High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20954/2017dismissed

Beant Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS.

2017-11-07Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath7 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'()#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#, - - - -

#!'"%'./ #"%"%'#, 0& "!"# 1'2!+!'3"/#,& #&4'3#'"& 5( 5( 5( 5(6 75 6 75 6 75 6 75 885 885 885 885 ,#&#'"( 5,2!9!:%'./#/!'-3)$!"#- ,"/#4#"%"%'#, 885 - 885 - 885 - 885 - /#4#"%"%'#,%&!..,%#)#3!.!%'&""/#,3#,&3!"#3; 4!&&#3+9"/# %)%&%'!:!'!:

%$#,-5!2%"/! %)%&%'-44#, !,% !+ !'!:-%,$:#*,%"&!,< =!'3 ; 4!&&#3+9"/#14#,%'"#'3%'. !'!:

%$#,-44#, !,% !+!'!:-%,$:#*,%"&!,<= #&4'3#'" %:#3 !' !44:%$!"%' +# ,# ,#&4'3#'" >?

,$,#!"%' !@/!:?A!"#,$1,&#*!,@#3!& ,*5.!

1,2%B "!.A!:%5%',/#!44:%$!"%'A!&3%&*%&&#3+9"/#

' > #&4'3#'" %:#3!44#!:!.!%'&""/#&!%3,3#, +# ,# ,#&4'3#'" ? A/%$/ A!& 3%&*%&&#3 ' ' "/# .,1'3 "/!" /# A!& '" "/# 4!,"9 !'3 /#'$# /!3 ' ,%./" " %:# !44#!: #&4'3#'" $/!::#'.#3"/!",3#,+9A!9 B - A/%$/ A!& !::A#3 ' B> !'3 3%,#$"%' A!& .%)#' " ,#&4'3#'" ?"4!&&!&4#!@%'.,3#,#&4'3#'"-%'&"#!3 3#$%3%'. /%*&#:

-,#*!'3#3"/#$!&#+!$@",#&4'3#'"> , 1,"/#,,3#,&-A/ )%3#/%&,3#,3!"#3; !::A#3"/#!44:%$!"%' %:#3+9,#&4'3#'" /# &!%3 ,3#, A!& $/!::#'.#3 +9 "/# 4#"%"%'#, %' !44#!: +# ,# ,#&4'3#'" A/%$/ A!& 3%&*%&&#3 ' ; " %& &1+*%""#3 "/!"

+"/"/#1,"&+#:A/!)#'"!44,#$%!"#3"/!""/#:!'3 ,#&4'3#'" %&4,4#,:9+#%'.%,,%.!"#3"/,1./A!"#,$1,&# !'3"/1&"/#,#A!& ' ,#C1%,#*#'" A!"#,$1,&# " %& !:& &1+*%""#3 "/!" A!"#,$1,&# $!*#%'"+#%'.*,#"/!' ?

9#!,&+!$@!'3&"!,"&

,* 5.! 4%'" B ?:# " !.A!:% 5%', !'3 ,1'& 4!,!::#: " "/# !.A!:% 5%', !'3 "/# 1,"& +#:A /!)# %.',#3 "/# !$" "/!" "/# A!"#,$1,&# /!&&"44#3,1''%'. ,*"/#:!&" ?

9#!,& /!)#/#!,3:#!,'#3$1'&#: ,"/#4#"%"%'#,!'34#,1&#3"/# ,#$,3 /# 4!&&#3"/#,3#,3!"#3; A%"/"/# ::A%'. +&#,)!"%'&( D:: "/# $ &/!,#,& 4,#&#'" A#,# /#!,3 $!,# 1::9!'3"/#&%"#*!4!:'.A%"/"/#, 3$1*#'"&' %:#A#,#4#,1&#3#4,"& :%A!:A#,#!:&4#,1&#3-

*,%"&!, /!& )%3# ,3#, 3!"#3 ,#*!'3#3 "/%& $!&# " "/%& 1," " 3#$%3# !.!%'!&4#, !$"!'3"/#&!%3,3#,A!&!:& 4#,1&#3/5%'./!/A!-731'&#:

, !:2%"%'./&?1,!"%'./!'3!"'!* %'./&?!,A!'%'./!,.1#3"/!"8/!:!" 4%'" /!& +##' :A%'. &%'$# "/# $'&:%3!"%' A/%$/ /!& +##' 3#&",9#3 +9 44&%"# 4!,"9 #!'" %'./ &? /1/!, %'./ !'3 *#,.# A%"/ /%& A' :!'3 /# 3$1*#'"!,94, !:&&/A#3#E%&"#'$# "/%& 8/!: "/# ,#&",!"%' A/%$/ *9 $:%#'"&

> !,#3#*!'3%'./%&@/!:#E%&"%'/1'@ 5.! 1,2%B "!.A!:5%',/# ,#4,"& :%A!: !'3 !%+ #/&%:3!, 8!:!'1, !:& &/A& "/# #E%&"#'$# "/%& 8/!: !& 4#, "/# ,#)#'1# ,#$,3 8/!&,! > /!& +##' &/A' !& .!%,*1*@%' $/#*#8/!:!'3!&4#, !*!+!'3% ,"/# 9#!, ; !'$/!9!" %& "/# A'#, "/%& 8/!:?7!'3 /# #!,:%#, 5!2%"/!

%)%&%' !& A,'.:9 3#$%3#3 "/# $!&# ' > +#$!1&# %'&"#!3 ,3#,%'. "/# 8/!: 3#*!'3%'. +9 *9 $:%#'" ! 8/!: /!& +##' ,3#,#3 "/,1./ "/# :!'3 !"'!* %'./ & 4#, "/# ,#4," :%A!: %" A%:: +# !44,#$%!"# " ,#&",# "/# 8/!: !" %'" %'&"#!3 4%'" *,%"&!,/!&!:&3%&$1&&#3%'/%&3#$%&%' 3!"#3 "/!",#4," :%A!: !'3 !%+ #/&%:3!, 8!:!'1, &/A& "/# #E%&"#'$# 8/!: !" %'" /# $!&#

!:2%"%'./)?& #!'"%'./,#.!,3%'.8/!: A!&4#'3%'.%'1,"+1"91,.3&#:

/!& %'&"#!3 "/#,#&",%'."/#8/!:%'3%&41"# ,3#,#3!8/!:"/,1./"/#:!'3 !"'!* %'./&?!,A!'%'./A/#'"/#,#A!&' 3%&41"#,#.!,3%'."/!"$'&#C1#'":9"/#$!&# A!& ,#*!'3#3 " 91, 1," " 3#$%3# !

,#&/,>/ #!'"%'./&?/1/!, %'./ &"!"#3 "/!"

,* 5.!

1,2% "-!8/!:,1'&4!,!::#:"!.A!: 5%', ,*A/%$/:!'3 !:2%"%'./&? 1,!" %'./ A!& %,,%.!"#3 !'3 "/# 8/!: A/%$/ %& ! 3#*!'3%'. '#)#, #E%&"& !" "/# &4"/#3#$%&%' > 4!&&+991, 1,"*!9+#$'

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

%'3%'.,#4,"A!&*!3#"/!"%,,%.!"%' ,* 5.! 1,2% B " !.A!: 5%', $!' +# *!3# %' ! +#""#, "/#9 ,* 8/!: %'"

+1" "/# !+)# !,#! %& .,!* !'$/!9!" !'3 "/# &!*# /!& +##' !*!:.!*!"#3+9 #!'"%'./A%"//%&A' :!'3 ' "/# +!&%& !+)# &"!"#3 !$"& !'3 @##4%'. %' )%#A "/# +#""#,*#'" $!'!: %,,%.!"%' 4,"%' &/A' !& 5.!

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

"#,/#!,%'.+"/ "/# 4!,"%#& !'3 "/# :#.!: !3)%&#,& "/# $!&# A!& !321,'#3 " /# 1'3#,&%.'#3 )%3# :#""#, '1*+#,

B 4#$%!:?

? 3!"#3 3%,#$"#3 "/# 1+ %)%&%'!:

%$#,- :%A!: " $'31$" "/# &4" %'&4#$"%' !'3 &1+*%""#3 ,#4,"' ' $!&# A!& !321,'#3 " 31# " '' ,#$#%4" ,#4," 1+ %)%&%'!:

%$#,- :%A!: ' "/# /#!,%'. A!& !321,'#3 " 31# " $#,"!%'

%$%!: A,@& ' +"/ "/# 4!,"%#& $!*# 4,#&#'" !:'. A%"/ "/#%, :#.!: !3)%&#,&7#.!:!3)%&#,& +"/"/#4!,"%#& &1+*%""#3"/#%,,#&4#$"%)#!,.1*#'"& "#, /#!,%'. +"/ "/# 4!,"%#& !'3 "/#%, :#.!: !3)%&#,& !'3 4#,1&%'. "/# ,#4," &1+*%""#3 +9 1+ %)%&%'!:

%$#,- :%A!: !'3 ,#$,3 "/#$!&#-,3#,A!&,#&#,)#3"%&

1'3 "/!" $/#*# A!"#, $1,&# :#!3%'. " "/# %#:3& !:2##" %'./ /!& +##' 3#*:%&/#3!'3*#,.#3%'"/%&A' %#:3& +9 #!'" %'./ &' /1, %'./ /# A!"#, $1,&# A/%$/ %& ,1''%'. 4!,!::#: " !2+!/!G!'!:H3#&'""1$/"/# %#:3&

!:2%##" %'./ & 4#, "/# 2!*!+!'3% #)#'1# #4!,"*#'" , "/# 9#!, ; 8/!&,! '1*+#, > *#!&1,%'. @!'!:& *!,:! %& .!%, *1*@%' 8/!: !'3 /!& +##' 3#*:%&/#3+9 #!'"%'./'"/#+!&%&

!+)# !$"&!'3"#'&1,#+#""#,%,,%.!"%'

%#:3& !'3 A/%:# !.,##%'. A%"/ "/# ,3#, 3!"#3; 4!&&#3+9 %)%&%'!:!'!:

%$#,- 5!2%"/! %)%&%'-

%" %& ,3#,#3-1'3#,#$"%'> G H ,"/ '3%!!'!:!'3 ,!%'!.#$"-;>G$"; ;>H-",#&",# "!," "/#!'!: $/#*#A!"#,$1,&# A/%$//!)#+##' &/A' %' "/# &%"# 4:!' 5.! 1,2% "!.A!:5%',!''#E#3A%"/"/#

%:#A/%$/A'#,&/%4 ,!*!'$/!9!"+1" /!&+##'3#*:%&/#3+9+"/"/#4!,"%#&!'3 *#,.#3A%"/"/#%,A':!'3&44#!: %:#3 +9"/#!44#::!'"%&3%&*%&&#3I "#,.%'."/,1./"/#!

,#&!%3"A,3#,& !'3 $'&%3#,%'. "/#!,.1*#'"&,!%&#3+9:#!,'#3$1'&#: ,"/#4#"%"%'#,-3'" %'3!'9 #,,,%'%*41.'#3,3#,& ,"/#41,4&# %'"#, #,#'$#-/#'$#-"/#4,#&#'" 4#"%"%' %& 1'3 "+# A%"/1" !'9 *#,%" !'3 !& &1$/ "/# &!*# %& /#,#+9 3%&*%&&#3 G885 H G885 H G885 H G885 H )#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#, - - - -

/#"/#,&4#!@%'.?,#!&'#3 #&? /#"/#,,#4,"!+:# #&?