← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/537/2010allowed

Kamlesh Kumari And ANR. v. Union Of India

2026-04-29Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

          





     

   

       



!"

 # $% & '( )( * 

!"

$!+!,+- . +& /( )( * 01!

2 2 !+&

( ( * Whether only the operative part of the judgment is pronounced? No Whether full judgment is pronounced?

Yes  &  34

5( 5  5

5



!  " 



# "

 

 

$%"  & '

(

"

   )))) 5

5

(

* '

 

      +   

       #     *,-./--.

+%       & '

"& 

      *00   !

 "*.11

"  2  '

3                    

 4      ,"50"---46# 

708  "         9       !

   "

/5**/--0 /   

   

     :

    #  +%    '

"  



    :

+    

(  + %

5

 4   54    5 ; '

       6    

 

+%    '

  #  

 +    '

"    %       

     +  #      +       # <

 "     

  " #  "  %

   #    4    

   

 + 

 ,

          

 # 

   54 46

  5

0 =3+     &

         Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 7 /

* 5,0$ .

!,$  # # 8" # #

         >30     

           

    

      

             

   

     

 

      

 

     

           

 

         !"#$            

 %#  !"&$

   

 &'   !"($       

 

 31)

       

        *  

        (+,                  









  

 

-  

   

 

     

      

 $          .  /

 

           

                 *  

 



            



                 32 

         

       (+,         

   (+,                 



 

          

             





        

   * * * * * * 42. )     



    &$          0

 1   $        !2    !(%+ %! %(

$ 

    

 3!4 %'#+

3!'#!#(

3!(#'&+

3

) !&&!&(

 3!#&'(+

 



   

 3!!(!((

35 (''+

34'!'(

 3(''4+

 5 =3+   &

  National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 7

* 5 *' 8    #   *00"*0;6*01   !

 "*.11" #   6$                

   

  8 9$ 

       

8 $ 6 

      8 7$ :

   

           

   

 

 

     



 8 -$ . 

 

   

; /8





   '

   9      >52. 6  conventional heads

    

   

 :/

<*

    :

%(+++       

  :

 !+++++  

   :

!+++++ 

 

        

      

   :/

 0  7 

 





      



   

 

  



 

   =    

      6                   

     



 

    

   

  

  

   

  > 

       

       

  

   



     



   

  

             

   

*

   



       

 



 

        

    :

!(+++ :

&++++     :

!(+++  

                

   9

    

   

 )                         

   

 

   



  

    !+,    

)   

 



  

 



  ?

?

?

?

?

59.3)   

  (+,   

 





 / 

   &+

   

 #+, 

  

&+(+

* 

  

 (+'+

    !(, 6   

   

 59.4* 







 $ 

   &+,

 



 

    &+

 6  %(,

  

 &+(+

 !+,

  

 (+'+

  

    

 

     59.5.              

           #+#%0@ A  



    

* 59.6. 



        

  0@ B &%/

 59.7 

       59.8:

  

       

 



 

     

 :

!(+++:

&++++ :

!(+++

   

    

  !+,  

C 1 =3+   &

  Magma General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Nanu Ram alias Chuhru Ram & Others [2018(18) SCC 130]  Sarla Verma(supra) Pranay Sethi (Supra)

  #            

D216  9

  E  0 <        

  

         

  >    

     

 

 *  

F  F  

   



 F     F  F 

 F F  F  

            





 

 

  



    )  

      

       

  



 %!! Spousal consortium   

        

        

    



F  

   

     

 /  F %!% Parental consortium      



              

   F    

   

     

   

     F

%!# Filial consortium             

  

 

   6

      

          

 

   

    

      

              22  





     

       3 /    

 

  

G     

 

       

   

 3 /                

   

           

 

  

      

 23 3@  

6  

    

      

  

 

 

* 

       

              

                

 E       

     

    6 6     

    

      

  

   

           

   

  24  

    

    

 

   F

  F   E  0 <* 





     

   :

&++++  

  

'

. 

   #        #  6%        ?   

9+ ?  &  & 

 %   

 % "  +       

=#  "    '



   %         '

   #

            % 

 +    "    

   ( &

?@  , 5A#



 

    "    '

"+%

9 

"

  ₹  %    0"---"  #  "        #     &

"  



% :

 # %    *- '

&

 

    #    +%  =3+     &

  Sharad Singh (dead) Through LR. v. H.D. Narang, 2025 INSC 1164 #

 +   %  #    9

     !

 "  

+  % 

 

   +     :

   +   

  '

  @       D()     

      

                  

    

   

           

          

     

 

%++!

     )     



        

   6

          

         



    



       

                    

/   )           

         6

        



  6

              

   

    :

(+++"  

 

%++!C **

" Kandasami and Others v. Linda Briyal and Another, 2023 ACJ 1653  =3+  @&



  %   ₹       /,"---46

    

 %  /--1'

     

+   (          %   */

  

        

    

9  %    " &



    

    ₹   +  @  ;-"---      # + 

+

  +9  # >9

  C   

 !

   %   :

% 

  +% '

 *; 



 # 

#     '



 # % 

   "

 "

  @ 



     "    '

  

 #  *4;

#   @ 

# 

+ *4/   # *<

"    '



%   */   *1"   #'

" #  :

   

&

  45

*,

 # ##+% =3+   &



+ 

9   " 

  11!9 2'

#  

*,-./--.

+%    '

    %'



             

Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded *  %   ;----46 /

   7<-8 */---46<-8 ;---- ;

$    #    @ 

*4/ /*---46</---D*4/ < '   /*---46</---6/*--- <

 *1 ,  $   % <,";0"---46/*---D*/D*1 

?

 *,"---46  ?@ 

*,"---46 

&  B <-"---46@/ 1-"---46 !

!.0 +# :!+ #()*;)*; <  2,-:!+  #  +% '

 #(;*; < += +- 2

.!,+ #() ; ; < )*)* *

*0   

    " +%=3+  &

Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma  /  * R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation  

5,0$ .

!,$  # # ;

  6     

7.8       

          E *5                         

  # 

#    '

#   # 

   % 9  '

   '

     +

       # 



        "      #     *,-./--.  '

 4        



  +(       

'

 *1

 " %"    

5

5

/( )( *

 F

  G

 (46  ( 4A G

 +