Balbir Singh And ORS v. Union Of India And ANR
!
" #$%&'() *+
!
")&,-.-$
$ /$0$
1".-$
$'1$
!"#$ %&!$## ' !()
!"#$ $# ' !()
$% 3 ( "&-"("+1#"+ -'
22222 $# '
$-",("10$0##$$ 0) -" 1($" )0"+ -"1,"- #- 4 $- 567 $8, 90"$-, -11"1!:*
;4<0= 7+>-)?-#"( ," 90"'"?-"('"+-"$)@#1+ -" "''"#-1 -$ 0 )? #-",, - 1 1"1 A
!
4<0 = 7'"$$1)?-
3 ( " &-"("+ "1 #0$ '$, - '$$0)(1-"'0$0"#-1#$$$01)?-+ -(">"$ 1-'"( #$1" -$"(
-0,-""' (+-$0+111"1
4<0=
7+">1 !;
;+)0- (">"$#"1"10("?"$ 1- -$'1$+ #$1" -("+-"0$?"1'$?@#1- #"()?"$$,,"$$<"#1-('0,11 -"$,
"$$,1)?-$$0$"")- >,#0$%= "7 -""''( -'$>"$"1 "1'$$+$0#-"$0" $(":0 "1$, $$$"# "1-90" #" -'$ " $(" >"$>?"$'(" #"" $("$-'+>-"$ -" (4 7>--'$" >8,+ '$#)1 90" #" >"$ 3"# '0$ # #"C )7 $ ,"1$ - 90" #" "1 1 # - (#"0 - '$+ $( - '$ > "''1"$" $("1>"$'(1"$" $("+ >-#- "#>"$$0)$""1"$'-"1$(1"1
A*;4<0= !7C #7 -'"(-?" A*A0""?"1>-0 -#$ -'$+#-",1-(#"0 - '$ "$ $, $$$"+ - + - $"1 - $'1$=1'"(@#,-#"( -'$ -", 1$$("$ >- ,"1 - 90" #" $ >-?($##1C -31 #0( 0$1"1
B"?
>-,"1>, -'"?$#")0$ --,$ $0#- "$ 90" #"$ # ("1 - $"( -$ ##0($"#$+-0,--""8#$1" -" (1 "#C 7
$
"1D"?@1"$" $(""1 0" $(""1"$$,$$$" --#-",
* 1$," ( " $(" $, $$$"+ - '$#")1'1#"(-) $,- #0'"$>8,-"('"(
"#+ ">, # &" #01$ " $(+ $, $$$""1"#C -'$"$>"$-" $(>8,- " ( '"( " 1$#-",, - $"( 10$"1$'$)$+)$1$-"90" #" "''("1"1'$$ "$>"$- "('"(>"$"$-$"(+ + ?" 1'(" " $("$-' "1 - ? 1 # >"$ -",# #"+>-"$ "''(-" ( >"$ > ?"$ 1'(" # #" " $("$-'C ,7 - " > 81$ " $(+ + "1 3#-"#""1 1," $("$-'+-"$01, >?"#0$+(#"0 ("?)'("+ "1 #"+)0 "$"1'0'$$+-"$ 01, > ?" #0$ ,, - # #" " $("$-'
? ##01, -$ ",0($+ - "1 #0$ - '0,1-0 $,="$1-('0,11
-"-"1-"1#0$ -'"$+"''"$1- '"')8"1" ->-"-"$,"$$,1)?-)? ?,0'- 1,$11-('0,111$#" "? ##") "01>- 1),-#"$>--
+ # ")"$$+-'$-")")$")$-"$ ->"1>-"("+-"0 >8+10#""90" #""1 1$," -'$-1)?-"''#"$- >1#" --"( "#+-?>1 -$"8 )?+-"$,"$$,1)?-'"("1$-0$%= 547
!
"
#$$
%
&'
(
!
"
$#$$ $$
!
$$$
) ' * +
,
!
$$$ $$
-
- 10#"" 90" #" " $(" 4"1 7 " ( #$ >"$ > ?"$F '(": #" " $("$-'+)0- +-10#""90" #" $, $$$" 4"1 7 $ #" - '$ -" #-",1-#-", (#"0 (" $("$,$$$" - , - ,"''#" -0$+0>+'$" $''1 ( #"(, '"?+ + ," 90" '"? " " ,('"
-10#""90" #"'$#)1 " $("4"1 .7( #$>"$;?"$'("3#-"#" ,,+>-"$ $,$$$"4"1.7 $
, #" ' 1$#-",,-$"(10$-"$)'"#1 #1 > $0#-$0"+- 11-'$ ," -90"'"?"('"#")$"1) 0$'$
!
- "$$ $"1 ")+ - 1 1"1 A
!
4<0 = 7$0'-1 $0"?+->'$"1$1$($$1
4 %&!$## - .$# - !() !() "
/ 2' 30 5 5 4/ 36 78
%
5 5 / 31 %