Som Dutt v. State Of Punjab
$'()*+(,-.-)/0 0 4
) "
5673
54 173 0 5 " 8 ")
0"8 3 0"8 9 0"8 50"
:
"
00 07
5 " 0 13 5 6 0"8 1 0"8 3 ;;;;;
! "
#$%&
1 " 1 < 1 " += $
!
" #$%& & '() " " *
+
1
" + +,
,+ , *-, . ( / / " , 00 0 .,. !""
" " 1 & 1
" 2"
1 1 / 2"
:
'()
> ! !&& 113 <
!
"
# $ % "
&'##(((!) " * ) ) +
,
)
+ !
!! ! ! !
- " .
/
+
+ +(0$
+
. 1 ! 2( ( !! ! !
!
!"!*
! +
!
! * !
+
+ + 223 "$! +$+ " "
* ! ! ! 4 $ ((3 "
((5(2 2 ) $
+! "$/ ! +
6 !* * ! ""$ !
"$+
+7! + + "
+!
6 "!
!6 $ !
!!
) +
!+"
$
+
*
!
!$"
*! ! $ $ ! !) ! $ * !
+!$
$" !
)!!
!
!
+!$ ! 6 ! +
!!
*!
!
+!
* !89 $ $+ +! "
+
! !
7! !
"$ * !
!!
$ ! !
! !+ ! ! )+ ! $ "
!
" 4! "!
!
! ! !
!
+ ! ! *!
!:
: " + + " +! *
+ ! !$
! + +;> < , != ;> %: ! ) 1 !
((003? 2 " 1 " 8 8 '() 1 1
11 3 3
8 8 "1 1 1 3 1
1'
' 1 '()
11 1 8 11 " 8 ' 1 " 1 "
11 " " ) 8 " 1
" 8 8
1
0"
1 " 1 3 3 "
" " "
1 1 "
"
5 8 " " A1 " " 1 1"
'()2 " 1 1
31 "3 3 3 " " 1 3 " 1 " 3 1" 3 11 " "
3
3
11 "" (
"
"1 8 " 5 8 1 1 " " 1 "
" < 1 + 2 " 1 8
1 " 1 " " "11 0"
1
" 818 " > " "
1 ?
1 1 " 3 1 1 " 3 3
1@ @ " 5 8 " //:4 , 2 " 1
1 " 1 ? 818 "
"
"
8"
0" 3 3 3
" 3
3 11 1 3
" 1 " "
> * ( 8 " 1 " 1 8
811 " B ( 31"
" ? %1 / 1 "
" # $ %&'% %%( 1 8 8 " " '3 . $ ! + ! *
+ * 4! $"+ + !
+! ! ++ $ * + * $
+ * @ @ $" $!
*
1 > "
"+ " !
* A
! !
! *
+$ !++ ! + + + + !
+! $ + * $ * *
)'$'( 1 /-% 2 2$#3$ 4'$'( )
*(
!
"
! - ! 5 <--(& = 7
+ ! "
- )!+
/ *$ > !/ +!
! >+ + ! * " + = !- ) + !
+ *
+ *
$
!
+! !*" + + ++ +!
! + !! +
"$ > "
! ! B $ +! + + 4!
!!+
! !! ! " ":+ !
> ! " +
+!
+"*+"$++ + + 4! - !
! ! " +
+ + +!* " !!
! ! !
+ + + !*
'2 ." * ! ! ! *
+ * ) + ,- .) ) +,-( % & /! ! % & !!"
! 5<--#(# # (= (. $
! + *
+ * 4!++
$!* "/ *
+ * + ! !+ !+ + !
$ ! 4! $ " + + !
+! ! ++ $ * *
+ * $
+)$"+ $ $ !
"! *
+ !
+ + + + !!* +
!+ *!
+ ! + $C ! ! $"+ * " ! + *
4! ! + " + + = !- 4! ! *
! :
+ +
+ "$ ! + ! + *
4! $ !! *
+ ! ! ! ++ + D"
+
!
! +
+ = ! - + !
*
!
+!+ $ " + =
- ? ' )
*
0 1 + 1 .
*
01 +1( % / % &/"
! - ! + + "+ !
! $"
) !!! ! * !++ !E E+ !++ " $+ !" ! ! + * ! * " ! ++ * $+
$) !!!+ !
+
!! !++ !*" $ !! ":+ :
!
! +"$ !
! ''
""
1 5 4-++2$# #$3 $'%-/5$66$ 2('#( 1 '$'( ) )* $2$#$.2'#$( % 2
/
% &/" ! :
" * ! $" +" $ E+ + + $- ( #$7$.2-/521 '$'()*-2$ $#4$-#$7$.2-/52 +-
% % /! % % % /2" ! - !
5<--#& (= ( 1 $ "
+ /
"
!
! !
+!
!+
+ ! ! $" +" $ $ E+ + +! !+ + !* ! ! +! $" !+ " $< 8 $/(.2 $9:1 $/)7$#$/4 8 $/ /(.2 $9: 31 ( % //!/
% % !/ /&"( +11 4
56 1 56 . + 1 1 4
56 56 1 56 ( % %! % 2" 7
+ 8
* $ )00 .7
+8
*$ )00 ( % ! ! & % " 9 ,+ +
+ '&1 + =- 1 1-" E $ $ ! "E + $F
+ + +
+,+ +
+
+ !$
+!+ + "
+
+ $)-#(,')#$'( )* /* *)#,(3(/' 1 .2)7 8:3$# $-/ 4-#(,')#$'()* /*)#,(3(/') ) 6*: (
% &
& "
! ! + +
+ !++ $" ?
(2):.2-%$ 5#$;$% $/+ ) '2(#. 1 '$'( " )* (%2-& $/+ /)'2(# % % & - +! !
-
!!!
+ + > " ! - ! + !
+ ! !
! !
+ !+ *
! * + ! :
+4!- !5> 3-
! "
$
"$+ +! ! *
+ ! "
+ ! +
!+ !
+ !!
$"
7!!
+ F /
$ !!
! + + " < = + + ":+ ! +
? = ( "1 11 8 1 8 11 " '():
11 " 8 "
0 "
"11 :
" "
1 "
" " //:4 :
11
8
1
1 " 1 " >81 1 " " 8 1 :
1 1
"1 8 "
" 1 8 ( 8 3 8 11 1 8 11 "
1 8
8 1 1 8 11 " 8 " "3 8 " . 0 8 8 "
" 8 " " C" "" 1 " 8
11 " " A
8
" 1 !& 111 "" "
91B
:$ "
&
+ " E 1 E