High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15504/2023dismissed

Nachhattar Singh v. Financial Commissioner (Appeals), Punjab And ORS.

2024-08-22Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger9 pages

# "

"$%& )&*+,+'-

.. $*//$%%$0 1+-2/ ......

&%+%+'-&0

3&0,4,

77&$5,8 4-9$:

'%/&0, ......

&,7'-)&-%,

;!<

1 1 !

0&,&-% 0.

.<.

!$9$98 )='*$%& 7&%+%+'-&0.

+06$59+% 1+-2/ "+>$-$8 1&-+'0 " 4-9$:

?.1.

+,,'>$58 )='*$%&

. . 1 !

&%+%+'-&0

$*//$%%$0 1+-2/ (+5&) +-,%$-% *+=+5 >0+% 7&%+%+'- 4-)&0 0%+*5&, '-,%+%4%+'- -)+$8 +-%&0 $5+$8 ,&&@+-2 >0+% -$%40& *&0%+'0$0+ ,&%%+-2 ..

--&A40& 8 $%+$5$ "+=+,+'-8 $%+$5$

,/'0% ;"+=+,+'-$5 '66+,,+'-&0; >/&0&:B ..

--&A40& 8 '55&*%'08 <4)/+$-$

,/'0% ;'55&*%'0;8 $77'+-%+-2 =+55$2& 2/>$0 ?/4>$9$ !$948 &/,+5 $20$'-8 "+,%0+*% <4)/+$-$C

$6 1+-2/ =+55$2& 2/>$0 ?/4>$9$ !$94.

(40%/&0 70$B&0 6$)& ,&%%+-2 ..

--&A40& 8

77&$5,8 4-9$:

,/'0% ;

'66+,,+'-&0;8 >/&0&:B $77&$5 (+5&) $2$+-,% ..

--&A40& )+,6+,,&).

!0+&(5B8 )&6+,& 1/0+ 6$0 1+-2/8 70&=+'4,

1 =+55$2& 2/>$0 ?/4>$9$ !$948 70'*&&)+-2, >&0& +-+%+$%&) (+55+-2 =$*$-*B.

740,4$-*& 70'*5$6$%+'-

64,%0+ 64-$)+ *$55+-2 47'- $775+*$%+'-, (+55+-2 ,$+) =$*$-*B8 $775+*$%+'-,

+-*54)+-2 '-& ,4:6+%%&) $6 1+-2/8 >&0& 0&*&+=&)8 $**'0)+-25B8 %/&+0 $-%&*&)&-%, >&0& 2'% =&0+(+&) (0'6 5'*$5 7'5+*&.

% %0$-,7+0&, $+:

&/,+5)$08 >&55 14:

$2+,%0$%&8 $20$'- 0&*'66&-)&) -$6& $('0&,$+) =$*$-*B ('0>$0)&) '55&*%'0.

. /& '55&*%'08 47'- *'-,+)&0$%+'- 6$%%&08 =+55$2& 2/>$0 ?/4>$9$ !$948 =+)& ..

--&A40& .

&,7'-)&-%

$6 1+-2/

*/$55&-2&) '55&*%'0;, ..

--&A40& (+5+-2 $77&$5 :&('0& >/'

=+)& +%, ..

--&A40& 8 $55'>&) $77&$5 ..

--&A40&

$6 1+-2/ =+55$2& 2/>$0 ?/4>$9$ !$94.

!&+-2 $220+&=&) $2$+-,% $('0&,$+) ..

--&A40& 8 70&(&00&) $77&$5

:&('0&

>/+*/ )+,6+,,&)8 =+)& ..

--&A40& .

$('0&6&-%+'-&) *+0*46,%$-*&,8 (+5&) +-,%$-% *+=+5 >0+% 7&%+%+'- 0&5+&( ,8 -'%+*&) $:'=&.

<&$0-&) *'4-,&5 ,4:6+%, &00&) 5$> ($*%, $55'>+-2 $77&$5 70&(&00&) $2$+-,% >&55 0&$,'-&) ..

--&A40& 8 '55&*%'08 $77'+-%+-2 <$6:$0)$0.

% ,4:6+%%&) ($+5&) %$@& -'%& >&55 ,&%%5&) 7',+%+'- 5$>8 <$6:$0)$08 */'+*& '55&*%'0 -'% :& 5+2/%5B +-%&0(&0&) >+%/8 &=&- +( %>'

=+&>, $0& 7',,+:5&8 4-5&,, %/&0& 7$%&-% +55&2$5+%B '0 7&0=&0,+%B %/&0&+-.

% (40%/&0 ,4:6+%%&) 6'0& 6&0+%'0+'4, %/$- 6'0& &)4*$%&) %/$- /+, -$6& 0&*'66&-)&) 5'>&0 0&=&-4& '((+*+$5,.

% -&A% ,4:6+%%&) &=&-

($+5&) *'-,+)&0 $('0&,$+) $,7&*%, >0'-25B 47/&5) '66+,,+'-&0.

% *'-%&-)&) *'45) -'% /$=& '-5B 70&0'2$%+=& '55&*%'0.

**'0)+-25B8 70$B&) +6742-&) '0)&0, :& '55&*%'0;, ..

--&A40& 8 $77'+-%+-2 :& 0&,%'0&).

&0 *'-%0$8 *'4-,&5 $77&$0+-2 '77',&) ,4:6+,,+'-, 6$)& :&/$5( ,4:6+%%+-2

6'0& 6&0+%'0+'4, %/$- +-$,64*/ B'4-2&0 $2& %/$- &A,&0=+*&6$-8 >/'

)&,&0=&, 70&(&0&-*& /& /$) 0&-)&0&) ,&0=+*& $%+'-.

% (40%/&0 ,4:6+%%&) 0&*'66&-)$%+'-, 6$)& 5'>&0 0&=&-4& '((+*+$5, $0& -'% :+-)+-2 '55&*%'0 '55&*%'0 0&D4+0&) $775B /+, '>- 94)+*+$5 6+-) >/+5& ,&5&*%+-2 6',% ,4+%$:5& *$-)+)$%& <$6:$0)$0.

% *'-%&-)&) ,+-*& '55&*%'0 /$) ($+5&) %$@& -'%& 6',% =+%$5 $,7&*% :&+-2 B'4-2&0 $2& &A,&0=+*&6$-8 0+2/%5B '55&*%'0;, <$6:$0)$0.

% (40%/&0 *'-%&-)&) '66+,,+'-&0;, (40%/&0 47/&5)

%/&0&('0&8 -'

+-%&0(&0&-*& 0&D4+0&) :& 6$)&

>/+*/ >&55 0&$,'-&) 94,%+(+&).

, 0&2$0), *'-%&-%+'- *'45) -'% /$=& <$6:$0)$08 ,4:6+%%&) >&55

/$=& ,$6& 7'>&0, $77'+-% '55&*%'0.

0&2$0)8 0&(&0&-*& 6$)&

+=+5 .

**'0)+-25B8 70$B&0 )+,6+,,$5 >0+% 7&%+%+'- 6$)&.

/$=& /&$0) *'4-,&5 7$0%+&, /$=& 7&04,&) 7$7&0:''@ >+%/ %/&+0 $:5& $,,+,%$-*&.

&0&8 >'45) :& $77',+%& ,%$%& 0&5$%+=& 6&0+%, *$-)+)$%&,

6&-%+'-&) '55&*%'0 +%, .. 8 >/+*/ 4-)&0 $0%+*45$0, &%+%+'-&0

$*//$%%$0 1+-2/

&,7'-)&-%

$6 1+-2/ 2& )4*$%+'-$5 D4$5+(+*$%+'- E %/

&*'66&-)&) &/,+5)$0 1"8 $20$'-.

&6$0@,

&%+0&) 5&0@ (0'6 4-+*+7$5 '4-*+58 $20$'-.

A,&0=+*&6$-8 /$=+-2 0&%+0&) (0'6 +5+%$0B.

7&04,$5 $:'=& &A%0$*%&) *'67$0+,'- *$-)+)$%&, >'45) ,/'> B'4-2&0 $2& %/$- ,4((+*+&-%5B &)4*$%&) A,&0=+*&6$-8 /$=+-2 0&-)&0&) ,&0=+*& $%+'-.

+=+5 8 '-;:5& 1470&6& '40% /&5) >+%/ 0&2$0) 1%$%& 4-9$:8 $2& *$-)+)$%& 0&5&=$-% ($*%'0.

, ($0 0&*'66&-)$%+'-, 5'>&0 0&=&-4& '((+*+$5, *'-*&0-&)8 $5%/'42/8 ,$6& 7&0,4$,+=& =$54&8 /'>&=&08 '55&*%'0 -'% :'4-) ,4*/ 0&*'66&-)$%+'-,.

#$$ %& '

()

+=+5 8 /&5) *''0)+-$%& !&-*/ '40% ($+540& 7$0% '55&*%'0 *'-,+)&0 *'-,+)&0$%+'-, 70'=+)&) 4-)&0 4-9$:

<$-)

&=&-4&

45&, 5+@& ,&0=+*& 0&-)&0&) $%+'-8 $6'4-%, 7&0=&0,+%B.

1+6+5$0 =+&> %$@&-

#$$ %&&'

()

1 .

40%/&08 *

+=+5 8 ':,&0=&) *''0)+-$%& !&-*/ '40% >&+2/%$2& :& 2+=&- &A,&0=+*&6$-.

1%+55 (40%/&08 + ( !

!!, '

()

+=+5 8 /&5) "+=+,+'- !&-*/ '40%

/$) 0+2/%5B >/+5& ':,&0=+-2 &A,&0=+*&6$- /$) $-)8 %/&0&('0&8 /& ,/'45) :& 2+=&- 70&(&0&-*& <$6:$0)$0.

70&,&-% *$,&8

>/+5& )+,6+,,+-2 $77&$5 (+5&) 7&%+%+'-&08 =+)& ..

--&A40& 8 ':,&0=&) 4-)&0

"# "$

$ $ ) * "+,

) ) - ./ "+0 ,

1 2 # !

% &(

) * "+, ) ) - . / "+0

1 3 4

5 1 7 ) - /0 )!) /!0 * 8 -/901!!/!0:9- ;

< 1 !

1 "+ 3

1 !

5 1<

/ 0 ;

< "+

; ; !

1 7 6 4 !

;

9 /90 )!) /!0 9:

=((= 3'

" # "

# !

"# "

)

"# " !

)

=+&> $:'=& )+,*4,,+'-

(0'6 7&04,$5

$6 *'-,+)&0&) =+&>

0+2/%5B 47/&5) >/'

/$)

1 =+55$2& 2/>$0 ?/4>$9$ !$94 47'- -'%+*+-2 B'4-2&0 $2& %/$- &A,&0=+*&6$-8 >/'

)&,&0=&, 70&(&0&-*& &,7&*+$55B >/&- '%/&0 6&0+%, *$-)+)$%&, (0$B8 $0& &D4$5.

40%/&08 0&2$0), 940+,)+*%+'-*'67&%&-*& $77&55$%& $4%/'0+%B 0&=+,+'-$5 $4%/'0+%B $77'+-% *'-*&0-&)8 "+=+,+'- !&-*/ '40% -

*$,&

,470$8 /&5) 4-)&0 >'

4 !

+ 6 ; ( ( ,

) $

' 6 ; ( (,

4 !

3 .

40%/&08

()

+=+5 '-;:5& 1470&6& '40% -)+$8 >/+5& )&$5+-2 >+%/ *$,& <$6:$0)$08 ':,&0=&) +(

)+,,$%+,(+&) >+%/ '66+,,+'-&0;, 0&$,'-+-28 -'

)'4:% '7&-

0&)&*+)& 6&0+%,C $**'0)+-25B8 0&6$-)&) :$*@

0&)&*+)+-2 +,,4&.

=+&> $('0&6&-%+'-&) ($*%, *+0*46,%$-*&,8 *'-*54)&)

4-9$:

0+2/%5B 47/&5) $77'+-%+-2 =+55$2& 2/>$0 ?/4>$9$ !$948 &/,+5 $20$'-8 "+,%0+*% <4)/+$-$.

**'0)+-25B8 %/&0& -'

,*'7& $-B +-%&0(&0&-*&

'40% +6742-&) ,.

'%/&0 $0246&-% 0$+,&).

&,45%$-%5B8 +-,%$-% *+=+5 >0+% 7&%+%+'- ($+5, ,$6& $**'0)+-25B )+,6+,,&).

&-)+-2 $775+*$%+'-

,8 +( $-B8 ,/$55 ,%$-) *5',&).

1 !

,9@, /&%/&0 ,7&$@+-20&$,'-&)

#&,

/&%/&0 0&7'0%$:5& #&,