High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/30428/2026dismissed

Madhu Purnima Kishwar v. Ut, Chandigarh

2026-05-29Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary9 pages

" #

$%&'()*'+,-,(./0121 %*34546.,7%8,-39%6 :5'&,&,(.'6 ;'6-4- <.,(.='66,&(6>?3%.*,@%63 :'-A(.*'.& BC DEBF G " ! HHHHH 56'-'.&/ 618%A,IJ,K%I?J'.,(6L*;(+%&' &36(4@3M%.* 61J%6&%NJ,.@3O%64I%?J'.,(6L*;(+%&'?9,&3 -1J47'*3%%.*61J,*3%6&3P6(;'6? -1=%;I''.%.*61M%,K3%;Q%,.?L*;(+%&'-)(6&3'A'&,&,(.'61 61L7,&Q3%.N,?J'.,(654KI,+56(-'+4&(6?9,&3 61%.,-3R%.-%I?54KI,+56(-'+4&(6<=%.* 61J34K3%7%.@I%?L55)(6<=? 61J3%-3%.SJ3'S3%6J3%67%?61$,T,&R3%6*9%N%.* -1J%6%-7,R4*3,6%N%?L*;(+%&'-)(6<=1 HHHHH

" !U F 1 LAA6'3'.*,.@ 3'6 %66'-& ,. VW O(1 *%&'* 011 ? 6'@,-&'6'* 4.*'6 -'+&,(.- 0 ? ?

? ? 2 %.* 2 ROJ

J'+&,(.- 2R? 2? ? #? #? 22? 00 W5? J'+&,(.-

$ %.*

() W.)(67%&,(. ='+3.(I(@> L+&? %& 5(I,+' J&%&,(. ? 3%.*,@%63?&3'A'&,&,(.'63%-),I'*&3'A6'-'.&A'&,&,(.-''S,.@A6'%66'-&K%,I1 1 X'%6.'* J'.,(6 +(4.-'I %--'6&- &3%& &3' (.I> %II'@%&,(. %@%,.-& &3' A'&,&,(.'6 ,- &3%& -3' 3%* 6'&9''&'* % -'+(.* ;,*'( +I,A (. -(+,%I 7'*,% AI%&)(67 ,1'1 YZ[? 93,+3 9%- ,..(+4(4- %.* 9,&3(4& %.> ,II,.&'.&1 =3' ())'.+' () )(6@'6> ,- .(& 7%*' (4& %@%,.-& 3'6? %- -3' ,- .(& &3' (.' 93( 3%* A6'A%6'*

! "# $ % & & " # " # ' ( $

&$)& " $ &"$ * * % & "'

'$! & &

$*& !"$ + $ && ' * ,%' "

'$!

"! & % (

* &$ "! - & . /$$ 0"# 1' 2" % & &$ 345 $ * $'

' *$$ '

6 $# & % '

$! $ 7

# ' * &&$ ! $# % $! & '

* " $ * ' * 8 * 9 % ! $#$ * ' *

$$ &$$! * * $

$ " " * "! :; :6 ''

8 $ ' & ' *

*! * &

$ &$$!

'$ &

0 '$ "$ * 8 ( '

$$' $ * '

! "

# # $ # !"% " % &

# % &

# '% " #( # )* & !(( # ( # ( ! (#% &

# +( # % ( (( # ,(

& " #'(

- & # - # #

.$ ##!# /

&#! ((# # # - ( # ! (#

/ %

& # - #

%1$02.3 # "%1$024 5206521.7%&

!8 9

)##& " & 2# '

8 #&

#"& '# #&8

! :

;' !+ &

& 8 $

& - # # ( < % &

& .#&-% ' (## !#- #

*= >*7 ; ?#"!<@%

& 8 .

& '(##<

$#! $ "

;#! "

</< %

& 8 .

& ' - # &

#& #''A;'# - #+A

- . $ B!

;.$ B

& 8 .

& ' - # &

#& #'' AC>+ "D&8 64:41 - # # D # '"% (# #'

" * " # E$

# # - # #

#'(#'

"0# # .;"#+

F - . ! ' ;

! ' G<8

)##+8 .

(# - # # )##+ (#'% ' '#- -

$ '' ;

! ' G<8

)##+8 .

(# - # # )##+ (#'% ' '#- ( '

# - - # ( & # "

(# # 0( :!

# #!"

# ' #! )##+% I#!H! ;0(+!

# *"'

(( +!

# #! # <

$ '

! "

$ %$& '& ( # )* + , % -.

"+/

0$++ 12 " 3 (" *$2 * &2 "" #

3$ $ + + 12 2 $4)/& " 4 2 23 "

# & "" 2 $ 2 23 "

2 2 "

$ $ "

# 23 # #$ 2 $ "

# " #$ 2 3

2 #+ 12#

2 23 2 # 2+ 12 2 23

2 !

2 #+ 12 $ 4 "

" 5 #+ 6+ 12 /$

$ ! & "2 # 2 23$ /&$

3 2 " $ &2 $ !

2 "

&2 + 12 $ & &2 2 2 2

2 "

"2$3$+7

+ -8 9:;88 <:=>:?@88 A;BC@88 D?E88 AF:FG88 HI88 J;@:=8

K * LM ,N 2 * "

#$ 2 !

$ 2 OEPE88 Q:BG?@88 J:RS88 D?E88 <ET88 U:BH>:=:B8

L * 8 AF:FG88 HI8 U:@:=:?@F=:88 D?E88 UH@VE88 A:W;V88 XS?:;B88 UH@VE88 AE88 XS?:;B8

K * K 8 YB;HB88 HI88 ZBV;:88 D?E88 <:V:[88 \:=:;B88 ]CC:=^:_8

K * 6 2 2 ` a + b 23 2

3 # 2 "" $ 2 " "

+ L+ 12 "

3 * + ++ # & $ $ 2 " "" &22 ` a + . $ " ""

K b2 # " 2

3 2 2 #

23$ 2 # ""# 2 ,$2

! ! "

#$ %&

'& # $(

) & $

) ** & '

* $ & #*#

!$ * $ &+! "

*! $ ** #, "

! # ' !, ,&

# & ** !$

# , ** ' # & *$! -. // // // - 0

' ! #$ *

#* *1

& *$ ! & & $

- // // // 2- ) ! !' 3 -4-- **

! ! &

- 5' *$ ! & !

! & # - ) *$ ! !& /$ * & ! & $ / *

- ) ,

! ** $ / ** ** # '

& *$! - ////// 2- 0

* '

& *$ ! - ) 5& &

/ /$ , '& *# ' !$ ! , * #

& & $ 60

! & * $

$ ! - ) 5&

$ & $ ! 60

! & * $ $

' *1

* $ * - 7

&'1-. 8- 59! *# :

;<::

=>?@ABCADAB::

EF<::

G?DHIJKDAJH:

KL::

MNLKDIHBHNJ:

23 3

! O $

" #$ % # & $

' ! &

" ( !

& " ( ) ! & '

! ) $

!" + !

' &

, ' ! '

$ &

!" - ! !

' !

$ & '

& & ' " . " / !

, -! 0 1 23411 56767387311 9:;11 <=411 5>7>?11 @A11 BC1 , ' - D - E "#"" F" GHH I, '

J"J"I,

! , !

' , ' K, ' $ !$ '' , $ %L# F" H I, $ $$

G"H"I,

' $ $K M '

" LK$ 1 9=6737A11 N67O11 7:;7=11 P;=37>11 <=11 5>7>?11 @A1 BCQ1 ' D - F HJ, "H"J, $

$ R!K

$ #' / ' ) K

!" " " ! # $ " %$ "

" "#& '& !" # " $ ( ) & ** " * $ ! $ # " && !"

" + ! $ " $ " , # $$ " $ " " # " && " -&-&

+ " " " $"

"!" "+

. "

"" . "& /

# 0" "12"& *& 3$$" + ! " ""

$ " $ # ! #

+ # $ " $

"4 " * ! " $ "

" " " $

" # " "

# 3""%(& **& / ! "

! " "

" "! " "4

" " $ " " "" " " "

+ "

5 $ "

" " $ " "

# # "

# & 1 $ " "+ " $ "" " $ "+ " "+ $ & 1

" $ "" $ " + "

" $ "

!" !

$"%"

! #

&' ("

" #

&" & "

" ! & !

& )

*+ *$ '

" " , -./01,, 213/4, ! + #

5 6789:;<755 =7>?@5 ABC55 6D7DE55 9F55 G7?;H755 =>7?EB;55 7<?55 7<9D;E>5 " IJK ' L' $ M '$' ' $' N

& & !

" &

# !

& ! & ' P &

&" & #

&' $' Q

# &

& "

& & "

# ! " !

!O O" &" RSO O O ST' Q, 0UVWX,, U-4.1YV/,

! "# $ $ %%%# & '& ( " $ $! " $ # ! # # % ## $# & ')& * +,*-./01231/456* & '

& ( ! " ! # $

#$#& 89:9;7<=9>?=9@AB7 CDEFGECFCH7 I>?JK7 % LM%N O PNQ L

O PNQ