← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2479/2016allowed

Sham Singh And ORS. v. Punjabi University And ANR.

2019-02-26Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi11 pages

      !"#$#%# &## ##% #  '(

 % %))* 

+,+)- )) ./ /01))2)3  4 '( 

 0-+)-#/0 )) ./ /01))2)3  4 '5( 67  +8/, )) ./ /01))2)3  4 ' ( 75 

/+)-+)/ )) ./ /01))2)3  4  

 

   

  

   

 

  !"

   ! "  # $% &

'()

*+ +))*

*+ ,- (

*+ +-.

*+    /! 0"

0   

00 " 

1      $% &

'()

*+

 "   

 

 0 4  53 56   !780! 0 0 0  4  59:$56  0 !



 "

 



!#;

!  # $00 0   <       "  

  

 "  " " "  !    ))'

"

    

 "  !

 )+    

 

* *'

))*

     !# ! 8!0          

.





  !

  

! ;

 

  

   

    

  

    

      

     

  

  !  

 "     



 



 

 





"

 #    

   '

))*

0!   

    #    

 80!   

  0    0 #0  00 

00    >!0

**-



! ! "

 "00  ;

9))-2)) 4#,, !# ! # !0   0  

0! $ !    ! 8     1  

0"

    

 

  # !

!# ! # !0   0   

0! $ !    ! 8     1    0"

    0 #0 0

 00 

?"   ! 00   00      >!0

**-

    ! 0

'

! !  + !

0  +

! ;

$ %&

'  

  (  

  

)*+

(

   



 '

 

 ,   



   -*.+

$ 

 



 &  "

  

  



  

-*/+

(

 -*0+

(

 -*1+

(

 *)+

2   "

 

   



   3





  "

 

 

 

   

   # @

"

#  0"   



!#/!





**,   80!     

 0 "0 0

 #  

 



 #

  

! ;

9))-2)) 4#,, !# ! # !0   0  

0! $ !    ! 8     1  

0"

    

 

  # !

!# ! # !0   0   

0! $ !    ! 8     1    0"

    0 #0 0

 00 

: "0  "    /!   

 "  !      

0 



   0



   " 

9:$  " 0   0 

 " 

 "   

  * *'

))*

     0  !

  !0 0 <

   ! 



   !    

0   



**,      " 

    

 "

3    0 0 "

 

 '

))* 00  <

  0 <



+

  "

 #!

0 #

 !0   !

0

!   ;3 

**+ 0!7  

, *+

**, "

 >!0

**- 0   

2     /!    0  

0  "   

  !;

. $











5

 

/677.

 



   

   



" 

,   





   :

776 

 

       ;< 



   

    

  

    

      





     

 



 "   

 



 



 

 





"

 # (



 

   



 

 "





   



 /=7=7

     

"  



    .1/.) *' > <?+

   



 



 "     ;< 



   

(     

  

    

      





     

 



 "   

 



 "

 

 

  



"  

 





 



,  

      



  " 

 @ .1# "  



  



 

,   ?

 





   



"     

   "





5

 

  

 "  



,   

 

 



    .=).= ' > <?.

  

" "



   

" " 

 

5

  

"    

  

 " "



  

      

 





 5

  





" 

,    "



 5

    

   

         ";< 

1/)<1/6  .17..



/0  6./ 

//7<0  6./ 

./<0  .10./ 

0=<07  ==./ 

071/<0710  6./



1/7<7  .../ 

=10<11  .6/.0 >

77<.  ==.0

>

11<1)  ..0 >

.16<.1=  .)..0 >

6<6  0/.1 >

.)6=<67  11.1

, >

07/7<0  /6.1 >

10/=</7  ).1 >

..<...

 ...) >

0=<07  .10.) > A

/1)/<)0  76.) >>

0/1=<17  ..) >>

077  ).6 >>

1../<1..0  //.6 >>

)))<)))  )1.6# 9 !0      

$00   00"

<   

  0 !0     !  #0  

2

      0 #0   

 

 '

))* " 0 <



0! 

2      *

 " 0 0

 ! "  !



**+   "

>!0

**-

2

     0 

 0 

)   !  

A 

 0   !     00

     * *'

))*  !!  

       0 0  <



:  

     0 0 !

0  0 !

1!



, *+

**,  <! 8;7

<  0!7   !

, *+

**, "0 0  # 

**, 0 "

0  



3   !  "

80! 

, *+

**,    " 0

0  80! 

**+

80! 

**+  !# ! 80! 

, *+

**,  80! 

, *+

**,   "

: 



! 

 00     0 

 <  

   '

))*

B "

  0   < 8!0

8!0 0  

   0

A 

 0

 

  <    

!   

2

    0 

 0 

**+ 

0

 $00     " <  

"

#  "  00"

    46    !  

<   * *'

))*

% 0 !  ! 00    !    00 

  

0  #!   0 

   00   !    7

0        

%   ! 0 00 0  

 "  

"   00"

#  

!1/3:

'# +; #+ + ( & 

"%

B   & ?   C D  B  

 C D