High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16593/2025allowed

Vinay Arya v. Sarva Haryana Gramin Bank And Another

2025-09-04Mr. Justice Rohit Kapoor18 pages

!!"" # $

% & ' "( !!!!) " !" # $

"* +% (( #( , "

"()"" -"( .(/ +# , ", +, (0 ', ", +"% , "

"() "#$%& 1111

# 2()"3")"" ( 4 0 "0

"""

3""( "

6 (.

"().( .(" 7 - 8/ "( 0"" 7 - 8 / 4 ) " 9 , 3(4 "( 4 "( ""()"" 300 "

4 "( "

() 7 ,4")0 ) . 300 " ( 3

"( & ' "0 0

"( ) . ( " 0 4 " ( 0 4 3"((0 . "( )

() .,8)"( 3 "4" "

"( " : :"( )

( 4

" "

"( ) ""

0 00" 04 "0."() ,. ""

0 (",3"( " "

"().( .("

" %

2("

"6"

4 "

"( ;

"( 0"()")"" ,"( ""()"" 3 )0

0' ( " "( & ( <

" " <0 :

% & ',"() ""

"() ' ==$ " "( ) ""00 7 0"4 . #>=> 3 0 4

"( "

0 ?. -# @/, :

4 )( 0, "%.

% & ',"( )"" ##( , "9 "

)"0 5" 00. "( )0 ", "( " "( )0 "

"( ( 4

))

(4 "()"" ,3( 3 "(& (+ .

"( " & ' .3"(##( "9 ,3( 00("

' ) "

4) " 8) "3"("( " & ' $ " )

(6 4 . 9 = 77 =

"3 "( ""( 8) " )"3004( "0 $ 3,) "

"."(& ',"( )"8" "( "( (3 "

40"( "( 0."( 4 '

""( ""

)

5"( "(

+ ( ,"()0 "

""(4 (

"( "& ' "<0:

8) ", " 3(( ) " ( 3 "

0 "( " "( 3 ( ) " 3"( "( & ', 3() ( 3" "

( 3 & ' # " & ' " 3 "( ""(

( 4

"4" "

"( "& ' & ( " 77 = "

00 4"3 "( )"" , " 9 # #( "9 ,"(

"3 ""

"( . "

"9 2()0 "

"(0 .:59 "7

" 0#"

<0:

""("(& (+ ., 0 , ;

0#.( ) & '+ ., 0 ,#(@ #( ""(

"()"" "( ".".

"( ""( )"" 3 " "

0" ."

"(".

) "- 8 /, "( 00.

000 4 "( )0 " )( " #(##( "()0

"(%.

% & 'A" 3 " ""(3

"( 00 ) " 0"(

" :5 7 2(" 0 "";." "

3"("

, .3"(""B C) "( "

4".

" "

"()0 "

"00 0D 3 )

"()0 "

" "( ", 3( 3 (0 ;

"0 0 40, "

' "( )

"( 0 )) 0 9 > 3 0 4 "( ) " & ' "()"" ""(

" ;." 4

"( " ))00 " ",3((3 " 4 "(0 0@""?.,:

.. "( ;." " 300 "( ,"() '( 0.0 # )) 09

"( ",3(( ""0 ). ; 5" 0

""( ""(E8" "" 9 77

= 04 )0 "

"( .((0.

0)"

",;

" 4;" ( 4 04 "()"" "() '5" 00.4 "()"" "( "

" "( "( "

00." ;"

("","() '( 3 "

7 7 - 8/"(

6" ,3((3 0 ) "

4 "("" 4 0. "

0)0 ))0"

4 "7 - 8=/ #46"0 "( ). ( .(" 7 - 8/ 00... "

4 '.

) 3 4 "( ) " 4 ' 5 "( "

""()"" ," 00."( ""()0 "

)( 0( (64 .9 = "77 = ( . "

# "& '

% & '- 3# $

% & '/

' F " )

G2()

"( (63""

& ( <

"( & ' " <0 :

, ( 3, "( 3 " 77 = "

"( "

#( # #( 3"( "

."(6" "( "

(."

"(4 '.) 5"

00."( ""()"" )) "( (

) "."((6

"(& ' ) )"

" 0 )) "( " (

". "(

" "( "

#( # #( "(4 'G "5"" 0 00."( "( "( 0 "

) . 0".

" "( 4 ' "

( "( 4 ' . "

. """ 0" "(" )) 0 ""(

"(4 ',"30048) "

00 40"

...

". )) 8 "0 , "5"

00."( ""

"(.0.

"()"" ,

"(0 3.0, ) ,(( 8) "(4 '"

2("" 00."( "(0"" 7 - 8 /,3((3

" " "( 3 ) "( 4 ( = 5 "( 0""> , ) "9 ,3(08.) 3 .0 7

"( # $

% & ' -<

E)0

/, # .0 ,(

" "

"(F#.0

G, ( "( ""()"" ( 00 "

4 "( "

( ) 7 ,4")0 ) .300 " (3 "(

"(& ',"0"() . 0 "(

) 5"3 "( "( ""()"" ( 00 "4 ""0

)

""( "

) (3004 ""0

)

" 0 4 ", "0 "( ) . )0",8)"( 3 "4" "

": = 5" 00.4 "()"" "( "( ""

. ,( 3,"(4 '( 7 ("" "

4" 0 ( .(" (,).(

) "" " 04 " 2(0 0 )) . 4(

"()"" (

."( ""(). "

"() '.( .(" 7 - 8 / 0""> 7 - 8 /) ""0 00.

4" ,"() ' 300 ""("6

"() "

"( " 3 ;

"0 ."( "" .3"("()"" 5" ""( ""() ' 0 )) ""(;."

"(" 0 ", 300 4;" "(8" )""

"(E8". ",;

"0 3"("()"" 5" 0 4"" "( " 0 3( " ( 4 .(" " "( )"" , 4 "( ) '"(.0 # )) 04 "4

"( " 5" "( . "( " "( )"" 0 4. ).

""( ""(" 0 " "( " ))00 " "( (0 "( ";

"0 0 40 "( ))(

40 "(.0 # )) 04 "() " & ',"( ( "

"().( .(" ( ) "(

7 , 3 .0 3"(( 0. ( " 0 4 " 5" " "( " "( "

"( ) '

"( ))0

" 0;"44.("4 "( "

5" 0 ."( ""().( .("( 4

"(#.0

,3(( " ")0 "(0

)0 " ,)

" ""5"( 44 .(""

"( "

"( ""( ""(" )" ) "

"() ' - 8/, 8 ""()"" 0 "2(0 0

)) .

"()"" ( 0) ";."

"($ G40 #) "F&''()*&*)*+&#'*,-*.'/* *.&' 0 &G

12,"

""( ""(#) "( (0"( " 3("(3 8)0 "0

" ".) ""

) .,)""( 00. "4.3"("(' 30.

"(@) "","( ""0 4 .

6 (."(( .(" " , "( 0 0 )) .

"( ) " & '( ."( ""

"()

"(#.0

,) "0 0 .0 7,"() '( .("0

"().( .(",

3.) 5" . "( ""(3")"" 04 "()"" ) ", "()0 ) . ). ("

)) .( 00."("

" ( . ) ") " "( , " "(

" "( "

""0 "

0)0 "7 ))0"

4 7 ,( 4 04 "()"" ) "

"(( 3 " "7 A 0

"() '(

"( ."( ""()"" ( 4

4 00")0

( 4 .(""

"( "

"= ,3(4 (3

.0"

0."

3 '3"( 0. "(4 . "( 4 ' "

0".

300

))( 00

,=7,7 >0"

"0 ,(3 )( "(@)0 "( "

4 ) . ) 0"

F" 4 "3 "

. ( " 0

)

, 0 3. 3 ( 4 )

,, 7>) "("

,, =>) "(, "( "

( ) 7 ,3"( "0 "

"5" "( . "( ";

" 0.

)) ""(;."

"(" "3 0 " " "

))0 ""() '"

" " )0 " ""()"" ,) 3("( 4

"( " "( )"" .0"

.0. ", 8) . "( ) '"

(.0.

0'A 0 )) .

"() '( ."( ""(;."

"(#) " (#( "

G -) / " ))0 40"

"("

" $4""( ""3 0 0 44 ) . )(

"(;.""( ""(

4 3("(@) ""3 "

(.0 ", "( ",3((

( ""( "

= " ",4 " 0

"("( ", ( 8" 0 . 5( ,( 0

, "0 3 0 "4 0. "

""0"("

"()

) ""

0) .A 0

"() ')0 0 ) "(;."

"($ G40#) "F'*(*34 564*3*7(37 (5, *'*3*.( ,*8-(8.& ".# +&# (

*(3.*3*'',6/9 :

;1<21,3("( 4 (0 "( " 3( )0 ) . " " 4

) ,"()0

( .(""

3"(( 0"()

. ""

"00() . )0" "( ""()0 ) . 4 "

""(""

06")0

"( "( ")0

"())

)0 ) . #) . "

0 "( ) ""

06 3"( " '. . "$ 0 ) "

""( ""(0 ) ""(:5( "4 )"4 "( )"" ", ) " "(;."

"( "40 3,"( 0) .5"0" "0 4"""( ""()"3")"" 4 "(. " "

* 0"( .(

0 "3 3("( ""3 "

' )4 "( "&(

"( " "( 0 "

( ., ( 3,"(0 0

"() " "( " "

"(0" " 0"()")"" ,"( ." 4 ( "( "" 4 "(4

" 0 40

5( ( "(0 0

"() " ( .

"( .("( " ))3"("()"" 3"("( 40 "

"."

." ; "."( 0, " "

"( ))0 40 "

) 2() "4 '

""F"(. 0& ' ", G#" "(

! " # " $ $ ! %& "# '(! ) ! & ( #" * + & ,%"# -""# + .& &# ( " /# &( " " # ( # %0( " ((" ""# ( " /# 1 2 % & %, " /# ,% !

H 5"8

"() 3#"

", "( " I# $

% & ' -<

E)0

/ # .0 , H( 4 2(0 ".0 ) (* 6 7 (5 # " " * (& ""#(% # , # "

( % #& ""##% # # #

" ! #"# #&

# , # " #( % " % # " # #& , ," %( " & %&

-""#8 9 #4

(( " # " ( %

# ""#4

" (4

# %"# %,

&" ( %(# %# ! ,% #, # " 4

# # " ( %" ( 0# % # ""#4, 9 5 8 (

"# ",

" 6& # # "( %" (#" ( " # ""# #"( % ( "# # 0(% "# ( # ""#"(( " # " ( %4 # (4 #(%4

" # # , : "# ""(%4

# % , : "# ""(% 20( ; (( " & " , ( %& %&

" # " ""# ## " " ( ( 0 ## # " (( ( # 4 (( "# " ""# ""##%, # " " # , 4 ""# (" ""# " ( " # % , , " # ," # " , "# " # 4

(( (" ""#" #("# :"(( #%" #( % (# 4

(" ""#""# (& # & " &, , " # (

## # #4 ( (" ""# (( (, ( " ( " (, & ## # " ((& # (, 4 " ""# ( ( . 4 " # " ""#& (( ( %# ( #% # # 0( " ( " # (( & ## #

" ((4, (( # # & ## # " # # # 4 # ( " # 8 ( (#"

"# ",

" 6& ,( ,% *( / % ""# # & " " # (( ( ( 4 ,((%" " "# ( " < %" "#("#& " "#& " %&, ,% -""# , # ",

" ( %" 5( (#" , & , 0#(,% ,% *(/ % # ,( # # ," ""# :% ,((% # # " "

" :% , &"& # ## # "( & ! ( ( " 4 ! # # ""#

" # # ( " # %, ,"# # #4 ""#

% " (% " # #4 2(%8 9 8 #4 # "

" # " ( 0# 0 4, 9 5 8 "4

" # " ( 0# = 4

"(# #4

"( %0 ( 0( " % # "" # 0 # "( %4

" #

# , : "# " " (%4

8 5( (#" "# , ", 1 " 6 ,( ,% *( / %& ,% #( % # ,( # ,"

(% :% 4 , ((% # & " "

" :% , "& # ## " ( & ! ( ( "

4 ! # # (%

" # # ( " # %, , "# # #4 (% % " (% " # # < >#( %(# "

/ ""# (% ( # " # # "( & , , # " "( " (#"#((" # ##" #( %(# "" 1 ""#(% ( ,," %,# #" ( ,% " ( ""# (% #( % (# , # , # " ( , #( %(# # " # (# ## " ( (# "

""# (% #( % (# , # %( % ? # " "( , " ( %" ," (# #( " ( 0#( #, *,% ; *;

20( ; (( " & ,"# # "( + % % , #(" #( %(# ( "

" ,% *(/ % "," , ( " " *(/ % < /(( % / )"# < @%& 1 &, ) 3+!?3$>?1 ? 6<&(, + ."A ) 11@%16&1 &# "#" "(,# + ."A

/ (( ,"& ! & * *( / %4 * & + 9 *(/ %4 + 9 & *( / % # ,% ! ,# "# ",

" 1

B 7 : "( 0 ""

"() ","(

3.) " ",3((6" * 7 ( #" ( ! # # %' #$ C 7 ( ( , , ( & # , (" % # #?# C 7 ((( "# ( # & " " (

7 0( %" D% ( # & " " C .

"( " "( ) " , "( 4. " 00"0 )

"( "

.0 4 ))0 ."())00 34 "(#) " + (

0G ) ," "4 4""( ""() " & '3003"(".(""

( 3 " ( .("

" 3"( "( )0 ) . ) """ 0 $ 3,3( ""

43("("().( .("

7 3"(( 0."(" 04 ""00 0

"()0 ) ., 4( 00.,"()0

" "

0"( )" 5"""00 3"( "( 3 ">( .(" "."

" ,4 " "

"."(.("

) "

,0"( ( 44 ) ( . ;" "

2(3";" "0

"( """

5 ( 0 " 0 484 6 (."( ( 3 " ( .(" $ 3, "( "

4 8 8)" 0 "

3( "( " . 0

"( ,

"(( .("00.

0 : )

"("

))3"("( ).( .(" 7 - 8/,"0 "( ""( ( 4 00.."( "

. "

"()"3((3 "(4;" """(0"4

"(" " ":

,3("()"" .3"( ##( 3(0;

"0 0 40

"( "( D" "(

00. )) )

( """."

" "( ""(& '( "

0 ;

" )) ""(;."

"(" 0 " )

"(.

)) 0- 8 /3 0 0 0 " "( ""3 "( ) 'G ".

"( ""( )"" 3 " 0 '

3 . .5"3 04 )) " "

) . 9 (* / 5# , (( " )

E1,% " ) ) 1 " "

" ( "" ""# (( " ) 5% % " "$

&&&? F6G(

" , 1H . A(#"%, ( ## 20 E7?* , ## ,% ( ""& '

! /?# ) H1 11 DH '% # ! &! # 8)A&; ,

A, ( "" " , # ## 20 7?/ &( ##) 00000= "+ ! &! # 8- ; , '% # " /?# ) 00000= " I+ ! I , ) 1DH=D 1H/?# $ ( / ( # 1H "# ## 20 20 7?* & " $ &&&? " , " "'

! ##) 00000DH"$ ( ) 1DH=D A, # :) 1DH=D 1H& '% # ! "

"I+ + ! I20 1E 7?/ # ,%+ ! , # 8- ; , ( "" , # # : %""# "+ ! &! # 8- ; , & 1H ' ## " (( )

, ""# (( ) 1 J %/% % E " (( "##E# "& " " # ( ) 11 " ( 5 # # # % # , # # ,% ( "" "

B 5" 0 4 " "( "( ";

" 4;" ( 4

04 "() ' .3"("()"" , ""(8" )"" 04 "()0 "

"(E8". "2( ""

"( 0 0

"( )"" "( " 0 .(" " "( )"" "(.0 # )) 04 "() ', 0 " " " = 5"(4 ' )

" "8," " 4 "( ""(3")""

"()"" ) " "

4"( 3

" ""("(( 0, 3 0"( "

))0 "

, ("

"( )0 "( ))0"

4 4""4 "()"" ) "

"(( 3 "3 0 0 "

( 3,"( "(( 4;""

( 40 ""

" "(,) 3("() '3 00

"("6" ,3("(:53 "." "

"( " "( & ' ( 4 . "( )"" "( 0 ) .4

"(" 0 " "( " ))00 " "2(

""() " 3 ""() "4 '

"(""

"(,3("("(0

"(( .(" 6" 7 , .

)). "( " "( " 0 "

. "0 , "( " "( " "(

" "

"( ,"( 3"

"( 6" 3 0( "

4"(

"5"3 04.

8" " "(0 ") . )( "(;."

"($ G40#) ", &''()*&*)*9& -) /,3(( * I / # :& % "(( ( (# " # "&""# % "# # 3 & # 0( % ( (# ( # #, " ( & , ( (# & "

" (% 3 & %,# ( "# # #& # "# # &,

# " " # & # 0 "# "# A # # & #

%&,%" , # " (#" ( (#

$"# # , # " # ' " 9 % ! ' / & # " : #( %(# " 1% " % /"# , # " * J 9 9>& ) 3! <& , #

( (# " % ,5& # # % ( " (%" # ,% ( #( %(# H

0"( .("($ G40#) "( 3

" "( ""(

4 ,3( 0 . 8)0 0

,4 "0 0 " 4 0 . "

""0 "( "

"( )

) ""

0 ) . $ 3, ) , "( ) '( "

' """

."( 0"

"()"" '

3 . ."( 00.""( )" 5"( "3

""," " 3, "( 40 "

.,4)"""

)0" 0" "

"(). ( .(" ) "(). 7 3"(( 0."( " 04 "

"()"" , 0 "(.

))( "( ""

00 ,"(""( "()..0 # )) 0,

" " #( " 3( 00.

4" .0 , "(

"( ) " 0 3

"( )""

,"()")"" 3

"( ). ( .(" 7 - 8 / 0""> 7 - 8 / " "( ) " " "

0 "(" 0 4 ""

"( )"" ,

3"(0 35",( 3, 0 "( ""(" 3"( "

"()0 ) .( 00."()")""

3 0 "( 4 . "(.("

"() "6 "( )0 ) .)"

"()"" ,"( "

4). 3((

( ""

;

5 % ("() '.> * J>9 ("() "

40* J>9