High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16181/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. No 6306149f Ex Sep Sewa Singh And ANR

2024-11-29Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

!"#$%

"#"&#'

!"#$(

)$ *+) ,,

, -

*+) , ,, , ) # "$%& ' () *+ (,

( -. - /*

0 ' 1( *(2(,")3( / ,

, -

5*#** (6

* 7 /"(, (%/* #("

/* "

"( " 888 9

7:, ( ( " $% * - ( " 2 " 3 5$(- 33 ",6* $%* 3-(2/ /* #(/ "($-%

6((--6

/'0&/1/'23"&#!

1 "2%;

(/( /* (-* #* 3 /* ,* 3 "* "($-%/

'<5 < 5 .< .5 .

9 '=:8;9:("6( "3*(# "/2 > ? * 2 /"3*(# ,* "($-%6(( "@A/6% (

5* "($-% 3-(2 / * 6( 3 .2

*%,** #"*(* ( "($-%6( * ($($- $ #(##()( "$% " /2-(%

/- " ,$ / * - ( "2 3 5$(-33 ",6* $%* 3((3*(-- # * (/ (" 3"

5* (" ,$ 3(2 (--6 ")"

"( 888 5*

() (/* (""

(3 "* (/

!# "$%"

&'( )

* %+

, >

-#(## "/2* (/ (""

( ( " 9 (:,$%* - ( "2 "3 5$(-33 ",*

7/"(*(/- "* (#(* (6

/ *.

"4056 "&0

= / 3

"#2(B ( // 3) ("1"3( 6

, ( /-((3 /"

2#6* /(--2 /(%" )7C7)(%2 2$ /* "

-,$ *$ # -- "* (2%,"

(* (- (# , *$ 32# - ",((2 2$ /* 32$(( / ($-*2 ,(* * (2 2(#"

3 ",% * (

,* -2 * #3($- $

* 3# (-$ #3($- $ (##()( "$ # ($($- 2-(% ,*(3D ",/2,* 3 /** 1"#2 !E$-

.,3( - ( ,

! 5* )( ((#( * / * (" ) "3 (

(3 * (/

12 3

-!+

8 . "$%-9

.4(( 17 ":;2

12 .

(

<7 = & 7 ">12?

12 '

17 $2

1 2 (

<7 ">12?

1 2 (

<">12?

1 2 (

A B 5

<">12?C

1 2 (

A B

4((

A 1A 82 -!!- 96

D 8 9

;

3) ("#9:/* ($)

(3 " 3 , *#* "-%"

3-( ,*(6* ("($-%$ (- " (%2 2$ /* 32$(("

/ ($-*2 ,("6*3*

/8A) ,* ,*#*(%3*"($- "2 2$ )(-"

"/2* 2%,$% * (# "* //"($-%

,* (#2 /"($-%

(% 2$ /* 32$(("

/ ($-*2 ,6*$ (- 6* ( "($-% (D(2 / 8A 2 , $ 2

() -% ( "

3-(( /2 * '

"3(- =(", (* 3(""-%

3#*(* ("(( ""($-%$ #($($- 32#(##()( "$%2-(%

5* (""

3-(($

1 6

8 . "$%-9

.4(( 17 ":;2 * 2 ,*#** ( 2 (# )7C7)* " *%3(-("2 (-* (-*/(%2 2$ /* / ($-*2 33 ",

3(--%6* (* (# /* 32# -- ",* 3"($*$ 32#$ 6*(%"

' ) ,*#** * (-(/*

2 , *( 6* (% "

( * , * 33 $ -%, * $% * (" *(

# / "

(9: #/(%" ,(* $ 2 ( -/* # ( ( 2 2$ / * "

/ ($-*2

() -%,* / )#* "62 D($ / 9 (:)7C7)* 33 ",$ "* -% ,(" 3( ,* (" 2(7"3*(# ",* ,* 3-(2( - " ) "($-%

' ) ,(--* /(3 (" 332(3 ( "( * " / $% * 33 ",( $ 3- -%3F ",*/"

3-(#6* * /(%" )7C7)* 33 ",( -D( "

/ 2-(% ("0 * (2 $ # (##()( " $% $ # ($($- 2-(%

= *((2(%,* $ (- /*(/*

3 9:*(% * 3($ "

(-/"($-%

* 33 ",$-% & (:* 2 /(33

(3 /* 33 "2-(% ,2 #$ 32# 3"

"3(- =(" )7(7) * $ # $ 6* ( " 6*3* *6 ,$ 33-"

% #*2 /$ -

$: % /* "

( * /, 2(% (- $ -%$ 33-"

"3(-=(", ( /2 " / 2-(% $ # ($($- 2-(% ,(* * (2 #( 3# (-"

* ,/* 2 "3(- *-"*(* " 3-"

*()

3 "2 "3(-

(2(/* 33 "$ # 2("

,* *$ 32# - " ,* ,* (2 6--$ "

"*() ( "# ,% * (9 (:,* '

"3(-=(" "( * (/ 33-"# 8

' ) ,(-"

3-( " (,*(2("(% /* '

"3(-=("/--6* #"

- -(""6.*( 7 /* G "

"3(-9'-(%

:,88HG - &

(- 3 G

5* / ,*($ 6"

2 "6* 2/ ($) 3 ,6* (* 2 / -2 /* * 2%,*(/ ( -2(%2 "3(-

(2( #2("

)7(7)** (-*,*( 3(2 3"

"($ 2 " $ # *2 ("0 6* 2 $ 3(2 (

"*(* ("" 6(("2((#

' ) , (- "

2 ",/2* /(3(*(",6* * (3((-

7 * /* " ,("0* # /,*

,* * --2 /* (B# -(3 , )7(7) * (3) " $% *2 / 2-(% ,6* $%,*.2(%33-"

*(* / " $(* 6(( -/* # * 2% ("(3*6(($($- $ 3(2 (##()( "$%* # 2-(%

("",(- #(* "/2* 3",6* * '

"3(-=(",""(--% 3

"2(B ( (- "3) ( (-3* 3B, (3-(-%(

(#* (") /* " ,*#* -%2 / ( /2 "3(- 3*D , * ) -# * $-3B 3*( # 3 3 3, 6* /2,(* * " 3(2 3 ' ) ,/* ("

-%2 /(- -(-%,* $%2(%$ 33-"

"D(

* /,*$ * (

-2 (B#

-(3 ,(* 6(3# (-$6 "# "/ 2-(% "

$ #($($- $ 32#(##()( $%

/2(3 /2-(%

.(-%,/* ( -%

3*D (* (# /(

-2 (B# -(3 ,*$%* '

"3(-=("33 ",- ("(33-,*(* ( (* "2(3"

/(%" ,$% * (""2("

*$#* -2 /(%

-* (2%,()%( /3

-(-%* $ (3) "

30 * /, "#* 3 / "/2-(% ,$6-"((--% ("(6 --33-$%* '

"3(-=(",*((3) $ $ 3(2 3 " /2 ( // 3) 3((- # 3 3 3 6* $%* 6-"$ "

(-/"($-%

!6 ,6* (" (),*. $

(3#* 3 /* ,($ 3(2 3"

2 "3(-$("

* (" #(", (( >/* (

7$B

(3 "* (/

5*((* 6(-62 "3(-3( #% =

9 :/* "($-%'<5 < 5 .<

.5 .

9 '=:8;9:J (* 2 /"3*(# * 6($#*$ / ("-%3 " '

"3(- =("9 '=:* -" ?(;'-(%! (-, 6* * 6(2 "3(--%K *%3(--%

(2 "("* "($-% 6( " I * ($($- (##()( " $% 2-(% (" 3 3 " 6* L6* 2(B*(3 3 "6*

5* "3(-$("( ""

/"($- @A/ 6% (6*32 ( 2 @A L

("#/* 3" (-*((* 2 /* (

-2 (B# -(3 (* 3(2 2("

2 /* 3 9 (:"

3-( !E$-

.3( - "( #$ $%* '

"3(-

% =(",*(2 " 6*3**6 ,""/$"* ,$ - "* 2%,""2(B -2(% # / , * "

3-(( / -(6 1"#2 9 (: *( $%* ( 2 *(* 3#/* ("" 6(( -/ "/ , /()($-%

"6 ")7(7)* 5*#** (" 2 $($- $* - (" )"

$* (" 2 3(2 3( *

!6 , * (" 3( )"

(""3#"3*(##)7(7)* ,(* /3# -% $#* (" 2 ,$((--%(-""3(( "%(- * '

"3(-=(", #(# -/* ()/ (*#, *#* -%2 / * ( / $-3B 3*( # 3 3((- 3 3 3*D 9:, 6* $% 2(% $ 3(2 () "*(* #/* " * (2%

-, 3(2 3 "/2( (-# 3/(2-%*% ' ) , $%6((- ( "* 2 "3(- ,*( " $/(6 --/2 " ((* 6((3# (-" ("$ 3(2 * (##()( "$%$ 3(2 ($($- 2-(%

;

!6 ,( ("#/ 9 (:,"3- *(*(

" ( %

" /2 (" ( *() $

9 (:

( "-%,3 )"

$ 2 9 (:*($

,* $%,* .3( "#) 6 #*(# * /* 2 "3(- $(",(

(3 "9 (:

. 3-%,* $%3 3($

(# "* (--/2 " (,$ "

* $%* # /* " 3($ ("$ ( -/( (-# 3 /(2-%*% .(-%, "

3-( "( /2 "/2-(%

("", "

3-( " ($($- $ 32#(##()( "$% "/2-(% $%* ?

' ) ,*#*( "* *(* " 9:

33 "6*- 3(2

/2 "

(* (

(3 ( (,$3 *

2("( * )( #-(,6*3*2(B * #/* " 9:(

(3 ( (,$ # (/* -*((3*,E #""

( /2 * " / 2-(% $ 3(2 (##()( "$% "/* 2-(%

3 ,* -(3B/* ("

2("( * #-(," 3(* .33-"

,*( /* #/* ("" 9: *33 "(

(3 ( (,* $%,* ("

# ( $ "

3-( " $ (##()( " $% $ # ($($- "/2-(%

* ,3 2/* 1"#2

.,3( - "(& '()@

*+,!- 6* ,("

3-((2("

,*(* //"#//,(* *($ "6 * 33 -(-%(-* "

/ ($- #* 3(2 ) " * / *

B# D( * (

"#//$ #2("

*/()

* 6 3 * "

3-(( / -(6 2("

"39 (:2(B * (""

3-(($ (

-(/-(6 2,* $%,*

-(/-(6 2,(2("

) "3 9 (:(-2(B * * "

3/ "$ /)7(7)* /

- 33 ", ,

, (- - * 33 ",*((%2

B* #(#/* "62 ( 2("

* "

,("*(,* /-- 32 ,(

- "

,$ "

3) /* $(,/(%,/"

-(%("-(3* 8 5* / , * #(# / * $ / / * (

"#//, 2/* ) "39 (: 5$(- 33 ",(-" // /2(%-- #(-%(" * -"

6#/1 !

"4056 "&0

(/ 2(*,*./"2 * 6

("6*$ )(($) ,* (2 "2

5* 2 # ""

,( ( - ( "5$(- 33 ",2(( "("(//2 8

"/(-#6*(--

"#(

-3(9:,/(%

, -

7, , )8 (

" * 5 /26#3:

/ "# !

5 9"0/;1