High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25753/2015disposed of

M/S Belz Instruments Pvt Ltd And ORS v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2015-12-09Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

!"##$%&%'( )

*&#+,'&"-./#'"& -%0!"#1%/%"#2"3#-& #"%"%'#-& 5#-&.& 6"!"#!-7!'!!'"3#- #&8'2#'"&

-#&#'"(4 -&3%&399!-:!+;6-20$!"#:%"3 -6!+!+;20$!"#-"3#8#"%"%'#-& <<<

3# 8#"%"%'#-& 3!0# $3!++#'9#2 $//.'%$!"%'& 2!"#2 =

* >

-#.'2%'9"3##!-'#&"!/.'"2#8&%"#2?7"3#/"-#!"%'9 !&!"!'#'2"3#%-!88+%$!"%'&-"3#!++"/#'"%'2.&"-%!+8+"&8.-&.!'" " !' !20#-"%&#/#'" 2!"#2

.'2#-"3#"3#'#@%&"%'98+%$7!'2 9.%2#+%'#& 7 "3# &!%2 !20#-"%&#/#'" !88+%$!"%'& :#-# %'0%"#2 - !++"/#'"%'2.&"-%!+8+"&0!-7%'9&%,#&3#8#"%"%'#-&!88+%#2- 8+"&!2/#!&.-%'9A &B/#"#-&&"3#'./?#-!88+%$!"%'&:#-#!- /-# "3!' "3# './?#- 8+"& " ?# #-#2 .'2#- "3# &$3#/#; "3# !88+%$!'"&:#-#%'"#-0%#:#2?7!1:#-1#0#+6$-##'%'9//%""##6%@ 3.'2-#2 !88+%$!'"& :#-# &3-"+%&"#2 ?7 "3# 1:#- 1#0#+ 6$-##'%'9 //%""##%'$+.2%'9"3#8#"%"%'#-& 3#&#&%@3.'2-#2!88+%$!'"&:#-# "3#-#!"#-"?#%'"#-0%#:#2?7"3# %'!+++"/#'"//%""##:#0#-;

"3&#%'"#-0%#:&'#0#-"C8+!$#2/%""#2+7;'"3%'9.-"3#-:!&2'#%' -#&8#$""3##!-+%#-8-$#&&

44 7!+#""#-2!"#2>

"3#8#"%"%'#-&:#-#%'-/#2"3!"

"3#6"!"#0#-'/#'"3!2-#0%#:#2"3#8-$#2.-#*8+%$7-!++"/#'" %'2.&"-%!+ 8+"&*&3#2& :%"3 ! 0%#: " ?-%'9 /-# "-!'&8!-#'$7 3# -#&8'2#'"&;"3#-#-#;-#.'2#2"3#!/.'"&2#8&%"#2?7"3#8#"%"%'#-& "9#"3#-:%"3%'"#-#&"!"=D8#-!''./"3#-#'3#8#"%"%'#-&:#-#!+& %'-/#2"3!""3#-#&8'2#'"&:#-#%'"3#8-$#&&%'0%"%'9!88+%$!"%'& -!++"/#'"%'2.&"-%!+8+"&!&8#-"3##:'2.&"-%!+ +%$73##:

'2.&"-%!+ +%$7:!&%'!$"%'"-2.$#2'+7' =

!'2"3#&"!"# !'!9#/#'" -$#2.-#& ;

:!&%'"-2.$#2'+7%' $"?#-;

A 2#'"%$!++7&%".!"#28!-"%#&:33!2%+#2!88+%$!"%'&!+'9 :%"3"3#8#"%"%'#-&3!2%+#2 AA>

:3%$3:!&2%&/%&&#2 ?7 !' -2#- !'2 E.29#/#'" ! %0%&%' #'$3 "3%& .-" 2!"#2

3#%0%&%'#'$33!&3#+2!&.'2#-(4

! "

# $%& ' $(

)

* $+!,,*"$*

, $+

+!,,*", $

! " 0

"120 3& %4'5#6 7&7

! $

9 #!-#?.'2?7"3%&E.29#/#'""%&'"2%&8."#2"3!""3%& $!&#%&%2#'"%$!+" AA>

> ":!&;3:#0#-;$'"#'2#2"3!"$+!.&# A>"3#'"#-8-%&#&

-/"%' +%$7 ;

-/.+!"#2?7"3#0#-'/#'"!-7!'!

3!2'"?##'?-.93"""3#'"%$#"3#%0%&%'#'$3+!.&# A>-#!2& !&.'2#-(4 %( !"#$ "%&

!'!& (!)"$ , 5,

2 $%% 8 %.%:

, 5" *

;

9 3#$'"#'"%'%&"3!"!++!$"%'&"!C#'.'2#-"3#8-#0%.& 8+%$7!'2'"/#-#+7$//%"/#'"&/!2#"3#-#.'2#-:.+2-#/!%'

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

&(!"#+!,'-$(!&, ,.!"%, !"#++!"%$

-%#, /0122/13 +.$C7