Satbir And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Others



   
      
 

 !"# $%& '

 

!$%$(%)# $%&   


 


  
   
  
*& +, *

-
 -- .

+, *

-


.,       !
" 
#"$"% &'" (# !)!"*%

* % """+# !
""

#!"

%  % """ !)!"*% &'"+# !,#"* ,"!"'#" "% &'" !
#&"$ " % &'" !- "$"% &'"" !


#"#"% &'" ( .

 //// -- .

/ 

0 #  '*"$  $"

    #  "  +      (  " $" "$ $"

# '' %%$( #*' " 01234205(# """ &$%# %# *"  *" ($"'6%#%# '$

."*&"

*(  (#6 *' 4 #  *"  '*  ""  (  #    #" ('(**  ' %    *")   $%    #  $" "  (
'020(# #"7$"" ""' 8"  '6%  #"

*"  "  *$  '%  4209 :#"(  (  #  (    "  #  ;'  (  4209;< "  '"$



'" #='(4209;%# # """'40(4205% &+#(">"' #"(%#"#*" " ."*&"

*(#*&" *'#(%# #""  #"#*" %'&(#"**"'#

"'6  '      # 8"  '6  '%  0531 :#"((#'"** "#;'(0531;<# '$ (** $" %"#"."*"&"

*(  (# *&" *'%# #""&"*"

*( '$

*" ($"'6

         
     



                   

  

! "

#

 $%#"

                   "   &  $%#"

'

  ""

 "'        ( )#  

 *  "

# 

"  "

 #' #

 '  ""' "

$%#"
+ 9 #" "& #+%#"# "#'"*(#  *" +###"& '' '"*# # #"&"'6 #*" * (& (#&" *  1 !&%"*' #"# #"& ' "

#"''(&  '$"%"$'# "%# *" #*" (#*" +"

?"' #*" %+#"%# '  ?'

 

#    *"     "'6%  # #  $")  #  $ 

('":< @     "    $  #  #"  #    "*   7A.49B@@.4205  (  #  7%  '#"**  # "'6' %&+(
'41:4<(#;'(4209;% +#'#+" $ # #" $"

21004242$( #  ?

$      ,  -#  "     .  / 0,12323$ 

4
 C (#"& #+%#"&+( '*"B(#*' " 01234205(# """ &$%# "'6 *"  *" ($"'6#*&"(# *':"<>"' #"( 5
6-# $

 ""    7  4"  

 &"'            '   " 

' ( !

  "#

    !

&  ""

 

! "'  

"   
!

&"

 #'   '  ""'  

*                   "

  8' 


9&

( !:#

 "   

 "  

 *

  ;   

   

0



'    "   "    "

 "   

     " '   %#"      & '   "  #  "'  %#"  

 

        '    "   ''      

 
2!; "      

*

    "&

!  ##

"#

 < 

    #



   
B ##"&"*(* ":>.

3< (#"#'' ) *" (#*"  &+(#*':"< 5 #%#" "& #+%#"# ."'6 *"  # "  '" *D#*" "$"#%#*"  *"

($"'6   &"

*."* 1 $% 2$!

!3)45%6 (895 5$% $2 :1!%# )$(% :

2$!

;4545$%!

3 ""#"#  7A.

49B@@.4205 (  #  7  +#  *(  (  #  "*  *"'#

"'6'  '$ '*"  '$*" &+( #& 
'41:4<(#;'(4209;%" %#"

+ '$ $ %21004242 +&%+## &(
'020(#;'(4209;+">'"#

'

$+##+:"<+" (#7% +#$(#" &%#'* #"* +'*"$>$:<*(:<($"'6%+#"% #$ $")#" '*"$#"*+% # % #" $"

$#"*+% #  "$   *"

   #  "  +  %  #  ""' ##'*(*%"% "(   4*477 02 #  *"  '*  ""  (  #    #" *") # $%"&*(
'020:"<"+**"% "'#('*"B(#*' " 01234205(# """

&$%      #  "   $  '$  '$** # %#("'("'(''> ""

"# B  (  #   *%    "(( "&%  "  (#    #     #  '' %'+#(">"' #"( =5
6 



"  



#  " ""    $>  % '"  

 $> % '"

'7
 /

 '"3"

6# "

 #'



' #  "$
6     

'

 && 1? @A

  
+ 00   "

 (  #  "  '%    $")  "#'

$ ':<%#"#*" ""$") (#"  *'" # "*D %"*D"

*%" %" &"

*(("'*" #" *'76*%# '*(#'"" %#"#*" " #  ."*    &"

*  (  ("'*"  #  "   *'

#'"+**"" $$ %#&



(
'020(#;'(4209;&+(#*' "

01234205  7"*%    &"*  $"  (  "*  *"'#

"'6'  #;'(0531;%## %("%(#*" % #%'"** +#  #  & *   .&  #   *'  %  #    "# '$***"+(*#" #"#"

&  $

"&*(
'020(#;'(4209;%*' "

01234205%'$**'"'" "*" "#"

 #"  #  "      #%  ""    .

"*&"

*(#  *" %#(("'*" # " *'%"#"  %"&*( ?'& '$*"%"$"

 #"#'' %" '# "

& ?'&#'$*"% $"("&%#"# *" "" "*'$(#*"*"*"  #'$*(#*&" *'#(%#*"

'*(##""

**") #"

&" $% #$ #&(
'020(#;'(4209; " E%%*' " 01234205 04 7'*    &  (  +#  &  # "'6  *" %    #     '' %  #  #"   "':<(('":<:"<%# +##
" '$ "

*+(#"'6 *" *"*#&$( '$*    "

*  +#  &  #  "'6  *"     #  .
"%#$")+**$+ +##"$ (# & '  ;

*>7#'"(

   

 ! "

#   $%&'(() 
)%&$")"*(# "'6 *" # # *'"'#%#&( 

 

*D %#>' (#"

&+ ""

*+% "#"

*%"# #"'$" '$('#

#
"( """%#+* "**# .& $ # *':<#(%>'"&">'"* ''$"'%"$'#"%'''( #"<  > "  $  (  '$"  $  $ %  # $") #*6 "%'""  #
" >'#6%#%# #"""$(."* &"

*((#"'6 *" %$" '$"



#
"( """ +&%#"

&>'""&"*"

* #' (#'" 09 7'*"*+##" " #*"



"* &'" "*% """#"+# "+"*(#*'

:"< "'&' "(# " #"& #*#*':"<*)* .'"**  01 !&%""*(""@(#*(*

# #+%&"* #"#"

#  '.#"  #"&  '&  #    "$  (  $

'$"#%# #'*"$(*":<>$(#   *" %  ($  #  "'6  "#  '$  '$** *&"#'" '*"$ ($#7 0@ #(('(#"

&%#"%# #"

$    "''  #  &"*  (  #  *"'#  (  #  "'6 ' %" # #""# ($'#"** # &"* (#*"'# (#"'6'  0C #%#7"*'"* " *+" ,-.  /  . 012.2 3 45

<

    6" *%

 )(

%#"

* #

"*+#$*""#"+#*&" ""

"#(#& ':"<">"' #"( =5
B" # ' 

" "     

'

       "    <    #'< 

  ( 789""""3  2:"    4 "4
  "

22;$ 4<2  %%  - :=4   :  "     10-         24"

  %"4":4- 20 :$     $ "     10-%  4<2  2  "  4   >(?@ 789"""  4 "4
4 30  4 2  4% 02 "     44%    4"

3  "   2 442  4<2   .43 %  2  "  4   >(?@ 789""" 44"

0 3"  "

" 4<2 "

:4- 20 :$

   $%"32%"

" "

 :2;%%" 42 :" .  % 0 .24-"  @ 25
6 '$323>"

           

 " #" 

   #    "      ?'  # 


/# #



    23>

 # 

       

6"

"   

$

'   #$3 23> '@ ;
223 

"

' '  8$%#"                  

    '      

"

   # "= #

+ = +
@#' &"'      #        $  3          '    $ ""

! #'       



 $  3           $

'                  $ %#"8 '  "#' $  4          

5         #

  " 

 "= #

+= +




>3
6"

$ 23> $4

5 " 

   $3
6#'' $4

5



&    $  3
 6          # $3 #?  '




6 



  

" #              "        $  %#"   "

<#  ?'  '


>
B " #$3 #   $%#"  " *  '  "

'  = #   +=  +   '

  4 42 .2:4 .2. 
7-."

  2..8 >
  

  #  

       @C

$

"    

  '   $ 323>  *  " <"

 $%#"    #

  

 #

"= #

+= + 

 '

#& ' =



+

 6      '      '   

!

   '    

    $  %#"  ?'    &      $  3          23> #$'#" #' ?""

 


""

    " '

  
,  #'  ""

       

      !


6  #" '

 

  ""

 

      !     &"  $   

5
D  

 #$ %#"8 '  "

 "

  #     

   

                   



6# #  "           "

   #             & "( =AB&

B,C67&8 6 '   $ 323> = *+  " <

 '#"                

        

      #  " = #

+= + ' 




AB&

B,C67&&8 6 ;
! '#
6 $3'#   #   

' 



  '



AB&

B,C67&&&8 6                  '#
 6

# #'      #  "  = #

+    =  +'   # 

 *     

 #  " 
+ 5%1:

!#!

$2
$(!4

0B "($"#%#7( $#+% #"$ '$**(&*%#6   $

+#'#(%#"$ $ +#'(@2%222E.

"'#(# (#+#  #$+## ;- 4"

  " .

 '

"

  " 

* ($ " #



""* "#
"''  05
'#$"'"*(#"  ' %#%"**#  "*'":<%("%"*" :<  (

=-- .>

  =.,  >   

  )"& # 747!

;1?5%6 !1 $%# &

$ 747!

!;$!418:

&

$