High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20805/2017allowed

Manuj Sharma v. Union Of India & Other

2018-08-08Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath4 pages

!" "#$%$&'

( &)*+ ,- "!$!$&", .% &$& &/$ &/!+",% "%0&/"&!% ('1 2(3 ('1 2(3 ('1 2(3 ('1 2(33( 3( 3( 3( ,"%"&!' (,4!$ ,""&5/6# !"5

,!+"0"!$!$&", (,$/+)5/6# !"5

,,"%0&/"&!% !7 33(5 33(5 33(5 33(5 +"0"!$!$&",+ %0, 4"/ ,!+"$%%) &#" 8,$!$&!+"& !)," #",!$, ,$ ,9) %+$&:!+" /6",%","- ,;%<%!0$-0%"/=%+8&$&!+" 0 %%0,! 00>$# !$&%! !)%/ !"/7? &/ ,%"!!$&: %$/"!+"0"& >!4 @ $-0%"/ )0& +$- A4 & , > ,/", / !"/ 7? , &! -"&!$&$&:+$%!"-0, ,4 //,"%%$&!+"0 %%0,! 00>$# !$& &/ ),!+", , $%%) &#" 8,$!$&!+"& !)," - &/ -)%/$,"#!$&:!+","%0&/"&!%! ,"&"8+$%0 %%0,!&!+" //,"%%:$6"&$&!+" 00>$# !$& ,- & A,$"

5 !+" 0"!$!$&", + % 6",,"/ !+ ! +" $% 0",- &"&! ,"%$/"&! )%" B75"#!,7B 5+ &/$: ,+"+ / 00>$"/ , 0 %%0,!$&!+"4" , 58+$#+8 %$%%)"/!+$-&!+"% -" //,"%%$" )%" B75 "#!, 7B 5 + &/$: ,+ $% >/ 0 %%0,! A" ,$&: 7B B?B8 %:$&:!"C0$,"& ? 5!+","

,"5+"+ / 00>$"/

,$!%,"&"8 >&

B +"0"!$!$&",-"&!$&"/+$%0",- &"&! &/

0,"%"&! //,"%% %)%" B75"#!,7B 5+ &/$: ,+A)! !!+ !!$-" +" 8 % %",6$&: 8$!+ 3! ; ( +$&/, &; &/ 8 % %! 4$&: $& ,"&!"/ ##--/ !$& $& > ! 75 !+ >,5 "#!, D 5 8 ,; 5 "8

">+$"8 %#&!"-0> !$&:!,"%$:& ,-+$%*A$&,/",!>; !",+$% >/0 ,"&!% !+ &/$: ,+5!+","

,"5 &!$#$0 !$&:+$%%+$ !$&:!+ &/$: ,+5 +"/$/&!-"&!$&!+" //,"%% ">+$58+$#+8 %+$%!"-0, ,4 A/"A)! +$% %+$ !$&: ! + &/$: ,+ /$/ &! - !",$ >$E" " 00" ,"/ A" ," !+" 0 %%0,! )!+,$!4&!+" 00$&!"// 4$" &/%)A-$!!"/ >>!+" ,"9)$%$!"/#)-"&!%A)!,"#"$6"/ >"!!",&D 5 ,#> ,$ $# !$&!

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

8+"," %+"+ %%)A-$!!"/!+""C0> & !$& %!8+4+"/$/&!-"&!$& +$%!"-0, ,4 //,"%%$&!+" 00>$# !$& ,- %+"8 %#&!"-0> !$&:+$% %+$ !$&:!+ &/$: ,+ ,- ">+$!>; !",+$%>/0 ,"&!% &%)00,! +$%%)A-$%%$&%5>" ,&"/#)&%"> ,!+"0"!$!$&", + %,">$"/)0& /"#$%$& !+" !& $:+),!,"&/","/$&!

7 <8$%+ , %+ / <8$%+ , %+ / <8$%+ , %+ / <8$%+ , %+ / .% +" &$& &/$ +" &$& &/$ +" &$& &/$ +" &$& &/$ !+,):+ "#,"! ,45 ($&$%!,4 !+,):+ "#,"! ,45 ($&$%!,4 !+,):+ "#,"! ,45 ($&$%!,4 !+,):+ "#,"! ,45 ($&$%!,4 C!",& >

$,%5 6",&-"&! &/$ 5 "8 ">+$ C!",& >

$,%5 6",&-"&! &/$ 5 "8 ">+$ &/ !+",%= &/ !+",%= &/ !+",%= &/ !+",%= BI J I$6$>J ?D &/ /"#$%$& !+" &/+, , /"%+ $:+ ),! ,"&/","/$&!+"# %" < :+), -3 -$%"!!4 < :+), -3 -$%"!!4 < :+), -3 -$%"!!4 < :+), -3 -$%"!!4.%":$& > %%0,!

$#", ":$& > %%0,!

$#", &/ &!+",= &/ &!+",= &/ &!+",= &/ &!+",= I7 JI$6$>J B!#&!"&/!+ !!+","$%&-"&%," &!+"0 ,! !+"0"!$!$&",8+$>"&!-"&!$&$&:!+"!"-0, ,4 //,"%%

">+$8+$#++"+ / ),!+","C0> $&"/ & !+" !+", + &/5 >" ,&"/ #)&%"> 00" ,$&: & A"+ > ,"%0&/"&!% ! 7 + % %)A-$!!"/ !+ ! !+" 0"!$!$&", 8 % :)$>!4 %)00,"%%$& - !",$ > $& ,- !$& !+ ! +" 8 % >$6$&: $& ">+$ &/ !+","

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

,"5 +" /$/ &! -"&!$& !+" //,"%% ">+$ & !+$% ,": ,/5 !+" *)/:-"&!%,">$"/)0&A4!+"0"!$!$&",$&!+"# %" 8$%+ , % /I)0, J 8$%+ , % /I)0, J 8$%+ , % /I)0, J 8$%+ , % /I)0, J &/ :+), -3 -$%"!!4I)0, J :+), -3 -$%"!!4I)0, J :+), -3 -$%"!!4I)0, J :+), -3 -$%"!!4I)0, J8)>/A" 00>$# A>"$&+$% 6),+"

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

"&#+ !+$%),!,"&/","/$&!+"# %" < ,-""! 8 &/+ &/ &!+", < ,-""! 8 &/+ &/ &!+", < ,-""! 8 &/+ &/ &!+", < ,-""! 8 &/+ &/ &!+", .%&$& &/$ &/ &!+",= &$& &/$ &/ &!+",= &$& &/$ &/ &!+",= &$& &/$ &/ &!+",= DD I)&* AJ

$&8+$#+!+$%),! + % +">/ !+ ! $ !+" 0 ,"&!% ," ,"%$/$&: ! + &/$: ,+ &/ !+" %!)/"&! $% %!)/4$&:$& A ,/$&:%#+> !%-"!+",0> #"!+"&!+"":$& > %%0,!

$#",%+ >>A"#-0"!"&!!$%%)"0 %%0,! &6$"8 !+" ,"% $/5 - !+"#&%$/","/0$&$&!+ !!+"

$&"$-0%"/)0&!+"0"!$!$&", @$%0 !"&!>4$>>": > &/",,&")%5 !+"% -"$%/$,"#!"/!A","

)&/"/!+$- &/!+"":$& > %%0,!

$#",5 + &/$: ,+$% ),!+",/$,"#!"/!0"&!+" $>" !+"0"!$!$&",58+$#++ % A""&#>%"/5 &/,"#&%$/",+$%# %" ,!+"0),0%" $%%) &#" 0 %%0,! +" &"#"%% ,4 ,- >$!$"% %+ >> A" #-0>"!"/ A4 !+" ":$& > %%0,!

$#",5+ &/$: ,+8$!+$& 0",$/ &"-&!+ ,-!+"/ !" ,"#"$0! #",!$ $"/#04 !+$%,/", I33(J I33(J I33(J I33(J

+"!+",%0" ;$&:@," %&"/ '

"%@ +"!+","0,! A>" '

"%@