← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16427/2024dismissed

Haryana Urban Development Authority Through Its Esate Officer And Another v. Savitri Devi

2024-07-18Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj19 pages



    

 

   !



 &'( )*  $

* (+,-,).

/!$ !$!















 



 #   

  . 





 

  

    !



 

 

!

!  

 ,   +%,  

 + 



!

 "

!

#

                 !

"# " $%& /0  '   ( )  *   ( )

+  *(,   - " +  '( 



  "

 " $%& /-0% %(  7 "7 ') ) * () 

1 +2(   

(   ( 

 (

9     / ,  *,    ((  ( 

 /+  /5+  , %(( 4    5-   "

""   !+ 5+-6/ $ 55 776/ /    " "# "" :

:   57#6/         ,     !--  7 " "50            5++ 776/         &     +"""6/       57#6/   ('(     +    , 

 ( 2

 '( '  ((

%  '((+  , (   !5"

"

"5     +((    +5+-5-6/    ( 5-!6/      ((    ( (,      !+ + 6/  & 

+  "+"" 6/ & 

 + +5"6/ ,&     (    /1;*% $ 1.0  - " ""!+  &

(,'(, (( 8   ((  (, (  7+!6/ ((   5+#76/    ((       "" / ""   

0



% 

 + ( (,   7!6/, ,(( ( ,          '     

  ( 

(,      /, *, () (  5 "5 '     /*  )  *  ( )

+ +$  

 <*)*)=0 *)*),   "-  "!((  (   (

2  (( ' ,>/ (  $"   

    



 

 



   

   +" ,  " #-.("         

       



   

  



 !

  " !

  "  !   

#$%    $ )!*+       

     $   "      !

   

   

   $ $& 

!

$  

         

  "

  '

'

  

$ $   

 

    "

       

   & 

 $     

   !

 $"

   '

'

   

    



  



  

 

           

      

 

$



$  

  

 $    

  /  





     &$     0$       $    1    

     

        $"      $    $      

  &$ 

  

    ;    <         

 

 

 

    $

"

 "  23 "

1+ 

    

   " $   & 

  

   

 4  $  

 

$ $ 

 

 &$

 

 $ 

 5     

 2 2

1+



 

 &   &$

  6 $ $  $         $   

 !    78 

   ! 

&$

  

              2 9 31+  5

 78 &    

 : 

"  )!*      (

   & $     

   



  



   

    





   " 

   $

 78 

    

&$

  

   

   

 &$

  5   

 &     

$  

   

  

 

 $  &   

&$

   : 

"

 $

  

       : 

3

      

 &$

 

            $     

 

    $

1

,          

   " 

    

&   : 

  



4

   



  

$ $  

    

 $ 

 5 

 &  

   $

&  

      =  %

 , +   

%(  7 "7 '     / )  *   ( )

 1 + 2($  

 <)*)=0+, "



" +('    ' *)*)+     &  1;

*% (  , 

   + ,&$& 0+& (( &



(( ' ,

     1;*% (  , ( 

 ((  +(    ( ( (    '*)* *)+ # 

     

  ,    -  "  '    / ( ) )  *  ( )

+ +  *( $  

   < )*)=0  4 )*),   !

"# "    (  

/ (  () $)  ) )

   0  ( + " "     ( >/



?

?,&6

   ,



"

"3 "3 " "9  ">

   

 



 &  ?+

 2 

 & 

  $$  

   

 $ 

 @A  1+  !

 4 )(    (@

 1='(  )     

$ ""#0 )) !-  '    

    ( )

+  )

  ((   *  ) 

  

   @    @    

(         @       

      ?   A  ?& A

 (, 

   &   >/ ( 

  



*   

     

 

 

 

*    

 $ & 

  # #-.( + 

   

#-.(( 

 2

            

 $   =

   

 *   

(    

 &   "



 *      6 

  

    

     

 =!



 =&$#-.(  

     

 

 

 

 *  

D     



       

"

   &    A   "

 

 * *    

 6 

 

   

 &$#-.(      

  

 .

.

 B  

 , * *    

  

    

 =  !

  = C"

 " 

   

  



*   C  

  

.

B  

, *  

!

  '

    

 = 2 3":

:!

  = 2 2

  4  )(       ( (   @

 )*),  ! "(<

2- &3

,-4& &.=+  )*),

"

"# " ( ( 1;*%''@   (( '         ((  

    '  @   

 ? A ?& A  -   

 '    "

  8,    ( ( 

, ((  (       % %     ( (  ' (  )(         @

  1='(    )      

/

; < +   ,

 

; <( '@    

"  

   

 $ "-0-)) 7+  /@ '1='(  ) ,

( ( (   

 ;<  ( (, 

  



; < &  >/  #

        &   



 

  (   * 

  5  '

 &  



   & &$

*  ,

E#-.( ,

";

3<,** 9F   C$





$  

 



,

E#-.(,

";

3<,** 9F

 



 ,

;

<; <";

<;<";

<; <";

<;<  ;

<; < 

(  !

! (

   "       

    6 

$ '

&   

$

   

 E G

 B ! B4  " ,  2 

  2   ,

=" * &  J  2 " H  9"A "39+ F5

*  *  *   .

IE*  * .

I";

:< , ,**

F"   

   



  

    (  A   &  &$  &  A  & 

&      

 

 &        &



= ;    4   2  % AE4 2 %A";

9<  ,**9 ?;

9< ,**;* < <93F<A

 $

"

 &  

"!





 

5

 





   E,

",  , , $*  

"K33 3;* * "  <F # # #  &

     &  

"   &

 $    

( ? % &'(&( ) *  * =   $  "  

"     '$

'

$"   

'  & &$  $  

&   & 4 & &   &$            



 

$  = "     $ =  !   $  "

 

"      '$ '

$"      $   $  "

      &$

 





      



"    &$

    5 & &    

 

    

 





&



    5   



=

    &

       

   

  



         " &$ + "    $ 

"  $ $, =  , 

;

<; < 

( "

? %&'(&(  *=   $

  &  

  "&   

"

     



  

 &4 "

 " "   "   "$   

 $" &       &

"    

"    "    

 $     

  

"&   



$

$             /=



 !



 "



   

4 ! 

   + +&

6 $ 5     

     "

   !



    

'   & 

0  $4 "

   

         

" !  

             L L  "

   

 

 

          =A $&

           &      

     4 "

     $  

 

"  &

$ $ & & '

'+ ,   

  4 6   +4 "

 

  !"  " " $ "' $  !

  

 ( " &

  





         4 &$

 %    $ &      

 6 

 

  )          

"

  &

1



      1$       

 

$  &"



$  &      

&

 

 (  ;2   ,  *   04 J   0 2 E,  *    04 J   0 2" ;

;

<3,**99F< '

'' #  &

    



  

    "  

    J.(  EJ.(  L LI % " ;

 <  ,** 

F "



 *    

'



&

$  $





 4 J4 .

.  (

$"       "

*   

( " : '

'%5

*  J.(EJ.( .(LI% ";

 < ,**   F & 

    ="   ,

;

<;&<"

 

?;,**3+ "< @5  =    ! A !

     

 &$ $ $   

$   

   & 



     " &  "   

" "   

     &    NNN

 5  

 



  0

     

         &$  

 !   5  &

 

 &$    B   "

  $     

   & 





  

&    

  

 

 

   

 



= ;   < '

' B

"

 *   &    

   

 =

 

 ?;J.(EJ.(LI % % ";

 < ,** F",** *3 +33" <  C

  

 =M. 

!



  $

 &       M *    & 

(

 

 $

$ &       $ $      $ > NNN



   5       &$   &$! $ $5  

 

 $

 A      $     & 

  5  $=   

=  

  0

  

  

 5  $=  

$        = A 04D J .

.

$

! 

" O $=  

$    $& $

  = $=

 =  =

     

  !



&6 +

 

 P  

$=

  !

&  ; <   

 & 

  !

     @5  

 

        &$ $&  5  "

  "    

    $& $&



  

 $ 

 &$

    

$= ;   < '

'5  "

*   

 '



?;,**3 33+3"3:Q "3"Q :

:< 3 5

4 

  

 &  

        & 6 



(  A   $

 

   &             

  $ 

"

 "

$     & &6

   

 (  @ @ ($ 

 "

 " !  &$ &$ $  &  

   & & 

   

0

(  



&

 

 @ (     +    & $     

$    &

(  $

  & $   5$ 4

& 

  $  &       ! &6



 (   

       & 

   &    &

$ $  

$

   $  C     & & !     

 &   



$  &$    $ & $    

     ; <  ,

 

 (  

    

  

!     

=



  =&$ $     @ , $ !



             

, 

 



$ 



 

 

 &   NNN : @ -  * 

    $ 

  )$  & 

  

 

$ &  &      

$ !    $       

$" !

!

     &$

 

  &  

 

  

   

   $     $    & 

 &   &  

   

  4

      

     

  &

$  

     @  "



 *     & 



6 

        

 &   

$&

*       

 $      &$   

 



 

    

= ;   < '

' *   &4  ,

   E#-.(  ,

" ;

3<  , ,** 9F"

*  

*.2*  6 

6 

 

$ &



     

  !

   &$      

$ 5

 *  &

  $ & & 

      

$ 

  +   

 

$D  $  4 &        

 $  =A   

   &$"



    &$ , ,

  E#-.(  ,

" ;

;

3<,** 9F &  

    & &$

 

   ' $   

 &

   = % %%C$   %.(E E%.(0& ,  ";

<3 , ,**3F



*  " $  J.(EJ.( L LI% ";

 < ,**  F" 

  

   !

    $ 6

      $ "   $    &$ $& $5  

6  ?;%.(E%.(0&  , ,  ";

<3,**3F",** 9+:

"< @5 "



* *  

( 

 

*   6 

      &$  $ $  &  

 , 

 &   &        

1

&    

      &

$          6$  &$

R @ C 

  &     &

$    !   +!

  &$  



$"

*   1B    $ & 

 

A 

*    1B  

   

   

    6$         $   "

       

   

 

$  $  



    $  

    &   & &&  = ;   < > % %5  "  

   &$" 

  

 

   

 

$ 

 

  $      $  ="& 4&$ $

  

   

 (  5    

 *   ,

 E#-.(,

";

3<,** * 9F"



 

 *.2*  6 

 6 



$ 

 

 $  "

 

   $ 

 6 6  

*  

&6  

 (  * '

$"

     

     & 

$ 

 " 

&$     % %      ',@

 1='(

) 

 ; <"(  

   

   , ' ,           



'    ,   ,(         

        ,   (     , +  ( (,             ,   , '   '   +   +            (

 ''     

' , , ( 1+

  ( ) (  ( 1;*%' '@   (( ' )         @       

      ?   A  ?& +A   &/ ((     )  % +-75(((( '1 ='( ) 8 , @



 B  +     '(( ,  /((   "

"" '  ('

 

 2  '( '  (   

(    (, ,(  2'    8   ( '    +   ,

   

,   !5 "

" "5+' 

  ('((  ( ' (  ) )*)((' ,  >/

 

 A  

   &

 



  '

'



    A    

      

  

  2"":

1+2 "91+   

A   

 

  

$

  



      

    2:3 1+" $    2:

91+     2 :9 1+  ! 2

1+  

 !

     !

    ( (

 #-.(  $"  !

   &  

 !  $&$

 "

"

       $  





5 # #-.(

$   !

   $   & & 

 $B

" &6 

 &  

         &$

    

&  

   

  

 

"

 ?+ S5   & & &  $ 4 $S &    



  



     

    5    

& 

$   

    

 A   

       

 "

A  



9  

!



 #-.(        "   ! ;

;!

  < !

         !

   

  $        &  

   5 #-.((

$+   $

    ".$       

/

 '

5  .

*     $   



 ,

 * 



   '

5     

   

  

     

 #-.(   $ 2  

      C

  



"

     # 4 (   1. 2 

  ( ,  (     (   

    '   (  ( , 

 2(' , ((   ()

 %(  ( 7 "

"     ,   7  "          '   ,   ( 7  "  1 +    *   ( , ,'      (' (     (  2      ( 

& ('       &(  8  +     (     /1 .,('  ' )*)(( )*)  ,(@   &   @( , +)  ) %(( &   (( (          

 (      ((( (  )*) )*)  

   '

5

@

    6.,'&

-678&#



 (((   (   6.,'&

-678&#( '  '

'1='( )    ,;9& 4('&3

-678&#   ( (   6.,'&

-678&#  ' (   ( 

(,

(  '(    ,   

  ' (  (   ,

( @

     8  &   '     @

     +  2  @

 (( (   (      2 '      ((   (  5   8            )   &       % ( 5   )   8    (2   ,'  ( ' ,  ', !

 

  

(     639 /"

$ 8&:

&8)8&

$



4 1  ?

  & ?



!





?T1  ?T1