← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25485/2015dismissed

Kuldeep v. Haryana Staff Selection Commissioner & ORS

2017-05-17Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma12 pages

 

       

  !""#$%$&'((  

           '  )*+  , +,-  )*+  , +, ** 

   



!

"  #" 

$   %"  " 

!

"    %"  $   %"" $  %""& $  '( 

$  )*+ # ! $    $   ," ! $    "

$  ( "' $   ( * $  + ( $  #-!

$   +-! $   "& $  +! $    %"" $   ".



$   "

"

$   '



    *(  $  , $  ).

 *"

$     *"

$  +"/'. $  "

$  0"' $   "

$   0" $  

$  ).

 $  12  *"

$   $  0

 $  +' $   (," $    '"

$   0#"!+ $   

'+  *"

$ "



  , #   (  ,"+)  45  *".

-+  5(04  "'  %5  #+ *" "    0 67%1 0 89:9;<=:>?   '    /

" "    0 >

::7%1 ;<@66@;<=:9?   %""    0 97%1 ;<=A:;<=:>?  -  *"/"  4(%  +  *" "*  + "4    '   #

  ,- .  / 0 7:? 5 . " 9>!



. *%1 0  <9@B9 <@66@ <9<66 :9<:@ <=BB9 <=:9$89B9 8:B= <B@@ <=:6$:<6B <=== :6>@ :6:@ <AA6 <9:> <>:A <><9 <>8A 9@A8 9B:= :99A <:=9 :968 8B@8 <>9:

:96= :6A:

<><:

9>=:

<@<< <9=@ :@@< :<<:

:><6 :>@< :@A9 89:9 <A:= :@B> @:8> :96:

8BB:

<=A:

:99B :8@A <B>6 9@=6 98@6 :@8> 99>@ 98B6 <:6= 98@< 8:88 8:=> :9BA :AAA<<@B <=:> "

"C



" 

 %    0 <>  D E#F "   C 3 7( %?  :AAA'

 

   <B =< <=:: !". C

  "   / 

, '   7/, ?".  . 

  " '       " *  '

 C



 C    '   2 4

G# G5

 "C 

 

H  



        

    

 

       

!"#" $ 

  %     "

  &'(I .  !*

   G



    *"J 

 -"



" !

 

 "   "  , ' %     / 

 , '   '  " *      4

 !"

" 

 '

 D;J :AAA C 

" " *.   * . " /, 

.  

% ''







 ! "'.*

" 

"  , '    " :AAA     

C

  

" .   * .  " 

   3 " .







" . D   '%1 0 <9@B9 <=:9  7<? -"

   *""

 



"#   "

J 

. "  

" ' "

, / 

   '   

4

 '

-'

 0 "  <==B;=A  -"    4

   

   '

" 8=4

    D;

":AAA   '  <B =< <=::      " 

 " .   * .    

'

 >A>   /,  

 := => <=:9  78? -"  "

    

4

  E,' 4

F  

 8 " 4

 ( % ''



:A96 *'' ' .

" *",   J 

 . ",  J 

%  ( 5   

   :> =< <==@   *   " 

 *''   <B =< <=::

" "



 * .

'  " /,  -"

 "    "*  ;

 

-" "'' "!". , '

 8= 4

  .  "    4

   2  '

  .  . " 

'  

" 

 !"

"    *  .  " ! ( $

  " , '  .     

 4

 2  " 4(%

 '  . " %  (

"

( ;  ",     "

<9@ "%

 " . *   

 . ! " E%  * 

F  "E F " '!

  

-"

" ' "

 . <=:: !   * .  " :AAA  "  '* '' '

 *"

 * . 

 

-"  

 ' "

 "  2

   "

 D    . "  

!



 "  '*

 

  

 "



 :@  :6 %

  7@? 5   !

 

 

    

". 

 " 

 -" 

" JD 

 5 

    (    :B =8 :A>9  =< :: :AAA

 ", 'G,* 2. "%  (  

    2 . "   (  

"     '' "   .  !     " .   "

 %  7 ?) *+ "  

    ,- .//01234 5678$7

? 

 

  ,   ./221.3 4 5 ..9$  7

?   +    

 ,- ./2:123;.0.

*   ",*G,

' .,'4

 2.4(%



!

'  



 2 "C

  79? %      (.'

'



" .

 " , ' " *",  J 

 ,' 4

  "    -'

 0  + "  ' " " 

"      

  " ,' 4

 

" *" " - *%       !"

    '

" . '   JD % ''

!

 ' 

"

!"

.'

  <= =A <==>7?   "

!. 

 !



' !"

"  *   .  



' "C

 *!  -"% ''

''

 

  !;            

  



  

   !"#  

 

  

    

 $

 

  $

    

%  & &  

       

 ( ) !* (  ( + & ,& -  .  +  !* (  & /& !*0 

    1

 (  2+&34 5&

 6&  

    #  *(  

+   $       

 *         

  

 

  $  77 8*  

   *( 8    (         * 

    $

*

    

    0

$    

   &8 $   * 





  &9 76? -" ( "  

"JD % ''

      ' "  '     '  . ",  ' .,'4







 2   '!" " 

 *   '

 

   !    !

" "  4

 ' %%4

  7 ! ! "//+   4

     ?    " 

 8=  4

 !  '

*, 

C   "  4

!    D;

J 

    0 <> 7% ';55?  :AAA     * ,' 4

 !"

"  '

" , ' " *" ,   J 

!



 *

   *  

  

!

"'





%%  *  4

 "

" 24

 '  

 .  ' .

 !"

"  C    " 

 . C

'

* C  7>? /  ".'

", ' . "

"

. 2. " % 

5   

  '



8= "5  

 % 

:AB@ "  

!" ' ! (

H  

  #     

!* 

( 

0  

0 

 2* $  3 

 *  # 

8

*

* *!*     '(   (  

     

   !*   (   !*  I  -" JD



 

 8=   H     I ' H 

 * *  0( 

 (  (  



$

 (

 * 

 * 

  ) *(*   :

 ) ( *  I 

" *

  (

  2  ,  %

     



 2. %  5  D 

 " ! ( "  '  

 2   ' "  

' " /,  (  7B? /   "   %   5  

"!

 '   %1 0 <=BB9 <=:9 '

"  !" " %  5 "   *    

" , '     . " 

   2 .

   

  



8=

.'

 (

 2 

 2 ", ' "  E   F  7A? 1""  "

  . * "*  " *" "  

  7:=? -" "C " %  5    % ". . " "



"5  % 

:AB@!"

" % * 

  

<7? "% 

 E  C

F

 '  E*

  !* ;

        1    

  F 4

:9

  C

!"

"   "3   " . 2   C

 

8=

 " *

**



  

" "*   

""

   "

 * 

" 

 ( 

"

' . 

"



 '

  .+

'



   . "   (

  '

     

  

  

 8=  * !

"

  

  JD



 " "

  !; :/5

        "    

  

&.

 

(   *   (  23  

   * *  

   *  0

 2* $  3  )  *   *

 

  *< 23   * *= > ) *(* (  

       

*



(

0 

0 

 2*$ 3

*# 

8

*2*$ 3

*   * *      '(  (  

     

 

  *   ( *

 & ?@  &A   *  A    

 **(0(

 (

 (



$

 (

 * 

 * 

    )  *( *       :

 ) ( *  < 3          *    *   ;

** $         *   * ;

  *   < 23   *;

 *



$ @    6B

' ?  (CD,(2

CD,&3( * * &9 K'"  L 7::? 3 "  "JD





8=

  .  "  '

     

  

 

    !

       " E'

   F   -"  "  ' 

   /,  , ' -" !

 2  

    

'  

  

'     

* E     F  D    ( D  !" " !".D  . " %  5   7:<? 5 " *"

" ", ' %

 . "

"

. 2. " % 

 5  "

 

 . D'

  !"

 

' 

 2 ", ' "  E

     FM  -"

 C

  !

   C!.  



8= ":AB@

!" ( ".' !

*  "

 1 "

! 

 D 

 !

 '  

8=A %

.  D 



 ! 

8= ":AB@

(  !"

' 

 2, %

  

'

 

 " '. 5  '

!

"   D    "  ! "   (   ' :AAA' 

 <B =< <=::  7:8? 5 ! "  % * 

  (  " . D  2

  2  

 2   , '  %

 " 

F 

"  , ' " * . ! . ,' 4

  '

". 2. ( . '!"



  C

   " !".D    /* 

""  *  "* 

 

"!  7:@? 

 !" ( "  '

 

  

", '"

 



  #  "  ' . ;

 "8=

"4

 " *"

!"

"". 2

"  . ' ' -"

 "  

."

 ( " .

  " . . '     * .   

 "' '. 

/,  

 7:9? "   

 ' .  

F  "   ' " .  2 . 4(% 

"  (  

 "

 .

.    

"  -" !

 2C

    D   " %  5  

4(%  %  5  

.

 !

"

" 





 %  5 , %  5    4(%  5 "   %   5    !"

   2 " C

      ! " D  !  

  

 :9

 -"   %  5 "'



 2 " '  .

"

 -"

      

.  !

" 

"

 !"

   

" ' " ' 1"

 "4

'"

 ,' 4

  

 8 " 4(%

" 

 ' . "' 

.   "   "  2. %  5  D 

 ! 

:9

 7:6? 5 " *"

".

  

! 

 '

"!



!"

"  * '

  7:>? -" '!



   *%1 0 <@66@ <9<66

 <=:9$ 98@6  <=:6  '

  ' !" 

 " .

 "  , '    2 

 D;J " :AAA    -" !

;

  "

!  " 

.    * .  "   /,  

    '   "%  / . *

 "!

;



 

", 

( '.  !"



  

  ' " D

 D'

  'G. ", ' ;N;

, ' /, %  

  " , '% .  "'  " 

 .    * . 

"  '   , '   "  D  " .   !

  

 !

!  "     

   7:B?   

,1/2 - &!

134" ((    0

,13$56017 0$ 

134"