High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18508/2020allowed

Paramjit Singh v. State F Punjab And ORS

2021-05-19Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal7 pages

!"# $%&%!'()**

! !"

$#%&% ' ( )* +

%,"

! !"

$#%&% ' ( )* +

%,"

( -.

* /.0/

#% - # .

# !

012 3"4 5"# 1 , ! !"

% 6"" 1 62 + 2 &

.0/

.1* 1#"&01 1!% 7& 0:

2 "

"5 5!6

4"::"

# , 8; 1 4":,

& 1"#! ;

!%:!%%!

1 /#! , ! !"

#% 5#": %#3!4 !

<#4!% "5 ,"/#% &

# &6 = #

/! 1 4 !"

2 1 "6!4 4 2 =

# !46 >8 "5 1 % ! & !"

"5 2 :7! !

01 !% 1 , ! !"

/1# % %1 : !

01 1 % 5!6 "

"5 :7! !

1 #63

!: / % /"#?!

% "

86 /1# % %1 : !

01 /

/"#?!

86 +#!3# % ,# 1 4 % "5 1 #%,"

% :

;

% 5"&# ,"6!4 "55!4!

6% /# ,& ? /" 4#!:!

:6;

#,# !

01 %"

"5 /

&#,# !

01 @ ",!

"5 &#/!

# !

01 5#": 6 !62 :#! % #2 " 1 "&# "5

! !"

6 %%!"

% & 02

#2 5"#

1; ""? 1

44&% ,#%"

% 5#": 6 !6 !

0"3# 31!46 8&

1 % : "

1 / ; /! 1

86 %1 : !

""? 1

44&% ,#%"

% !

,#!3 31!46 5 # ,#"

&4!

0 1: 85"# 1 "&# 2

"5 % # !01 / ; 8#!

0 1: 8 4? " 6 !62 :#! % #2 1;

44"::"

"5 44&%

#,# !

01 /1# 1!% /!5 6#

; ,#%

1# 5 # 8" 1 1 44&% /# 66"/ " 56

;

!% 6%"

660 /1 44&% /# ?

"& "5 1 ,#!%"

#,# !

01 / 66"/ 6? " 1!% /!5

#7! .

&# :&6 !,6 !:% "

1 :"8!6 ,1"

"5 "

86 &?1/!

# !

/ " !4 8" 1 44&%

# !

3"63

,,#"<!:

6; "

"A 4#!:!

6 4 %%

1 4":,

& 1"#! ; 3!

= B 1 %#3!4 "5 1 , ! !"

# "

1 0#"&

! /"&6

" 8 4"##4 " 1"6

% 1% "55!4!

6% 84 &% & " 1!# 5 #2 !% 6!?6; " 4": 5"#/ ,"% !

,, % 1 "# # , 8; 1 4":,

& 1"#! ; 1

6%" 8

!%:!%% #%&6 !

0 !

5!6!

0 "5 1% /" /#! , ! !"

&#%&

" !4 "5 :" !"

2 #,6; 1 5!6

!%46"%

:7! !

01 3 #!"&% "# #% "5 ,& !%1:

3 8

> 5&# 1# 8

1 4":,

& 1"#! ; #4"#

! % % !%5 4 !"

1 "# # ! %65 1 ! /!66 " 8 ,#

4"& %6 5"# 1 , # !% 0 1

/! 1 1!#

%%!%

42 ,#&% 1 , ,# 8""?

; 8 1# 1

5 # 1 7& 0:

% #%#3 2 1 "#!0!

6 #4"# % #C&!%! !"

4"& %6 5"# 1 , ! !"

# /1!6 #6;!

0 &,"

7& 0:

2*!'& 34 5! .

46&* '%!'!"'#% 1 /)7 4"

% 1 4!%!"

"5 1 4":,

& 1"#! ; "

% /! 1 1 C&!#; / ,,#",#!

1 % !%5 4 !"

#4"#

8; 1 "55!4# !%

! 1# #

"# ,# 1 #

%%!0

1 "# # /1!6

0 /! 1 1 #C&!#:

"5 #0&6 # !

C&!#; 1

" "

/"&6

,"%

% 1 , ! !"

# 1 " 8 %!%

# 4"

2 6

4"& %6 1 % %&8:!

, ! !"

#% 8!

0 ::8#% "5 1 !%4!,6!

#; 5"#4 1 3 4"::!

"&% 4#!: 8;

66"/!

0 1 1 4"# 4#!:!

6% " %4

42 %1

6% 5"# &,1"6 0 1 "#

1!% "&# 1 % 4"

1 %&8:!%%!"

# !46 > "5 1 % ! & !"

5#% 4"

% ! & !"

6 ,#" 4 !"

&,"

/1!41 4

/! 12 %!6;

#8! # #!6; :#6; !

# "

3"!

1 1"6 0 "5

#5&6 #

0 "5 ,#"3!%" 8 " # !46 >2 ! !% 1 4":,

& 1"#! ; !% #C&!# " 8 % !%5!

5"# %": # % " 8 #4"#

8; 1

& 1"#! ; !

/#! !

02 ! !%

86; ,# %&41 !

("# 1!% ,&#,"%2 5"66"/!

1# !

0# 4%% #;- 1 6!

C& 4; %1"&6 8 %&41 /1!41 /"&6 66 5"# %&41 ,& !%1:

1 % !%5 4 !"

"5 1 4":,

& 1"#! ; !%

4%% #;

> 1 # % 1 3 " 8 #4"#

/#! !

/"# "5 4 & !"

! !% 4%% #; 1 1 # % :&% 8 #4"#

1 "# # "5 #:"3 6 ! %65 % 1 # % 4

8 #4"#

1 5!6 "/2 6 &% < 1 5 4 % "5 1 ,#% 1 , ! !"

# "

0 % :7! !

; 3 #!"&% C&!#!% 1 3 8 16

1 1

6!%

% :

;

% %!< "44 %!"

% ,#3!"&%6;

!66 5&# 1#2 ! 1# !

1 "# "# !

1 /#!

"# "

1 5!62 1# !%

; ,6 &%!86 # % /! 1 1 1 # !46 > #C&!#% 1 4":,

& 1"#! ; " #4"#

% 5"# ! % % !%5 4 !"

! !% " #

86; ,# 1 ,#% %2 6 1"&01 1 4":,

& 1"#! ; 1 % /#!

& " 1 5 # "5 1 , ! !"

#%2 "8"

; /!66 4": 5"#/ " 0!3 2 1"/3#2 1# "% # " 8

; :

%&,,"# 1#"5 #5&6 ,#&% 6 "5 1 5!6 /1!41 1 #C&!%! !"

2 ! !%

# 5#": 1 5"#% 4 %2 " " 1# :

6 1

!66 5&# 1#2 1!% !

!% "5

= B

; ! %652 ( % #0!% #

% 1 44&%

% /66 % ,"6!4 "55!4!

6% !

46& 0 1 , ! !"

#%2 1#!

1# 5 #2 1 4":,

& 1"#! ; , 1 !:,&0

# "

1 8 %!% "5 1 #,"#

> = B #5&6 #

0 "5 1

#,"# 2 ! !%

,,#",#!

% " %1"/ 1 1 1"6

C&!#; !% !:,# 86 1 0!3

1!% %,4 1 6#

; 8 <

8; 1 E86 &,#:

"&# !

&8 '/%'956&*/ !" :';

31)) /<7 '#7

</ 1 E86 &,#: "&# #6;!

0 &,"

1 7& 0:

#0# * 41 !

'%!'!"'#% 6&*:4&%

41) </ <) 16 1 # % 5"# #4"# 0 % !%5 4 !"

:&% 8 8"# "& 5#":

1 #4"#

8% 4 1#"52 %&41 "# # 4

" 8 %&%

!:!6 #6;2 1 4 % "5 2*!'& 34 5! .

4&:>?

2 1 "&# 16

,"6!4 4"

86 4

" 8 <,4 " 1 3 !

56& 4 "3# 1 /!

1 "&# 16 %&41 8 %!%2 1 !

C&!#; 4

/! 1

#5&6 #

0 "5 # !46 > "5 1 "

% ! & !"

2 !

" ,&86!4 %#3

%1 66 8 !%:!%% "# #:"3 "# # &4

? <4, 5 #

C&!#; !

/1!41 1 1 5"#:

"5 1 41 #0% 5#

% 1!:

0!3

86 ",,"# & ! ; "5 8!

0 1

,#!3%" " # !46 > 6 ;% "/ <4, !"

6 &% 8

86% & 1"#! ; "

% /! 1 1 !

C&!#; !5 1 & 1"#! ; !% % !%5!

5"# 1 % " 8 #4"#

8; 1

& 1"#! ; !

/#! !

0 1 ! !% " #

86;

,# %&41 !

1&%2 1 & 1"#! ; /1" !% #C&!# ?

4!%!"

% /! 1 1 %#3!4 "5 ,&86!4 %#3

2 1 % " 8 % !%5!

5"# 1 # % " 8 #4"#

! !% " #

86; ,#

#5&6 #

0 "5 1 !:,&0

#2 ! 84":% 46 # 1

= 1 4":,

& 1"#! ; 1 % #4"#

1 #0&6 # !

C&!#; /!

%%% /!66 8 ,#, " 4": 5"#/ " 0!3 % ,, 6;2 1

5"#% !% !

4"##4 1

C&!#; 4

/! 1 8; #4"# 0 # % /1!41 1 " 5"&

1 , ! !"

#% /# 1 6"/% #

? !

1 ,"6!4 1 6"/% #

?% 1 4":,

& 1"#! ; 1 6%" "8%#3 1 , ! !"

#% 1 3 6"/# #,& !"

"5 1

! /"&6

" 8 !

,&86!4 !

#% "

& /! 1 1 :,6";:

"5 %&41 ,#%"

!% 5&# 1# "8%#3

1 , ! !"

#% # 0&!6 ; "5 0#

%#!"&% "55

1 4"

3!/ "5 1!% "&# /1!6 , %%!

0 "# # "5

0 /! 1 1 #C&!#:

"5 1"6

C& "55!4!

6%2 1 4":,

& 1"#! ; !% #C&!# " < 1"/

# ! /"&6

" 8 ,#

!% "

6; "

1 8 %!% "5 1 5"#% 2 1 #C&!#:

" 1"6

C&!#; 4

/! 1 1 4":,

& 1"#! ; 1

"&8 2 #4"#

1 /!

%%% /"&6

" 4": 5"#/ " 0!3 1!# % 1 , ! !"

#% 1"/3#2 5"# 1 1# !% " 8 %!% 1 +,& ; &,#!

"5 "6!4 /1!6 %&8:! !

0 1!% #,"# 1 #4"::

#5&6 <

"5 1 5!6%2 !

!% 1# !% " :

6 "

##!3 %&41 4"

46&%!"

42 1

4!%!"

"5 1 4":,

& 1"#! ; "

% /! 1 1 #C&!#:

"5 1"6 0 #0&6 # !

C&!#; !% " %&%

.,!

0 !

3!/ 1 5"#% 4 %2 1 "# #% &

# 41

# % %!

"/3#2 !

1 5 4 % "5 1% 4 %%2 ! !% , ! !"

#% %1 ! 6 " 8 #!

1 %#3!4 1; /!66 4"

& " 8 &

# %&%, %!"

1 "55!4!

6 #%,"

!#4 4":,6 1

C&!#; !

44"#

4 /! 1 6 / /! 1!

,#!"

"5 %!< :"

1% ,"%! !36;

! 1 1% "8%#3 !"

%2 1 /#! % 66"/

B .0/

%1"?

1 1# %, ?!

0F#

- G% F "

1 1# #,"# 86- G% F "