High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25709/2015dismissed

Indu Bala v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2022-12-21Mr. Justice Arun Monga17 pages

"# $!%&'&"()

!%!*+!, -

) .

/ 0 1 ,!'!( )

" # $ %&

'%&

( ) 22222 - 0

+# & &

- ..

/0 ./12, 3 12- *

.) ./12 , 3 14-

/5 1.

./12 " ( ) "

# & 6& # &

/0 /7 ./1.

" ++ &&

8 &

/0 /7 ./1.

"9+

+ # &

+ && 3+ .;

/0 1075

, 3 1-

./).107;

./ 1/ 100)

& & "

+< "

8+& " & 1 !

"# ,3( 4!,'5'

&, 1&(671 #+

)1 /2 1001, 3 .-

+< :

+ 1.//./5/

/1 /1

)1 /2 1001 "

17 /;

100; "

/1 1074

/1 /1

= &

+ " "

/1 /1 '

/7 /0 1000, 3 5-

.1 /.

.7 /;

1000, 3 2- # & 6& # &

( . ( ) ( .

1 '

.0 /) ./// , 3 4-

22//0/// 12/ & " >

& ?+

1 1992 (5) SPJ 1

( ) 154.1002 + # & +

)/ ./..

+ + + 1/ /) 100. :

+ "

" "

/2 1.

1005

& %& &

1/ /4 ./1) ( ) &

/2 1.

( ) ' #

)1 /) ./12, 3

11- &9+

( ) &

+ + " "

( )

./ /) ./12 )/ /) ./12 .2 /2 ./12

1.))../12

1/ /4 ./12 , 3 1.- *+ &

/) ./12 , 3 11-

& A &+

/0 ./12, 3 12- ( )"

/0 /7 ./1.

)

.1 /1 ./14 "

( 1.

9 B

!"##$ % & '(

(% ) * + ,- .+- / .+ 0- ,2 * + 10+ )") 3

2 * & '(

(% .- ) * + ,

, , 10 24%5

(%5 6 + $ ") 3

' -

+ $ 7- .+ 4+ 6 + 8 * + ,- - - 0$3 ' (%& '4 '4 (( 94 :0+- + ;

< * + 0 .+= 3 - (( 1>23 * - < #+ .- <-

: # + - 1 # ,2 ; 9

< '

(( .+ 6

6@ ## 0

" '( %4' 4 (( + $ 7- .+ ! ((>4 '

$ ( (4'54 (( 1") 3 A - + 0 + 6 .+

('4>6# %4'4

((&- ;- < '

(%5 '

(( % '&

((& 1") 43

- + * B > %>4

!"C $07 ((' 4' 4 ((( " *- + '%(54 ( '

$07 (( '4'&4 (((

- - 3 " 3 +

(( 1") 432-'%

(( 1") 4352'( '% '

1") 43&2+

* + .D . 0 0$3 5 ((>@ 3= .+E '

@ 3 2 + '

(( -+-B A 3" '>

((- * - 1 2 #

((

3" '>

(( # .D. 0 - ! ( %'4(% !"5 $ ( - '4' 4

(( +@

4' 4 (( + A - 6 .+ +3" '>4

((@ ! $ 1 2 $07 '

- (4'>4 '

"+- @ " '>4 (( *

&% $ '

> '

> 1") 43

52- 730-1") 4

>2- @ 3 + ( % '

+ 3

+ + # - *

- +* + .D0

+/+ F

$ + + ++& & "

/5 /2 ./14 "& #

9" :

, < &

- "

B CG ( '

5- 0 94 :" 7301") 43 >2 + '

((( '

(((* + @ H @ 3 > '

((( 7 3 0

.+ - * - + '

((( # 7 3 0 + 3+-$0 77- .+ -# * 0 +- 6 .+ * "* '( '

: # B -

7 7 -0 +6 .+ -) 94 :

:A - * > '

((( ++ 7-

/ + '

((( +- > '

(((+ + "+ 7 3 0 17302- + + 730

> '

((( # - 730 + ( '

5 .D 0

- + .D . 0 ( '

5 - 730

+ 3 +- $ 0 7 7- .+ + : " B ) + '

((( - * / # 4 *+ +

") "4 * + + - '

(%5 + '

(((

* 4# , + '

(%%'

(%5 + *B + " / + '

(%5 '

(%%-+

- / + 0 +?

+ 4# , # ?

D- 0 / +

(%5 - ?

D # - /+ +

-++ '

(%5 '

(%%+ B +

- + 1 2 + 4# , '

(%5 3 0 +- 6.+ '

+ - # 0 +- 6 .+0 '5 '> '

5 '

'' "* '5 '> '

/ '

'' F "

.) /.

./14

9 "

) # +

> %>4

$07 (( '

((( " + ") 4"

# - @ *

> '

((( " + ") 4" + + 7 " + 34 ") 4" + " > '>

((( - % + 0 +- .+

('4>6# % '

((&- + 04### + < <44< 04### + '

( %% 1+ 34 2 .- * % '5

((( '& '&

((( 7 ;

* 1+ 34 &2- +

@ 3 <44< # , < + '

((( / + E @ 3 * .I . 0 # *- + '%(54( '

$07 (( '

((( "+ ") 4" A - * > '

((( @ + + 7- / + '

((( +-

> '

(((+ @ + "+ 7 3 0 17302- + + 730 > '

((( @

+ 730 D ;

" + &

" ( ) ++ 8 & " & &+ + "

010 1$'&4'<**3 4!,'5'

1 !

*&= $5.

17&+ 17(>, "7? , ,'0 @!,'5'

1 !

,,&'

,'0) A!($, , ?

1&(67

$4 ($ " 7!,'

4!,'5'

1 !

"# 00

($ " 7!,'5 1 !

"# 5(A+ ($ (,0 @!,'5'

=>,( 1&(672-

,&="%7( 5(! 7 ! %0 4!,'5'

5+=&% 1!,4&%!

,&+5(=- ,>7($

!7,$5(

7!,'4 100

$4 ($ " 7!,'

4!,'5'

/"> 1+7 ($

(" 7!, 5(5'

+""+7& *&$ $4!>, 4!,'5'

1 !

21975 (1) SCC 151 32010 (12) SCC 471 4 2011 (7) SCC 743 5 2007 AIR (SC) 641 6 2008 (4) ALL. LJ 386 7W.P. (C) No.162-2013

7,'7 , 7,"567 & '

1!%,! ,3 ($ " 7!,'7 ,0 @!$5B"

1'5 ($

,'0 4!,'5'

1 !

"# 6=($ ($

,'00 17$!"

C!,>!

'"( "#

= !

5$75 4!,'5'

&"(= (' & 5 !

"# "5($,3 ",6!

!%7("="631/ ("7, /= 4!,'5'

00 @&$7( 1+7 ($ " 7!,'11 76<(

,'$ 1&(67 4!,'5'

1 !

&7, ($ " 7!,'1.

+ ( ) + " "

& 9 +

8+& "& * +& & +

+ " +

+ "

+ & &&

& ,0 010 &= 5=+,6 (&4!,'& 3 ($

,'01) +1; + &

& " +

& "

( ) + * >

E +"

+ "

++ 82009 (2) R.C.R. (Civil) 208 9 WA-11-2022 102019 (1) J.C.R. 177 11 2017 LIC 10399 12 2008 (6) S.C.T. 666 132010 (10) SCT 63

( ) + * " & "+

+ +

" ( ) 154.1002 ++ &

/2 1.

1005 + &

+ ( 1 &

+ & "

1/ /) 100. :

+ &

+ "9+

/) /) 1000, 3 5-

E"8

( ) :

+ E +

& + & ( )

+ 154.1002 " ( ) !

F 8+&

)/ ./.. &

" & $&

+ :

B C '

" / 47 *+

+ * + / 7

7 / , + &

((-

(( # B - , '

((> +

E +

(5 0 + 7 + + 3 0 ( '

(& - + - + 3 0 ,- + 0 +- .+6 # - + ,+ + , # +)/ * 6 - - /+

- 0 +

(( - 0 +- * *

" / ,- '%

((>-

1! 2- '' %J / . %' %J / "+- -

- +-

- ++

4 * 0

* .D")0 .+E = , ((5="70

> + * A * - .D ") 0 + / +* - - - * "+- .D")0 +

* (%>4%5 (&

- *

@ * , + @ E = .+ !+ , E "#@ (( 0 >&

* - * - + + * B

*- + F 1/

8+& ( )

+ +

& & #

/) ./12, 3 11- && &

( )

& "

( )

8+& "

! #

+ "

+ 1.))../12

# &

= ( )"

+ #

/) ./12 && + & ( ) *

( )"&

2 & &"

# & 6& ++ &+

/0 ./12, 3 12-

" && & " #

+"8

! &+ &

+ +B C# - - # , 6

(%% & (

(% +

@ 3 * 0$ ' (%& - + <44< + 3 + 7

@ 3 + 3 + .D. 0 '

@ 3= .+G . B +- +1+ 2 # ,

- -

@ 3+ # , ++

@ 3 -

@ 3 3 + # , B " # , 6 # - < - 3 " 3 +- 0 + /

+* +-

- + 3 + A7 * # - + 3+ - + - - 3 + B

8 -

@ 3 # ,

@ 3 + ,- .+ '%

(%5 5 '5

(%&

((

. '+"0@G

#+- + +

@ 3 3 +

- - B - 3++ + # ,'( '% '

- +

@ 3 4K4 #,-

@ 3 3+ * # , - # '( '% '

" +3+ - > ++ +@ ( ''4 %''L ''63 3+ 3 + # , - # , - '( '% '

- 3 +- + # ,- / / # , B B ) + ) 3 " @ ) "- !

!"4 $07 '&- & '

''&- " B '> '& ''&

+ A 7 +3+ +@ ( ''4 %''L ''63 + 3+ + A7 F 1/ 1

" +" &+ &

9 +1 !

"# ,3(

($ " 7!,'

4!,'5'

&, 1&(67 ($ " 7!,'15 & "

/1 1074 &

.5 /5 1075, 3 1- !

B C# + .+ 60 (4#6 &

( '- > A- 141992 SCC (4) 118

(& * .+3 0 ,-.+ + + -

+.+6 M F + #

- - * +

/ + D

" " & ( ) + &"

* "

" "

& .4 /0 107;

8+ ( ) &

/1 /1 1001 "&, 1&(67.'8+& 1.

&+ &+

8 " + 8

1) + &

3+ & "

& 8+& 1 !

"# !'

!(6= 4!,'5'

67",!

!412 10C0 17 4!,'5'

,!* ,>'7 ($

151993 (3) SCC 371 :

" 7!,'14 A & + *

9 & "

"++

8 & "

& "

9 &+ !

& &+ #

&& &"

& A # & &

& " 0)//)57//G5.//$ &"

" A # & F &&

H + +

#& (

+ ,-

!%!*+!, - & 6

9+F B I F( 6

" B I F(

161994 AIR (SC) 745