High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25337/2015dismissed

M/S Star Wire Vidyut Pvt Ltd And ANR v. Haryana Electricity Regulatory Commission

2016-11-23Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan12 pages

!""# $%&"'() *" "

+"% ,-"%./&-"%))

. 0

!"# $ %"& !"# "& '"(%'"&% "

"/ ". "!&)*1 2! "3' 4* ".*5*

"./*'50"23' 2

"*0 "

"$ !6*"4123'2 "*" 0

$ %"&) 7*0 "

*' -*0" 4"0 )0&/ / * 8 3

9&") /*+"% ,-"% ./&-"% ))

7")

") 7"

") . 4:- , "/% !&" 2 . 4:- &"* :-/ . 4:-, "/%" ./&-

2 " *"2;*

; ("

- " * 0 "

&:) * * 0 "

* &0<< # 0 6)

4"-

" * "/"*2 4** :) 0" - 7* +"% ,-"%./&-"%))

" *"2;*))

-4

" ")

" /&0 . 4:-, "/%4"

"1 7* "- 0" " " 4:- 0" * :

24**)

*0"&" / 4** * " ") "

*--") '-./&- =

0"' " "-0"""'40"#0" ":* *--: *"%"

* "

%":/

/ ")* "/&-

-- /*":%*0" *"%"

4&- " 0"' ./&- =

0"' *"'

" 9 "-0" *-- :& "> - 9) * 0""* * "

"-0"2 *4'"2 *"' "* 9 "-0": "

)) ) 2 * "

0" * 9 / "/&-

*-- &") "& -"' "/&-

" 2 &:1 1& ) 0""' "/&-

7*&/* "-0"*90" *9" ""' 4 : 9) *

0""*"2

' 0 4"> * &)0" /

4" :%*))

"-%4%"

*" "

7*) )

8 " *"2;*3)

; = *3)

0"' * * "/&-

*--9 --*.,"1 ))

: ))

? -@"

= *3)

0"' * * 9 / 0"1 ))

&" / * ? - @" = 4" 2*"' *--:00-:-0" 0'-% ")*

*3)

& -

*"4 0"'

?"*0"0""*"2*9 / 0"*

*--:00-:- "0"' ./&- = *3)

0"' * *"' "/&-

"* 9 "-0" ""&: "* " *0"2*"

0"*3)

*-- &: "& - *"' "/&-

" * "-0" *--: )*': 9 ./&- =

) "-0"4 ) ) &"%"

/ ") *? -%" = 7*/"' *0 "

4 -?"

-%4**

& *3)

8 2*" 4&-:

" ") "*0"

0" / * ) "- 0"A )-%24**))

*"0"1 *%" = *0"

24**))

*" "2* "-0": /

) "*%"

") = ?&"*"4 &:) * & * "- 0" 0"" * * 3)

-% -%" =* : -

" ") 24** ") "%+4 % --/./&-

/*0 "4 --%0 &

. 0 / * 0"-) "% :1 " :% * " 0 *"0-% -2-"

- "*0 "

&:) **./&-

*': :%*))

2* 2*!

"%0"% "* ":& )0 *%*'

* / 4* * "/&-

# 4 &"*" &:) * * *-- / *0" 0 : /*./&-

200-: "

= *300--3&*"%4 )0 # &00"2"- 4 0- &0 1&/) + ;:-*!&0")&"

= !&0")&" 8 * *" * 2 -"

- " * " 0

&:)* ") /

* * -/ -'

& ./&-

*':0-: "*3

):-% 00"'-+ 2*!4 "B&":)0- 0"%$"

%"/&- &-:*-- / -% */"& )0

*&*"% " * " "' 0" 3"*

& # * * 2* */"& 4*** *-- /* : )+ &"*" &:)*

4 --%) * "/&-

"* &:

B& "-0"" 4-- )21& ) *--: 0"* "' "/&-

7*3) ./&-

0"' " % 1& ) "*0" B& ?"*0"0""*

*3)

8 2*

4--: 00-:- 7*" ":""

" * 00- * 3)

7*0 " 4%'"

< # " 0

2-"

- "*0 "

&:)* *--/-% "/&-

:9) ' *&*

3"-= *

& # 7*"/&-

*&-*' 9&

4* * :1 &/* : *' 7* " & " :- ") "% *

+"-"

- "*0" 0"& *00"

:> ! 8 *,-"%32

" *"2;*3; :- * ))

") "/&-

9" 04"

""& "* " 0"'

7*))

7* ) " * * 0&:- *CD.-' 0"'

" 9":-4 < *

E< ; "-"".'4";)

*0" &" / 4** * " ") "

"/&-

*--") '-AF = *

E= "- " " .'4 " 7* "

"-"".'4"& "* ./&-

*--: *"%"

4*** "

%" *--:* 0" ")* "/&-

"* "'**: *)">0- "!-"

$ !-"*")-0"1 )%:"'4

&--% :%*))

"' &"*"**"

") 0"

* ./&-

" * ., 0"1 ))

&" /* "-" *-- &:00-:-

"* "&" *7"

:-4 "'- **"'

9 "- " *-- : & "> - 9 ) * 0""* * "

"-"

./&-

" * 9 "- " "

& -)) ) 9 "-"2* "

0"* ./&-

*-- &

") 00-:- & - * "'

&:1 1& ) 0" "'

F & &

(!" '%!"! & # !

* 7* ./&-

*-- 9 -- * ., "1 ))

:))

?@ =2 = 2 * !

+"% ?"*9 /0"1 ))

&" /?@ = 4" 2*"' *--:00-:- 0" 0'-% ") * *

& -

0"' *"4 *

?" * 0" 0"" *

29 / 0"" 0-./&-

*--:00-:- " &*0"1 = +

& ! ,

(!" - , !% "#".

(!" 7*9 /./&- = *" 0-

*--: &:

& & "

E= !

"&* 7* "-"".'4"& "* ./&-

*--: &"%"

2 4*** "

%" *--:* ?@ = "'**: *)">0- "!-"

$ !-"*")-04"0"1 *--:"'4

&--%:%*))

"' &"*"**"

") 0"

* ./&-

" * ., 0"1 ))

&" /* "-"2 *-- &:00-:-

"* "&" *7"

*" 0-./&-

"'- **"'

9 "- " *-- : & "> - 9 ) * 0""* ** "-" *./&-

"* 9 "-" " 2& - )) ) 9 "- "2*"

0"* ./&-

*-- & ") 00-:- & - "' ./&-

2 * "-0" *-- : ) *' : 9 &0 *

"* 9 "-0"F 7*& *0 "

:)0" - 3 0"& - * ./&-

*4 * * 0" " 4** * "/&-

4"") "4 *"%"

%"4 ")* *

-- /*":% *0" *"%"

4 "0"' ./&-

0"' *9" ""' " 9 "-0" *--:& "> - 9) * 0""* "- 0" # "/&-

" * 9 "- 0" "

: "* 9 "-0"2*"

0"*

4 ") "& -"' "/&-

" #4 &:1 1& ) 0""' "/&-

# 0& * 9" " "' *

4 " 9) * : "*90"% *9 / "-0" 7*9" 4 " -% *%" &:- *" / 4 *- 4** ' * 0 ")0 % 4

"0" $ "" =8 2 * ))

00"' * 0"0 ) )

7*3)

8 ") *""0

:%*))

4" 8 *3)

0"' **./&-

*--:00-:---*. 4:-, "/%"1 ))

:))

")? -@"

= 2 * "- 0" &" %"

4 0"' ./&- * 3)

0"' * " * 9 / 0"1 ))

") ? - %" = 4" 2*"' *--:00-:- 0" 0'-% ")* *3)

& -

*"4 0"' *3)

?"*0"0""

* 29 / 0"*

*-- &:00-:-7*3)

4")

" ")* 0&:- *

-/D7*3) =0"' ** "-0" *--: &"%"

)) / ")? -%" = "0"' *"0"' * "' "/&-

"* 9 "-0"" "

: " * )) ) * 0"2 * "

0" * 3)

*-- &") 00-:-2& -

*"' "/&-

* "-0" *--:) *': 9 &0* *"/&-

9 "-0" = 7* " :%-"

- "*0 "

* *" ") "% 00- "/&-

B& * 0 "

;

)0 % -%:& "0" *? -%" =2

)0"**"0"1 24** " & / "? - %" = )"-%: "17*&/** "- 0" ") * ? - @"

= 2 *4'"2 *

< 3)

-"-%0"'* "*9 /0"1 ") ? - %" = 4" 2*"' *--:00-:- 0" 0'-%2 ")* *3)

" * " :%-"

- *0 "

"/" /00- *3)

" 0"' ./&- =

2 -"-%0"' **9 / 2' "*0" &:

B& *90"% "- 0"2 *--:00-:--- &*)"'

" +4'"2* ) *--: &:11& )

0""' "/&-

7*4&-) 21& ) 2 %2":

--%0"' " *3)

"*0"0"" * 3)

*"'" 0-

*' : 0"' " *3)

" %"

2-"

- " * 0 "

0 & *4 * 0"1& * 0 "

# --)" -&-

"4** 4"9) :% *))

4*-0

/*"" =8 2 *: 4**2 *./&-

4") 7*0"-) "%:1 " :%-"

- "* " 0 "/" / )0-) * ! 4-- * ":& )0 )"-%: "1 *%

: :

"%0" "1& *- *-- / /* '-% *./&-

"):%*))

" *

& -"

'")% "

2 &

* * ./&-

") :% * ))

" & "

*-- /2*300--3&*"%* 1&" / *'-% *" # )0- "" * ))

4** 4 & "

*-- /. " :)1&/) + ;:-*!&0") &"

;

&0" 8 ?"*"

) :'24 %)"

*0" 4"0 7* ) " /-% )

< 6 "0" /4**""24&- " " &"

") /*0&"0 "4***,-"%32

24 * " 0

/ '"& &*" 7* :1

*3""0"&*"& "

E3 3

- * -4 "- / / " 2"

)

2 ":& 2" / &

-"% / "--% "> /) &" &' '-0) -"% & "%2 0") / )0 *" 20" / "

&)"

&00-% -"% -- " 2 " -D

-"%"

&" /"

0" 0- "/" /

2 0")

'" ) --% : / 0- 2

& "- ,-"% 3&*"%2./&-"%))

:- *)

300--7":& - ")"

*"4*"

-*"F 7*30"' "

& ./&-"%))

* "--'- *!-'-7*" &

*': * &

/ * ! ))

"/&- -"%0&"* 0"&") 20"

":& -

-& /*0"4***-"% *--:0"&" ")* / " / )0 " -

" ") *" &" *"&/* /") "0&"* 04" " ":& &00-%4* ! 3 *" )0" &

/ 0") : &- / " / " -"% ")" 4:- &" "/%

0&"* -"% ") &* &" 7*

") "*0&"0 ") "

"0&"* 04" ") " 4:- "/% &" . 4:- "/%)

04"/ " ")

)--*%"24 2 -"2:)

2: &-/ " 2&": ")& 0- 4 " 0")"

*': -4 "") "

"0&"* 04" ")

" &" "" ") /

2*"

4 ") '4 *""

:%*))

+4'"2*

- 4 *" 4" &0"

:% * ./&-

# -"-%0"'

**))

*-- "*0"

") */ ""

&)- 9 ) * 0""*:/

/ * "-0"?" % 0"12 0"00- - : - "") "

") "

2 "

)"/&-

' &0 7*&/* * "/&-

-"-% 0"' * 9" ""' *"/&-

*-- " 9) * : "* 90"% * 0" * * "' "/&-

) " ))-%4* 4 "-0" " 2*4'"2 * " '-:- ""2*9" 4 " "-%4%"

"* "-" "-0"4 -"%'"7*3)

8 " "-0" ")= -- #

2*"/&-

' -% ")8 7>" " '"& > *-"

4** -& 04" / ""

":& )0 *

&)"

2 *0&"0 "4*** ))

*':

&2 90* ) &) 04" :9" 4* )) ")2 &- *&-: 2

"%-/ # 2 -4 %0"'

*-4"*"&-

"):%*!"*))

2 %04" :9" :%* ))

&)4* " ) ") - * 0"

2 *--:0 % *

0"%)'00"0" 00- *))

>&0*

&# *--4"> -% ") "7* &" /' /"/* % *0"% '> 1&" 24*" *'"/* -%*))

4** 9" &)04"*0 &&")-% *-- :> .1 *6 - G&/ +" "! /*!*& '

G&/ **" 0> / " @ **".0":- @