← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5460/2006allowed

Parveen Bhandari And ORS. v. Pawitter Singh And ORS.

2019-02-11Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi7 pages

 



      

  ! "#$#%&  '  () %* %!

(# %!* ($ +,, -- . ($/$  0# (1#%2* %!* ($ + $,%! %$   & 34 51 

164 ( $ %& 5(1/) (1* 7 %!8!)"

%$ 5( (! , 9 -8!)"

(( $,%! %:;%$/(

%9 ===   

  ,, -* $> % #- !>9* <* (80#!08!

%!$%   #%! ( ?/< ( * %!

(# 0* !# ! #%  <( ) *#"/- ( ""#! % %

: 

:  ( 9 ( #$ ( %* %" < %   "<, %$ #%    8:8:

(! ! >9 *  - (% ! 5( ""#! %$ #<$ (#>/% -8 4/!*# A* ( #%

 (( (( ! $B*  (#>/% -3C : *  - (% ! (#>/% - >9 7#%2 #% ""/% *  ! "

 #%! (?/< (* %!

(#0(7#%2 $1 %#(4 "/( (#% %2-#$* , (< %

 (9 -- 2 8 4/!*# $$ $$ ! *#$ #%"<     @; , ( <%*8

,,-# !</-#,-# ( 8< ! ! !/"#% @:(! * #%"< 0 (!$*#$ , ($% - D, %$ $ %!>9 (!#%2

@;% /% ( - D, %$ $8 8

@;% -"%$(#/<8

@;% -) 

"#%8 (! ! -"<, %$ #% 8:8: @;

  (% !"/%$ - %$"% %! !* *  ,, -#$ -# >- >  --0 !8 (!<!# # ! %!"<, %$ #%, >-  %* %" !>9

(!#%2 //( ,($, "$>9 7#%2#% ""/%*  2  - $$ * %   9 ($8 ,,-9#%2 </-#,-# (   :8 > $#! $8 >9 (!#%2

,,(,(#  "<, %$ %!, -"%$(#/<

-$ >9 7#%2 #% ""/% *  #%"<    *  ! "

$ , ( *#$ $ (9 " (# #"

D0*#"*( - " !2($$;$ (9 8@;, (<%*  (% !"/%$ - (( $,%! %:;%$/( %9

#(-9 !#!%!#$,/  7#%2#% ""/%* 2($$$ (9 8@;, (<%* >/"% %! !* * $ < 0 $$/>E "! !/"#% #%"< ;

D-# >#-#9 # $ 8

$, (*  D, >- %*  %%/ -#%"< 

(* ( - ) % $$ $$< %9 (#%)# 0 , ( A###C * ! "#$#%

%3>-  *  1/,( <  /( #%  #% - %$/( %9 4#<# ! )$ ( 91 *# %!* ($8 FAC A #)#-C

' *  D-# >#-#9 $  ! >9 - (% ! "/%$ - ( *  %$/( %9 #$ % !#$,/ ! >9 "/%$ - %$   * )  "%$#! ( ! *  $/><#$$#%$   - (% ! "/%$ - ( *  (# $ F !<# !-98* ! "

$ !0 /%!> G9 ($ 2  $, ( * ,$;<( <( ,(A DC0* ( $#%* 

#!

)#A DC80#!0 * ! "

$ !* !$  !* * (*/$> %!0 $ 9 ($ 2  * #<  *#$!

*#% ( ! ""#! % <9<#%!8#%* "#("/<$ %" $8*  2  * ! "

$ !* !> (  ! $G9 ($ %!#% %9"

$ - $$* % 9 ($ %* "#("/<$ %" $8*  #%!#%2 * - -* $ <(  * %   9 ($  2   *  #<    *#$ !

* 0*#-  ,,-9#%2 </-#,-# (  ,,-#"

>- #%* "

$  , ($% *  2 2(/, <(  * %9 ($8#$ --9/%0 (( % !

: G ""(!#%2-98* ,- - (% !"/%$ - (( $,%! %:;

%$/( %9* $ !0 $<( * % 9 ($ 2  *  #<  *#$!

*#$0#*/< (# %!#$( E " !$#%" 8%" #* $"< #% * ,$;<( <( ,(* $ !0 $G9 ($ 2 8* ( #$% > $#$ (* - -* )  7 %#% ""/%* $ <(  * %   9 ($  2  (  * )  ,,-# ! *  </-#,-# (   

,,-#"

>- #%* "

$  , ($%<( * %9 ($ 2  ' % *  -#2*   *  ,$##% $ % ! >) 8 $ , ( , ( 2( ,*    *  ! "#$#%  %3>-  *  1/,( <  /( #%    

 

    !!" # "$8 2 2(/,   9 ($8</-#,-# ( :#$ ,,-#"

>- ""(!#%2-98* $ < $* -->  7 % #% ""/%0*#- "<,/#%2* "<, %$ #%, >- #%* #%$ %"

$     1#%" * ! "

$ !0 $0(7#%2 $1 %#(4 "/( (#% %2-#$*  , (< %  (9 -- 2 8 4/!*# $ , (*  ,$;<( < ( ,( DC* ! "

$ !0 /%!> G9 ($ 2  %!* $> %(  ! > - $$* % 9 ($ 2 8* ( ( 8 $, (, ( 2( ,*A###C *  ! "#$#% %3>- * 1/,( <  /(#%%  &'  (  )*( )

  !#+ ,

#!!"8:

H *  $ >-#$* !#%"<    * ! "

$ !<#%/$ *  D "<,% % $* -- > 

7 % #% ""/% 0 (!$ //(  ,($, "$ 0*#-  "<,/#%2 *  "<, %$ #%, >-    * - -< ! ! !/"#% @:(! * #%"<  * ! "

$ !0 (!$*#$, ($% - D, %$ $! $,# * 

"* > *#%! /(! , %! %$# <* (80#!08!

%!$%$, ( ( 2( ,*     *  ! "#$#%  %3>-  *  1/,( <  /( #% 1 (- . (< 3$ "

$  A1/,( C 0* (  %/<> (   ! , %! %$   *  ! "

$ ! #$ > 0 %8, ($% - D, %$ $ ( > ! !/" !I@*

 * #%"<  $ ! 1#%" 8#%* #%$ %"

$ 8* ! "

$ !- > *#%! /( ! , %! %$8 * ( ( 8 ! !/"#%   , ($% - D, %$ $   *  ! "

$ !$* --> < ! I@* * #%"<  $ !0*#- 0(7#%2 /"<, %$ #%, >-  #%$! !/"#% @:(!< ! >9* - (% ! (#>/% -   4#7 0#$ 8 $ , ( , ( 2( ,*  A)###C   *  ! "#$#% #% *( -' & 88

@;#$, >- % /% ( D, %$ $ %!8

@;%  $   ""(!#%2-98 #%$"<, %$ #% 

(! !%

""/%  /% ( - D, %$ $ %! %#- % ""/%   -$$   $  8 * 

(  * -! %#- !   8

"* % ""/%  /% ( D, %$ $ %!-$$  $   :  6#!0 $ !0 (! ! 8

@;% -$$ -"%$(#/<0* ( $, (* ! "#$#%#%*(  - ' & 80#!0 $ !#$ %#- !

@;% -$$ -"%$(#/</(* (8 $, (, ( 2( ,*GF * ! "#$#% %3>- * 1/,( <  /(#%./0&'  ) %& 1&& )

  !#$ ,

2228 $/<   

@; #$ , >-   "* "*#-! % ""/%   -$$   , "%$(#/< %!  $#%" 8 *  ! "

$ ! -  > *#%! 0 <#%( "*#-!( %8 * ( ( 8 ( (< $/<     

@; , >-   *  0#!0   *  ! "

$ !% -"%$(#/<8G

@;#$, >-  * 0"*#-!( % $ !% , -"%$(#/<    " !0#** 

( < %#% !,$##%8- (% !"/%$ - %$/( %9 "% %! ! *  #% )# 0   *  $/>$ J/ % ! "#$#% 

%3>-  *  1/,( <  /( #%   )

  %   &'  ( ))

 !#" #

$38 (!

 "<, %$ %!, -"%$(#/<#%*  "

$    0#!0 %! 0 <#%( "*#-!( % 0 $ ( $(#" !   8

* ( ( * $ < "<, %$ #%>  (! !#%* #%$ %"

$  -$%*  -#2*  *  ,$##% $ % ! >) 8 "<, %$ #% , >-  % -$$ %!, -"%$(#/<* 0#!0 %!*( "*#-!( % * ! "

$ !#$( $(#" !8

@;   1#%" 8#%* #%$ %"

$ 8* ! "

$, ($ (9" (# #"

D0 $!( 0#%22($$$ (9 8@;, (<%*8* $ #! </% 0#-- >  7 % #% ""/% ( "<,/#%2 *  "<, %$ #% , >-  #%

""(!

%" 0#** ! "#$#% %3>- * 1/,( <  /(#%(4  )

5/)

  !#! ,  3 3#%$ ! > $#"$ (9 8 @;, (<%* 7 %#% ""/%>9 * - - 0 ) (8* $ < 0/-!> $/>E "! !/"#% #%"<  D $ , >-  $ , ( *  ( ,,-#"

>-  #% ""(!

%"  0#* *  ! "#$#% %3>- * 1/,( <  /(#%. 





  )

  !#, #,#3   %* -#2* * ,$##% $% ! >) 8 ( * -! %#- !*  --0#%2"<, %$ #%&;   6)  & ) 7( 7&  & )7(

 &  5%*-9%"<    @;  %%/ -%"<   @;DK  @;DK 8F8 @; :8 8:G@; :  !/"#% D 8GG@;   8

  %%/ -%"<  8'8:'@;  8 8GG@;

 //( ($, "$ #- :

H 8 8GG@; KF @;  -%"< $$ $$ ! 8'8:'@;  8 8GG@;L F @;K

  :88G@; @:(!  @*  :88G@;

F  !/"#%A0 (!$ KG8:@; , ($% - D, %$ $ 8'8:'@;K :8:

! "

$ !C G  , %! %"9A%%/ -C 8'8:'@;;  :88G@; :8:

@;K ;G8:@;K 8 8@;@; 88':@; ' 5/-#,-# (,,-# !  : 8 8@;D  88':@;D:K 

<, %$ #% (! ! K8:8: :8F'8F'@; >9 ,,-9#%2</-#,-# ( A(/%! !

 :8F'8F@;C  4$$ "%$(#/< 8



@;A6#!0C 

"*A !

%!$%#  G

@;C -K# ! !!!89C

0 ) (8 "<, %$

$,/$ -@, "%$(#/<#$7 ,  # !! !!!89#%)# 0 ! "#$#% %3>-  * 1/,( <  /(#% .#<-  )#3$"

$   /% ( D, %$ $ 8

 8

: 4$$ $ 4  8

8

4  4$$ -) 

"#%   #% ( $ FH, ( %%/< FH, ( %%/< 

   : ,2 2#!89   22 !" +: 89

F F  ""(!#%2-98 #%$"<, %$ #% 8:8: (! ! >9 *  (#>/% -8 *  (  * -! %#- !  "<, %$ #%       22 !" +: 89 -%2 0#* #% ( $ I FH % *  %* %" ! </% , (

%%/<0#*

" (<* !

"- #<, ##%#--!

, 9< %8- $$ 9< %8# %98< !  (-# (

 ( #($< 7#%2, 9< % "<, %$

-@, -"%$(#/<* 0#!08!

$% $ !,,(#%< % * "<, %$ #%$* --> < ! #%

""(!

%"  0#* *  ( # $#,/-  ! #% *  (! , $$ ! >9 *  - (% ! (#>/% - G  ""(!#%2-98 ,, - #$ --0 ! >9 <!# 9#%2 0 (! !

 ! F F

, $$ !>9* - -84/!*# *  D % $% !

>)  A164C 

  '

<#  6* * ($, 7#%2@( $% ! &  $@ 2. 6* * (( ,( >-  &  $@