High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3558/2011dismissed

Sarabjit Singh @ Bittu v. Rajni & ORS.

2016-04-11Mr. Justice Veeraswami Ramaswami11 pages

#$$%!

& '()

""""##$%% &'() (

$* """"($*#$ *"

+%#!

(

""""##$%% *"

&'()

$* """"($*#$ *"

+++ (

,-( . ..

, $ - #.

$*#$ 1"

1" "

2""

,3%.

1" $*#$ 1"

/0 $*#$

$*#$

1" "

3%.

$*#$

1"6

$*#$

1" "

000

. 1 /$ 0# $

3 *

##$%*

*$ 8

3 "

#**$ 00$

-%8* 7!%.

;

7!%< -7 -*$ 1"

$$9

#$ !$ $0

&$ 0%$* 0

;

=< %$

0%8

00!

>/$$ - $ * 3 (8.

!* (

?@ / 2!8 $*#$ *>$$ % 2!8.

8 00$

" " =.

# %%3$

(*"=. =.6A 3$ "

##$%* %% *#*$

088 ! 8$ 00$

00!$ >/$$ - $ $ !

/%%

*0 1"> =

8 090%$ $

1"> 4- 4

$$ $$$

8 090%$< /$

$ %

" " = >/$$ - $ *!00!8$

!$* *!* $

00$ *

B8 ($#

=" " = !$ $0 * =.

6 6

B >$% -$ $ $$

>%0$ > 3 $*#$0

00$

C!$* *

$*#$

/$.

3$ *!$

8 090%$ 3$$

$% *$/$%%9 %%$ #98$

($*#$ *!0$ 08#9 $0

3 8

0%8 3$$ 8$ %$

$0$/$ $$*

4D !8 8

0%8 #$

%% $%E .

$0/$9

#/** $0

$$%

$/$

3 #**$ 7!%.

8 090%$ **%$

3 "

*0%8 (

$* #$$$ 1" 0$8$

*!8*** 8$ 0!*$%

# $*

$ $0 #$!*$"

2#$$%2!

**%

$8* 0 *

*!0$ #%09 #

/$ 3$

8 090%$

*!0$ 08#9

$0/$

0%8 8

/$ 3$.

0!*$%

/$ *!8

$##$

3 $** F (G > 1"

'F"(.

*#$00%%9

%0$0$ $

A1,B "

" **!$

0$ ,* 0

7*#

0$.

2#!

/% /

8 090%$A0A 0 !# " =

8*#%0$

%0$0$ $

1"??4 A =

8 090%$ 3

8 0

/% 3"$""

" 4" =

" ="

$$ $.

$ $ !% /

%0$0$ $

1"?> 4 1"> 41,?A =

#$ " " =

" ="

%$$H* %0$0$ @

*!*$C!$

$ !% %0$0$ 'F"(6 3$$

$$$ $/$0$

?$$ 0!*$% !

%$ ##* %3

!$ %39*

*!0$ 08#9

$* %*

$8*

#%09 $8#%9

!%9 %0$0$"

#/$

%0$0$ 0

$$$ $/$0$ /% %0$0$"

* 0$.

8$$ *$0$ 9 $

%0$0$ 1"

A1,B "

$0 #!0$ (G

-%$@.

,"7""

0$.

2#!

% 3!%

%0$0$

**!$

* 0$"

$0%9.

$/$

* %0$0$

/%%$.

$$$ $/$0$ %$$H* %0$0$ H@H 0

#$ " 4" =

" ="

00$

@ #%0$

" " = 0/$$

%0$0$"

!*$C!$

$ $ !% %0$0$ 'F"(6

*!0$ 08#9 %$

#/$

%$$H* %0$0$ @

$ !% %0$0$ 'F"(6 3$$

$!$ 0!8$ *"

*$0 %0$0$ #!0$

$ 7!%"

7 *!##

!8$ 0!*$% $%$ !#

!!"#$%&'"$( ##$* 0$

/$ !8$

0!*$%

0**$F8 .

%0$0$ "

A1,B "

" **!$ ,* 0

7*#

0$.

2#!

5$ 00$# 0$0

0#9

* %0$0$ 'F"(

/%%$

!0% %$"

5$ !

* %0$0$ @$"

$8$

0%$

%0$0$ "

A1,B "

" 'F"(

#/$ (G

-%$@.

,"7""

0$.

2#!

%0$0$ 'F"(

**!$ ,* 0

7*#

0$.

2#!

% @$ %0$0$"

#/$

'F"(

/$ !$

* !$

9 $

**!0$

%0$0$

#!#

/$ **!$ 8**

$0 #!0$ (G

9 "

" .

#**%$ $/$0$

#/$

%0$0$ 'F"(

@$ 0!8$ * $ *.

$ !% %0$0$ 'F"(6.

#$ " " =

" ="

##$

* %0$0$

**!$

00$

"$"

" " =

$$$

* 0!8$

$%#

%$$H* %0$0$ @

$$$

$/$0$

%* 8# 0$

0!%

#!0$

% 0!8$

00$# $/$0$"

$3*$ %*.

* %0$0$

##$

$!$ 0!8$ /

%0$0$ $

A1,B "

" 'F"(

#$ "

" ="

##$*

$F#9 3

%0$0$ 'F"(

$ %$$H* %0$0$

#$ " 4" =

%% "

" = *F 8

$$ $F#9

#$ %$$H* %0$0$

$ $ !% %0$0$ /%

#$ " " =

" " ="

B 9 0*$.

*0$ %9 # 0#9

%$$H* /

%0$0$ #!0$

% 3

$%.

* %0$0$

$/$ 9 /%!$"

!*.

*0$

%0$0$

@$ %0$0$

$8* 0 *

*!0$ #%09.

$ 8$

$0/$9

#/** $0

*!0$ 08#9 0%%* $/$ "

##$% $

*8**$"

2+%#2!

?$$ 0!*$%

*0%8 !$

6 9$*

00$

9$* 8$ $

#* 8 $8 $# *%9

@$ (*"

4. A 8

30$ ##%$ $!0

*%9.

00!

#$*% %/

$F#$*$*

*$0%9

$#$$09 0%0!%

>G >@.

-%$@

0$ ,"7"-"0!8:

,$0

0**$F8

8%9 #$* 0*$

( %

$088$$

"I"

0$.

$$$0$

08#**

($%9

)

*$%%$#'(

#(+',

0!*$% !

# #$*

3* 9

/%%$

0%8

00$

0 $!0 %$ $ $8

!$ $0

?$$ 0!*$% !

/$8$

$8#%9$$

!$ #*#$0 0$8$

*%9 !

3* %** 0* !8 !$% $F#$*$* %* /$9 %$**"

)*#!

$%9.

>/$$ - $ $8#%9$ >$

0$ ,$#!

'F0*$ 7F -88**$0!8:

,$0 .

:% "

*%9 0$ 0

#!0$ $0 'F"> 00

*%9 (*"

.64 A"

* 'F">

*%9 0$

$8*

>9 -88**"

$/*$ *0%$.

0%*

*0 #9

(*"6 A 3$$ %%3$ *0 #9 (*" A"

00$#

$* 89 >G

( >G % 2!8.

$#*$

>/$$ - $ 3

*%9 (*"

4. A 8

$/*$ #9 *0%$

**$**$

08$

*!0

"$"

(*"

4. A 8

/$8$

$8#%9$$

0%8

*%9 0$ 0 #/$ $0 !

$** $*

8$ $

*$/0$ $0

#/$"

0%8 %%$

6 9$* %

$ !

#* 8 $8 $#

8$ $ 9$*"

0% $0

$%.

9$* 8$ $

#* 8 $8 $# *!//$ 33.

8 *.

8$ !

8 *

$*#$ 1" 4"

8 !

* 3$$

8#%$$ 0%8 *"

$C!%%9 $

0%8 %9

8 * !

/$ %*

08$ !# ##$% *

*!*$8$

7!%"

$$9

* $

*$% $#$$

3$$

$#$$

$0$*$"

B /$3

3 0%8 *.

$!0

08$

#$*% %/

$F#$*$* !%

/$ $"

= $

9$* %

9$* *$/0$

0$ B -

. $%%/#'( #(00 1

% 3 5H%$ #$F -!

#$8$

$%3 9$* D

0 !% *%9

3* !

!$ #*#$0 *J

$%3 6 9$* !% DJ !

9$* !% 8$"

%3 % 3

-1

$%&'#'( #(&0% !$ ;

" # #

# ## $ % &' # # ( ) $ % *

+ B

0*$

*$% $8#%9$ F$ 3 $*"

*!#$! 9$*"

* *!0 $

/$3

%3 % 3 % &$8H* 0*$

*!#

($*

$*H 0*$

*!# 9

0 !% 08$

3* !

!$ #*#$0 0!% %%3$"

9$* *$/0$

0%8 $ %$

08#%$ *%9

* $

9$*"

53$/$.

9$*

3!%

/$ %$

#$*

%** $#$$09

0%0!%

#$*

3!% %$

00 %9.

#9%$

*0%8 0%0!% !$

08$

(!#$$* (*"

4. A "

0 !%

9$* "

!% $#$$09 A (*"

4. A

K (*"

.. A 6"

!% #%$ % &$8

$*H 0*$

*!#

@$ # 8!% #%$ *#%%* /$

9$*"

$$ L *!#$! "

L "

-8#$* !%% *%9 #$ "$"

!# 9$*

(*"

.6. A 4"

-8#$* #$* #$ "$"

9$* (*". . A "

7 %

0%!8 1" L 4 (*"

.66. A B

(*"

.66. A 0%0!%

3* $#$$09.

(*" A 3$ !$

!$% $F#$*$* 0$

(*". A $$*

(*" A 3$

3* %** 0* !8

( 0$

(*"

. . A"

(*"

. . A 3$ 00!

%**

!0$ %/$ $0 !*

$C! $"

00 %9.

##$% 1" %$ *(

$* # %%3$

#**$ 8$"

0$ (*"4.=6. A %% #

*0%8 3

6 9* 8

$0$#

0$ $ 0#9

! 8$

*0%8 %% %$

$$*

"D !8"

3%% *!*$

*0%8

$8* $*A0 * 0#

7!%"

$0/$9

*!0$ 08#9 %% $8

*8$"

. )

" $