R.S Verma v. Haryana Right To Service Commission And ANR

 


   

 


 

+,-., ,/+55 4

$& ()0 %1'1(55-56
      3
7


            
     





    

!  "   

    !  "   ( 
  *  

# $

!% &



 !  "

  )1  ' 88888 

2 #$34  

    $

      **+,'+*-   !"#  +-4 .

 * 


     $.

  !$ $  

 

 .

 '  /



$  *0)*1)1"

" 


    ! '+*2 )

" "  !

! '+*21!    

  .

.

 

 "  "

"    

$%&'()&* %$'

+ '


'.     *0**'+*0

3  4""

" !

 5



"  "   

" " / 

 " 49+!73*!

 $   $          *2*+*6-*  !"#  +,4:

 $ !$

$ 

  $         $  "   *6-*!   '     "



    ''*''+*0  ! '+*2 ."  ;



    



 !

7% !

   !"#  +4 < = (  ;



    

 ! 7% !

!

    **+*'+*- ""

""



     

 

!'+*2 $!(   ;



 

  $   

 "" 

 !    3  4""

!

  "  

            ""

 " 

         *0**'+*0 " 

 '       

/  $

/   .



      .

   $  7%        !"

"#  +4 2 :

  

 "     **+*'+*-!  3  4""

!

!

       *0-9   '9+*'+*-

 !"#  +64 

  5  

      $   5 5 . 

 ++*'<9   '9+*'+*-"
 *'!-6< $  %;>

 ' 

   * 0**'+*0 9


'! .

  "

.

    '

   !"#  +74

" ! "  !'+*2." ""

 "   $ $    

  ) ?1! !

!        $   

   ""

 "   

+-+''+*-    $ $      ""



= "

 $ "$  "  ! !   .

   ""

  =    ""

 $

     "

 "   "     5   $   

 ."   

*<+2'+*-!$ $!  ,+    "

 ! 

 !'+*2!     ,

$ $!$ $

"

",+  "   "'

     !'+*2! '

'

  

 * "   " "        *9+<'+*- -

 !"#  +.4 !$$ /

 $ $  *0)*1).1"

"  !'

'+*2   

 0 =

"

 

."  * **+,'+*- -

 !"#  +/4 4! $!        **+,'+*- -



 "
 9+++    3  "

""

   

 "

" 

   

   /

 " $      *0)*1)1 1@)1" !'+*2

 !"#  +-4 #8"9 &':;&* *  &1&1( #+ - (    "    ;



".

  '$   "  **+*'+*- - " .

    

  " .

    '        $ "  ! '+*2

 $  

   

 

   

 $  3  4""

    ""

 "    "     "    '  A   .

       *0**'

'+*0      $



$ 

"(  ;



   !  *0-9 '9+* *'+*-$  .

3  4""

$.

" " /  "

"
*'!-6<

 "4 9+!73*!

 $    ' 5. 

++*'

'<9 $  %;>

6

"     $ 

     "

 "  

.

 "

  ".

  '.

!

!   ' " 

  ."  

 

    !'+*2$   ." .

  "   .

   

  ) ?1! !       +-+''+*-        5   5   

$ $     ""

= "

  $  "$ $    "  !  !     .

   ""

 =    ""

 $       "

 "   "    5    $    

." 



*<+2'+*- *+

$ $! $ 

      $    

.

  

  " .

 '    "     $ 

!  

 

         *          

" $    

    .  

   .   

!'+*2 2  "      



""

$   ( (    "    *

  $ 



"  

"

.

 

   ! '+*2  

"  "  

 

 



 "

 $ 

  "

 ! $!

   

'!  "

  $   "!    5 "" $        " !$  .    "

"

!'+*2 2 ** "      *       /

 

.

   

  . "

."   

/

",+

   

0)'1"
  !'+*2     * "

    

",+ " 



 

"  

        ".  

"

"  =.  .  ! 



 E "

"  B. 



 " #18*&<' 1'&#1%&(33 %&(# # $0 &* #' 

  5,4   =         " $ C D

     .         . 

 =  "#  /   


  

  

   

  




     

       





 



     

  



         

      

 

         4   

       

 ! "  # 

$% %&'()&%*+ 

  


      )

        

        4       

    

! ! , -   .  $  

$ %&/% ) ('%+ 0   

     

            1  1 

 

    



   $ .2

   !

 5 6     )  # , , -  %&(+%))3*3+ *'

"

"   

  "$C D.  "

"$C "    . D

 0)'1" 
 !

! '+*2             " , +   .

      

      .

. 

    



 # "  . 



 " $>$ $

$9<&$&  ) &&$# #$0 '*&*#("8* %# # &$#;0"%$&1(":*$8+,5 5 (< #9 & ) ) &&$# #$0 '*  &* #' 

 5,7 4  6-  "    F       =     "  # /   
 01

7  

7 4    1 -     8 "   , ,

- 

$%&&( ) *('

'+  1

 9

   9      

  

                 

    

1       5    

     

          

  5   

   



 : :;) ,- 

5 < <,- 

$%&((  ) *'%+0

   

 

     



 

     1     



                        =        

  <  *< (    "  "  $ 

       **+,'+*-           $   

      "

                 
 !'+*2=    



"   

 "

.

."  $     

. "

." /

",+  #8"9 &':;&* *  '?(0 & *2 



  .      .! (      "     $  

 " .

   " ""

      .

 ' 

 . 

$ 

5     
 

!'+*2 .     .

   .

 " .

 

 ) ?1!

! !   G 

    !              "       .



    .  

    .



 



  *9  .     .# .

    "  !

! '+*2$    "  "   .   $ 



 "

   " 

 $ 

   .       ')1 " 

! '+*2  " C     D$.

 . "

.

   .

  $ 

   "

   D  "       ') 1 " 

! '+* 2 "

 C  D  .       /     



.

% 4""

= "! #

 

"

" 

"

 


  !'+*2   

     

       .  *,  " .       "       5 .

 ' "

   "  "

   $        . "  .

    *      "  

 .   "

   *<0 0

 C  

"

 D$      "

 "9  .       " 

  .

  .

".



'$ /

",+  "  

    "

 $  .

 

 '9+*'+*- -

 "    .    " ,<         .  

#     .

 * *0 (      "    "

       "

" 

 5  

 $   

       $    .

    .   "    

.

""

"

" &  
  

       

 

.    

.

" 

      .# " 

! '+*2  "    *.

      .

  

 "

!'+*2"$     

"  

"  

!'+*2 2 " $ $  ./ .

    "

"     "  .#     "

    

 

   '

    .  

 =" "

 " 

   



$ 

 $   .

"$    . 

$ . " 

   *-    E   .  A  .

   ('10 #$&1(+ + *6 :   .      "    .  $   .    

'+ >"

 

"$   "        "
  !'+*2$    

" #  

"   =    

. $

+   * +  2%    3 ' ' %  "'        !

+  * +2 3' '0- $    "#4%' 

 '   -  &

+  35  %

 74%' 

'

$ $    %"  $      &

+   (/  '$$' &6

,# %" $ .   '

'$$' 

 "'% (   $ 

 $    '$%  '

'$$' "#)*'+ ' ,- #-   

. '#   ' '$$'      /   *' + '

, ,- #0# '#   '

-(    0$#

   $   "#  ) *' + '

, ,- #1   '/  * '+ ' ,- #'# # '

'$$' '

0$ $#

0# '# ' 

'  '$$ ' ' $   "# -

 '- 

 %'$$' &

$

''$$' -

-"  ./ 

* *' + '  ,- # '# $' ' '       %'$%'$$ ' ' %4%'

   $         %"  $       8% '#   - $ $

. ' '# " $     (  '  % ' %  ' 

 -   ( 1   '"

( %'$$' .' $$ -#

'%  %" $  ' "%' "#/ 

*'+ ' ,-  #1   - ' '

  '

 "#  / 

*' + '  ,-  # -     '  "   -'  "

$' "#% $ 1   -''$$ $' '

- -"    '  "   "#  /   *' + '

,- #  ' $

 0# '#    '

$

'$$' .' ''$

" &

+   %( !

   

 ) 

& 6  9  '  "  -#

       - $ $  $ ' 

,'   '8-%%  /'  * * 

 -% "   #

 & )    $ $-$ .  '#.6 6

''' $ 

  -   !

" '8 -    

' -       '  ','

 -'

  

 ) *' +  '  ,- #   / 

*'+ ' ,-  # $'-  .''#"  '$$ $'!

'# -$ 

-   # #

' 



)*'+ '

,- #' /  * '+ ' ,- #!

    4$''

'  '  '%' '#

   $ #

  /' *  .   ' '    - 

'%

- '-$ $ - ,!

    '%   $  - '  $   %%

  #

  '# '8  

 # '$''

'1    ' "

 '8% % - '   ' .     '   -    , ' /'#  '%

4$'   !

    '

 '      "     -      '  '# '  -%%

'       ' ' '

#-

"$ ' 

  ,!

% - %'  -

.        $  

  ,

  %- '

 4%'

.  ) *'  + '  ,- # '    /  *'+ ' , ,- #!

 $  $' #  4 %'  

  '#  

'   $  

$  %--$ $  '-

# -' -$.'  -   -'

''

'

 $' -$    -' -$. "$' 

 %" $ "# '- !

  .   '  &

  '   ''' '"   % % -  :- '' '% -

$  

 ,.'#.-  .' ':-#$

& '* ; .   " .

!   

$"    "

  / / .

$ 



 



 =

5    "  

."   

         $      .   0 " !'+*2 

   

 =    "        

  #  "  B.   

#18*& "?#$4   "  . 



$>$ $9 "?# #$4      "
 

!'+*2  .

       

. "

  !   "    

.  .#A  "

!'+*2       .  !'+ +*2   



 .  

   

     $  "   

 "

  ''  0)'1" !'+*2 2  

     .  )*1 J B .   .

     &  


 $ 

  " /  "  "

"

 !J  "    . B = "$C D

C "    . D

 . "



  $  . . 

 '< =

"   .   F    

  

       5 "



! $      

 

  .  

  "

   / /  "  

 

 .$



"   !



       I

 H      $  

 

$   "

     "  !    .   

"     5       " 5

    "     !

! 

   $ 

   I

 $!$   

  .

  .  . "

    

!

! $ 

   "

 " ! 



!5  

.   !   

  $  " $   

#  

 

   

    "   I /

'2 :



 "&$& () ">$:< $&;$?$3# ?(#& 0$'
,=.= = =5!

B.    "

  

 .$   

    " $=.     

 .

.



   "   . ! $     "

.

. 

$  5   '9 

   5         

!  "

            

 

 "   !

!   5   ! $    5

  

!   . .#   #  

!$. 

  .""

!  $ 

 .     

=

 





    

"

 " 

L         . 

! .            ', = 

 " $    "



   !

! $    "  

  K   K     "  $ K !K           !

 . .

     :

 !  

    "  "    ! $        

  .#  " 

 

 =  

" " 

    

 

  %0 0 

   

 = 

4    4   

*0 0 

 

<       =  

        4     '0 =  K K   $ $ 

  



 

:

    

 /" !

 .

  !  .

 "  

 !

!

.   

  I  = " K K 



  .

     .

      = 

" 



     

!   .

  I.#! !  !

 3   . 

 !

   /

$ K K !

I.# !  

" =              ! 

    " K !K      :

  !  "

    '- = C "    . D "  " !

! "



   .   $ 

"    = B.  

 "@*$"*$  #' <' &$& &  () ">$#$&  #'     ,=//4 ,  5- $

 



 C "      . D    / 

   . !" 

. !  . ! " . !   

  .  C  "    

 . D  ! 

"

 $ $      $  " "

 

 " 

  ! .  " / .    

    $  

$     $    " 

   

 " $  =  C  "

"      . D     "  ."     . "

B.  

  " 1# %&

%#"1&3$''

81 #18 ))1% #'A''(%1$&1(<'&$& ()$*$#$'*&#$ $ #'   ,==54 /,7:$    .#"

 "/  C "  

   . D

. .      " 

         " . "  .  $ =/  

  " .  "  . 

   .

" "

  5 5 .

   "

  ""! $ " "

 .

 "

"   .  ! "

""

 "   $  

    

  $

 '6 :

   "  $#$9$'1<$9 9 <' "#1'  3$B$   

5,4=6 6.5! B.   !$

 

   C "    .

. D!     .

.

  " 

. " / .

    "   " / .

 /  

  $   C  

   . D= " .    "$C D

 !    

      

   /

 "  C "    . D

 " "

. " / .

= #

 

" .

  

 

!'+*2

   "

" 

$            

 .    .          "   $  "      

  !        " 

""

:



"#18*& "?#$4 

  .

  "    $    .

  B.        $  

"     "  "  .

       

 "       !$      

 



#   $      $ $  !   "  .  

  

  : "       $ 

F   "

"    .    .    "    " " .

  <+ :  ""

     .   !'

'+*2     .  

= 



 

! '+*2  



   "



 

 

          

 $  .   $ 

  .  

!               ""

$ 

 "  <* = !

   

 "     "    $ $ !     $  =    **+,'+*- -

.



*   / / "

" 



 




 

55-56 

4

 '%' /% H H 

A      .   MA MA