← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25831/2015dismissed

M/S Bellsonica Auto Component India Pvt Ltd v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-12-10Mr. Justice Darshan Singh20 pages



       

  !" # $"

% #&'(

)"$"

$"



   

  

 *(+(  

   (,

& (   

  !$ # $"



   

  

 *(+(

    (,

& ( -)  ./-  0 *  

( )  

!

" 

"   #$%&'()%*)&  + , " 

"

  #$%&'(*%*)&  

- " 

"



  #$%&'()%*)& 11111 ) ! 

 -    ./ % #  ,0     1 0./

*  2

    

 

  !

 



2  #$%&'()%*)&

  3  2

 

     

- 



   

0  #%&'(*%*)& 0  

0 ,   %

 0

   

 "$-"4   $ )*"%*)&

  

  

0      ((5%656  

1 

")7895 :

:6

  ,   ; 

   

  $&3  2  

  0  < 

)="%*)&



   (    

 0  0 

    

 

 

 





 

03   ,      





  



2  , 0 

0

    



0  

0   

   

0 #     $&  , "

0 >





 

     >     

 2

0 

         !

     "

4  



,



   

  0     

    

     

     

 

 

  ((5%656



0

0 

 0

   

 

  

   $8     

0  

2 1      $8"  

 

  0   



  ?   @ 



" 0  

0

 



    ;

    8   

0



 A

>



  



  ,



       

 

 ,

     !

,

     0  !

  

      0





 

0  

  2

 "  

 

   

 2   

4    

 

  

           

,

!

  

"  0

 # $)9=&8%*)&     0%&"%*)&B  C    

 &                    

   0    ((5%656

  

 

             ,

      !







   4    

 

;  ,



"

       

0





  

,

      "

4  >

 

 0" 

0 "  

  0



0 





  2 

2

 

   2   !

   ;

   00  0

 

0  

0    

   

   >   

  

    0  =    ,

 >

  >

  + 3%4%

%% 5/6&  7 56 )7&7D===E -)7=*)=*     >

 

  0 F    



     ((

"   

    0

> 

0

  0  







  

0 

0    ((5%656"

   !

            ;   

  >  

    " !

  

  

    



 

  

 

0 

 9  

0  " 

!

"



  

0

     

 "

  

 



 !

,0 

 

E/ &9(7 %:-( 56 8)7=) -'=*"-%

+  % 38)7&' -97"7 %

%&;%<(/6& 7+= % %(%64% &%68  -  %**&    &9*" %(;%   0+=%  -( /6&  /%5(76  7% & % &  7(8  -  )7=(    =99"  + 3%4 %

%% 5/6&(;

56 8)7=*5)6-'*="-(% 7((/6&8 -)7'*%)%8"%,+>%0%7%5%7

6 *5%( %6 ,%25%**%6%%88"%'+%0%% (, -& 

%68 -)79()8*8"%%

00- &%52)7=& 5(6-8))"

&% 5 # &%0&7%7%7%5%4 <85%**969 =9*"% 

0,

 =% =/6&/%4 + +2 78#$%==31)7=&

 )&%)7==" 67% &   0  A

"  # $7%')    %**'  

    ((%**7" 0 +7 < # &%/6& (& = ##'2 &+(%4+ %% & %

78%*)85)6$99=5A

6"% %0 =7 (& = ##'2 /%4 + +2 %%%% &%

78 %**9-%8&" 7% (,  , %

 7%  0 =78 %*)*  -  7*7   /%%  %6  -% %=6  #-76'% 5(85)79'6() '

  

        0 

  

  

!



2







 2

E!

  (( 

!

;  

;



 !

  3

  !

 

     

  D



     ((5%656

; 

  )*

!



 A



0

 !





0

)(=   

  

!



 A

 

  

   





 0          

 

                      

   

"



 

   ;    



  

!

  0 0

  0 !

  ((5%656

 

      "  

 

   

  



0  ; !

 

 

        



0   

 

   7

"

0 !

" 

 

   

 

2"  0 "   ;     

        

    , 

 "    0







 0!





 ,0   

 

   !

 0    

  

!

;    

0 0   

0    "      









,







 2

      !

 " 

0

  2 

>     



  

 

 >

  2  "4   )*      

-

2

   ((5%6

 

  2 

         

?

 0

 2



@!

  ((5%656

 

   

  2 

 

0     

    

    

  0          

    



  0 

  2     0

  0 

    



 ))

0 "  " 

   

   0     0   

          

,   !

0

0  

0 

 

  

 ,   

" 

    "B

 

-  

 C 

 



0

  "      

03 



  

 



   

  "

 ,

 

  " 



0     2 



 0

 0 03 

3 2   !

0 

   0 

 0

0 !

2 

 

 

H 

  

    



0 !









0 

 0 

F2  

    

 )%

03  

            ;    

- , 

 

!

2    

 A  )*"%*)8!

03  

    )%

A

0" 2



0

 0 



0 



       

2

    

  0

 

0  $

0 

 

03 

 2   )( 

   

0    2 

0       

,  

    

B  2 C    B

0 C 0 " 



 



     



      !

 0   D0"D

 "4   1  %*"%*)8!

  0





 

  0

   0 8&  2

     "  



03    A   )9" %*)8 

0   

 "  

  

 

    A  %%"%*)8" 

  2 "





  "    $ ("%*)8!

2



       

 

03 !

2 "

 "  

   

0





   ;   

, 

 



    0

     "  

  0         2

!

2  , 0!

  

 

 

03  1  ()"%*)8

      

0     D 

 &"  %*)&  !

   

    



   



 >  > D 

)%"

%*)& %E(*!

   



 D 

%*"%*)&!

0    !



  89 0  

0 !

2

   

 

0

 

  

0 0   D 

(*"%*)&" 



> 3%=!

  

0   2  < 

)="%*)&  "

,   

   

   "4  "  "



     





0  

    !

2 



    

  



!

  ('  2      



   (("77'3 

  < 

)="%*)& 

 0

    $&

  2  

 )8  

 !

        

  )=    )9    

    A (7-)I%   2



2  0

03 !

  E3 ?)=

1  

     



    

0

 0  0 2



   2 

  %%)*%*)8

 

  



03 

    

03   

  )9

     

   

           0 

0 

  0     

        

  *())%*)8@ )& <   0" !



   2 2   

  



03 

 0  0 

      

 

0      "4   A  %%"%*)8

  

 A  )9"%*)&    

 



0 A  )9"

%*)8!

 

   

  

 0  0 2

     !





0  0 0  

"%*)8

   2 D "%*)8!

   

 

03 

    

!

   

03 

 

 

03 

     ; 



  

    

  )=  !

     #$)9=&8 %*)&     0%&"%*)&

   





 

 

!





E

  ; 

A

 

 

  

0 0

  !

;   

  "$-"4    0)7"%*)&





0!

   

  

,



     3 0

  0

0 

 0 !

 

   ;

 0  ,

          ((  5%656    

 

   

   

0       >   

      2  

      

!

 "

   " 

  (( 5%656

 0  

   

 









"

 

!

 

 

     

 

B

C / &9(7 %:( -(   ( 56 2  -)7=)'=*A     

 1  



 

 -(% &  (+6 ( %/6&%<%07%6%8)7'()*8



     

 0 

 

 

 

  0

 

 



 !



   

  ;

> 0!

    

   



      

 

0

   

 "$-"4   2 

!

            

 

   " 



  2 

0     ,

  

,



 >



 0 

%%= %%9      

       (( 5%656

 )9    

> 2

  0     

 



  !

    ((5%6  ; ,

        0 0 "  

5

6!

  

 

;  

 0 "



  

      0  "

   0   

 

0 , 

  2 

 

   

 

"  !



 

 



03   2   !

0 

0

03   A  %)"%*)8

  

  

0

03  0  



1  %8"%*)8     

!

 



0 

  

   2  

0 



   !

0 

 

 

  

  

2   

0   A  )*"%*)8!



 



 0 

  !



  

 A  %*"%*)8   "

3G"4 0 0 

 

 0 !

  



 

 



  

 



 2  )' $>" ; 

 

 0A  2  

  0A " ;

" 

0 

2     

0<  "

03  

  2     

2 0      

 !



03     2   )9"%*)8



      A  %)"%*)8!

2 0   

1  %8"%*)8



03 

  2 !

    

   2 :



03   

     1  %8"%*)8

 0  4  !





8)  

 

 2 



   A        

         

  

     



 

;

   0       :  0    

   !

 

 2   !

 



2

 < 

)="%*)&

 

 < 

%8"%*)&

  0

0

 

    ((5%656 

!

 

0 

 

  0A 

   2

0



!

 

  &%/6&   %2 %**8586-'%=  ;  2  0>  

03   



0

 2 #  



03  2  0

0"    

  



 0  

0!



  D 

(*"%*)&    $%98 1  %*"%*)8  0 

   2   A (7-)I% 

  )&)  

     



   ;

    ;

!



0     



       

        

  !  

  > "  

  

,   

  



       

0 !

2 





  

  0   

0 !

 

   0A

2 



0 

  

0

"

0

"   

  2

0   "  

0



       2

0                 ,

 

     2 !



  

  

!

 

0               

  

     2    !

             

 

            

9%<%   -?(  % '2  %'+%8 )7=8  5%6  -  )*8 





0 



  E3 ?!



 5

  

 

 



 



0       

 G  4  !







  ((5%6 56   



0    " 

6 

05

6

  0 5

0

  "  



 

 



  2

     ((5%6

 "  





 

 0     2

 

   @ )'  

  

   

0   E3 ?

  

 

   



0  

)=%%*)& 1  "

 

3%"  4     %*%%*)&  

 

 





 %8%)&  1 

 "

3%"4  !

      1  "

3%"4  "

 

           "



"

    )=%%*)&  !

              1

 "

3%"4   

      ((5%656 

 

"  )789         

 "$-"4  !

   1     "  

3%"  4      

   0           

  

 )    

      

   ((5%656        

  1  

"

)789 %    -0       

!

 A  (        



    

 5J



0 6 8       2

 $ & 1

J ;

-  

       

"

0

 ;

   

 

  

  1

 "

3%"4  

"  0



 

       

 



2    

 

"    

  



"      

  "



"  0



   

     



   

    >    4  " 

     

       "



   

 %&*2  

 4  !

-A



0

 

"   

 

 

  



1  "

3%"4   $



  

 

    

  

 

 

 )'%)&

  



0  "



2

  <    

  

      

    

         



       

  

 

0 

    0<  

 2  0 0 

 

  0" 

  



!

  

 

 



 

1  "



3%"4  

    

 

           " 

     

           

    

           



0 

    0@ )7 <  " !

   ,

0 

  

 2 



   

 

  ((5%656

"?



 @  

    

  0

  

     

   0 

     

0     ,





         "

"?



 @     0      

"?

@  

  

  

 ?



@

    

0 ?

 @  

    0

                  

     !

  2 

 

0

  

   , !



 

0   B

C

    0 0       " ?   @" ?



 @"

?

@ ?

 @     

  



   



 

!

,0         

     0   

   A 



   ((5%656"

 

    :



  

 0     



;         ;     :

0  0     2

 

            

"    "           

 



   

"

     0

 

   0A



       

  %* 

 0

   ((5%656







   

  2  0  

    ((5%656

0

2





 

  "    



  >

     :     

   "   

  

  

 

  "

     

   0A 

   

"    2

"   

  " 

"

   !

  

 >      

   

 

 0   "  "    " , 

       > 

 

  2     0





  

         



  2      







 %%   "  

            

0    

 0



 

      0  

    2 

03 " 

  0 

 !



     

  -% %= =  ' 2  / <&%4%&9%+ %5%'85)77(689%9! > 

 

 0  

0

 

  

0

 > 

 "$-"4    2



     

  "  



   

4     

     >

0



,



  ,

 

 "

 

     %( 

 "

  



       1   )*"  %*)&        0       

   0  , 

  

  

     

 

0 0 1 

)*"%*)&"  

 >

   

 "        

        

   " 

0

    

"

  F       



"     

 







  !

 

9    

   0"



        0   ((5%656

!

     >

  ;

     

 0



"

 

  2  @ *  A   '64"$2 $"