High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/552/2006allowed

(O&M)Brij Bala & ORS v. Raj Kumar & ANR

2023-04-24Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

!"# $# %&'% ) **(( +! ',!# ) *

+ -) .!/"

'!$) # /"

**((

)!(% (/"

% (/"

* 0

%&(2

""!

) % ( '& # )&"!( /)&3&%&'% 4 5&5/,!(*$) # 4/0&) $) # /&

$) # 4#& !6)

&)$) # 4#&/ ((& % (0 / #7 8& 2) 7!6) "( &!$"

& +)&"( "

/ 9 )&

) "

* & ',!# 4&"!#5 0

(:! " 8#* 23 &!

&8 7 &66&

&0;

) &6 "

/ "( &#&6 "#*

&/ 7 ) ""& 8( &# -&7! (/ #7

)-&7! * )& /% ( '" 5 6&6#)&)! 8(

. /#7 8& 2 )&7&"2"(""

( & ) <

#/5) ) ) ") 8&&( ;*&

( 8)5./ #7 8& 2 ) &6"

7&6&72* 0 ',!# & ) 6(&6 # "

# # 7)& )& )& 7&"2"(< !(

(2% ( '((5 !&'!&<)5 & (2

8&&(;*&

(/#7 8& 2#5))5 )& &(&

2 ;*&

(/ #7 8

/ )5/ ) !""!#7 ) &'!&

7&6* )*(&"/# (:5& 6 5 " ""&6 / )" 5 6 7!

2 )) &#:& #2<)5 6

&6*& /=*# )<)! 5.5& )+&.&6- !/#7

8& 2 5 7&6* &/>=*# 2< (( 5* )& &6-)"( " "#*

( .) 7&66& &"/7 &(*

# " & : )5&

# &(72* 0 /)&

)) "

! &5)&")% ( ') ( )&(&72 ) 6(&6 &&6 &?! &72)&#

))"

#!* 5& &

)) 7 ((2&(& 72 )*(&"

: )5&

# &(72* 04&! " "#* 2/& (&&(# &?! &&

& 7*( & )&"

72 )*(&"& "((!&5& )* 0 '! @ "#*

&# &! ""#* 2$!")&! ""#* 2 ( & 7'"

* 0 5 &6 (& "

&&&6(&""

&# )) &(

# "& & &! "*(&"2/ )/ )&! ""#* 2& (& 7( * 2 2 "#*

& > )*( &6 )* &((5&6&!5 #

A) ) )

)% ( ' .*( "! ) ) 6(&6 &&6

&8 0; 72*

0 B A) ) )(2(6 ()& )" ( "#*

&:/)5#!") #5)#B A) ) 0 5 )(&6 (&&&6 (&""

&# ((6 :/& "

B A) ) &&7 '&" 2 * &B (& % )* &5 ?!

** !& & ( &"&*"

)&*"

&"( &# 9 ) &6 ( "!( ) * &/ ) "( * &5 &#&72 )-&7! (&5

/5)&") ( 66& )2) &( (7 )&

8! / &"5)&")5 &! ;5/(2 * 0 &! " "#* 2 ) *!

& " )!6) "!( "

:) ) ( "!( )* &7&6&6

)!6) )" :&

)&#*!6 "

'!&"& ("!

&2 &(& 7( 7 &

-)-&7! () # &(2&#& &

!( &&6&!0 "&&6

&! )(&6

5 "

!! ) 6(&6 &&6 72 ',!# 4* 0 ) 7 ((2 &(& )&"

72 &"((!&5& ) ',!# $!)&(,!# /5)& & 5& 7&6(

)) * ((2

;5/ ) & ** ") )-&7! (& )#

! &#**-)-&7! ( 5& )#

"&&6 "&#& ("

5)! *6!&( ""! )&6)&

2 )*"!

&/"#*( (26

7& 5 "( &!$"

& +)&"(/ 5)&")& *&"5( (6&(

5 *&*#*

"#*

& */5)!

&&'!25 )** 5)&")& # 6 (6 (*

&*/5)6 .&((&

& ;2* ")&"

( ** ")& 7 * 5)&(

'!&"

&6!") 2** &$ &"

!(*"! &"

**(&"

7( )

0 )(/ ) (!&"& ( 5((

"!#

2&" *&!0 7!

)-&7! ("#*( (2 #& )&" 56(2& * )( 5 A$!)&(,!# *& )25& ""! !** 6&& &;5 "@ #&

(6 )7) ( 7!

)"!( 7)

2 #

& (*& 0*&!#& 27 5)&# * 0 7*/*#* 725)&"))#&6) * ((2

!")* -)-&7! () '"

)&*& & )

)"#!

7 (

& )"

*& & )& 5& "!( ) 7&"

& !")

# :

&5)*&

*& & (

&& 7 '"

&6) (2-)!6)& "

7 &

!")*& && 7 "!

&&C"((2; )"&7&(& 2 A$!)&(,!# "!(

7) . 2#

& (*& ;&*"

)(

&#"#!

! ( *7 7( ""! 6&72)&# 5 )2(& ":

5 )/5))

. )&'!&& ((2 8&&( ;*&

(/#7 8& 2 ) &(&

2;*&

(/#7 8

)/5)) * )#

5& )6 *(&" )7 &)&

# /# (:) 7"

!7 )&6&72$!)&(,!# )

): 6& & )! ) 2 5

'! && )#&) * )&##&

"" )5& 5

. )&'! ))*&

(& )&(&

) ( &6 )&#!

6&6 )*(&"

&& (6* ) D )5&/ )&#!")( 2&* )#

*(&"-)

.*( " -)&'!5 )*&

(&C

&(&

2 ;*&

(/ ) *(&" ) " )&

# :

# 27# &)

)* 5& )6

( 27(6 &

0 >/"*2 5)&")D@ D*72 A>;8$!),!# # )

# $) ((2$) # /& ()(# & )8! 8E /#7 /&

* 0 ',!# & "&6"&#& ( & ( !&6 $)) **) "*2& *( )*( " D@ /! )

.& "! 272

)*(&" & 76 ( !* &72 ',!# :

& 7

* 0 7 ) *& 5& 7@ *

)# !

7&6&72)&#) "

! -)/ )&" !"72 6!7!

-)*(

.72 )&! ""#* 2

&( &&"((!&5& )* 0 (((

)

* 0 5!(

. !7( 6

&6)&#(&(& "&#& ("

7&6 &

/ 6

&6)&#(( 7 &(/)&"

7&6&C72 )*(&"/6

( !* & *!"&6 & )8! ") 2

) &6<)&#(7&6") (( & < &6&

)8! ") 2

) &6 "&6 )&. &#*&# 5& )!

2)2# 072

#!")&.

!7('! 7(#* 6 "#*

&-)&*(

)&! ""#* 2&( "&"&6-)/ )&"

6&72

)-&7! (&!0 & (6 ((2!

& 7( ) #&

& &! & "& & ! ) "( * )(&6 )

)% ( ')

.*( "! )

6(&6 &&6

&8 0; 72*

0 ',!#

) )* )-&7! (&

"&&6 &!0 /& & 7 ) "& ) )&!5)& 5 ?!& 6&&!5&&&6

0 )(/:*" "& )&! (

> A& )6 &!0

/# )"& *&

%&'%

&5&5/,!(*$) # &# '/0&) $) # &

$) #

#& !6)

&)$) # &#&% ( '/ !"))&3 ) )2 ( 6 "#*

& &#)&

)/" 5

7 6 7!

2 /6

&6*&/= # )(2 2/>= -)&" !"72 72@ #&&6 A$# .

)/ ""!

/F,&6-/#7 8& 2/5)

" 5 #*(2 G

,*5& 2 5 6

&6 2 />=*# )*&6 2" &&"

D@ % &#2 A #)$ ") /$*"& (&

/ 0%/% (0 /#7 / 5)) 7!6) )*&""

)) 6

*& ! =& )# )"

))&5&5%&'% 5 6

&6*&9=:

*&7&6 572% ( '5 =5& )>= # )(2 2/

(&"#"#!

> =

: &5 )

& !

)& 2

## $"

%5) 6" 5 7 5 2 /

H #! & 7 5 !

!**"

# )(2&"# )" &

. > I> J9=

9 : # )

& !

)& 2

& '

(

% )"

## $"5) )!#7* #&(2##7 ! /!"

& 5 (@*& 7

. = ) &6

*"2 "( "# !

>= * # )/ !

*"2"#!

>@ J>/= ,*&6&&5 6" 7 &&5 '!6#

" #!( &*(&

& ?!& 7 **(& &6

)"#*

&* 7("#!

>/9/= >/@

* )(

'!6# #*

+, , #- .

$ ( !

)1213

44%/

3/ 7 6 !#/=&

(! )) (" &!# -)"( ! ) (6 /= ! (@* /=(

("#*

&"#!

>/9/I>/J //=% (& 7( * 2 )"#*

&'& (2

((25& )& K>H* !## )

&(&6 "( & &(( !

( (&C

&7&" )* & -)! &! 0 & "& & ! "( =* & 05"#&6 &!0&

!"#L-)! * )&&!5

)&! ""#* 27!

& 7!6) 2&"" &") 6 )!8!( )&! ""#* 2) "(& &"

&6&! "*(&"2(2-)!/ )&&!&"&

)&! ""#* 2 6 &!0

!"# /& &7

)&/ 5 &! ""#* 2 )&6"

) 7&#*(

* 0 )*&! 7" 27 -&7! ("

& '!&"

& &-)/ * && 7 '& )" 2* & )&&!& "& 0 & ! ""&6(2/ (& ""* -) & & & "#*

&//=5& )& K>H*

!## )

&(&6"( & &(( !

( (&C

7&" )* && "( )"#*

& / )(& 7&(& 2) ((7'& (7 -) #! ) ((7 ** & ((5

&0 4$# %&'% H &0 40&) $) # /&

$) #

&) $) # #& 4 H ") &0,!(*$) # 4 H $&" && )2 2 ) ( *# )

& & !

&/* &0 40&)

$) # /&

$) #

&)$) # #!

&# '& 725!")!&)&6*# '& 2/ )&) 7 ( )# &6) 2& *& )& )# &#

(&C7 . $&" )# & (

""* / )#&"(( !

**(&"

& /& 2/

&* ""&6(2 %&'

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#