Hargopal Singh Parmar v. Secretary Punjab State Power Corp Ltd & ORS





    
  

  

"#$%"&'$( "#)"#  **# +#,-, '#*"#. -/"0'*"* 1##%2*"*(#,  ,%*,
  

 !
!!" !

#,*

3# ) "&'("#)"4"* 5#*(%**# 3# "#)# "&'$((*(4"* 5#*(#,%*, #$%&'$#(&()*+,*&-   $#.  
*(%#,*1#*%***(("&&$,**(##"* 67 !89:-# ;6<0.1((*(#4#.%#$,("40 *"*"$",**(%**#5##4#.5*(")-*1((1",%" **(%**#%-#,-"**(##%",,0.*(,-#*=  865! >

>*($#-*("**(," ##(","&#".0,*",0.*(4,(5*(,-#* (  5"*,  ",  )*    *(  1#*  %**  "#  *("*  *( %**#("*"&&./*( -/"0 =&*#*.#"( ! !!!

(#"5*#(1",*#",5##**( -/"0'*"*&*#*.

"#   "  -&*)"*&.  *(  %**#  #*#  5#)  *(  -/"0  '*"* &*#*."#"**"$*("$5,-%#"-"*7 !

(%**#"&$1*(,)*(#&&"$-,5&*(1#*%** 0$=  865! >**&",?2'-"*(#,+, '@

 1(#*(.("&")05*5*)0-:*($(#,"&"5*# "  !8  ."#,  5  ,#4  (  ,"  1#*  %**  1",  "&&1  0.  " #"*0(*(,-#*

>""#*1",$4* $#"**(%**#1(1",5*(%**#,*(,"1#* %***(05*5($(#%".,"&)%&*5 "!8."#, 5,#4$",**(,"/-$)* '5&2

> *&*",?/(0#1,#,+ .+2,$&2&,3#$4  +,5/4#(4,*+$%@ -#$*(%.5*(,"2 *(A-,*5&"1 1((1",%$,#"*05#*(4,(")-%5# ,#"*05#B0&'-%#)-#*5
"4&%%"& 6>6 5

**&",? *#6$#+#%#(#)+'+(,#$4 +, 7$&%*#(7/'#$8&0#(4#(,*+$@"&$1*(*(#*"%%"&, C#,("C-)"#+/9,-%#"<1",! 7 =(&"&$1*( *(A-,*5&"1",*1(*(#*()%&.,5*(#,%*,;"# 1#**&5#*(05*5($(#,*""#%".,"&"5*###$ "!8."#,5,#4#*B0&'-%#)-#*5
"",1# $"*4"(&*("*05*,*0%"",0$&")0.*( )%&.,(#*$40.*(,-#**%".*(,"05** *(,)&"#&.,*-"*)%&.,1",,*",
%"#"$#"%(> 5*( "5#,"/-$)**(5&&1$#*,1#,,- ;

?> 
*,*,%-**("*"&&*(#,%*,54"#-, "%%"&,("4,)***(55"**"$*("$5 ,-%#"-"*  =(&  *(.  1#    ,#4  )".  0   "-*5##,5*($(-#**,"4*,&55#)0$ ("-&-%5#))**$*)%*5-#*"#(",)" %".)*,**()*1"#,"##"#, *5*#,-("&$

&"%,5*))#,1(*(#,%*,("4"&#". #*#*1&&0("#,(-#%"#**#*#4#.*(#5 (-,  1  #*  *("*  *(  ")-*,  "&#".  %"  *  *( #,%*,1-&*0#4#0.*("#@
*(."# !2

>")-%5#("#$ "*(,")1",,%,5*#),5*(##%",,0.*(B0& '-%#)-#*5
"4&%%"&6>6 5

DC#,(" C-)"#+/9,-%#"<E!

7 2

>( #&4"*##2

>,",-# ;

?(,2**#, "**%%"&1&&,*"4#0.*(, ,  5  *(  '-%#)  -#*  "*  ! 7

%",,4&%%"&6>6 5

"*(# *",, =("4%#-,*("5#,"##"*,-# ,#41*("**(,2**#, "**%%"&,(-& 0,%,5*#),5*("5#,"##"* ! 7 %",,4&%%"&6>6 5

" *(*(#*",, 2**#, "**%%"&,",1#"#$&.@
*,*,%-*0.*(&"#-,&5#*(%"#*,*("* *(/-$)*5*(&"#'$&-$"*

>9:-# ;

!<%",,=  865! >5&0.*(%**#"&$1*( *(#,(""&#".0)%&)*0.*(#,%*,;"#"*( 05*,    *#),  5  *(  ,"  /-$)*  1# "&#".  $#"* *  *( %**# 1"5*#*(,5*(2

>*( #,%*,("4,*"#**(%#,,5#4#.5*(,"05*

1((1",:***(%**#*#),5*(##%",,=  865! >F%$41*(,2

>

4,%,%".)*##1",,,-6 7 !8#4,$*( %,5*(%**#0.1*(#"1$*(05*1((1",:* *()"-*5*(/-$)*%",,0.*(,-#*=  86 5! >4*(#4#.1",*055*F%$41*(#4, %,%".)*## ($#4"1((,0$#",0.*(%**#,*("* *(B0&'-%#)-#*5
"(",(&*("*#4#.,* 055**("*5*(#,%*,#4#$*(")-*5#) *(%**#,0"&"15#*(#",*("*4*(2 5&0.*( #,%*,;"#1",,%,5*#),5*(##%",,0.*( B0&  '-%#)  -#*  5 
"   4&  %%"& 6>6  5 

 (#5#*(-$(*(#,%*,1#1&&1*(*(##$(*,*#4, *(%,"#.05*,0-*#4#.-&("40## 2"#-,&5#*(#,%*,;"#*(*(#(" ,*"*,*("*",%#*("#*(*#%#*"*5%"#"> 5*( /-$)*5B0&'-%#)-#*5
"#%#-05#1-& )"*("*&.*()%&.,1(1#,#4"1#$#"**( ,"05*,"("*(#"5*##*##4#.,*0)"5#) *()1(#",*(%**#(""&#".#*#0.*(*)*(.("5& *(1#*%**%-#,-"*1((*(%**#1",$#"**( 05**(#5#*(/-$)*5*(B0&'-%#)-#*4& %%"&  6>6  5 

  1&&  *  0  "%%&"0&    *(  ",  5 *(

%**#A-"#4#.5*(:,,")-*%"(#,%*,"# *#.$*,*$-,(*(##5*(B0&'-%#)-#*5
"

-#*(#&"#-,&5#*(#,%*,,*"*,*("**(# 1","-#*"F$$40.*(%**#"**(*)5#4$*( 05*%-#,-"**(/-$)*%",,=  865! > *("*",*,5-*(."#***&5#*(,"#&5*(,") 1&&  0  #*-#  "  *(#5#  *(  %**#,  "#  -#  *(  ," 0&$"**#*-#*(:,,%"")-*
("4("#&"#-,&5#*(%"#*,"("4$ *(#-$(*(##,1*(*(#"0&",,,*" *(B0&'-%#)-#*5
"(",#**( #,%*,**55**(#4#.*($#-*("*%#,,(" #*#5#),#4*(,")1&&0"%%&"0&*(%**#",1&& 4*(-$( *( 05*  %-#,-" * *(/-$)* "*  =  865!

>1",:***(%**#"5*##*#)*( #",",,$0.*(B0&'-%#)-#*5#*55*$*( #4#.1",*("**1-&0("#*55*#4#.5#)*(#*# )%&.
*,*,%-**("*"**(*)5#4#.*(%**# 1","&,"#*#)%&.*(#5#,**"0)"0.*( #,%*,*55**(#4#.5#)*(%**#0.

 #4%-#,-"**(#*,$40.*(,-#*=  865! >*(,"-#*"F$*#5-")-*1&&05 ,A-5#*(#",*("*-#*"F$1",$4"**(*)5 #4$*(05*1((1",:*%-#,-"**(##, %",,0.*(,-#*"*(#"5*#B0&'-%#)-#*5
" #***#4#*(")-*"&#".%"",*1&&0("#,(% #*#)%&."*(#5#*(/-$)*5*('-%#)-#*1&& ("4%#4#*(-#*"F$$40.*(%**#,%"&&. F%$41*(5"**("**(B0&'-%#)-#*5
"(& *("**1&&0("#,(%5#"#*#)%&.*#5-*(")-* "&#".

#41((,"%%&"0&-%*(%**#,",1&& 4*(0",,5-#*"F$*(#,%*,"*#4#*( ")-*(#5#*(#4#.5*(")-*",,-$(**05#) *(%**#,(&*00"","#$&.,*", 2"#  -,&  5#  *(  %**#  ,*"*,  *("*  *(  ,) ")-*(","&#".0#4#0.*(#,%*,(")-* #4#0.*(#,%*,1&&0#*-#**(%**#1*(" %#5*(#)*(,5#)*("*5#%*5#*5%.

9 : :

;!!" !< ,

5"

=(*(#,%"F$G#",  ,G =(*(# %#*"0& ,G