High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4085/2023allowed

Jitender v. Kuldeep Through His Lrs And Others

2025-07-23Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal17 pages

!" #$% &'(')&' % *(+,!

-&./ (' &0* && *.

/ 1& '0* &02'%

&/'&.&0* &02%34 32%3 & %

6' & %

0%2*

$ 2' 27 &0&& $&48 *9%& +, ' 2 *$ $ ( / :

0 /%&0 1'

' ' 9 %

%2+,'%

1& .

6'; 1'

'& 2 & &1'' & 2%

%2.& 01' '$ 22% '&+ %&,20 $'9 ('&(&% 1$' %$& 22'&-&..&'&2-% 1'' & 2%

%2.& 1$ $'$ 22%

6'2& 0&.&& (2.' %

0&'&' %

' &22&'<%

%$& 22 '$= & 2%

%2.& 2&(.$$& >> >0 & '& + 9 +, %2& 34

#$% 2& 2 %

%$& 22 '$ 2 &$ 2 &

&$'"%$.& ( ;,0 .% &($& 38"4" .

& !

$$&(?&'

@&'.& -1&/'& $,&' .22 $ (2' 0?&$ 3 0/%&02&&$&$

& 2 $&-' * . 2 4 $&-' 1& %& & & .,&'&$1&+( +2> 47

$, 40 %2& 34 9 & &$ 2 >

; , 2& 2 2&% 3 & . / (' & /'#.&2&.2 0 0"01'

'$'2 $ (2'

*(0 46'%2&'&$$ $$

$,+2 &'%2&A(.+

4 6' 1& A(. & & 4>4 4 *9 %& +, ' 2*$ $ ( / :

0/%&* 2%

%2.& 2&(.$$1& %& & %2& 34 1& 9 &$ ;& ' %%, % 2 +&$& & 2 4 $&-' B'0&$& 8 49 +,%2&34

2&2%2&3 & 1& $&+$$&

* &%%&$ 1& %2 +, %2& 34 $,0 1' %2& 3 & 1 .%$& & %2.& %6'& &%%&$1& .

+,'2*$:

(0 /%& A(. & & 4 3&+$,0 %2& 3 & & 1 % &(& / $$2'0%2&3 & %2&,%&&&%%&$

6' &%%&$ '& ( + .

0 & 9 &%%$

*941&.+,'%

%$& 22 '$

: ( ' % , 2 ' 9 %

0 & +A

1&2 $+,%2&34 #$%71&& '&#$%/ ('1& .%9 &,&(.$$& '

$1&2

71&&$. '+A

'&&$ &444 '&+9 2&2' '$%& ' '& (+ &&%%&$'& (+ .

71& 2'&'& '&$$(&(.$$&>> >0' 1 . &

& (& $ , 2 % &0 '20'; 2$ ,2% &9 %

& 71&&$&'&$ 22% '&+(' ' '& &, $ 2 (& ( % + (& & $, & 2%

%2.& 1&%&C'

.& 0 1&&2% $+ 6'$&+A

'&1&& 1&'&A(.+"+A 1 9 $ % 2' %%,&0'20'; 2$ ,29 $ % &

6'+A

1&%%+,1&,2%$, *9 71&&'&&$'&&$&,+9 2&2 ' %

%$& 22 '$ '

2 ' ' &.1 @, 1&, 2 ' .%( 0 ' 9 %

1& % 2 '$ ( '& % $ + ( & '& ' %

%$& 22 '$'$2 $& 2% & 2%&

0$& ('2 $ (2'% %

)& $2'%& 1'& 8 !

-&. / (' &0 $& $ % ( ' %

%$& 22 '$&(2 ' 2.& & &+ $ ,

2 ' % %

)& $ +.

'& ' +A

%&,+A

0' .%(1$+ &%%&$&+$ &0 '20 ' & %

1$ + .& & &+$ 84

. 0$& $$,('&' .%( & &+$D+.

'&%&'A(.& & 4>4 4 '& ( + %&0 &$ '& &$&, + 9 444 71&+.

'&'9 ( ('$ 22% D+.

'&'9 ( 1($, %$& $ & % ' A(. 2 & & @ ' '

& 2

&'A(.2'DE+$/%.27 & ' & 2!"#$""

%&'&

($)

*+D+.

'&'A(.2'DE+$/%.27 & ' &2 ,"-./ 0

1 1& $, $ % & .

% )& $ +.

'&1' &$ 12'A(.2' /%.27 & ' &22-(%

3 '

%$4*1*)45"&&5& 6 7"

0$89 "(%$0 '& '

%$4 *4)4+"&&5& 8 7 1& +.

+, $& $ '& 1 2 ' &' & % .2'/%.27 & '&2& A(.0 ' 1$ + ; . 2 2 $ ( & 2' 2 % &'&'9 ('$'&(&'& $ 2

0&/'&.&0$& $% ( %2& 34 +.

'& ' $$(&$ , '

.%( 4 *( ( 2 ' 2 .& & &+ $ ,0 $& $ +.

'& ' 9 %

'& 2 &$$, +

0 & &%%&$1$+.& & &+$&'&' & %

1$ +.& & &+$

. 0 1&+.

'& '$& A & 9 $ $, 1 +, ' %2&A(. +0 ' $ 22% $'&+(&&'$,.,1& $& 2% & 2%&

)& $+.

'&'

.& 0'+A

'& ('$,+ .

7 %%2'

0'%$& $ & %'A(. ' & 2 7 $

, 6- )1 6 6 %$ 5+ 0$

:3;92!-3$16 6 %$ +

1 6 6 %$ + !"#$""

%&'&

($6 6 %$+7

7$0 *56 6 %$2- (%

3 6 6 %$)& 3&%%&2%3 & %

7'& '+.

.&+,$& $2 '%& > .

(2 ' 2.& & &+ $ ,0'+A

1 2 $+,&'

%&,&&$21'

'0'&.1$+& & +A

4 $ >0 > 4 + 1$ + +A

4$ &0'20'1$ +&%%&$&+$&'% %

1$$,+.& & &+$

8 >4 .

( ' . 0 ' 2 %

%2.& 1& 4>4 43&+$,0 (' &$&$0 1&&('&& . 2 %

%2.& 1& .& & &+$ & ' $ 2 2 % '&+('6'

1&1+,' &$ & 1&%

&$$,'$'&1'& 2%

%2.& %&0& '$ $+% % 2%%,1 ' % 1'

'' 1& 1' ' 'A(.

' 0%

%' '$ % '& +( F

& / $" $9 9& " 0 9 - 0"9" 09-" 9 "" -3$3" 0$99 $990

0 &/ $" $99& $ 0 " $"

& %$ 51 0 &!0 $9 0$ 0$99 9$ 0 " 9 0"9" 09-" " <$ $9 9 0- :"&8 $$ $990

9 0"9"09-"&/ =3$0- 98 0 $"23'$

>'$7 '$ !86*+ ++ $ -?$?

?9 0$99 0"9"$$?"$-0

% 00? $9 90

3 $99 0"9"09-"9 "" 9 $& / =3$ " 9 :3 ? " $",

&/ *++ '65)* $ "9 0"9"09-" 0

" $ $300

9 00? 0" " "% :- " 0"9" " 0 " $ 0

%&/ =3$6: " $" ' &92 %6-

6- 1 %$ + $ 9 0"9" 09-" -3$ "$-$990

1& " 0$99 $ " 9 0"9" 09-" 9 - $$ *&*&* < 00? - < ? 0?- 9 3$" $ " 96 &) 49& $?0

&1 4 -? 9@&%"0 *&*&*#A& 4& AAA AAA AAA

+& 8%9 9 %

& 0

9$3? 0$99 "" - 3?" " & ! " 9 0"9" 09-" 9 - $$ *&*&*3?" 9&A" $ < 00? - < ? $ - 9% 9 0$99 0?- 9 3$" $" 96 &) 4 9& $3% &5*1&&A"3? 9 & 9% 9 9 & 1 < $ - *1&11 <? 9 00?- < ? $$$$$% - 3 9 0$99 " <$ $9 9 0- :" 9 9-$" 9

00? 0

9% 9 0$99 9 &/ 9& "A" $4< 00?- <? 9% 9 0$99 "% 3$" $ " 09- 9-0

9 :-9$ " 0$99 $$ 3 $3? 00" A" 9 "-0$"&("4 300""$?9$3" "4-9"-0$"&B > 7 0 '20 $& '& ' &$ % 2& 34 9 ( &$ ;& ' %%, 2&2'%

%$& 22 %2+&$& & 1 '

& % 21.'2.'%& (2'A(. 2 0' &$ .& '& ' &$ + 9 + % + $ 72& 0&&$&,

0' 2% 1&&-% +2' &$&$1'

'1&$,&1+,' &$ > *&%%&$1&%2+,%2&34&(& '& A(.& +'&.&$ &.+ .

A(. & 4 %& +, ' 2 *$ :

(0 /%&

> *(& '&2&

0&($& &%%&$ & + % ( + $, ' &, 6' %+$. 2 ' %

%$& 22 '$&&2'

1 '

2& 6' %$ %2& : & 2 $ ( +A

& ('&.% 1'

''&+&1+,' 6' 9 ( &$ 9&.

' .& 2. ' %%

& .%$, ' &. .& ' +A

'&. 2&2'+A & %2'9 %

> 72& 0'.&1&$ 12'A(.2 'DE+$/%.27 &

# & %&&23 '$

>$$7 '$*+1 6*5& >8 7 $ !"

# & %&0& 2%

%2.& 2 &&(.$$1&2 $01'

'1& 6' ( &$2& '&$' %%,.'%& 1&'+; % '&1'1 ('9 % (0' '& (+ '&$$(&,2'6'9 (-& 1'& &$'(''1&& 2%

%2.& 0 &,&,'

( &+ % ( ' %$& 22 % &0 '20 $ '& % 6' & 1& '&$$( +2 ' D (' 0 1'

'&$$1'%

&& '2'9 (& '9 (1& 1&&2% 6'.& & ' ' & ' ' DE+$ /%. 2 7 &0 1' &2 9&.

('A(.2 %& %&& '( )'*(( $ %&0 '/%.%'$'2'D ('F C / < 9$$ 9" $9 9 0

-? 3 3? A" " " 3"9 0"9"09-" -0$"

> A0

$99 990

9 00? 3& 1& / 0 9$

3 $3? " 923'$%& >'$7 '$0*+

$$3"9 0"9" 6$9!"*1$ $9 9$$ -? D & E " 0

9 00? A"$ %$? ""0? "9 0"9" 09-" -0$" 0"9"$$? 0% 9 $%? 9 0

-? % "-0$ $9 " $& / $ " " "

9 / 9 9 0? !" ++ " 3

$$3 < 9 3? " 0 " " 0

9 00? - & 3& "$? " $9 9 0

" 3 99"%$? "4 $ 0"9"$$? "$- $9 9 0

9 " " 00?3"%? :$? $3? 9 0 " 9 "" 00? 0

9 0 0$99 3"-0$99"%$9- "$- $9 9 990

% 00?9$ $990"&9<& 5& E ""?9" 3 % " " " 3? $ $ % -$0$"? 9 0" $$ 0$99- 0$"$"$- 9 $990

0"&? 9 0"& / 9 $ A0

F? 9 0"F "$ 9 A" 9 " 3? A" "& / $% 00 9- " 0" 3$D F1& / A0

34 " 9 " F 000 " F %? 9"& / 0$99 -? 9 $990

0 00

F 000" F&!

0$%9G6$ 9 9 %$ " - 3 $9 9 0"9" 09-" 0 0

"$3"-3 H%3 " 9 " 9 "$- $9 9 0 0

"$ "" 0$99 $? 9 "< $

4 00? A"9 $ 9% " $99 0"9"09-"9 ""9 $ 3 -" 9" $990 0

$9 "$ 3 "-3 & -$$? " -? 3 % $ 9 "" 3 0$99 9 00? 0

9 0 & ! - $9 9 0"9" 09-"9 ""9 $-?$ 0$99 30

0?"$0

9 00?& !

- " 9 0

- 3

0"9"$$?"$- " 0 33? ""

3 9"& 8 " A"$ % 0

""0?"9 0"9"09-"9 ""9 $ -0$" 0"9"$$?0%9 $%? 9 0

-? % "-0$ $9 "4 $&8 9? " -"-0$$? 3 $? A" $ 3 $ 0 00?0

9 "4 $&/ 0% 9"

" " 9 / 99 0? !" " 0% $$ 3%3 < 3? " 0 " " 0

9 00? - & 5&/ -?3""- " " $990

" 3 99"%$? "4 $

0"9"$$?"$-$990

%>& 00? 3"%? :$? $3? 9 0 &8 " " 0$993"-0$ 99"% $9 - "$- 0 9 00? 0

% 9 9&8 " " $990

- 3 0"9"$$?0$& AAAA )& / F0"F 9 !"& GA9("?9 F"?9"$ $$"0"

?"3? ?9"9 $? 0" 3? 0?F&F0" %?"-0 %/ --$$? 0- 0 "3" 9"99"$$ &8 " "$ A0

9-" 3 -39 -$$3%3? & 8 " 0 "3 - " :"$ ""& 3

/ =0"= " "$ A" 0" $ & 8 6- @ %& I& & I

44 2'&!86* !$$ +D* !'5)D* !$$;6 J " % &8 -% 9- "9$ -?: " 0 " &#A" $$0" &8 0 :"$0"

&8- $&8 0 $&8 :?9$ % & G9 - A"& AAAAA &8 "$ $ $ %-0$0 "$$--9 0$? "$ A" 0" & 8 " $990

3:" 3 $9 9 0 0

3$ A"

? " " $ % $$ 9 -- 0$ 00? $ % 399 09$3:"&F &/ 9 0 9$ 3"$?3? "0

" 96 7" %& 0$89 " (%$0 '& G & 0 5 8@ * % 3 % D F1&/ 23'$ 00"-39 " +19 0"9"6$9!" 0"%$? "

9 / 99 0?!"3 % $?F000" F 0$99 < 0$? $990

0 0 0

" -?3$ $99 0"9" 09-"& / 3 % " ? 9 A-0$ " 0

9 00? A"$ % "" 0? " 9 0"9" 09-" 9 "" 9 $ -0$"

0"9"$$? 0% 9 $%? 9 0

-? % "-0$ $9 "4 $& / 3 % - 9$ 9- "

9 / 9 9

0?!"&F > 7 '( )'*(( $# & %&0'A(.2'/%. 27 & ' &2+*',# & %&1&&$ & '&20 ' 1 1& &- 1'

' 1& %'$ $ !"

# &

%&F

4 C+& ; 00 9- "$ 9 " !" #$""

0 " 9 23'$ 0 " $" 0$" " 9 E$ ,$: 0 " "A 9 $ 0"9" 6$9 !"& / E$ "" " --3 33?%9 0"9"6$9!""*1&/ " 23'$ 0 9 % % ""0? 9$ 0 "-9 0"9"6$9!"*1&/ $%00 9-23'$ 0 "9$"0 9$ A" 3$D F&8$30009 9$ A 0 --9 0"9"6$9!"*1&G % "4 $ "<$ "%0

$ A"A"9 "9 0"9" 09-"&8 -#?I$$ %& 7 $$I$$ 7 K!86*1+!$$51D8'6*1+!$$))D*1+!$$ ' *D ) 8 51J (% 2" 9 !$$ 3

$ < 3 %D F!"9 0"9"09-"$?"$ 9 "4 $ % 9 A" 9%9 00?"%3? "&/ " 3? $9 9$&/ 00 9- 9" $ 00? "4 $ 0"A"""" 0% 9G9 &$

$ A"9%9 "4 $ 3? 9 3? " $ 00?- % 9$$ A"9 $ "4 $ 0

9 00?&8 $? A"9 $ 9 $ 00?&F )&87 $%&(32 " :K!86 * $ 1D 8'6 * $ 1 J (% 2" 9

$" % 9 % -3 9 0" %>&6: %&7$ (3K8'6*1)

$ )D5 $;@ )D 8 J,- %& :

K* 5 ' *D 8 +J (

%& K* '15D '/1 8 1J !$ 2 ?!" ? %& 2 2: K!86 *1 )*D '/1D18 *J3 %D

4 F&&&8 " 3$ 9 0"9" 09-"9""9 $9$ 0 0$99: - 0? 9 A" 9 9 9 9 "%?90

9 $< &&&& LLL ; --3 ""

0"$9-9" 9 0"9"09-"

00$3? %$ " & 0880"9" 6$9 !" $ % ""- " " ""-?39" 0"9"$$? " 3 $$&; "" 3 0"9"$$? 9"- -0$? 0 09- ""-$$? %9 < $$$$ " 0 $ %33 3 % 9 & ! $ 9 00?90?-9 " 0 A"9 9 $0 00 < %0 0" 0

9 00?& 8"3 0?"- 9 0"9" 09-" 9 "" 3

9 -0$? A" 9 "- 0?- 9 " -?& / $$ 0? 9 0"9" 09-" % A"" $$ 0 " < %9$$99" "9 0"9"09-"&2? " 9 0"9" 09-" 9 3 $ "" 3 0 "$ " ""A 9 A"" & 8-?3"9 " 9

0"9"09-" 3" 3 - 90$-?" " " 9$$ $ $$ 99 0 " <3-0$- -09 " 0"9"09-"9 ""&/ A"" " " % ?

?" &F +& 82$-%& K!86* 5!$$51D* 5!$$ '

D * 5 !$$ ;6 55J " 9 0"9" 09-" 9 "" 9 $ $ $9 9

4 $%?90

% " $9 "$-

&8 $3? !$$ 3 A" " $$"-0$% 0

&8 9 $ "

? 9 0"9"09-" 0$?"$-0

?9 " 0

" 9 0

& ! " 9 0"9" 09-" 9 "" "$ %? "$ 3 3?0? "-0$ $ " 3$ 9 0 " - 3 % 3? "

9 / 9 9 0? !"& 8 7 %& '$K!86* ) )D* )2'6 1+J % $9 9 0

$9 9 0"9" 09-" 9 ""9$ "A""9 0"9" 09-" 9 " "" " 0

9 00? "4 $ % " 0%9$%?90

&83 7-2:%& -( K!86*

$)J $" -$% "%0

0 9 "" " 3 0"9"$$?9" $9 A""-0$9 "%?"

" :-43 3$%0

"4 $& *& 8, --!$!3$ --%&2 -7- !3$$ 3,-K!86*)1,?

1D*)1,% '1J ,?

3 % $3$? $% 0

9 0"9"09-" "

$?-0$ " 9 0"9" 09-" " 9 A" $ 0"0$9"$ 99 34 " 9 "

9 / 9 9 0?!" "" " $3$?$%0

--$?0 A"9 $$

3?- 9$%? 90

0 0& & 8 9 $ $ $% 3 9 09 ' --

"" *1 &F#-0 00$ *& / $ " !"#$""

00" 9 0"9" 09-" 9 - $$ " 0 - " 23 '$ 0 "" " 3 33? " 9" + 0"9"6$9!"*1 0"%$? " " 9 $9 %$3$ " 3?

4 $$ 0$99 $9 9 0

0 "&

-$ $?$ 0?9 0"9"09-"& 1& #% 9 % " !" #$""

0 9%$ 0$99&8 A0

$? $3? - F 9$F 3- 3 9 %- - 0$ 9" $9 "$- & 8 ? " #A"$ ($"-- '& %& !

6" " & 8 '& 0 +

*$ -9 A0

9$F00 $ 9 ' 9

9" $" 3 % D F1&! 9$ " $9"$-$ $$%?90

9$--%3$00? K !"#$""

'&%&($K!"#$""

'& %& ($J & E 3$ $ - 9$ "$$$ 3$? 0$ %" 8 ,$

-"$ &%&( " 2K5

1)J&893? %- 0$0? 00

9$ $$3 $9 00 $$"$% $ & MAAAA & 8-?3 $"9" 0? < $%? 9 0

9 00?& / 9 0?9$%?90

-0$" 0 " & / 0? 0$ "$ % 3 $%? 9 0

9 00? $ "9" $9 "-0$ $%? 9 --%3$ 00?& / %9 9 !"#$""

K!"#$""

'& %& ($J $ 00$? 0? 9 $%?90

0 " &/ 9 $ 0 9$&F#-0 00$ 1& -$$? ,$: 0 ' 0 7 && $ $ $ 3 " 9 9 00 93"90

" $$ 3:"9 - 99 3%$% " 9 < 9$$"$?& ' 0 9 $ 9 00 % 3 - 3? $ $ 00

" 0? " : " $-0 &8 9 $ "$

48 3 "90? " %9 9 " 0? ? $&/ 3 " 3:"9 3 9- %- -

$ " $9 0? 3 &B > 7.(2.'&2& + (% '&1'& 2%

%2.& 2&&(.$$ 2 $0'$ 22 %

'&.&'1$+$(

& 2 %

%2.& 2 & &(. $$ 1 ' - ( % 7'% &0' &$ '9 2& &$7 &0+,&, '2 .&( & 0+'$'&'

9 '&$1&+1 '% >> 6'&&-+,'+A '&' $1&2

'&'$&1&A 2. 020 '&1&&- ( ' 2' &$*+% $,0' 1& &' &%%&$1& .

&& ; 2 $+;$,&'&' $&1&A 1$+%.

G'1 0 1&&%$ &

/'& $,&0'20' ; 2'&.+ (A 4 6'9 (-&&$$, 12'.& & % 2 9 %

6' .%(0 12 ' &2& & &+$&+& 44 7 '& ( '(' ' A(. $ % +, $&

$2%+ 12'A(.2'DE+$/%. 2 7 & ' & 2 $ !"

# & %& & '( ) '*(( $# & %&0'& A(.1$+&%%$

&+$ 4 H'

$ ( '(' ' 1'

' 1& $, ..0 '

+'&,% +$221&.&+,' :$&, '9 +,

&$$,&%%& (&( (% & +;$,. (&%%$

& & '02 $ (+A

4 &'$&, (''& ( '+A

2'&7 & .& 2 (& '& ' 1'

' 1& %& 4>4 4 .& 9 $$&, 7 12'&2&2& &

.& 0'% %

&$$16'&48 *9%&+, ' 2 *$ $ ( / :

0 /%& & 6' 9 %

&$$1&%2&A(.+ & '&'% 2' %%,'%

%$& 22 '$1 '

&% 2.'2.&, (&%%$

& 0 2&,0'&$$&$& %2 - .

$','&,*!+',/012/1/3 (&( Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes/No H''%&+$ I"3