← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/4684/2009disposed of

(O&M) Laxmi Narain v. State Of Haryana

2015-08-31Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain6 pages

 

    



 

 !  ""## $!% & '!( "  !"# $%&'( )*+,-( !.(*/,$0!'

)! ""##"! *!+,,-.$/!#.'!(

!.(*/,$0!'1 0,##1,"!""#,+ ,2!

,  #!   !  0%!  $  2,,  ,  +3  #  +(  , #2!# 1,1,! "% 4% #.

2! 

5! #(,  ,!$#+#!!!, ,""##.2,""!"!.# , 6# #2 +(, ,! 5%, 2%1,+4%!+(,&$    %    

 %  %!  &      ,   4%.  !,!.7,7 %!& 

,2% 

.2,,2"%+#,

8,

4%0##! !,!.7,0##!7$2!

, !6$#% ,4%!#9,!

,""##. #(.5%, "!   98,""## 2+! 9 ,(%1!+!,!&+!&1,  8,(  2!      ,  62#1    ,  4%  8,   %  

 "2"(:,(! .,( 62

! ,!"!#%#,,#2+(,! ,! 5%, 24%!,(!

+%,2"( "8,

!26%"2,,%,!;  .2$%,!. 

 $%! ,""## <= $%! ,+!,!&+!

&1,.2!.2,,2!"+(,""##8,""## %  !"!1  ,  %,!  !  "(     4%  "+%!"2!$0$#>!)

2 #,0%!!1,1!$, "2 ""4% #8, 2" 



1$1#+!(,""##,! #+3+ !,0##!.

2,,2!+! !!,#!0%!+#2 !! 

 "8,#!0%!+#2$ "%1!!.,2!1#(  ,+38,""##2 %#8,#2 4%!,(!

8, ",%#,$+", !1, %#2! #(,! !,! ,""##, (! 9$+ !,2!2%+(,0##!8, %,!2!%(+% %,#1#,! , #2!    "(  ,   "    ,   8,(  ,$1  #   ,!1,!%(.,""##+ %

!' %!,!

%+ , , %  ",+6"  ",(!

.,""##2%#,$11 %

 " !1,!,!)(  9, 136', %+",!1, ., %# +%# !"%!, ,!#8,""##+1 %#., !3 ,+3 #+(,""##% #(# !!%

;,,!,.#!%# !,&%+ ,  !,%  ,2!+(,0##!

.,  %     " 2  "  , !%!(#1  2,  ,  % ,!#2!:"%,,""##+  3!,(!9 +%6",!#  " ! #(+3!, ! ,(!9 ., $ ""#  + !  ,  ,1,!  %,!  : #(  ,  !  2 4%! ! ,!!2 %,, %2#(1 ",8!%!(8,$%,!2!1"!"!, ""##'2$!.,! %", ?$,! !,

""##! 4% !+% (!##%, , #0>)

,0%!.2,,2" 



1$1 #+!(,"! #+32,,2!+"! #2:

!,#1, & ,.,+3 # ,12!#!#( +!!,#( #1,! %# +.,# %,""#+#8,# ,""##"(,  ","!!##( $, " !4% #,+ , %  %!& , (    %+4%  ,!  ;  !.    $  2  #  +(  , ""##%""! ,# ,1,! ",

%  %!& ,  '!,""##,%# !,&

8,%"% +(,""##.,& %#,$ !!!,,#2+(#5%,  . ,! ,""##2 %!& ,



8,2!2"+(,0##!

5%,    98,""##2 !, , +!,  9 '(%1!+!,!2+!  *1,!+( ,,  , ,! ,!5%, .,""##, +!,!&+!&1,2! !8,0##! !%1,2!.

" , %  ,!%!( : !  ,!  

!2!# , +(,""##.,(! ., 2 ! +(,"!#%#,,#2+(, ,!# 5%, 24%!2(+6,(!

 " 2"8,! !.,""##6%", !2,,%,! 8,%1,, !24%#+%##!!2 %,% 92",!%!( !%  ,2!+( ,0##!,! ,""##2!!2! ,#,  '%## , ,,"!+ !,8, ""##2,

!, "  9.,(! ! %", :# ,,%!"!1, %,!+%2,4%:,(!

.0>)

2 #.2,,2" 



8,!#$"!

 ,!!!+#2= @;  ,  ,!  ,.  #!  "%(  $ /!#%+ ,, " %2 "! !,2!, #1(+ +("#11!+% 4%,+#1'2$!61 %  ,    ,  "!7    6#  #  2 4%!    ,  ,  !1,    6    ! !  !

,   ".2,,,%#$# % !(1!.2 " 1!, #+!(%+ ""#%!& , 4%   4% 0##!2,!,,""#,##+ " 2, %!26,! !   !4%!  %!  #2  2%#  +  ! !!    #! !-%1 !!   " 8,  !1#  $%,!  %+     0%!  ! !%!#!#$/!#.&,! ,,A"%!B :2,! !,,+32! #+(,""##.

2,,2! +(,#!0%!+#2 9  ! ,#  ,""##!1!1 "(  

 ",!""#+#,(! .2,,2

! , "!., +"! 

"!$ ,.!12,,,%

 !!   ",2,, %!& , %!,"%!"! !+  

    

 &00



$,+#+(,""##+ !,#!  !0%!%""! ,"#,,$#% ,#, %  %!& ,2 !,2, 22!+(,0##!, !$+,, 2!    ,  0##!  2    3%    !  '.  ,    !

,   "%, %

 '2$!.##, ! ,,#24%!+( ,&2(+6,(!

%+.2# ,,  %  "2",!%!(, 2 # +((:2,%( ,&#,$,  ", ",!1, %#2!8,"!!==!  ,  ""##  2  "!$    ,  #  2,%  "(     (  " 8,  %.      2,,!  2,  ,  "     %  

 "  +( ,  /$!     ,  8!%!(.  ,  #+#(   "( !"!.2!+('7+#,&%"! 0%!

       

!  "

     "   

 &00

."!,! !+#2= @ 2., ",2!2  

2!%,#2! !$, ",(!$ ,   ".  ,   %    9  !!  2 ",1$! !%!(0+, " , %  ",1$!  !%!(4%$#, %  "" ,#2!<"!!C>,6 :   "!$#(!  . , 0%!     #   $   % & & '   #

&00

.!#(1%",!#! )! ,A"%!$#!#D!0!" :

   &009., ,#,," ,  % , ",7!$%%  $#,#+#( ,"(! %+##, %,+"0%!B  ",%""#  8, 2 ##2   



      

   &00      &!  5#3  1!  # $& 8 #%,!

&0 ?

:,,."%,, %

 ""(+#,"!!==! ,""##2

  !#(",8!%!(2

!,""##  !

"( 

(!,! !'.,#+#("(!, &5%, ! ,#24%!2(+6,(! 

8, %, 2 1!+%,$#% , ( , 2 %, !: #$1,,"! #% #%#,!. (".,"!""#+" 2,!,&"(#% %  %  #, # !1,!,!!,% ,&"!$1 ,"! ,!!1, %##  !%,#1"!. 

.

<=  "8, +#",# !1#(,! ,!,"!"!( 8,  ""#    "    !1#(  8,  !!  +  "#2,2,2 ,

3,5# $ -%1  !"!!