← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/36501/2022dismissed

Mandeep Kaur v. State Of Punjab

2023-03-13Mr. Justice Namit Kumar15 pages



       

  



 



   : -  

  





 

 !

"    #

 $" 





 

 !

"      









%$!& "'

 (%  (

 "

)* %"

  $"(%%+( ! , (%  (  -,

(%  (

  .





 

/"

 ",,   

 

-

  

 !

""!

,

#12 $

 

& ! ,   34 .

    5

  

 # ( # 6(  74($   ,  

2 (8  9 "



 

 "2

!

&(  ,,  - 

 7  

"   "   , /, ( 



, $( .

, 4  -& :

-

( 7" 2 - , 

$   $")

  #

*(;&

 "-(  )

  

*(

$"  $"$ $ -!<<,-

 + -  4  " ! ,,$  "   , 

 "  

 $"  

 +" $"  

 9  .

 = # +   .$( > 8

 ;,"00 2 $%   "



.

,4 -& :

-

( 7" 2      9 0  $ &

  $ ", -  -  - (7" $ ! $"

" 



  , /,  

 8

, $$ $-!<<,-  " 

" -&  $ > &

 0

 "  

 $" "  --

 -!<<,-

" 

  5 (#(1 =  ? "   

!&

 $"0



! 2 /"

( "340-

!$  

 

, , 

 !

 " 

 , %

, 

;$( 9 "

(

$



 

& ! ,( 0"

" 0  -     1 1

 %$$  $  "   ( 

 "

,    

 ! $

2 $

 

&! ,(0"

"-





" $!

 "

  1 1



,, $ 0     

          

    

   





    ! "

###   $#%&$%$$     

 %'

 %(

 #$%)*      

+ 

,  -     

   

          



  

     !

 "

 

   "



 #  $     %  &  '

 (  

  

 



)* + , "

 .

 %$##$%$$ + !

.

 

    ,/0  

   





  



    



#)     

 .

      3            

 .

.   "

 

  .

 4.  + 

*

.  

 "

$ 2          

    5+.

   6 4 

     7 .  



$ %$##$%$$            

  8    

 !



$         

     7  

   



         

  

9

 .

.      

 .

  - 79     

   1   9 

  

9 

/  :2 

7  

   ("-  

   

  

     

 

  "

 * 

 ;

#

/"

( 



$" )"!



  *

, #

 2 $ 

 

& ! ,  "   34(  0"

" 



 -

 0

   



    !",

"    "

 ,&  !",

  .

4 -&"!

,(0"

"  ,&     ,  



" "

 ,&

,  !",

  .

4 -&             7      

  ! "

%###   $#%&$%$$    

 %'

 %(  #$%)*      

+ 

    

+

< 

7  )  +

 

 =

>  ?   .

+

1  



 +

 



    @)

 +

 

 

 0

 

   

    

7    /

   

 

  .

 9     %##$%#

 7        *

 2 + 

 7 $&#$$%# 7  7  

   

 .

  .  

 .

:   9

 2  %%$%$%   . !

 *

 +

  + 

*

2 "

 

 .

4   

 

        ,9

 +

 ,9

 2  "

 

  .

 4  

          ..  7  

    

   

  .

 + 

*

2 A

      .

   

37 

  

 3 .. 

   

 

  

  

 .

.



 !

 - !   

 

  



  /



 " -

 !   0121 "

 

  )  #1 ,21343  

        "

 ( ' '&

   !

   

 !  $5   -  &    

 6  / .

 !#  &#%:) 

 

 / "

%''#'  *  

 !

7  !

 *

 ?

 7   7:

. .

  $)* / -  !

4

.

?

 

   .%&#$$%# #'%($%#(  / .

 ! B% %%%:) 

 

 / "

'%##%##%%%B((  *

 

+  -

 0  *

  ?

  7    7:

 .  .

 $)* / -  !

4

.

?

  

     . ##%'$%#( $#%$%#( / .

!#B % %#B:) 



 "

($%%%#B%%%$#'(  "*  <+C    *

 ?

    8  "      !

  -  "

#:#%  + 3

 ?

 

   .#&%B$%#& $%%$%$% 9 / .

 !$& B %$:) 

 

 1

  "

(#'%#%%$%#%$  /8 *

 *

 + 

   !

  9  !

 :

  / .

 

   +

 +

   <  +

+

   7

 

     . #&%B$%#& %%#$%#( 9 / .

 !#B %% %%%:) 

 

 "

(%%%#%'%($('  "*  *

 

 !

*7   !

:

  





 -  "

#:#%  + 3

 ?

  :



 "   !

;

#(##$%#( 9 / .

 !(& %B%:) 

 

 "

&&($#$&  *  , . "

 + 

   !

.      7    

      

3: 9 

 

       3 ..    +

 

   

9

 7   

 .



9     =>  ..  .

DD.     .



 !&B  %:)  . 

   

   

 .

        .

   

      

3: 9 



        .       7

  

  .   .

 7   

   

 .

 - 79  

  9 

   7  9           7  9

   .  ..

   .

  !  "

%#B%': +<":#( +

 

         "

%#B%'   %%B$%#(  7

    

.

 !$ B %%%:) - 79

 

 

 +



 7   

 .  !# $ B%%:) 7  7    . 

 

   .$&%B$%#& ##%$%$%  +

 

        "

%#B%'  %'%#$%$%  7

    

.

 !#B %% %%%:)  +

 

 = ) ) 7> 7   

   

  .

 - 79



  

 7   

 .

 . 

  +

 

 

    .$(##$%#( %'%#$%$%7  

  +

 

          7

   

.

 ! # %( %%%:)   7

5

+

 <   

     

 

 .

   @)    "

%#B%':+<":#(  $&%$%#( ! #% %%%    "

 %#B%':+<":#(   $#%'$%#( ! % %%%    "

 %#B%':+<":#(   ###%$%#( !$ '( %%% 9   "

 %#B%':+<":#(   %#$$%#( ! %% %%% - 79

 

    +

 <     7    

  .  ! # #'

%%% 7  7   .

 

   . #&%B$%#& %$%$%$%    .    .     "

%#B%' $$%&$%#( !# $( 'B%

  "

%#B%' #%$%#(  ?  .

     



.

 !B '% %%%:) 7  7   .  

  ?  .



   .##%'$%#( #%($%#(   <  !  

   ! /

 



-



!    ==      

        

   0121 ! 

    8      !

 7    9  !

  !

  - 1 3   .      

 3 ..   .. 

   

   

   

7      E

. 2  F

 -    7    9

 

 3

 .

  / ?

  

E2F

-      +



 .. 

.

DD.     !&B  %:)

      +



 7

1

   .

   = >7   



2  

   3     E2F

-    ..    

     

 %'

 %(  #$%)*  

     

+

<  +



?  .

+

1  



 +

 



     3           -       

 7  9   3   

   -2  + 

 ,   -       

 9 

 .

 7  

 !

    



7   )



7   

2  

     3 +

 

 

    

7     

 $$%'$%$%   

   

 .

    3   +

 

   

     

7     

  

 .

9..

. %&%'$%$$    7    7   /

8 6!)#6    .

   9

 ..     

 .

DD.      

   

 .

 . *     ..

.

 )    .

: 

  

 7 

 

  +

 

   ! $B   "





  .

 =

  , 

 / > ! $%#  .   A





      .

  

    3   .  3   $##%$%$$ 7     9

  +

 

  9   9:

 B  < 

     

 

          



 

6

 

     !

 "

 

  "



# $   %  &  '

        "

! 

    -     <    *  )*  + ,> "



   



   



               &  !  

  $         !   





        -  -    "

-    

 

      

   -  

 *)* >+,> 4<   

     



 

 



   *  )*  >+,>



   -   !  

 

 ! 

!  !

 

   

        

  !!

!   

 '

  !        $         !   





 *)* >+,> - 





     $ 







      -  -    

              ( <"?

   

   !

   

 $   

 





       -  ! 

  

       

        <     

 !  



 *  )*  +,>        

  



!     

     



      :  >   

; ) -

     

  

 

       

   

 0< 

  



   

 (> 

,,, 

  

           



   

     !

 "



        &  '

 

!

  

)* >+,> 

     

   

          

   !   

 &  '

   "    

 

       

   

 8          

!  

7  .    

!    9

 = .

 /

)$>$'%$%#( =   

 $&%$%#(      

  >  $#%'$%#(  ###%$%#( G %#$$%#( 

 7  /

86!)$6 6!)6 6!)6

6!)B6    9/    

!        9

      7    

   

  .

 

 9



.

7  9    

 .

 .    

 

 



3   3 

 

 

   

          

  

   -      *   

 !    

 )* >+,>

  

)* > ,>  >>    



       & 

  



! 

 )*  >+,>        &  ! 

              .       

  



  (>  

 "

       

  

 





(> 



      "

   - 

"

     -  

     ,,,





 (>  

 

     

3        

 9  .7 8.   ; :  ,

 " 

)*   " " 

      " ! ,,& -,    "    "  &  0 ,, $

 " 

$

  9  " !-

 "  "  

 ,  &

"   .

 

,

 $

  "     >   /"

( " -& ! $  " 





 

&! ,  (, ,

  .

   ,  ,

    .

4  -&  

"  

 $"( 0"

 0 0 2 $  %   "

  -&  0     2  7" 0 

5 ( 0  $ " 0 2

   $

 , -  "  -    $

 -$=, 

 "

,(  --



0

" "  

 -&  > &(

0 , " - 

5 (#(1 =0 , ,&  

- "  

  .

4 -&0

"97 72( !& 

 $" !& -  $ "

 48

 

 !2  

;&

"-("

0

)

  

*(  $"  

$" )! $

    "

,*(   $" )!

" ,0

 

  $"* 

 "

 0      > ,&( 34  >

 0 $  $   

 $" 

 

  )"!  0

*( ;&

 "-( 

$"    $"    "  

 ,,$



-!<<,- ( "&



,

$

 ! , "  

,  $

 > 

 &

-!<<,- 

5 (#(1 = 4 "",  ,

 " 

 

"  34  "    " ! $   " ,,$

 "  

 $"( 0"

 0 0 2 $  %   0

" " 4  -&( " -!<<,  - 

5 (#(1 ="   " - 



  

"  ( , $ "

 "

 0

( !

" ,0 )  $"*"



  0

"

$"

  $"0"$" !& ".

,4 -&  "

 ,  

 0 



  .

  " 



, !& 

  )

* 0   1 1

  "  ,   "   -

 ( 1(

= " ! 

 !& " "!  $" )

 #

*0

"  .

4 -&"

" "  %@ ("

0( "     " ! "- ,&   !&    .

4 -& !&  

$ " "       !

$    " -  "! !& "4 -&/"

(

 , " " 

, -   -

   " 

" 

)*

 $  "  - (    -   -",



 ( 1(

= " ! 

 !& 

 $"( "!



3 "(  0

", 

  - 

" (

,  $



" 

)* 0 , ! > 

   $ " -!<<, - 

5 (#(1 =/"

  ,,$

 $  " 

)* 0

" $

 -!<<,- ( /"

(



$

 "

 $

!

, /"

    " 

 7 8   - <    +9  ,:; : ; ,23 :+@(; " ", " 

 & "

$  !!

 &

"

 0   "!

 ,  - "  !&,& $ ! $

  -

" "

$  

 $" -!<<,  "$ - 

   .

4  -& !& , ,&   $ " -

"  

"

,

("

 0  

"

"

 0

  )

  

* /"

(   !& $ $ 0 $   - "   -

 ( 1(

= " ! 

  " !& " "! 

$")

 #

*("$

"  &     1 1

  9 0(    .

4 -& "   

 & " -   !& " 

 /"

(!&-2 $0 $  - 

",& 0

"

"

   "    

"

0 ,



!!

$

! $-, &

  .

 4 -&0 &!





- "0 2  

#

"

-("

0(!& , ,&   $ "!, - &

"



0     "   

 "

 ,

( " "  --

  - ,!"

  /",,$



  2 $  0  

" 

  0,,  " 

, - 

   



 ! , 

   

( "  "-

"

(  !

,

&

"

 - $0

" " 

   

 "

 ,  ! ,( , 2, "



 "

 , $ 0& - "   



"        " $   - ( @   & ,   ,!,  

 #1  

 ! $ 

"

 /"(   

   -  0

"   

 (

=

   



" 

 (

=0

" " !  :$, % "

&0

"

 



- "



$ "-("",,  "    0

"

 " !

  



 - " !

 " 8 & -- 

(9 "

4( "

 



"    

  (

= 0

"

 " !

  

,  

   

   "  

" - !

 " 8 & -- 

( "

(

"

" 8 & -- 

( "

(   

 $  "



 &

" - 

 (

=

, %  &

"

  ! 

"  !   :$,   % "

&( " $"(  0,,  8 &  -- 

( "

(

&



 

.

"

$    " !

 ",, !      @





  "-



"



!

 

    A" "2 $=   '=.

A" " !,  '=.