High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/194/2018dismissed

Sat Narain v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-01-16Mr. Justice Amit Rawal5 pages

!" "#$%$&'

!" "#$%$&'(

! ) $& "!$!$&") *% ! !" )+ & &,!-")% "%.&,"&!% /' /' /' /'0 1/2 0 1/2 0 1/2 0 1/22/ 2/ 2/ 2/ )"%"&!' /)-$3 4 5, 6,7# !"6

)!-"."!$!$&") 22/6 22/6 22/6 22/6 -"."!$!$&")$% 88)$"7", 8 $&%!!-"),"), !", (

9:+ ;-$#-3$#"&#"

$%%<",!-$5 ))<&&$&8!-") !$&,".!- %:""& )"74",:+!-" $%!)$#!, &,<..3$"%&!)33")6&". ! &, 3%!-" ),"), !",((

(. %%",:+!-" ".<!+55$%%$&")#<533"#!)6 &". !:+;-$#-!-" .." 3 $3",:+-$5; %,$%5$%%", -" $%!)$#! , &, <..3$"% &!)33")6 &". !6 ;-$3" )"74$&8!-"3$#"&#" !-"."!$!$&")6- %5 ,"!-" 33;$&8:%")7 !$&% & (

9' ="8 ),$&8 &5 3$"%

<&, $& %! !"5"&!% .")! $&$&8 ! !-" ,$%!)$:<!$& ) !$&:+,".!-3,")7$,"!-$%

$#"3"!!")

>99 , !", ??

!-" ,".! -3,") ; % # 33", ) $3$&8 )".3+6 .),<#$&8)"#), &,.<!!$&8 )!--$%%! &, :+ #5$&8 $& .")%& & ?

&, !-"

)".3+ ;-$#- - , :""& $3", :+ !-" ,".! -3,") & ?

&, -" # 5" .)"%"&!

).")%& 3-" )$&8& ?

&)"8 ), ! !-" )"% $, 5 !!")% &, % &8<$&" "@ 5$& !$& !-")"#),.)"%"&!",:+,".! -3,") - , :""& %%$8&", ! -)$ 7""& 3$; 36 &%."#!) -)$ )$&,") -3 ; !6 &%."#!)6 & <) -" &A<$)+ &%."#!)0%)".)!)"7" 3",!- !$&!-"5&!- 7"5:")6

!-" ,".! -3,") - % ,$%!)$:<!",!-";-" !B 48%.")5"5:") &, $& !-" 5&!- "#"5:")6

C !-)"" A<$&! 3 ;-" ! - % :""& %-;& ! :" ,$%!)$:<!",$&"@#"%%-",".!-3,")- % %-;& C 48% ;-" ! ,$%!)$:<!", ! " #- # ), -3,") !

# ), -3,") & ?

C;-")" %-"; %!,$%!)$:<!"C 28% & " #- # ), ".! -3,")- % 8$7"& &3+%!#4)"8$%!") !-".<3%":<!-",$,&! .),<#"% 3")"8$%!") &, )!-$%)" %&!-" ,$%!)$:<!$& .<3%"#<3,&!:"5 ,"% .") !-" %! !"5"&!% 8$7"& :+ ( 1> # ), -3,")% !-" ,".! -3,")% ,$, &! ,$%!)$:<!" !-" ) !$& ;$!- "

"#! )5 7"5:")6

C ! / )#-6

:<! ,".!

C -3,"),$,&!.),<#"!-"% 3")"8$%!") )5 &< )+6

!/ )#-6

!-")"

)"6!-" ,$%!)$:<!$& ) !$& )5 &< )+6

! / )#-6

#<3, &! :" ! 33$", ;$!- !-" %! !"5"&!% -")"

)"6 %")$<% $))"8<3 )$!$"% - 7" :""& #55$!!", :+ !-" ,".!-3,")$&) !$&,$%!)$:<!$& &,$&!-$% ; + -" - % 7$3 !", !-" 8<$,"3$&"% !-" ,". )!5"&! -" ,".! -3,") $% 8<$3!+ &! :"$&8 .)"%"&! !!-"!$5" $&%."#!$& -$%,".!6 &! - 7$&8 "3"#!)&$# ;"$8-$&8 5 #-$&" $& !-" ,".! &! ,$%.3 +$&8 %$8& : ), ,".!&!-".)"5$%"% ) !$&,".! &! - 7$&8 !-" 3$%! ,$%!)$:<!$& #55$!!"" 5"5:")%6 &!4"".$&8#5.3"!")"#), % 3">%!#4 )"8$%!")6 $&,$&8 ,$

")"&#" $& !-" ;-" !% %!#4 ##),$&8 ! % 3" )"8$%!") & !-$% ; + #!$& $% )"A<$)", ! :" ! 4"& 8 $&%! -$5 -" ,".! -3,") - , :""& -" ), :+ !-" <&,")%$8&", $& .")%& &

9 :<! -" #<3, &! .),<#" &+ %3$, .) $& -$% ,"

"&#" -"&#" -" $% &! "&!$!3",!3"&$"&!7$";6!-")"

)"66/ &$%- /"-) 6

$%!)$#! , <..3$"%

&!)33")6 &". ! $& !-$% # %" )+ & <:3$# $%!)$:<!$& +%!"5 D"8<3 !$& &, &!)3E:+"@")#$%$&8.;")%<&,")),")

)"74">)"%#$&, !-" .<:3$# ,$%!)$:<!$& 3$#"&#" ,".! -3,") -)$ !+ & ) + &6 *$33 8" -<) & 6 "-%$3 - & &, . %% ),") ! ) "$!", !-" ,".%$!", %"#<)$!+ ,".!$& 7<) )+ & 7")&5"&!F -" ".<!+ 55$%%$&")#<533"#!)6 &". !6 ;-$3" ,$%5$%%$&8 !-" .." 3 $3", :+ !-" ."!$!$&")6 - % 5 ," !-" 33;$&8 :%")7 !$&%&((

(' = !") -" )$&8 :!- . )!$"% "7 3< !$&8 !-" $3" $! $% )"7" 3", !- ! 5 &+ $))"8<3 )$!$"% - 7" :""& #55$!!", :+ !-" ,".! -3,") &, -" ,$, &! .),<#" !-" )"#), ;-"& -" ; % %4", ! , % " .),<#", )"#), 3 !") &

!") #&%$,") :3"!$5" &,-",$,&!.),<#"!-" #5.3"!" )"#), -" .."33 &! - % :""&

),", ..)!<&$!+ -" )$&8 :"

)" . %%$&8!-"$5.<8&", ; ),:<!-",$,&! .),<#" &+,#<5"&!,<)$&8!-"#<)%" -" )$&8 ;-$#- %-;% !- ! ,".! -3,") ; % &! .") )5$&8 -$% ,<!$"% .).")3+ / &+ # ), -3,")% - 7" 5 ," !-"$) %! !"5"&!%

9 8 $&%!!-",".!-3,"),<)$&8$&A<$)+!- ! ,".! -3,") $% &! 8$7$&8 !-"5 <33 ) !$& -"$5.<8&",),"), !", (

9. %%", :+ $%!)$#! , &, %<..3$"% &!)33")6 &". ! $% 5")$!)$<% ;-")"$& & $&!") ")"&#"$%; )) &!",-"&#"!-" .." 3 !-" .."33 &!$%-")":+,$%5$%%",-"5"% 3

!")#5.3$ &#":"#&%$8&",$&!-")"#), )5F -" &3+ )8<5"&! ) $%",:+ !-" #<&%"3 ) !-" ."!$!$&")$% !- !!-") !$&# ),-3,")%- 7"8$7"&

$, 7$!%!- !!-"+- 7"&8)$"7 &#" 8 $&%!!-"."!$!$&") &,!-") !$&,".!; %.).")3+)<&:+-$5 5 ) $,!- !!-$%4$&, "7$,"&#"# &&!:"34",$&! ! !-$% %! 8" "%."#$ 33+ ;-"& !-" "7$,"&#" - % :""& )"#),", 8 $&%! !-" ."!$!$&") :<!7 )$<%$))"8<3 )$!$"%#55$!!",:+-$5$&!-",$%#- )8" -$% ,<!$"% % ) !$& ,".! -3,") "&#"6 , &! $&, &+ 5")$! $& !-$% ."!$!$& &,!-"% 5"$%-")":+,$%5$%%", D22/E D22/E D22/E D22/E (

-"!-")%." 4$&8>)" %&",

"%> -"!-"))".)! :3"

"%>