High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/413/2008dismissed

Jai Singh v. Raj Pal Singh And ORS.

2015-11-03Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

!"##$%&%'()#*+#,-.

!%%'/0 11#22!'"

3#,&4&

!5 !2%'/0 "0#,& #&1'6#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.& 70#"0#, #1,"#,&2$!21!1#,&*!8+#!229#6"&##"0#546/*#'": +#,##,,#6""0# #1,"#,&,'":

70#"0#,"0#546/*#'"&0426+#,#1,"#6%'"0#%/#&":

,#&#'"( ,6!,&0!%'-6)$!"#- ,"0#!11#22!'" ,;!,%'-#'%,6)$!"#9%"0 &2<!!,%'-6)$!"#- ,"0#,#&1'6#'"& ===== *)+%,'

0#!11#22!'">12!%'"%%&%' #/42!,#$'611#!2!/!%'&""0# %'6%'/&,#'6#,#6+8"0#;9#,11#22!"#4,"-90#,#+8"0#546/*#'"!'6 6#$,##"0#",%!24,"6#$,##%'/"0#&4%"-0!)#+##'&#">!&%6# ,6!,&0!%'-2#!,'#6$4'&#2!11#!,%'/'+#0!2"0# !11#22!'">12!%'"%&4+*%"&"0!""0#;9#,11#22!"#4,"0!&$**%""#6 %22#/!2%"8!'61#,)#,&%"8%',#)#,&%'/"0#9#22,#!&'#6546/*#'"!'66#$,## "0#",%!24,"!'6%''"!11,#$%!"%'/"0#!$""0!""0#1!,"%#&-+#%'/

!514"+8!&"#-9#,#/)#,'#6+8"0#4&"*!,8;!9-90%$01#,*%"&"0# &4$$#&&%' "0# 1,1#,"8 '28 +8 *!2# *#*+#,& !'6 '" +8 #*!2# *#*+#,&!"04%'/00!6"0,##9%)#&-'!*#28-!'/!?!4,-%'/!,?!4,

!'60!*#2%%0!2%'/09!&+,'4",*"0#2%'!'/!?!4,!'6 9!&*!,,%#6"4'#0!,% 4""0#9#62$<-'#6!4/0"#,-'!*#28-02% !%- 90 /!)# +%,"0 " 2! %'/0 0# !11#22!'">12!%'"% %& "0# &4$$#&&,>%'>%'"#,#&" 2! %'/0 %0!2 %'/0 1,#6#$#!&#6 !"04 %'/0!"04%'/06%#6%'"0#8#!,@ 2!%'/0-)%6#,#/%&"#,#6 !61"%'6##66!"#6@@-9!&!61"#6+84'#0!,%'#&&#'$#-!"#, "0# !61"%'- 0# !$A4%,#6 "0# 9'#,&0%1 "0# #'"%,# 1,1#,"8 !'6- "0#,#,#-'#%"0#,%'/!,?!4,',0!*#2%0!6!'8,%/0",&0!,#%'"0# 1,1#,"8"%&%'"0#&#$%,$4*&"!'$#&-"0#&4%"&##<%'/%'54'$"%'9!&%2#690#,#%'"0#",%!24,"-!"#,'"%$%'/"0#,%)!212#!6%'/&"0#1!,"%#&""0# 2%&-,!*#6%&&4#)%&>!

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

70#"0#, 4'6#, "0# $4&"*!,8 2!9 !& 1,)#6 %' "0# 1,#&#'"$!&#-"0#*!2#026#,6#&'"#C$246#"0#9%69&!'6 "0#9%69"0#1,#>6#$#!&#6&'-"0#*!2#026#,-A4!0%& #&"!"#90&#%'0#,%"!'$#%&4'6#,$'&%6#,!"%': 70#"0#,!*!2#0#%,6#&'"#C$246#"0#9%69&!'6 "0#,#*!2#0#%,90%2#&4$$##6%'/""0##&"!"#!*!2#

026#,-%',#&1#$"1!,"%#&90!,#/)#,'#6+8$4&"*!,8 2!9:

,;!,%'- 2#!,'#6 #'%, 4'&#2 !&&%&"#6 +8 &2<! !,%'6)$!"#-!11#!,%'/'+#0!2"0#,#&1'6#'"&-&4+*%"&"0!""0# ;9#, 11#22!"# 4," 0!& ,%/0"28 6%&*%&&#6 "0# &4%" +8 !1128%'/ "0# 6$",%'#!<%'"

%'!&*4$0!&"0!"2!%'/00!6%2#6!

$%)%2&4%"!/!%'&"0!*#2%%',#&1#$""0#&!*#)#,81,1#,"8-,90%$0"0# 1,#&#'"&4%"9!&%2#6+80%&2#/!20#%,&0#&!%6&4%"9!&6%&*%&&#6)%6# 546/*#'"!'66#$,##6!"#6.@D C 0#!11#!21,##,,#69!& !2&6%&*%&&#6)%6#546/*#'"!'66#$,##6!"#6.@DE C '$!&#- 2!%'/00!6"$2!%*"0#6#$2!,!"%'-!&&4*%'/0%*&#2"+#"0#9'#, "0##'"%,#1,1#,"8!""0#0!'6&!"04%'/0-0#$4260!)#&4/0""0# &!*#,#2%#-"0#,#,#-!&1#,"0#1,)%&%'& ,6#, 42# -*4$0 2#&&"0#1,)%&%'&#$"%' -"0#&4%"9!&'"*!%'"!%'!+2#'"0# 546/*#'"!'66#$,##6!"#6.@DE-%"0!&+##'0#26"0!"0!*#2%9!&%' 1&&#&&%'+89!8!6)#,&#1&&#&&%'-"0#,#,#-"0#&4%",1#,*!'#'" %'54'$"%'%'"0#!+&#'$#1&&#&&%' %&'"*!%'"!%'!+2##4,"0#, &4+*%"&"0!"

"0#,#%&'%22#/!2%"8!'61#,)#,&%"8%'"0#%'6%'/&,#'6#,#6+8 "0#;9#,11#22!"#4,"-*4$02#&&'&4+&"!'"%!2A4#&"%'2!9!,%&#& ,6#"#,*%'!"%'+8"0%&4," 0!)#0#!,6"0#2#!,'#6$4'&#2,"0#1!,"%#&!'6!11,!%&#6 "0#1!1#,+< "%&!*!""#,,#$,6"0!"2!%'/00!62&""0#2%"%/!"%' 41""0%&4,"90#'"0#&4%"%2#6!/!%'&"0!*#2%%',#&1#$""0#&4%" 2!'60!6+##'6%&*%&&#60!)#/'#"0,4/0"0#,#$,6"0#",%!

!'6"0#$18"0#&4%"!'6$*1!,#6"0#&!*#9%"0"0#1,#&#'"&4%"0# 6#&$,%1"%'"0#1,1#,"8%&%6#'"%$!2 '$#"0#,#%&!2,#!68%6#'"%$!2 %'6%'/9%"0,#/!,6""0#&!*#1,1#,"8-"0#&4+&#A4#'"&4%"!""0#+#0#&" "0#&4$$#&&,>%'>%'"#,#&"2!%'/0%&'"*!%'"!%'!+2#!&%"%&0%"+8 6$",%'#!<%'"

0#*!""#,%'%&&4#6%,#$"28!'61,%'$%1!228 %&"0#&!*#'$!&#2!%'/09!&!//,%#)#69%"0,#/!,6"!'8#'",8 *4"!"%'%'!)4,%'/!,?!4,,0!*#2%-0#$4260!)#$2!%*#6"0# 6#$2!,!"%''"0#+!&%&$4&"*&4$0,#2%#0!&+##'&4/0"%'"0# 1,#)%4&&4%"!'6-"0#,#,#-$426'"+#$2!%*#6%'"0#&4+&#A4#'"&4%"!&%" 9426+#0%"+8"0#1,)%&%'& ,6#, 42# 6'"%'"#'6"6%#,9%"0"0#%'6%'/&,#'6#,#6+8"0# ;9#,11#22!"#4,"-90#,#+8"0#&4%"0!&+##'6%&*%&&#6'"0#/,4'6 "0!""0#&!*#%&0%"+8"0#1,%'$%12#

*4$02#&&'&4+&"!'"%!2 A4#&"%'2!9!,%&#&,6#"#,*%'!"%' 0#!11#!2%&!$$,6%'/286%&*%&&#6 /01,2 *)+%

034 '(-.&