High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25598/2015allowed

Mohinder Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2017-12-07Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath9 pages

!" "#$%$&'

!" "#$%$&' (

(

( ( ( ( ( )*$&+",$&-* "!$!$&", .% ! !" ,/ & &+!*",% "%0&+"&!% )' )' )' )'1 2) 1 2) 1 2) 1 2)33) 33) 33) 33) ,"%"&!' ), --45+6# !"5 ,!*"0"!$!$&", ), 4, 7*)*4&! 5 5 ,/ & ), &+*45+6# !"5 ,,"%0&+"&! ), 8845+6# !"5 ,,"%0&+"&!9 ), *4: "%; :5+6# !"5 ,,"%0&+"&!( 33)5<2= 33)5<2= 33)5<2= 33)5<2= *" 0"!$!$&", * % #* ::"&-"+ !*" ,+", + !"+ > ( > 0 %%"+7/!*" "04!/"-$%!, ,50", !$6"#$"!$"%5 *$; &$7/;*$#* !*"":"#!$&0"!$!$& $:"+7/,"%0&+"&!94&+","#!$& ? @ !*" ,/ & 0", !$6" #$"!$"% #!5

> A , %*,! B!*" #!1C * % 7""& ::;"+ &+!*"":"#!$& !*"0"!$!$&",* %7""&%"! %$+" &+!*",+", + !"+ > 0 %%"+ 7/ !*" "#,"! ,/5 "0 ,!8"&! ,0, !$&5 ,/ & 7/ ;*$#* !*" ,+", 0 %%"+ 7/ !*" ++$!$& : "-$%!, , <+8&=5 0", !$6"#$"!$"%5 ,/ & $& 64, !*"0"!$!$&",+ !"+ * %7""&%"! %$+"

& 7,$"

5 !*" 0"!$!$&", &+ ,"%0&+"&!% 9 D ( ," !*" #88$!!"" 8"87",% !*" &$ ,$8 ,/ -,$#4:!4, : 0", !$6" #$"!$"%5 $%!,$#!$,% A*","$& !",,"

",,"+! %B!*"#$"!/1C5;*$#*$% ,"-$%!","+4&+",!*"#!*"8 & -$&-#88$!!"" !*"#$"!/#80,$%"% 8"87",%;* ,"!7"":"#!"+ ,8 8&-%!!*"8"87",%$&!",8% 7/": ;@>;*$#*," + %4&+",' E@> *" 8"87",% !*" ) & -$&- 88$!!"";$::7" %4&+",' "& ":"#!"+ 8"87",%5 4! ;*$#* %"6"& ;$:: 7" ,8 -,$#4:!4,$%! 8"87",% &+ !*,""

,8 && -,$#4:!4,$%!8"87",%54! !*"8 ! :" %! &" 8"87", %*4:+ 7" ,8 #*"+4:"+ %!" &+ &" 8"87", ;$:: 7" ;8 & 8"87", *" # &+$+ !" %"#4,$&- *$-*", 6!"% ;$:: 7"+"#: ,"+":"#!"+ &" &8$& !"+ 8"87",% ,8 !*" $&%!$!4!$& 0,6$+$&- $& &#" ! !*" %#$"!/F *" ":"#!$& !*" 8 & -$&- #88$!!"" ; % $G"+ ,

@*"&8$& !$&%0 0",%;"," $:"+& @@(8"87",%

$:"+!*"$,&8$& !$&0 0",% ,!*"$,,"%0"#!$6"# !"-,$"%7"# 4%"4! 8"87",%(8"87",%;","!7"":"#!"+ ,8!*" -,$#4:!4, :H&" &+ !*,"" ,8!*"&& -,$#4:!4, :H&" !",;$!*+, ; : !*"&8$& !$&5>

@ 8"87",% ,"8 $&"+ $& , / 4! > 8"87",%5 8"87",% $:"+ !*"$, &8$& !$&0 0",% ,8 -,$#4:!4, :H&" &+@ ,8&& -,$#4:!4, :H&" *",";","># &+$+ !"%7":&-$&-!!*"#*"+4:"+ %!"# !"-,/4! > 8"87",% @ 8"87",% 4! > 8"87",%5 7":&-$&- ! !*" #*"+4:"+ %!" # !"-,/5 ;"," ,8 !*" -,$#4:!4, : H&" &+ &" ,8 !*" && -,$#4:!4, :H&"*"":"#!$&%;","*":+& @*"!! :6!"% 0::"+;"," @ &+(6!"%;","# &#"::"+*"&:/;8 &5;** +

$:"+ !*" &8$& !$& 0 0",5 7":&-$&- ! #I; ,+ : %% # !"-,/5 , && -,$#4:!4, :H&"5; %":"#!"+4&00%"+*"!;!*",%" !%5:" !$& !*"&& -,$#4:!4, :H&"5;*$#*;"," $::"+;$!*!*"":"#!$& )*$&+", $&-*<0"!$!$&",*","$&=57":&-$&-!"&", : !"-,/5;** +%"#4,"+ 6!"% &+ J 8<,"%0&+"&!(*","$&=57":&-$&-!#*"+4:"+ %!" !"-,/5;** +%"#4,"+ (6!"%*4% ::!*"!*,""%" !% !*" && -,$#4:!4, :H&";"," $::"+40;$!*!*" ::;$&-8"87",%' 48 &

"6$ < = ;& 4&00%"+ )*$&+", $&-*"!$!$&", <"&", : !"-,/= %"#4,"+ 6!"% @ J 8,"%0&+"&! ( <#*"+4:"+ %!"= %"#4,"+ ( 6!"% $G4! %"6"& -,$#4:!4, :H&"%" !%;"," $::"+40;$!*!*" ":"#!$& :; &! $&-* < =5 4I*0,""! $&-* <"&", :=5 4, J * & < =5 *40$&+", <"&", :=5 $! , 8 <"&", := &+ 6! , $&-* <"&", :=

> ;"6",5!*"(!*%" !$&!*" -,$#4:!4, :H&"; %&!7""& $::"+407"# 4%" $!$% ::"-"+:/I"0! ,!*";8 &8"87",$&!",8% "#!$& <= !*" #!5;*$#*," + %4&+",' :"#!$& &+!"&4," #88$!!""% <= *" 8"87",% !*" #88$!!"" # 0", !$6" %#$"!/ %* :: 7" ":"#!"+ $& !*" 8 &&",0,"%#,$7"+ &+&0",%&%* ::7"% ":"#!"+4&:"%%*"$% 8"87", !*"%#$"!/' ,6$+"+!* ! !:" %!&"8"87",7":&-$&- ! !*" #*"+4:"+ %!" &+ &" ;8 & 8"87", %* :: :% 7" ,"0,"%"&!"+ !*,4-* ":"#!$&$&"6",/#88$!!"" #0", !$6" %#$"!/$&!*"8 &&",0,"%#,$7"+' ,6$+"+ 4,!*", !* ! ! :" %! &" 8"87", 7":&-$&- ! #I; ,+ : %% %* :: :% 7" ,"0,"%"&!"+ !*,4-* ":"#!$& $& !*" #88$!!""5$ !*"$,&487",$%!"&0",#"&!48 , 8," !*" !! : 8"87",%*$0 !*" %#$"!/5$&!*"8 &&",0,"%#,$7"+F *" ,"%0&+"&! 9 #* ::"&-"+ !*" ":"#!$& 7/ $:$&- & ":"#!$& 0"!$!$& 4&+", "#!$&% ? @ !*" #! 7"

," !*" "04!/ "-$%!, ,5 0", !$6" #$"!$"%5 *$; &$ ;*$#* ; % ::;"+ &+ !*" ":"#!$& !*"0"!$!$&",; %%"! %$+")" &$&-!*","7/5,"%0&+"&!9 ,"0: #"+ !*" 0"!$!$&", *" ,+", + !"+ >( > 0 %%"+ 7/ !*" :"#!$& ,$74& : 84#* :"%% !*" "04!/ "-$%!, , ; % #* ::"&-"+ 7/ ; / &

00" :*"% $+ 00" :; % ::;"+7/!*"++$!$& :"-$%!, ,<+8&=5 0", !$6" #$"!$"%5 ,/ & 7%",6$&- !* ! ":"#!$& !*" 0"!$!$&", # &&!7"%"! %$+"7"# 4%"*"* %7""&":"#!"+ ,8 +$

","&!H&"$" && -,$#4:!4, : H&" ;*"," % ,"%0&+"&! 9 * % #&!"%!"+ !*" ":"#!$&

,8 -,$#4:!4, :H&" &+* +!#80"!";$!*!*"# &+$+ !"%7":&-$&-! *$%H&" &+# &&!7" ::;"+!! I"!*"%" ! !*"&& -,$#4:!4, :H&" ;$!; %!*"!4,& ,"%0&+"&!9!-$&,"6$%$&;*$#*; % $:"+ 7"

," !*" "#,"! ,/5 "0 ,!8"&! ,0, !$&5 ,/ & *" % $+ ,"6$%$&0"!$!$&$% ::;"+7/!*"$804-&"+,+",+ !"+> $&;*$#* $!* %7""&7%",6"+!* !,"%0&+"&!9* +%"#4,"+*$-*"%!6!"%<= 8&-%!!*"# &+$+ !"%7":&-$&-!#*"+4:"+ %!"# !"-,/!*"," ,"5*" %*4:+* 6"7""&+"#: ,"+":"#!"+$&!*"# !"-,/ #*"+4:"+ %!" 2" ,&"+#4&%": ,!*"0"!$!$&",* %%478$!!"+!* !!*","$%

:: #/$&!*" 00, #* ,"%0&+"&!%D@$&0 %%$&-!*"$804-&"+ ,+",% 7"# 4%" !*" ":"#!$& ; % *":+ !*" # &+$+ !"% #&!"%!$&- ,8 +$

","&!H&"%"%0&+"&!95!*4-*7":&-$&-!!*"#*"+4:"+ %!" # !"-,/5* +#&!"%!"+!*"":"#!$& ,8!*" -,$#4:!4, :H&"5!*","

,"5*" * +!;$&,:%" ,8*$%H&"&:/ &+# &&!7" ::;"+!"&!",!*" !*",H&",!*"&& -,$#4:!4, :H&"!$% 4,!*",%478$!!"+!* !!*","$% & +$%04!" 74! !*" %$G 8"87",% ;* * 6" 7""& ":"#!"+ ,8 !*" -,$#4:!4, : H&" ;* ," * 6$&- 8," 6!"% !* & ,"%0&+"&! 9 74! ,"%0&+"&!9* %&!7""&-$6"&(!*%" !$&!*" -,$#4:!4, :H&"7"# 4%" !*"% $+%" !$%,"%",6"+ ,;8 &# &+$+ !"$!*,"- ,+!!*"%!0,6$% ! "#!$& !*" #! ;*","$& $! $% 0,6$+"+ !* ! !*"," * % ! 7" !; ;8"& 8"87", $& !*" #88$!!""5 $! $% %478$!!"+ !* ! :," +/ ;8 &

9 8"87", * % 7""& ":"#!"+ 4&00%"+ ,8 !*" && -,$#4:!4, : H&"5 !*","

,"5 &!*",;8 &* %!7"":"#!"+ ,8!*" -,$#4:!4, :H&"!$%

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

,"5 ,"%0&+"&! 95 ;** %-!8 G$848&487", 6!"%$&*$%# !"-,/5%*4:+* 6"7""& -$6"&!*"(!*%" ! 2" ,&"+ #4&%": , ,"%0&+"&! ( * % %478$!!"+ !* ! ,"%0&+"&! 9 * % & #&!"%! ;$!* *$8 7"# 4%" *" 7":&-% ! +$

","&! H&"!*4-**"7":&-%!!*"#*"+4:"+ %!"# !"-,/&%400,! *$% %478$%%$&%5*"* %,":$"+40& +"#$%$&,"&+","+7/!*$%4,!$&!*"# %" E.$J /348 ,4,$ E.$J /348 ,4,$ E.$J /348 ,4,$ E.$J /348 ,4,$.%*"$!$H"&%,7 & *"$!$H"&%,7 & *"$!$H"&%,7 & *"$!$H"&%,7 &0", !$6" &I2!+ &+ 0", !$6" &I2!+ &+ 0", !$6" &I2!+ &+ 0", !$6" &I2!+ &+ !*",%F !*",%F !*",%F !*",%F @<@= <$6$:= 5 $& ;*$#* !*$% 4,! * % *":+ !* ! !*" 0"!$!$&", 7"$&- 6!", #4:+ &:/ #* ::"&-" !*" ":"#!$& $,"#!, ":"#!"+ ,8*$%H&" !*"0"!$!$&",$%&!$& &/#80"!"&!0%$!$&!-"!

( ":"#!"+ ,8 &/!*",H&"&!7"$&- 6!",5;*","*"$%&!"&!$!:"+! "$!*", -"! *$8%":

,"-$%!","+ % 6!", , , $%" & 7J"#!$& - $&%! !*" $&#:4%$& , "G#:4%$& !*" & 8" !*" 0",%& ,8 !*" 6!",% :$%!5 *" 76$4%:/ ;4:+ 7" : #I$&- $& :#4% ! #* ::"&-" !*" ":"#!$& ,8 % $+ H&" 8 &! 0,"0 ,"+ ! ," + !*" 0,6$%$&% !*" #! $& 8 &&", *:+$&-:#4% !*"0"!$!$&",!#* ::"&-"!*$%":"#!$& ::!*"H&"%!* ! !!*,4-*&"0"!$!$&;$!*4!$80:" +$&-!*"0",%&%;* ,":$I":/!7" "

"#!"+7/ &/ +6",%",+","$!*",$&!*"":"#!$&0"!$!$&,$&!*$%;,$! 0"!$!$& !$% :%%478$!!"+!* !7/": ;@>+"%&!0,"%#,$7"!* !!*"," ;4:+7"&:/&"#*"+4:"+ %!", !*",$!0,"%#,$7"%!* !&"#*"+4:"+ %!" * % ! 7" !*"," $& !*" #88$!!"" ! ,"0,"%"&! !*" # !"-,/ ! $% %478$!!"+!* !*"* %,$-*!:/7""&":"#!"+* 6$&-%"#4,"+8 G$8486!"%$& *$%;&# !"-,/ 2" ,&"+#4&%": 00" ,$&-&7"* :

! !"?,"%0&+"&!% ! > * % %478$!!"+ !* ! !*" ":"#!$& %*4:+ * 6" 7""& $,%! *":+ , !*" -,$#4:!4, :H&" &+!*","

!", ,!*"&& -,$#4:!4, :H&" * 6"*" ,+:" ,&"+#4&%": ,!*"0 ,!$"% &+"G 8$&"+!*" 6 $: 7:","#,+;$!*!*"$, 7:" %%$%! &#" *"$%%4"$&6:6"+$&!*$%# %"$%6",/%*,! &+%$80:"!* ! % ! ;*"!*",!*" ":"#!$& !*" 0"!$!$&",#4:+* 6"7""&%"! %$+" &!*" %I$&- ,"%0&+"&!9L *","$%&+47!!* !7/": ;@>0,6$+"%!* !!*",";4:+7" ":"#!"+8"87",%4! ;*$#*(;4:+7" ,8!*" -,$#4:!4, :H&" &+ @ ,8!*"&& -,$#4:!4, :H&"!$% :%0,6$+"+!*","$&!* !!*",";4:+

! :" %! 7" &" 8"87", ,8 !*" #*"+4:"+ %!" &+ &" ;4:+ 7" ;8 & 8"87", !$% :%0,6$+"+!*","$& !* !!*"# &+$+ !" ;* ;4:+ %"#4,"*$-*"%!6!"%;4:+7"+"#: ,"+":"#!"+ $8$: ,:/"#!$& !*"#!0,6$+"%!* !!*"8"87",% !*" #88$!!"" !*" #0", !$6" %#$"!/ %* :: 7" ":"#!"+ $& !*" 8 &&", 0,"%#,$7"+*"8 &&",$%0,"%#,$7"+$&!*"7/": ;@>&!*"%!0,6$% "#!$& 5 $! $% 0,6$+"+ !* ! ! :" %! &" 8"87", 7":&-$&- ! !*" #*"+4:"+ %!" &+!;;8 &8"87",%* ::7","0,"%"&!"+;*"," %$& !*"7/": ;$!$%0,6$+"+!* !!*","%*4:+7" !:" %!&"8"87", ,8!*" #*"+4:"+ %!"# !"-,/ &+&";8 & *" 7/": ; # &&! 6",,$+" !*" 0,6$%$& !*" #! *","

,"5!*"!*",;8 &8"87",%*4:+ :%7"!*","$&!*"#88$!!"" *"# &+$+ !"%;** +%0"#$ $# ::/8"&!$&"+$&!*"$,&8$& !$&0 0",% !* ! !*"/ ," #&!"%!$&- !*" ":"#!$& ,8 !*" 0 ,!$#4: , H&" $" !*" 0"!$!$&",* % $::"+40*$%&8$& !$&0 0",!#&!"%!!*"":"#!$& ,8!*" && -,$#4:!4, : H&" &+ ,"%0&+"&! 9 * % $::"+ 40 *$% &8$& !$& 0 0",!#&!"%!!*"":"#!$& ,8 -,$#4:!4, :H&"5!*"$,%" !%* 6"!7" +"#: ,"+&:/&!*"7 %$% !*"6!"%%"#4,"+7/!*"8$&!*"$,H&"% &+ !*"/# &&!!,"%0 %%!!*",H&"&!*"-,4&+!* !!*"/* 6"%"#4,"+!*" *$-*",6!"%,!*"/* 6"-!8,"6!"%$&!*"%$8$: ,# !"-,/ - $&%!!*" # &+$+ !"#&!"%!$&-$&!*",H&" &!*$%,"- ,+5!*"+"#$%$& !*$%4,!5,"&+","+$&!*"# %" .$J /348 ,4,$<40, = .$J /348 ,4,$<40, = .

$J /348 ,4,$<40, = .$J /348 ,4,$<40, =5*":0%!*"0"!$!$&",!*:+!* !,"%0&+"&!% &+@* 6"#88$!!"+ 0 :0 7:"",,,$&%"!!$&- %$+"!*"":"#!$& !*" 0"!$!$&",;$!*4! 00,"#$ !$&-!*" #!!* !!*"0"!$!$&",+"%&!7":&-!

!*"H&" ,"%0&+"&!9&!*$%,"- ,+!*"+"#$%$&! I"&7/,"%0&+"&! 00" ,% ! 7" J4%!$ $"+ &+ !*4% !*" $804-&"+ ,+", 0 %%"+ 7/ ,"%0&+"&!% D @ ," *","7/ %"! %$+" &+ !*" ,+", 0 %%"+ 7/ ,"%0&+"&!$%,"%!,"+ $!*!*"%"7%",6 !$&%5!*"0,"%"&!0"!$!$&$%*","7/ ::;"+ <33)= <33)= <33)= <33)=

(

( ( ( ( ( *"!*",%0" I$&-?," %&"+

"%? *"!*",,"0,! 7:"

"%?