High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28576/2013dismissed

M.C.Ludhiana Th.Commissioner v. State Of Punjab & ORS.

2017-03-08Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

!" #$% &"'()*&'+# , #$ *-'.&.&,/-0+&&

1(-( +2&" -3&45+(

(.0(

!"# $%&'(#

(' ")$%*+#

() * 1(+&2+&6&,0'&, "+.

* &02+&6&,00

-3&4, "+2&

* 2+78 29&,0'&, "(.0( !

&,0'&, "(.0( :$

;;;;;

(' ")$,-.

*-'.&.&,/-0+&&(<.&9&(+ 00&0:

#$ =>- ?@.&((047+ &'&66(( +.6(+&&9&(+00&0%$

?A@"+

&'&66((,+""'0.((, ,+.&(.0( +&0'6+(- A% " #$$&04769 *('

..'& $# %! " #$$, <+0< + < . &0 +&"60&&..'&"'&9"+0&0,+",+

&'&66((,+&9.<<,'-0&+ &..'&&0,+-(,+0-0'+&9((-(&&4

.7"+&..'&+&((+9+"+0&7, +","'(&440&<+&+.&7<&(6&047+ &..'&(&&+607&0"(-'+.&7(6&0&0'00 +0,<"+&0'00'-0-"-& /01 232 4 & /05-

),.,.,+.6(((060 +&49&0 + .& " * 1(+& 2+&6&, &0 '-( " + .9&096&&&47"+&..'&4"+ 66((,(-9.&((9"+0>- ?,(+47 .0B3'0

6(,* 2+&6&(-460+&0"'&0&0

$$ $: : ((-0 47+6" -3&4,.&6"/'& 6-(9&0 4&.6,+6"+. .& <&( >00 &0 1&9 +&-& <+ + &&( <&( '-00<++6("+..& &+&0<&( 499+&6 &'+&7&,+&-&&0+2+&6&&0"&9 <+ + && " + (&0 &6 &'+&7& (0 &("0 + ..& +6-&"+&0<&(0-7(&'0 "&-"+..&&(.3&6&4&0"+7& ##A?#

"-+(-460+&+(.0(60&&..'& 4"+.-766((,/-0+&&.&79+&+6-&"+ &0C-(4(&'0+&6(&0&-(&((,+ .-7 66((, 0 0 0&0 %

##% =>- ?

@, 0(6((0+&..'& +(&00<&('+&9047"9&&..& 4" + (& 66((, &&&, <+, 0 0 0&0

##A=>- ?%@&<0+&..&,4-0'-6&70'

<&(.0-'0'09&09+&90>'+&90"&0,6-'+(( &7(-"+ &'+&7& ."".((((47<&7"&7 0'-6<&(.0-'047/&0+& &6&0+( +&0C-(( "*-'.&.&&0&((-'++ -.&6&0+

+&4&.&6+&&-+7&+&0/&0+& &6 &0 +( & (.0( "&0 .0-' &7 0'-6&7 0' +&"600<&('+&904"+ 66((,<+,000&0%$

?A@,&<0

% !" ##A +<&..'&,+-(,<&(6&&&4 "-+(-460+&+<&(&0&&0 ->.&00&7"&4-9+6+("9"+<&..'&

+0-0'+&9((-(&&4+7("&<&(+ ..&(+"-<"+&0 +&"60 "'&+&(4'+&9047&7407&0,+",+ (.0(+&3-(0'?.+6&

'&,* 2&,&0'-("(.0( :

$ (-460 +& + 0 =>- ?@( ."'79& &0 3-("0 +9&'"+.4"+66((<&(7 <+9&0+>'+&9"&0 <, &'&66((+&( ?.0+((-9&09&6"+&0+(.0(, <+'+<&(<++06&&0.<"+ &'&66((

(+(4&'D0."+6&,+&..'&<&(60&0+

&'&66((&(9+&6(&D,'&0+0&0,+-(, .&7("0(6((&"+<.

+&+&0+&0'-("+.&(,&..&(0+ .&. 4D &0 " + < +& + ( "' &0 6 +

6 (-46((("* 2+&6&&(+0-0'+&9(."'79& &03-("0,", (+''00.('0+&+.& (.0(+&04&0+&01&9+&-&,<+'+<&( .(((("/&0+& &6 +.&7<&(""'"7+ -'09&09+>'+&9 +&96">'+&9<&(0&< $

$: !

0 06 &...& '66 + >'+&9 " + &0 &( + (.0(+&4&4.'0+"&'-6">'+&9, 4-+"&'6&(+&+7+&4&0&0.:

, , + '- "" 0& < " + & 0'00 '-0 - +-7 - 80-9- 1-/ :37;:-- 1 232 '0 &- 3 4-< - =

2)<++&(4+0+&+&'-(+&+(+&6&&0 <-04"&6 &'+&7&,4-+&"+2&6'&-(0 +&606+ -3&41&966/&0 9-&&7&& 606'$::!0' $%"$::!,<+47(-4?'&-(=?&@ &"'&-(=@"2' =9@<&('.&0&0<&(+0+&+ (+&6& 0+, <+'+ +&( 4 &0 C-&(?.6& 4&(( & 0(.&'0.(,,+&(4+<(&("0&7.(47(& 47&7+6&<+&(&"+'66'6"+(',4- 4"+:+0&7"-7,$:

,<-04&(+&6&0+ +-(,+

&'&66((<&(<+(9+<+0

67<,+00&0%$

?A@'-0 ?.+'&("&-"+.&(.0(&(+.&<&( <+9&0+>'+&9"&0 (-&7,+0"+ 66(((60"0+>+&+&6"&-"+ (.0(6&0<&74&'D$: !(-.+0

+9&0>'+&9,('+.&(.0(+& "&0.'0+(&6,+C-(">'+&9(,+", &44&''.0&0+(&6(+473'0

+<.,<+-.+09+0"+ 66((C-&&6"&0,(+470(6((0

-80) ,

(' ".

-7 $%*+# 0 2> -? /@ -2

= 2@

0 > -<