← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16678/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. Ex Sub Hari Mitter And Another

2024-10-24Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Alok Jain10 pages

 

        

   !" #$%$!&!&'   

   

  

    

 

 ('  )*(  ++

+ ,

  )*(  +* ,        !   "# 

$  %%%% +

+ ,

-.

*/ & '



   (

! 

 







  

 

&)&)*)&+,  -&.

 

"

 /0 ' "00 !(

   (    

 

        ! 

   0  

 "

1- -1 "



#0 1 #234!0&5 *  2&(  ""



 &))3&345 ( 0

  10 ( 6))3*))*# 7  0

  

  10 ! 

   (    

  ""(

 "

  " (



 

    







  6 '

"

! 

' "00



       $  "

 

 *)8 9)8( )&&)*))*'

 

"0 (  ""( 1  

&)&)*)&+,  -&.'



1

    0

 

   

 

    

      

               

 

      

  !                   

     

 "

  

   !!

#$%&& !



 " % ' ()! *+&, - 5 /

"

    

    ! 

-   "



 (

 +067$%%$!&%!"8 1 4& 5#!0&% 1"!48 9 $$!& 4% 9 



"

0 "

-   

 ,.1 :



;"



# !(

!  

       

    

 

 

1 (

 "

" ( 

!

"

' "00 " 0

    



 <   ""

!  0  7   

29 <

 

;"



# 0 

  (  &&.

//// 



* # +

01*, .

2 2 



 "3



4"

"5%6

2 70 #%! 0 &6)+*))+'

 

29 < 0  0

 

 " #        $     %     

 &       '  &    



  $#   '(   

 

     )   $    

     

  $    *              

        % +                 $                  

 $        $ 

 !

        

   ,   

     !           

         +  $$

       

 

         

 -   

  .    $    

    

               -

$   

 .  /0 

      .     

  

  

     1 

 1

     . 

   

  #  /  0   

   %        

  1

      $       

 

             $ 



   $   



  2

4  

29

,  .0"

"

 0

 0

0    0"  

10 

" 0

!

"

  



1

 "



7 

 

 "!  "

 -  

  

! 

! 

    

  0"  !  

 

0    

( :

! 7   ""( ! (



  

  0



 



 



"

(

 + 

 0 

2<

!



#

0" 



# (  :  

   

01   

&<

 

(



 3 '

 1 ( "



 00

 :

  (  &&.

  



* # +

01 * ( ,.





, "0% ( 6 3



4"

"

5%$"!

"" 

 '

1 

(

 

 0

 

 3 

 







   # $



  $ *    





 4 & 

 

"

 " &

"% %  + +"8!%  !%  % !% !

+"#"  &

"

 +%  #/0    

  

    $ 

/    

  

              $  

  

      

    /0     

    

 

     +  (#   

&

"9!"

#%

% "

&



% & 

 ) * 

  $ 

  

    4     

     

    

  /0    

 #  

  

     

  +067$%%$!&%!"8 1 4& 5#!0&% 1"!48 4 %9!&5 & &)





!

"

0 "

 

   :

  

"0 "



0  !   

   

  0  0  "

 (  " 

 "

 

( 





0



 =  ,.!

 (""

"

 :  "

0

 && 

    !

" 0  " 0  

>

 ?

0  :

   

 ;"

 

  # !   *))3*)&<!0    :$&5 4+$&38;% &$!&!"&5$ &5 8 4%! ( 0 $:$199 1!<< !"    '

1 



 1    0

 

 #     (   5

 , #   6 + 0     ( 783  





        331##   

$       



%  %           

    

$ #          



        ) 

         

      #              

      

   #       9   :4

       

           

          

 331   8

  %  %         $  

 )            

    $ 

331;3  

  

     7 2 &" 4 &# %!"8$%!04 &* '



!1"

0    

    

 (

 0 ""

0    0"  

00

 !

   

    =

 

10   " 0

( !

0



 1 0 ! 



 0 



# 0   3



4"

"5%6 7 #%*+&, 0   0% ( 6 3



4"

"

5%*+&,$

 0

 "00 ! 0 



 - 

1- -1  ! (

 



   0

"

 



 

"

 &6 ?

  ! 

0

 



 0

! 00

,  .  



# !

0    "



0





 !

 1

  "





(" "  0  0  0     0   1- -1 

    "

! 

 

   0"  !

("

 0



  " 



   

10   " 0

("  1 0     " "0= 

   

""

" 

  &5 /

  (

0   0 ( 0  00 1- -1

(   0  0  0   0   

  (

0

!

 "





!      

 0  

1  0   0 00

! !

 =  1

;"



# 0   ) &$!&!"&5$ ;%

7:

4;!



 + &1$& ! 0 &)&**)&5!(

!

 0"   

  !

       0 (    

 00   '

  1 

 00

,  .   0

 



 5+       & '  .      $ 

  

                



        $     $     !

 #  & '             

   0  7 &'-3;-<&=!0'  

      >      < ?$     

    @     

        $            ,

=  $     $    

       ,  =      $ ") $          1)     % & '

  & '              !

   

   

  ;# 

    * /0 



#    

             

  &9 '

 !0

  "





! !

 = 



# !0    ) &$!&!"&5$ ;%

7:

4.%094 /  7 "!

 0"  " ( 

,  .!(

    1 

0 ( 1- -1

00

  "

(

 

!1- -1

00 ! 

   0  

 0     

 

 

:

  !  (

    

  7 " 

  

 

   0"  ! ! 

(

 &< 0

 1  ,  .   0    &)&**)&5 

  

 

 1

  

' "00 !

*)&+'



 

,  .     

    0

!      "

 

   

6@ 

  = " 0   ( !  (

 

  (   

 1- -1

!   ""

0     "

 

 7    '

 !  (

 

  "

 

1





,  .

00   "  0     0      0  0     7 

  "

 " 

    "





 

= 7 



      1 &4 1   

(  0

  0"      " (     ,  . =

  0"       "

" ( 

!

 "

" ( !   1

,  . " =

 0    1- -1

0

 "  00 !  !    

!  " 

00

   

=

  

(  

 ! 

!

""

0

! 

 !  

1

   " 0



$& 1 45 4!"8$%!04 &+  

#  

(

  (

  1     ! 

         '

         &3 0

 0   " 

 0

! ""



"0 ,.!  ! " ,.       .+

+ ,

/  .* ,/    

 = 1



8 8 4%9 2$&3=4 %!& 5 '

 %=!

8 8 44 9!4 '

 %=!