##.# .# (*
!# %&#&%( # 6
".(!#+@ ( 906 *
(@)!:
#!
:
(
@@&%%:
##.# (9 # 6
".(!#+%@ ( 906 *
(@)!:
#!) # !#=.
!#:
"(6!#+ :
( ##.# # &% 0""
""!# # !# =.
!# :
( ( "
/ :
" 7
;/ ( !#+(
@)
(46.
!#) 9" ;
# "
!# 7.( *- 7!
6.
!# @>>
@ !( 60
6.# ( :
# B :
(
&%C ! " 4@@4?&4%%>A5 :
# :
" 6
!9 # :# ("4.
:)! ) 6.# "44&4%A5 ! &?H ) 9(
/ ;
# !";.("
# :# (" # ;
6.# !" "
!99 !9 ( !";.("
) 4 !# 7!
:
! 4## # !#+ # !
"0( " (!;
.# (*
@ .9!99 " (
0 (! ? /
(" !" #
CWP No. 20704 of 2017 -5- 609
4 0""
""!# 9 # "
# "
# ;/ ( ( !#+ (
(I#6 4:)! )) ";
#) 9 7 9! 6
8!#+0""
""!#
# .( 6.# 60
!#:
" .9/
J )."4 #
"( ( " 0"!#+ !#0(
!#+" #;
.( ( ".;6!
# !# =.
!# !" #
""
(/ (
906 0.(0"
" !
9!+#6 ( :)! ) :
"0 99/
# #
;/ )!" .( :)!9 !"6!""!#+
(9!
( :(!
!# % 0(
!#+
4 !
!" !60
!7 0# ( .0#
G!"
!#+9 90"!
!#) # (7 ("/ (00 .0 (.# !#
(0(
*
@:
"0.
;/ #"
.
# ) *.0( .( !#
;/9 /!#+ :# 0(!# !09 " ( (!#+
) 0"
.# (*
@) 0 G.( ) " !" .""
!9 99 "0
"#
""
(/ # ( (!#
(0(
!#+*
!# BC @4 # !# )!"( ( !";
!#+6
# 9. !#+ 0 +( 0) F. +6 :)! ) !" ( 0( .
) !# ;
9:$5 K, !"
$#$" %
! "
" ! "
! &' !
"(
)
!"
! & " %) % %% !! *"
( " ) ! " ' "(
" "
$#)$! "
! & "
!
! ) & ,%-."
#$) %
"
)-.
CWP No. 20704 of 2017 -6- -. , ! "/ "( "
#$ ! "
! & 0
"% "
! !! "
" ! "
' ! ) 0"
) %'" ) 0'"
) ' ! "
) ' ) 0
, * 1 1 ! "
#$! "
! & "
!"
" ,"/"!2 "
#$ " ) % "
3 ! (
)!" # %$ ! !" ! "/ "
! "
!
) "
""" % ! "
! &" ) ( "
& ! 4"/ "
!
)! !
' "
& ! "
" ) ( 52 ! "
# " $
! "/ "( " ! 2 % "
3 ! (!! '"
"
! & ) 6 %6 ! !" ! "/ "
! "
!
7 " ) "
"
& $! "
!
' "
"/
"
#$ 2 2 !"
" ,) ( "
) ( "
& $ 4 % % ! ""
"
% ( !" ! ( "
' " "/ "( "
#$! "
! & , "
#$! "
! & ) !"
#$ !"
$#)$ 8 , ! 0( "
!
"
"
#$ ) %(!/ 9 :"% ) 0( "
! "
!
' (
"
#$ ! "
! &' "
) 0 "
#$ + , !"
#$ (! ! "(
") "
CWP No. 20704 of 2017 -7- ! "
0
"
! ! )! "
! &" !"' "(!
"/ ( % ""
, !) "! )" )*"
"
!!
"
#$! "
! & ( % " ! "
/ ( ! ""
"( ! "/ "
"( ( !!" ! "
! &''
2) "
""
"(
% % / ( !
! 0( "( ! !"
!" "/ . & ".6 # ".;"
!#
(0(
!#*
@;/ *.0( .( !"
"
89 0"!#+; ) # !#+ # !
" 0(7!
! ;.
0)/"!
9 0""
""!# /6 60
;
.9!99 6
#!#+ ;/! (
# !
!# !"#
!"!
4 :.9 ;
#9 0"!#+ " ;9!+
6 /6 !#9!
. !" # (# 4 ) ";
# 9 (!!
". );9!+
0 /!" 609
;/
(!#+
60
!#:)! ):.9 6
60
6.# :
!9 # :# # !) ) "#
4!
:!99# !9 ( # :# 9 !6
60
"#
#0 ! *!6!9 (9/4 :( L 0"!
M) ";
#!#
(0(
0"!
!#+:!
) 3( (
".(/(
.( ( :!#+0 # )# ) ";
# #"!
;
7 9! 0(
8!#+ 0)/"!
90""
""!# # # # "
# "7
*
4 !" # !7 !#+ 0(7!
.# ( *
!# BC @ ) *.0( .( ) ".( ( 9 (!!
(! (:)! ) #/!#
(!6 ( (:
"!#0
!#4:!99;
G 9.
:)!9 60.
!#+ + 00 (!
CWP No. 20704 of 2017 -8- !7 /
("*!6!9 (9/4!
) ";
# 9 (!!
*
@ " # +!7 (!"
# : ."
=.
9!
/ # 9.
0(
!#+"9 "!
009!
#9/
)"
" :) !# 0(
!#+" :
0 # !#+ #
#( @ 7!#+ )
( ( "0
!7 (+.6 "4 +!#+ )(.+) "0
!7 09
!#+" ;7 99 G0"!
!#!#
# $4:
#"!
0!#!#
!#"
:(!
!#!"9!
;
!"6!""
(6( ##
"# *.0( .( !#
# $)
+(!
99/) 9
09
*
@!"
!9 #9/ )"
# :# ("4!#( "0
:)6 0(
!#+":
# !#+#
6!#+!#
@: ) ";
# 9 (!!
*
!# @ #
"0 # !#+0(
!#+" # # # 9.
#
8!#+
!9 !" .""!#" # 09 !#+ ( 9!
# 0( 7!." F. ! !
90(#.# "4 *.0( .(
@?&) "6
!
*
!#BC ## ."
( 7!7
# "
!6"
# # 9.
## (6!
;
#7 ""
#
0(
*
!#
@?& !"
) !# ;
9:$5
! !
"
#$
%&
CWP No. 20704 of 2017 -9- '
( ! &
&
! (
)
* )
(! (
( + (
!
* '
,-
"
#$. !" 6!
0(
""(5!#5!#
() #+ !#0(
!#+";/!9!#+ @%&% "
! :(!
!# :
" !"6!""
=.
0(
""(5!#5!#
(7!
(
%;/"0 99/;"
(7!#+
# !#=.
!#!"
!#+ 9!+#6 ( )
(4*3 !9 !#"
"
! ( ( :
" :!
) ( :# !9 ( 0(
!# :)! ) !609!
!#0(
!#+")
!# !# 9!
/ ".9 :)! ) !60
(!"
!6 ## 7!7 .#
+.!"
*
@!#
(6" ! 0(0"!
!#9 : @
##
8 #/( 9!
!#
(6" 0(7!"!# *
@ "(
(! !7 /
("!"# 609
!"0""
""!#
((6 # !#=.
:
" "
/ # @ ! 4 0(!( ##.# :
( :)! ) ( ( # !#.
!99&@ !#+"4"
! 0 (! !"( ;
G 9.
:)!9 60.
!#+ :!# : 0 (! ? /
(" ;
:
##.# :
( # 6!#+!#
@
CWP No. 20704 of 2017 -10- ! !#
(6" 0(!# !09 " 9 ! :# !#
# $# )!"( ( ( !"6
0 @@ F. +6 :)! )!"( 0( .
) !#;
9:$5 $/
(
)
( ) &!
!
( &
+&
(
&&
(
(
+ &
"
(
( !
&( $ 0
"
#$(
,
-
&
'
( )( ! " ,
!
$1"-
(
(
2
! 3
&
& /
( 2
!
, 44-
& 1#
)
& !
(!
&!
( (
( & &
%
(
&
)
&
!
% . #
(6" ! 4 :
) # ) "!
)9
G 9. !#+". )0 (! :) #!#
(!6( (:
"!#0
!#4
(! ?/
("!"# 609
)."4*
@ ## 6
009!
!#0(
!#+"=.
# !#=.
!# ? 7 ## "0
# !#+ # !
"0(7!
!#*
@4:
# !# #/6 (!
".;6!""!#"6
#;
9
() 0""
""!# # .9 # )
.
0
!#"
/( (# !"0""
""!# # 9
(#!
:
#;/ ( ( !#+ (
@40.(".
:)! )
# 6.
!# ) 9" ;
# "
" " 60
!#
CWP No. 20704 of 2017 -11-
# !" # (# 4!
!"
+(!
99/09
09/
6.# 60
!#( !( # :
"6
!9
99 # :# ("4 :)! ) !" ".;"
(6
F(!
/ 60
6.#
# " !";.("
# :# ("#
)!" ( ( 1( 1!
9 ) ""
!# 7!
: G0"!
!# !#
# $ ;9!+
!# *
0 /
60
!# !" !" ) (+ ! 6.# 60
!# !"
:)! )) ";
#!#
(0(
6
6.# :
"6
!9 # :# (" ";"
(7
@:)! )!"( 0( .
!#;
9:$5 # !
5 6 $,$-
!
) 7 7 8
! 8 &
;% ' "
! ) % % )"(! ) ( 0
" " )
! !
0( * (
+
"
$1 ,!
! .
& (
! (
+& $
-
&
9 (
+&
(
( ( & $
(!
1#
"
#$
1#
"
#$ !
:
;
'
!
&
! ( '
+
)&
$,-( ;% ' " % ( '
) "
& '
" : & ;
CWP No. 20704 of 2017 -12- '
+
(
! < ! (
&
2 . > 5"
" 9
(9/ (
9
6.# 60
!# :
" .9/
" 6. ) "
6 F(!
/ 60
6.#
# " !";.("
)."4 *
) " !" ) (+ ";9!+
:
( "6 8!#+ 60
!#(
)."4 09
!#+( !"
;/
) ) "#
#0 ! 60
6.# !"(
#7!
:9 :9 ! :#;/ #E;9 .( 4!#( 9 !6 0"!#+ !# 0(
!#+"4 ; ) # !#+ # !
" 6."
;
.9!99 *
@0( " (!;
: # !#+ # !
! ##5
8!#+ 0""
""!# # ##50 /6 60
!#J ! 0""
""!#!"
#;.
60
!#!"# ! (!0""
""!#!"#
#;.
60
!#!"0 ! 4 #;
#9 0"!#+ !# *!# ## # !#+ # !
"0(7!
!#*
@ .9!99 4 #
# ;
6
0(
!#+") 0"
.# (*
@ % " "
=.
9 ;7 !" .""!# # !# 7!
: 9 : ".66 (!I !# 0 @>@
# $4 "0 99/
() 7!#+( (
!#) # 4 0)/"!
9 0""
""!# # !#=.
!#) 7!#+;
#4 ;9!+
!#( /6 60
!#"
# " !" ) (+ 9" #"!
(!#+
# !#=.
!#!"7 (/6. ) ""
9 )!
0.;9! 0.(0"
4:
# ) "!
)9
!# !#"
4 *
) " .99/ !" ) (+ !
";9!+
!#=.
; ) # !#+ # !
" .((!#+!#*
CWP No. 20704 of 2017 -13- BC @ # !
;
!#+ "4 0( 0
!# !" !"6!""
& 7!#+ !"6!""
6 !# :(!
0
!#4 0 # !#+
009!
!#4! #/4 9"6
*
."=.4! #/4"
# "
B -*' C * B
33C *
6;
(%4 # F )
("0
8!#+A(
"# "A )
(( 0(
"A