M/S Apple Enterprises v. Union Of India And ORS
!"
# $ %&'()(&"!*!"
# +,&---&&*.///.!0",*12-( $3* $$$&1* 4(32$$
5&(&
3$62&
&-3&
!"#$%&!"!$ & '
!"#$%&!&% (((
&'
+ 2$32$&$3$*3%$6 + 1(32+$2$*3%$* 2-
77777 &% )" 2 - 2$& $&&$3 2 3 3$3 !
"8 !"
# 9:( .0;-$&&3<=2(&>$:%&$31%$: 1> >>&&* %-$ %2* ? 2* ?2<= 2 $--%$ 2-2$3<&3$ 0#*@0*@A#,.&$3 3(=$%%-3<=2&-3& 0 *0#*@!8,.
2$&<&$32$2-*3()2-3$($=* !"
8+$=*!"
A*>-3<%=%-$&$3<%=%-(>-& $)(3 2$-2$3) #A $3# 2(&>&$ %*
A@ "0 "@ !"
A*2->&& 2-?&$%23<=2%$ ( )%* 4(32$$ () &$%2* %>$) 3%(>&*%%3%&9$--*><-2&$3-3&;?
%3$3&(>3 B(=*?$& (32$2-2$3 &>&%C >-3<%=%&-$&$(3! * A*@A#,.
2&$>? 3$3$32$33 $DE(>$E$$*-- 2 -&(-3$ &2?%$(&%3$3"!
!"
A?$&&3 (-2-&.$.&>-& -$=(32-&& 1%
!9$;69<; 2(&>&%*
8!9 &2*2%;<= 3>$3)3(= 0#*@0*A #,.
2-&(<>3$$--%$3$3 "
!"
#(3 1% !A 2%*< 21>>>&&*(&>&6 $:%&*?29:( .!;<=$%%-)3(=$<= *0#*@!8,.$3$%%3)=2-3-&32$ >3 $>($)?2& !* @*""",.
21>>>&& &32$--%$ 2-$0#*@0*A #,.$3%$3(-2> 3-&2>$)%(&>&3(= A* @*
!,.$)?2&* <&3&3>- 0@*""",.$3 !@*""",.?$&$&>-&3 $)?2-$= !*""*""",.
2$ >332$&< %2$)32)(3?2221>>>&&?$&D(& 3 &)$0#*@0*A #,.* *&-3$(2&$3>32$<= 2( 0 *0#*@!8,.
$$ $3*23 21>>>&&3& %$ $= %$&3& $$= 2%3&$<) 2&((3%!!8 2&( 3$<)23 (32:-&&FD(3%$?G* *23 21> >>&&&<$&3=3%(>$=3%<(2&$>& 2?&&&%(3)2$ 2- 2&%(= &(>3%3&$3%= -(&
* >>$3 $DE(>$E$$$32$$2 >+,&
$$ ?$& -$) > 2 &$> ->&&* ?2%2 2& & &2$E(>$E$$?$&$&)$)3$& 3(=<=&) (3.$($$3>&3%$$ <%=%-$&$3<%=%-(>-& 2 %= $%($%&*- >$%&*%$%($&2&* >$ %&-3%$&$32$2-&3>&3%$$ $2> >- >2$$3&>$= >+,& $$ ?3<=2&& 2=?%)?&& %&,3%(>&*2 ?2?$(?$&-&32(&>&$32$%($?$& $3 %>>%$$&$% $$>( (3$($ <22 >&?$&&2&1(--2()2& >23 %(= %$&23 21>>>&&<= $&&(>)2 $--$$(2= (?*2$>(&3<= 21>>>&&%$<&$3<(&B($<
)(3 %&>$3(
&$3&3&>&&3
+"!$ & ' , +&% , "#'-!
"#'-!
./.0) 12 3 3 04 15 /6
3 3 19