Karambir Singh v. State Of Haryana And ANR












 

 




 !
"
#$ %
"
&'(
)%*
$+,
#$!

-%%./
012

 3'4'

2
0%
"
%*%%
5
%2

'67'



  !" #$%&'
" '&!(#$)*"

22
6'
"
&%
6%6'
.%*
/
%87

'
2
9471.:


/
"7

2
6'

:

22
2
9471.
'247
/
67

2
1':

'( )

%24
02%.%;,7&%, "
2
6

) -'2%
46%,
,
%*%%, "
2
0%

<<<<<







































 '&!(#+,- 2
6%*

2
6'
8
6
'
"
=4%'21
"
2 7
7%7
+

#$
>?4
;

@,
82/*
2
6
2%'
/ '%7

'&

%&=4%,
/4
2%'
/
77
2
&'=4% /"',
  ,
/%&A
8%1'
%7
&4*
"
'&


847
/
&''%*

1
/"
"%&'
"
2
&%'

2
6
8%'
%667
%'
%%7%
'4&
 !

$BB#
%7
2
'
'%7

/
"%'*
.6&%7




B
7%7 $+

##
47
0&'
C
%7
82
0&
$ >$@>7@
%7
+
"
2


"
46
&
2
06&%
471,
%7%/%7,
7
9471. 7%7
+ $#

##,
&&7
2
6
%"
&1
2%
2
&2%1'

 %1%'
2.
2%
/
67
%7
'&7
2.

471
.6'. "

*%
%7

6%*
%
"
"

!##D;


2
/%''
"
2
&&,
7 7
7%7
+ $#

##
2
6
8%'
7'.''7
".
'&
2
7 "
&&
8%'
&2%17
/*
2
6
/*
"1
%
%66%,
  , .%
66%


B;0
"
##
2'
4,
7
9471.
7%7 $B

#$ ,
%&=47
2
6
".
2
&2%1'
/*
'1;%'7
2 9471.
"
&&

64'4%&

2
%&=4%,
2
'67 %42',
7
7
7%7

+

#$
>?4
;

@
'%7
2 6,
28,
77
2.
2
/"
"
&4*
"
'&
%7
/%&A 8%1'

)

%24
02%.%;,
%7
&4'
%66%1
"
2 6
'4/.'
2%
2
""&
"
82&2
2
6
8%'
7
'
 2
1%'
82&2
2
6
&%
/
'%7

2%
&..7

2' 6'%
&%6%&*

2%'
"42
7
46

"
2
49%/
 0&'
4',
%;
34.;
%'
%66&%/

2
0%
"
%*%%
 &7
2%
2
.6*
'
7

&4*
"
'&,
"4
/%&A 8%1'
%7
%8%&'

&%'
2
2%'
/
"4*
?%7
,
24',
6%*'

2%
2
.6417
7
7*1
2
/"
"
/%&A
8%1'
%7
&4*
" '&
'

'4'%%/

2
*'
"
%8

'466
"
2'
'4/.'', 2
&4'
2%'
7
46
2
9471.'
77

%./0,% 102 3.3 %,  .

4,5, 6 0 3( +-%#7, 6   # 6,2 3.3 %,  , 8  ,,,, 63(+-%! ) -'2%
46%,
%7
'''%
7&%
%, %*%%
%66%1

/2%"
"
2
0%
'4/.'
2%
2
6
'
 7

/%&A
8%1'
%'
8
%'
&4*
"
'&

2
6&6
"

 E
8A

6%*F
%7

'466
2%'
7
46
, /00 64
0,.4 &0,8   2 3.3  &0  %.9  

  "

1

(  *.4,,  " //:

,6( ;;+-%

(  ,6 % 102 3.3$ 

'

6,,

0 3(<+-%

77($ 

'

6,, 632 3.3#,9,% 10( +-%

, 6%, ,)0,=, 2 3.3%,  , 8  ,,,, 3(+-%
& 
2%
2%7
2
%7
&4'
"
2
6%'
%7
%66%'7 2
6%6
/A

"
%71

2
%
&'
%7
2
%
7&77 &47
4

2
%".7
9471.',

847
/
%6

?%& %
,
/7,
%'
47(;

EC >$@ 2
%
.
.6*,
82
2%'
/ 7'.''7,
.,
&.64'*
7,

'4'677,
' '%7

847
2%
/
'%7
/4
"
2'
. 
'46%4%
2
%42*
&.6

7
2 '%.
'2%
&'7
%7
.%A
%
'6&"&
7(; >%@ 1%71
2
6%*
%7
%8%&' 
/
6%7

2 .
.6*
"
2
67
"
2'
%/'&
".
74*, &&%'7
/*
'4'6'
%7D
7'.''%,
.%
 &.64'*
.
71
82
2'
'%.


2 7%
"
2'
'46%4%
%'
2
&%'
.%*
/,
%7 >/@ 822


2
'%7
67
'2%
/
%7
%'
%
67 '6

74*

> @ 2
2
%42*
.7

'4/
4
>$@
'
" 6
2%
2

.6*
2%'
/
"4*
?%7
, 
&%'
"
'4'6',
2%

8%'
82*
494'"7,
2


.6*
'2%
/
1
2
"4
6%*
%7
%8%&'

82&2 2
847
2%
/
7,
2%'
2

/
7'.''7, .%,
&.64'*
7

'4'677,
%'
2
&%'
.%*

 / 
64'%
"
'4/;4
> @
"

?%&7
>'46%@,

'

7
2%
82
2
.6*
2%'
/
"4*
?%7,

847
/ 494'"7

8227
2
/%&A
8%1'
%7
%8%&',
82&2
2
.6* 847
2%
/
7



2
'%
&%',
'&
%'
6
9471.
7%7
$B

#$ >?4
;@,
2
6
2%'
/
"4*
?%7,

''&,
2%' /
%&=47
".
2
&2%1'
"
82&2
2
8%'
7,
2
'
7
 &4*
"
'&
%'

4,
.4&2
'',
&%'
%8
2%'
/
&7
/*
2 %7
0%
4'

&7
2%
2
6
'

7
 &4*
"
'&
&&71*,
2
6
'
27
7

2 &4*
"
'&

'
1%7'
2
1%
"
/%&A
8%1',
2
%14.
"
%7 0%
&4'
%
2
"'
'%&
%66%'

/
*
%%&
%7 '%'"%&*,
/4

11
2412
2
"%&'
%7
&&4.'%&'
"
%&2
&%', .4&2
'',
2
%
7&77
&47
4,
2'
4
"47
2%
2 %".7
9471.'
2%
/
77

2
6.'
2%
2 7=4
.6*
2%7
7417

&.%
&%'

2'
6%
&%6%&* %7


'6&
"
2
&46
&2%1'

2412
2
'
&2
"

2'
4

0%
%
2%8%G'
&%'
>'46%@,
%"
7'&4''1
2
"%&'
%7
%' 8
%'
2
9471.'
"
%4'
4',
"47
2%
2
""&
8A1
 2
%A
8%'
'4'677
74

2
&..''
"
&.%
""&
47 2

"
46
&,
/4
%

&&7
%7
'4/'=4* %&=47,
2",
2
847

/
27
7

"4
/%&A
8%1'
"
2 67
2
.%7
'4'677

2
%".7
9471.,
2
%A

 77

"

%*
4',
82&2
847
2%
6.7
'67 %42'

8227
2
"4
/%&A
8%1'

8,

2
%
7&77 &47
4

2
%".7
9471.
847

/
%66&%/

2 "%&'
%7
&&4.'%&'
"
2
6'
&%',
6%&4%*

11
2412 2
6%
%7
'.6
%14%1
"
'4/;4
> @
"

>'46%@

0&
2
6
2%'
/
"4*
?%7
".
2
&2%1', %'
6
2
4,
2
847
/
7

"4
/%&A
8%1',
.4&2
'', %8%&'
%7

2'
1%7,

7%8
'466
".
2
%
7&77
&47 4

)

7%G'
&%'
>'46%@
%'.4&2
2%

2
'%
&%',
2 6
8%'
'%128%*
7'.''7
".
'&
/*
A1
2 6''
"
&
$$
"
2
'4
"
7%
2",
2 6&6
"
E
8A

6%*F
8

/
%66&%/

2
6'
&%'
%' 2
6
8%'
7

%
""&
82&2
8%'
%7

2' .6*.

8%'

"
'.21
7
/*
2.

2'
6'%
&%6%&*

&&71*,
2
.6417
&7'
.6'7

2
7
"
'%. %
2/*
=4%'27
2
6
'
27
7

&4*
"
'& %7
%'
8
%'
/%&A
8%1'
"
2
67
2
.%7
4
"
'&
2
'67'
%
7&7

%'
2
/"'
"
2 6'
%'
?674'*
%'
6''/,
6"%/*
82
%
67
"
2 .2'
".
2
7%
"
&6
"
&"7
&6*
"
2'
7

2
8
6
'
%&&71*
%87

,:<( + '&!- ,> #$)*"