High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19236/2022dismissed

Dalbir v. Presiding Officer And Antoher

2023-12-07Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger13 pages

" !

!#$% (%)*+*&,

-- !#./*0 ---1 %$*$*&,%0 2%0+3+ 0%+*(*,4

''*)%05 ,(3+$0*#.

0*/3,#.)367#/&30 &30$5

#0*(#/#( #,&$8%0 ------

%+9&,(%,$+

: 7 -

; ;

0%+%,$ 07#.*$ &8#, #0#0#5 (<&)#$%

#99.*)#,$9%$*$*&,%0- - - ;

99.*)#$*&, #..&=%(5 90#>%( ?9%0*%,)% %0$*'*)#$%

,,%?30% $#@%, 0%)&0(5 +3/A%)$ #..

A3+$ %?)%9$*&,+- - %$*$*&,%0

!#./*0 '*.%( *,+$#,$ =0*$ 9%$*$*&, 3,(%0 0$*).%+ &,+$*$3$*&, ,(*# +%%@*,4 # =0*$ ,#$30% )%0$*&0#0* B3#+8*,4

*6934,%(

=#0( (#$%( - -

,,%?30% 5 9#++%( ,(3+$0*#.

0*/3,#.)367#/&30 &30$5

#0*(#/#(

8%0%*,#'$%0 0%'%00%( C$8% 0*/3,#.DE =8%0%/> *,(3+$0*#.

(*+93$% 0#*+%( 9%$*$*&,%0 0%4#0(*,4 $%06*,#$*&, 8*+ +%0<*)%+ 0%+9&,(%,$ &-

8%0%*,#'$%0 0%'%00%( C0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$D5 /%%, #,+=%0%( #4#*,+$ 8*6-

'30$8%0 90#>%0 /%%, 6#(% 9%$*$*&,%0 (*0%)$*,4 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$ 0%*,+$#$% 8*6 +%0<*)% =*$8 )&,$*,3*$> '3..

/#)@ =#4%+- - 0*%'.>5 9%$*$*&,%0 0#*+%( #, *,(3+$0*#.

(*+93$% 0%4#0(*,4 $%06*,#$*&, 8*+ +%0<*)%+-

8% +#*( (*+93$% =#+ 0%'%00%( #(A3(*)#$*&, /%.&=-

+ 9%0 ).#*6 +$#$%6%,$5 9%$*$*&,%0 +$#$%( 8% =#+ #99&*,$%( #, 99.*)#$*&, ,4*,%%0

- - +*,)% $8%,5 8% /%%, (&*,4 8*+ A&/ =*$8 %,$*0% +#$*+'#)$*&,-

8% 9%$*$*&,%0 #..%4%( 8*+ =#4%+ =%0% ,&$ 9#*( 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$ 90%$%?$ 8% =*..

/% 9#*( %,$*0% (3% =#4%+ =8%, 0%B3*0%( 9%$*$*&,%0 #$ $*6% 8*+ 6#00*#4%-

8% 9%$*$*&,%0 +$#$%( 8*+ 6#00*#4% =#+ +&.%6,*F%( GG- 90*&0 $8%0%$&5 8% 6#(% 0%B3%+$ 0%+9&,(%,$ #,#4%6%,$ 9#> 8*+ (3% =#4%+5 8&=%<%05 6#$$%0 =#+ 93$ &''

&,% 90%$%?$ &0 &$8%0 40&3,( *$+ '*,#,)*#.

9&+*$*&, =#+ ,&$ 4&&( #++30%( 9%$*$*&,%0 =&3.( /% 9#*( 8*+ (3% =#4%+ 6&,$8 ;%9$%6/%05

8% 9%$*$*&,%0 ).#*6%( ;%9$%6/%05 5 8% #4#*, 0%B3%+$%( 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$ 0%.%#+% 9#>6%,$5 8&=%<%05 +#6% =#+ ,&$ (&,% +3/+%B3%,$.>5 8*+ +%0<*)%+ =%0% $%06*,#$%(

- - #, *..%4#.

#0/*$0#0> 6#,,%0-

8% 9%$*$*&,%0 +$#$%( 8% =#+ 4%$$*,4

+- G5

9%0 6&,$8 9.3+ 9%0@+ #$ $*6% 8*+ $%06*,#$*&,- ))&0(*,4.>5 9%$*$*&,%0 90#>%( 0%*,+$#$%6%,$ +%0<*)% &$8%0 )&,+%B3%,$*#.

/%,%'*$+-

- 8% #'&0%+#*( ).#*6 9%$*$*&,%0 =#+ )&,$%+$%( 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$ =8%0%*, # )#$%4&0*) +$#,( =#+ $#@%, $8%0% =#+

,& 0%.#$*&,+8*9 %69.&>%% %69.&>%0 /%$=%%, 9%$*$*&,%0 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$-

8% ).#*6 9%$*$*&,%0 =#+ (%,*%( 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$ 90#>%0 =#+ 6#(% (*+6*++#.

8*+ ).#*6- -

0&6 9.%#(*,4+ 9#0$*%+5 /%.&= '0#6%( '&..&=*,4 *++3%+

, +399&0$ 8*+ ).#*65 9%$*$*&,%0 8*6+%.'

#99%#0%( $%,(%0%( (&)36%,$+ ?- ?- #0@H-

, &$8%0 8#,(5 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$ %?#6*,%( #4#, ;8#06# $%,(%0%( (&)36%,$+ ?-

%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$ #.+& %?#6*,%(

#83.

;8#06# $%,(%0%( (&)36%,$+ ?-

- G- 9&, )&,+*(%0*,4 6#$%0*#.%<*(%,)% #<#*.#/.% 0%)&0(5 /%.&= 0%A%)$%( ).#*6 9%$*$*&,%05 <*(% *6934,%( #=#0( (#$%( - -

,,%?30% - - , #'&0%6%,$*&,%( )*0)36+$#,)%+5 9%$*$*&,%0 '*.%( *,+$#,$ =0*$ 9%$*$*&, /%'&0% $8*+ &30$- - 8#<% 8%#0( .%#0,%( )&3,+%.

0%+9%)$*<% 9#0$*%+ 8#<% #.+& 9%03+%( 9#9%0/&&@ =*$8 $8%*0 #/.% #++*+$#,)%- - , *,+$#,$ )#+%5 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$ 8#( (*+93$%( 0%.#$*&,+8*9 %69.&>%% %69.&>%0 /%$=%%, 9%$*$*&,%0 0%+9&,(%,$ #,#4%6%,$-

$ =%..

+%$$.%( .#= &,3+ 90&<% %?*+$%,)%

0%.#$*&,+8*9 %69.&>%0 %69.&>%% /%$=%%, 9#0$*%+ 39&, =&0@6#,- ,

&,:/.% ;390%6% &30$ 8%.( 3,(%0 I"# $ %

% %

&% % '

% %(

%( & & &%

") *+ , - ( .&%&/ .

& -%

1 2

3# 4+ 3) 5 +& 7 8. & %

%($ %(

%( %& & ( & % %($ %( %8 "3 -

:&%

. ;

& +& <

3#= 4+ > 7 8 %

(

% +

( %

%( +

& % 8 => . ?& %(

%( %& ?&

( 6 +& '

% @&

( &( & %A!

$ #.+& =%..

+%$$.%( .#= &,3+ 90&<% =&0@6#, 0%,(%0%( )&,$*,3&3+ +%0<*)% $%06+ ;%)$*&, G )$ *-%-

=&0@6#, =&0@%( 3,(%0 #,#4%6%,$

(#>+

6&,$8+ 90%)%(*,4 (#$% $%06*,#$*&, #.+& =&0@6#,-

$ '30$8%0 =%..

+%$$.%( 6%0% #''*(#<*$+ &0 +%.'+%0<*,4 +$#$%6%,$+ 6#(% ).#*6#,$=&0@6#, =*..

,&$ +3''*)% 6#$$%0 (*+)8#04% /30(%, 9.#)%( .#= =&0@6#, 90&<% 8% 8#( =&0@%(

(#>+ # 4*<%, >%#0- , $8*+ 0%4#0(5 0%'%0%,)% )#, /% 6#(% )#+%

!"!# $$

&' %'(') '

*"+#,* - 8% /%.&=5 0%$30,%( '&..&=*,4 '*,(*,4+ " .& & &%

% '

% %(

% . %

B%%

( % >"> >

( &%

0'$ +

0'$CB

6 % 0'$

%( %

B%%

>"> > >#>3 >" % (

0'$ & % % &

0'$ & ( % & &

- & % :

%% %

& (

" 0' $ &

& @

'% :

%% %

%% D$

% '

& 5&

( 6 :

%% %

'% >#>3 >"

%( % & % & 0' $E

( & . 0' $E

& .

?& ( & ( % %

( %

% % ( ( > &

=>>>>>C$

E>" ># ( &

#>" >#

( :

?& ( & ( B+

+ ;

& %&

(

?& ( % % &(

& 5&

( . :

( >

* F2 G

& % @ *

% 9

,& >" % & % %( 9

D $H % >>E >

DC 2' +

( +

(

& D $H &

@ DC 2' +

DC 2' +

>>E >E

&%% ( % % = ;& %

(

>#>3 ># &

&% '% 0' $ >#> >"

(

% & '%

>#> >" % & (

(

( > %

E % &(

%% #>" >=

& +

>>" >= &

% (

>>" >= ( > %

(

>>" >=

(

( %& %( %

( > % & (

& ( %

& '

& 5

% .

( % &

'% 0' $

%% %

& %

%( %

& -

%% %& (

( B

( & % %(

%( &%

( . & %

% %&

% & (

D$ :

(

( ) .

% %( %

( 6 &

9%03+#.

#'&0%+#*( '*,(*,4+ 0%$30,%( /%.&= =&3.( 6#,*'%+$ 9%$*$*&,%0 8#( '#*.%( 90&<% 0%)&0( 8% =#+ #, %69.&>%% 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$-

#$8%05 *$ /%%, 8%.( 9%$*$*&,%0 8#( =&0@%( =*$8 #4#, ;8#06#

#83.

;8#06#

9#0$,%0+ 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$ )&66*++*&, /#+*+ $8%0% #99%#0+ /% +&6% (*+93$% 0%4#0(*,4 6&,%> $0#,+#)$*&,+-

83+5 &,)%5 9%$*$*&,%0 '#*.%(

90&<% 0%.#$*&,+8*9 %69.&>%% %69.&>%0 /%$=%%, 9#0$*%+5 #))&0(*,4.>5 8% =#+ ,&$ %,$*$.%( #,> 0%.*%'-

30$8%05 /%.&= ,&$ (0#=, #,> #(<%0+% *,'%0%,)% #4#*,+$ 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$ ,&$ 90&(3)*,4 0%.%<#,$ 0%)&0( 0%4#0(*,4 #$$%,(#,)%5 =#4%+ %$)-

- , $8*+ 0%4#0(5 *$ #99&+*$% +$#$% (0#=*,4 #(<%0+% *,'%0%,)% &9$*&,#.

,&$ &/.*4#$&0> +#6% =*$8*, (&6#*, ,(3+$0*#.

0*/3,#.-

30$8%05 (0#=*,4 #(<%0+% *,'%0%,)% (%9%,(+ '#)$+ )*0)36+$#,)%+ %#)8 )#+% #(<%0+% *,'%0%,)% )#,,&$ /% (0#=,

&,.> /%)#3+% *$ .#='3.

(& +&- , &0(%0 %,$*$.% &30$ (0#= *,'%0%,)% 3,'#<&30#/.% 9#0$>5 &30$ 63+$ /% +#$*+'*%( %<*(%,)% %?*+$%,)% )&3.( 8#<% /%%, 90&<%( "-. %

&' /

% (') '0 *"+#,* -

- , *,+$#,$ )#+%5 /%.&= ,&$ (0#=, #,> #(<%0+% *,'%0%,)%-

30$8%06&0%5 #9#0$ '0&6 /#0% 9.%# ,&,90&(3)$*&, 0%.%<#,$ 0%)&0( 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$E $8%0% ,& 9.%# 9%$*$*&,%0 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$ +3990%++%( 0%.%<#,$ 0%)&0(- , #/+%,)% +3)8 9.%# +3990%++*&,5 ,& #(<%0+% *,'%0%,)% )#, /% (0#=, #4#*,+$ 0%+9&,(%,$#,#4%6%,$- , $8*+ 0%4#0(5 0%'%0%,)% )#, /% 6#(% A3(46%,$ &,D/.% 9%?

&30$

34 30 *"!# 56*5 =8%0%*, *$ /%%, 8%.( 3,(%0

= A .

(

& % (

% "> (

( .

@& & (

$%& & % &

( % &%%

(

4 (

@& (

( 6 +& & B

E + &

& & & ( % . ' % &% A!

30$8%06&0%5 9#0#6%$%0+ %?%0)*+% A30*+(*)$*&, *48 &30$ 3,(%0 0$*).% &,+$*$3$*&, ,(*# )#+%+ *,<&.<*,4 )8#..%,4% #=#0( 9#++%( 7#/&30 &30$,(3+$0*#.

&0(%0+ 9#++%( &$8%0 A3(*)*#.

B3#+*A3(*)*#.

/&(*%+ #0% =%..

(%'*,%(-

=0*$ )%0$*&0#0* )#, /% *++3%( )&00%)$*,4 %00&0+ A30*+(*)$*&, )&66*$$%( *,'%0*&0 &30$+ &0 0*/3,#.+-

=0*$ )#, #.+& /% *++3%( =8%0% %?%0)*+% A30*+(*)$*&, )&,'%00%( *$5 &30$ &0 #)$+ *..%4#..> &0 *690&9%0.> *-%- *$ (%)*(%+ # B3%+$*&, =*$8&3$ 4*<*,4 #, &99&0$3,*$> /% 8%#0( 9#0$> #''%)$%( &0(%0 &0 =8%0% 90&)%(30% #(&9$%( *$ &99&+%( 90*,)*9.%+ ,#$30#.

A3+$*)%- &=%<%05 *$ 63+$ /% 0%6%6/%0%( A30*+(*)$*&, *48 &30$ *++3% # =0*$ )%0$*&0#0* # +39%0<*+&0> A30*+(*)$*&, ,&$ #99%..#$% &,%- 8*+ ,%)%++#0*.> 6%#,+ '*,(*,4 '#)$ 0%#)8%( *,'%0*&0 &30$ &0 0*/3,#.5 # 0%+3.$ #990%)*#$*&, %<*(%,)%5 )#,,&$ /% 0%&9%,%( &0 B3%+$*&,%( =0*$ 90&)%%(*,4+ %?)%9$ =8%, A3(46%,$5 &0(%0 &0 #=#0( +3''%0+ '0&6 #, %00&0 .#= #99#0%,$ '#)% 0%)&0(- 8*+ #/+$0#)$ +$#$%6%,$ .#=5 /3$ <%?%( B3%+$*&, =8#$ #, %00&0 .#= #99#0%,$ '#)% 0%)&0( =8#$ )*0)36+$#,)%+ # '*,(*,4 '#)$ 0%)&0(%( #, *,'%0*&0 &30$ &0 &0 # B3#+*A3(*)*#.

#3$8&0*$> )#, /% )&00%)$%(- 0&#(.> +9%#@*,45 #, %00&0 .#= &,% =8*)8 )#, /% (*+)&<%0%( # /#0% 0%#(*,4 A3(46%,$5 &0(%0 &0 #=#0( 3,(%0 )8#..%,4% #.&,4 =*$8 (&)36%,$+ =8*)8 8#<% /%%, 0%.*%( 39&, *,'%0*&0 &30$5 &0 B3#+*A3(*)*#.

#3$8&0*$>- , %00&05 (*+)&<%0> =8*)8 9&++*/.% &,.> #'$%0 # (%$#*.%( +)03$*,> %<*(%,)% 90&(3)%(

9#0$*%+ .%,4$8> (%/#$% #$ /#0 )#,,&$ /% 0%4#0(%( #, %00&0 .#= 9309&+% # =0*$ )%0$*&0#0*-

'*,(*,4 '#)$ 0%)&0(%( #, *,'%0*&0 &30$ &0 )#, /% )&00%)$%( &,.> *'

*$ +8&=, 0%)&0(*,4 +#*( '*,(*,4 &30$ &0 8#( %00&,%&3+.> 0%'3+%( #(6*$ #(6*++*/.% 6#$%0*#.

%<*(%,)% &0 8#( %00&,%&3+.> #(6*$$%( *,#(6*++*/.% %<*(%,)% +#6% *,'.3%,)%( *6934,%( '*,(*,4- ;*6*.#0.>5 # '*,(*,4 '#)$ /#+%( ,& %<*(%,)% =&3.( /% 0%4#0(%( #, %00&0 .#= =8*)8 )#, /% )&00%)$%( # =0*$ )%0$*&0#0*- &=%<%05 +3''*)*%,)> &0 #(%B3#)> %<*(%,)% 0%.*%( 39&, *,'%0*&0 &30$ &0 &0 B3#+*A3(*)*#.

#3$8&0*$> )#,,&$ /% 4&,% *,$& *48 &30$ =8*.% )&,+*(%0*,4 90#>%0 *++3% # =0*$ )%0$*&0#0*- 7*@%=*+%5 6%0%5 9&++*/*.*$> '&06*,4 # (*''%0%,$ &9*,*&, 0%#990%)*#$*&, %<*(%,)% 9#0$*%+ ,&$ +3''*)*%,$ *++3% # =0*$ )%0$*&0#0* 2 ( 7 1' ' '

)81$65! !,,9 ' ' ': '( 7

; '7 ( '

)81 $6, 5$9 < ' 1 ' '

= ')=' ' )81$6+! 6,591 &>( '

$666"!#11"#*?

"#-< $666"5# * , ' '' @) '

) < / '

< "+# 56

& &$8%0 9&*,$ /%%, 304%(-

&,+*(%0*,4 $&$#.*$> )*0)36+$#,)%+ .*48$ .%4#.

9&+*$*&, *,(*)#$%( #/&<%5 $8%0% ,& +)&9% #,> *,$%0'%0%,)% *6934,%( =#0( (#$%( - -

,,%?30% $8*+ &30$5 =8*.%

%?%0)*+*,4 *$+ =0*$ A30*+(*)$*&,-

%+3.$#,$.>5 *,+$#,$ =0*$ 9%$*$*&, '#*.+ +#6% #))&0(*,4.> (*+6*++%(-

G- ..

9%,(*,4 #99.*)#$*&, +5 *'

#,>5 +8#..

+$#,( ).&+%(-

;

-- +A@+ 8%$8%0 +9%#@*,40%#+&,%(

"%+

& 8%$8%0 0%9&0$#/.% "%+