Balbir Kaur v. State Of Punjab And ORS

  

        

!"#$#%&'&()*
 !+,&-.!/- #"&"&(#- '

0#-'/'

1"!"#/(2!,!($"3#-'

 #'4($#(" '

)  56  1 .

61  -#'#(")7 -0&8!' 3!"-!"39$:%!"#9-"3#4#"&"&(#- '0!($!(!!+3"-!9$$&"&(!+ /(2!,  3#"3#-"3# #4-"#-'+%!+(#;'4!4#-<!=,#!++;#$" '##"3#2/$><#("?

 ,#-##--#$""3# #4-"#--(" @ 3#"3#-"3#2/$><#("'3/+$,#-#4-"#$&("3#$&>#'"? 77 77 .

61 

6 /-,!8'31&(>39A7 ('"!,+#9"3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#- $&#$(

*
;93&';&# 4-#'#("4#"&"&(#- 3!'&+#$"3#4-#'#("

;-&"  4#"&"&(  &(  "3#  =#!- 
 9  %3!++#(>&(>  "3#  &<4/>(#$  -$#-  $!"#$


B ((#A/-#77
9:&$#;3&%3"3#%+!&<"3#3/',!($"3# 4#"&"&(#-  -  4-#<!"/-#  -#"&-#<#("  ;!'  $#%+&(#$   13#  !+'  '##8'  "3# C/!'3&(>"3#&<4/>(#$-$#-$!"#$


B ((#A/-#77
9;3#-#,= "3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#-;!'$&'<&''#$-<'#-:&%#13#!+'%+!&<' "3#4#('&(!-=,#(#&"'(,#3!+3#-3/',!($"&++"3#$!"#$#!"33#- 3/',!($&#

*
!'3#3!$%<4+#"#$
=#!-'9*<("3'!($D$!=' '#-:&%#-#($#-#$,#-#"3#'!&$$!"#$&'<&''!+;&"3DE4#-!((/< &("#-#'",=%('&$#-&(>"3#%!'#/($#-"3#/(2!, &:&+1#-:&%#' -#<!"/-#

#"&-#<#("  /+#'9*B  "  &' /-"3#-4-!=#$"3!""3#4/(&'3<#(" &<4'#$  /4(  "3#  3/',!($    "3#  4#"&"&(#-  <!=  ,#  %(:#-"#$  &(" 4-#<!"/-# %<4/+'-=-#"&-#<#("&(:&#; /+#
"3#/(2!,+&%#

7
7

/+#'!"#-%('&$#-&(>"3#4-:&'&('"3#/(2!,+&%# /+#' 3#1"!"#&("3#-#4+=3!'!$<&""#$"3!" /-,!83'31&(>3;!' -#%-/&"#$!'! ('"!,+#(
*D,="3#"3#(1#(&-1/4#-&("#($#(" +&%#96/$3&!(!#;!'4+!%#$/($#-'/'4#('&(!'3#;!'("4-#'#(" $/-&(>"3#<-(&(>-++%!++(@*
 $!&+=$&!-=-#4-"@!"

D)    ;!'  -#%-$#$  (  @*
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
B# #:#($&$("-#4+=""3#'!&$'3;%!/'#("&%# ('#C/#("+=9"3#-$#- $!"

#$


B ((#A/-#77
;!'4!''#$3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#- -#<!&(#$%("&(//'+=!,'#("-<$/"=;&"3##%"-<@*
 "&++"3# $!"#$&'<&''!+-<'#-:&%#!($"3#'!&$"&<#;!'"-#!"#$!'(($/"= 4#-&$3#>-'''#-:&%#"3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#-!""3#"&<# '/,<&''&(!44+&%!"&((D
@-'##8&(>4-#<!"/-#-#"&-#<#(";!'
=#!-'9D<("3'!($*$!='3#((C/!+&=&(>'#-:&%#"3#3/',!($ "3#4#"&"&(#-;!'""!+*<("3'9
@$!=' 3/'93&'(#"C/!+&=&(> '#-:&%#;!'*=#!-'9<("3'!($
$!='9;3&%3&'+#''"3!("3#4#-&$ -#C/&-#$-#("&"+#<#("4#('&(9!'4#-"3# :#-(<#("&('"-/%"&(' $!"#$*D9!'3#3!$("%<4+#"#$
=#!-'C/!

7@7 <#-&"'9-#'4($#("'2/'"&&#$"3#-$#-$&'<&''!+-<'#-:&%#!($$#(&!+ "3#4#('&( 3!:#3#!-$"3#+#!-(#$%/('#+'-"3#4!-"&#'!($3!:#!+' %!-#/++=>(#"3-/>3"3#&+# 3#&<4/>(#$$&'<&''!+-$#-$!"#$


B ((#A/-#77
'3;'"3!""3#++;&(>4/(&'3<#("';#-#!;!-$#$""3#3/',!($"3# 4#"&"&(#-,#";##("3#=#!-'
"
 )7 1- ++#>!"&( /(&'3<#("'

 -  "3#  -#!'(    %("&(//'

!,'#(%#&("3#=#!-
 /(&'3<#("    %($#<(!,+# '#-:&%#;!'!;!-$#$&("3#=#!-

-"3#-#!'(!,'#(%#D $!='9
@3/-'9B<&(/"#'&("3# =#!-
 1#-:&%#    "3-##  =#!-'  ;!'

-#&"#$&("3#=#!-
 @ -"3#-#!'(!,'#(%# $!='9B3/-'9@<&(/"#'&("3# =#!-
 1#-:&%#    "3-##  =#!-'  ;!'

-#&"#$&("3#=#!-

 /#"!,'#(%#-<D
 "@
 /(&'3<#("    %($#<(!,+# '#-:&%#;!'!;!-$#$&("3#=#!-

 /#"!,'#(%#-<
"

 /(&'3<#("    %($#<(!,+# '#-:&%#;!'!;!-$#$&("3#=#!-

  /#"!,'#(%#-<DD
" *D
 /(&'3<#("    %($#<(!,+# '#-:&%#;!'!;!-$#$&("3#=#!-
@  /#"!,'#(%#-<
"

 /(&'3<#("    %($#<(!,+# '#-:&%#;!'!;!-$#$&("3#=#!-
@ /#"!,'#(%#-<
D
" D
 /(&'3<#("    %($#<(!,+# '#-:&%#;!'!;!-$#$&("3#=#!-
@ * /#"!,'#(%#-<
D*
" 
 /(&'3<#("    %($#<(!,+# '#-:&%#;!'!;!-$#$&("3#=#!-
@  -"3#-#!'(!,'#(%#D* $!='9 3/-'9@<&(/"#'-< D

"B

1#-:&%#    /-  =#!-'  ;!'

-#&"#$&("3#=#!-
@  -"3#-#!'(!,'#(%#

$!='9B3/-'9B<&(/"#'-<

 

"B

1#-:&%#    (#  =#!-  ;!'

-#&"#$&("3#=#!-
@


-"3#-#!'(!,'#(%#*
$!='9 3/-'9@<&(/"#'-<  

"@

1#-:&%#    &:#  =#!-'  ;!'

-#&"#$&("3#=#!-
@ @ -"3#-#!'(!,'#(%# $!='9
3/-'9@<&(/"#'-<


" 
@ 1#-:&%#    ";  =#!-'  ;!'

-#&"#$&("3#=#!-
  

-"3#-#!'(!,'#(%#"; <("3'9$!='-<BB
@ "
B
@ 1#-:&%#    "3-##  =#!-'  ;!'

-#&"#$&("3#=#!-
  B -"3#-#!'(!,'#(%# $!='9 3/-'9@<&(/"#'-<
DB

"

/(&'3<#("    %($#<(!,+# '#-:&%#;!'!;!-$#$&("3#=#!-
   -"3#-#!'(!,'#(%#@ $!='9
@3/-'9@B<&(/"#'-< @

" 

 /(&'3<#("    %($#<(!,+# '#-:&%#;!'!;!-$#$&("3#=#!-
   -"3#-#!'(!,'#(%#D $!='9B3/-'9B<&(/"#'-<


@"



1#-:&%#    '&A  =#!-'  ;!'

-#&"#$&("3#=#!-
B ("3&';!=9"3#""!+
=#!-'5'#-:&%#"3#3/',!($"3# 4#"&"&(#-;!'-#&"#$9;3&%3;!'</%3<-#"3!(3&'!%"/!+'#-:&%#( "3#&(C/&-=9&";!'/($"3!"3#;!'!3!,&"/!+!,'#("##3#&<4/>(#$ -$#-&"'#+-#:#!+'"3!""3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#-/'#$"-#<!&(!,'#("9 '<#"&<#-<("3'">#"3#-!($'<#"&<#-(#<("3-<-#("3&' ;!=9"3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#-;!'!(&(%--&>&,+##<4+=##!($&";!' -&>3"+=3#+$"3!"3#&'/(&"-4+&%#'#-:&%#3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#- (#:#-2&(#$"3#$#4!-"<#("!+&(C/&-=$#'4&"#-#%#&4"("&%#'##:#( $&$(","3#-"-#4+="3#'3;%!/'#("&%#:#($/-&(>3&'+&#"&<#"&++

*
93#(#:#-%3!++#(>#$"3#'!&$$&'<&''!+-$#-9;3&%33!'(; ,#%<#&(!+ 3#+#!-(#$%/('#+-"3#4#"&"&(#-3!'!->/#$"3!"

&";!' 3#+$&("3#$&'<&''!+-$#-"3!"!$#+&(C/#("#<4+=##&'("#("&"+#$" 4#('&( ,#%!/'#3&'<&'%($/%" &'''#-&/'"3!"2/'"&%#$#<!($'"3# 4/(&'3<#("3&'$&'<&''!+-<'#-:&%#$<&""#$+=9&(!%!'#$&'<&''!+ -<'#-:&%#9!(#<4+=##&'("#("&"+#$"4#('&( 3#4-!=#-"3# 4#"&"&(#-&'"3!""3#%($/%""3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#-;!'

7B7 >-!:#9(;3&%33#'3/+$,#$&'<&''#$-<'#-:&%#3#+#!-(#$%/('#+ -"3#4#"&"&(#-3!'-#+&#$/4("3#!/"3-&"="3&' /-"&(3!(1&(>3 0#-'/'1"!"#!-=!(!!($"3#-'9
D @ 1 
*9$#+&:#-#$,=!

&:&'&(#(%3"3&' /-" !< "3#:&#;"3!""3#!%"'"3#'!&$%!'#!-##("&-#+= $&#-#(" ("3#'!&$%!'#9"3#-#;!'(#!,'#(%#4#-&$ $!='9 ;3#-#!'"3#!,'#(%#4#-&$&("3#4-#'#("%!'#9-#4-$/%#$!,:#9'3;' "3!""3#!,'#(%#-<$/"=;!''<#"&<#-$!='!($'<#"&<#- <("3'">#"3#-($&#-#("%%!'&('  /+#
"3#/(2!,+&%#

/+#'-#!$!'/($#-)7 F 
&'<&''!+)  &'<&''!+'3!++,#!;!-$#$(+= -"3#>-!:#'"!%"'<&'%($/%"-!'"3#%/</+!"&:# ##%"-%("&(/#$<&'%($/%"4-:&(>&(%--&>&,&+&"=!($ %<4+#"#/(&"(#''-4+&%#'#-:&%#(<!8&(>'/%3!( !;!-$-#>!-$'3!++,#3!$""3#+#(>"3'#-:&%#"3# #($#-!($3&'%+!&<"4#('&( FA4+!(!"&(  G  -  "3#  4/-4'#    '/,7-/+#   9  "3# ++;&(>'3!++9&("#-!+&!9,#-#>!-$#$!'>-!:#'"!%"' <&'%($/%"  &(  -#'4#%"    !  4+&%#  &%#-9  !%&(> $&'%&4+&(!-=!%"&()

& ($/+>&(>&('4=&(>-'</>>+&(>!%"&:&"&#'H

&& $&'-/4"&(>  "3#  <#!('    "-!('4-"  -   %<</(&%!"&(H

&&& $!<!>&(>4/,+&%4-4#-"=H

&:

%!/'&(>&($&'%&4+&(#!<(>'"#++;4+&%#<#(

:

-<4"&(>  ##+&(>    #(<&"=  -  3!"-#$  ,#";##( $&#-#("%+!''%&"&I#('($&!(>-/($'-#+&>&(9 -!%#9%!'"#9%<</(&"=-+!(>/!>#H

:& &(>('"-&8#-<!''%!'/!++#!:#--#'-"&(>" <!''!,'#("&('H

77

:&& 14-#!$&(>$&'!#%"&(!>!&('""3# :#-(<#("H!($

:&&& !/'&(>-&"'!($"3#+&#J 3#!,:#-/+#<!8#'&"%+#!-"3!"$&'<&''!+-<'#-:&%#%!(,# !;!-$#$(+=-"3#>-!:#'"!%"'<&'%($/%"-!'"3#%/</+!"&:###%" %("&(/#$<&'%($/%"4-:&(>&(%--&>&,&+&"=!($%<4+#"#/(&"(#''- 4+&%#'#-:&%#3#>-!:#'"!%"'<&'%($/%"!-##(/<#-!"#$&("3#'!&$ -/+#&"'#+ ;#:#-9"3#4/(&'3<#("' !;!-$#$ ""3#3/',!($"3# 4#"&"&(#-!'-#4-$/%#$!,:#>#'"'3;"3!""3#-#;!'%("&(//' <&'%($/%"("3#4!-""3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#-#;!'&(%--&>&,+# !($/(&"-4+&%#'#-:&%#3#-#-#9"3#-$#-$&'<&''!+-<'#-:&%# ;!'-&>3"+=&<4'#$/4("3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#-3#!/"3-&"= "3&' /-"&(!>"!-1&(>30#-'/'1"!"#/(2!,!($"3#-'9
 @ 1 
9$#+&:#-#$,=1&(>+##(%39&'!+'$&'"&(>/&'3!,+#("3#!%"'"3# %!'

# 3#  +#!-(#$  %/('#+  -  "3#  4#"&"&(#- 3!'  !->/#$  "3!"  "3# -#&"/-#'#-:&%#&'(+=!$&'C/!+&&%!"&(-&(%-#<#("!($"3#4#-&$&' ",#%<4/"#$-"3#4/-4'#>-!("4#('&(#3!''"!"#$"3!"!' 4#-  "3#  ;-&""#(  '"!"#<#("9  -#'4($#("'  "3#<'#+:#'  !$<&""#$  "3!"  "3# C/!+&=&(>'#-:&%#"3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#-;!'<-#"3!(*=#!-' !($<("3'!($/($#- /+# &:&+1#-:&%#' /+#'90+/<#79"3# -!%"&(!=#!-#C/!+""3-##<("3'!($!,:#'3!++,#"-#!"#$!'! %<4+#"#(#3!+=#!-9"3#-#-#9"3#C/!+&=&(>'#-:&%#"3#3/',!($ "3#4#"&"&(#-&'",#"-#!"#$!'
=#!-' #3!'!+'-##--#$""3# &(-<!"&(,"!&(#$/($#-"3# &>3""(-<!"&(%"9
B9 ((#A/-#7 7B 9;3#-#&(&"&''"!"#$"3!""3#""!+'#-:&%#"3##<4+=##;!'
=#!

-'9 D$!='9/";3&%3((C/!+&='#-:&%#
=#!-'9D<("3'!($
$!='9 ;3&%3<!('"3!""3#C/!+&=&(>'#-:&%#"3#3/',!

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
@9&(;3&%3&";!''"!"#$"3!""3# #<4+=##&'("<#("!++=##+&(>;#++;#:#-9(<#("!+&++(#''&'4-:#$ (-!

(=$%/<#("&'!((#A#$;&"3"3#4#"&"&("'3;"3!""3#$#%#!'#$ A7 ('"!,+#;!'<#("!++=&++  3#-#-#9-<<#-#!:#-<#("&("3# !44+&%!"&(9 "3#&++(#''%!((",#!''/<#$ &";!''9"3##<4+=## '3/+$3!:#&+#$"3#!44+&%!"&(9!%%<4!(&#$,="3#$%/<#("'"'3; "3!"3#&'<#("!++=&++3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#-%("&(//'+=/'#$" -#<!&(!,'#("-<"3#=#!-
!($"3#+!'"!,'#(%#;!'-<@*
  3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#-;!'(#:#-$#%+!-#$&('!(#,=!(=<#$&%!+ ,!-$-,=!$%"-(-"3#-#&'!(=#:&$#(%#"3!"3#;!'#:#-"-#!"#$- "3#<#("!+&++(#'':#(&9"3#4-:&'&('"3#/(2!,+&%# /+#'!-# !44+&#$9-'/%3!(&(%--&>&,+##<4+=##!$&'%&4+&(#$-%#9"3#(+= 4/(&'3<#("'3/+$,#$&'<&''!+-<'#-:&%# ;9!"#-*=#!-'"3# 4!''&(>"3#$&'<&''!+-$#-!

($ =#!-'!"#-"3#$#!"3"3#3/',!($ "3#4#"&"&(#-94-#'#(";-&"4#"&"&(3!',##(&+#$&("3#=#!

"3#-;&'#,!--#$,=$#+!=!($+!"%3#'",#&(>'9"3#-#&'(&++#>!+&"=-

7D7 &(&-<&"=  &(  "3#  &<4/>(#$  -$#-  $!"#$ 


B   ((#A/-#77
9 $&'<&''&(>"3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#--<'#-:&%#3&' /-"3!'( '=<4!"3=;&"3"3#3/',!($"3#4#"&"&(#-9!'"3#$&'%&4+&(#3!'",# #(-%#$;&"3&-(3!($'!($"3#&($&'%&4+&(#&("3#$&'%&4+&(!-=-%#'+&8# 4+&%#!($!-<=%!((",#"!<4#-#$;&"3 (:&#;"3#<!""#-9'&(%#!$&'<&''#$#<4+=##&'("#("&"+#$ "4#('&(!($"3&' /-"&'("&(%+&(#$"&("#-#-#&("3#'!&$-$#-9 "3#-#-#9"3#4#"&"&(#-&'("#("&"+#$">-!("4-#<!"/-#:+/("!-= -#"&-#<#("-4#('&(-!<&+=4#('&(#(%#9"3#4-#'#(";-&"4#"&"&( &'$&'<&''#$  

.

61     *
 '28' 3#"3#-'4#!8&(> -#!'(#$ ) #'

3#"3#- #4-"!,+# ) #'