← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4188/2008allowed

Ajay Kumar v. Rishalo Devi And ORS.

2018-09-18Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry12 pages

  

      

 

 !"#$ %%&&  '$" (&) ($ %  



 

 !"#$ %%&&  '$" *+ ,( ($ %        

 -$ 

$(& $. /$)+( $'0$  /) $(%%&&  $0( !"#$1&/) $($%   

 

3(",# (&&% +%%&4$ ,



5 / 

(4

& $($ , $* 64&("%$#7"$$# () $$

3(%$)%$ ($$$"

$ 

  

       



              

       

                   





  

 

    



    

!   



    "   

       





  #   

 

 

   



$  %

 



$ 

%

   

  

  

& &(",(/%$(* 64&"48" 7 " 9 (

("%$#7"$ (  '"!"  () *+, -   "   ./01(1*$023 $# , (8" &+

 $  $%& ( %%& (*,(7"$/  %%&$,)$ 4    (-"

47"$/ (+)$/(7"$+"&#% +$8" ) +((( * 64&"%$#7"$($# (#$40 :$ &&/# +"&4$8"$4  .+ +## $ &&(%$(&, *(+  #& 7( #$# 0"$%& 



7)&"

++ ,$  #$+($     $  ,$  ,$      7(  #   0"$/  (  %& 

;"  ($  $,$  ,      <

 )  ,     <=/ <>  <   ,?,  ,($ $%$%$  )"$

(  +($,$,$   7(3( $  (,  +# ($) "$$4  $ ,   ,(#"

@ </@  @ @ 3(  %& 

#   0"$  &    "  $ &$  

<

>

(&& , ,(,  (,$"

("(, , ;"4  $" (($( /   ("5# 4 ,   (,(# 0"$&&,() %( !"&% ,(+(+,$,$  #$ $

$,$% +;"4 ($ = @

3("+ &4 # 0"$($",((!"&%/+(  +%4 ($ A$ $&7"$ $%%$ ,() (&(( ;" (, %$) (%& 

# 0"$( #$4&  && ) %$)((, +$$"& $"3($&)   , ($&7"$ ($,$/$"

$ 00       4.   

  )   

    )#05    

 

6 )06 ) #  )7 

  



8,)# 

   

   



# 4007 

.009:/ 

 

8"  

  021099. 

            





   

   

 

40:10:: 

.009:/ 

  

          

       

   

   

 

  

     

 

   

    

 

  



    

  ) ,8       

 

 

 

) 



 

   )#05   

   8"   

  

 

    & *+)$/&$ $&7"$(&( ()&" %$%$  (  4  #  /  ($ $/  "(  ,     +$  & $   ( /

4"  *+)$/(" &4 # 0"$+#5# 4 (# 0"$("$ ,%    ("   !"#$% +#%&&,&($ A$ $&7"$(+)$/+(&# ,("(&(   ( /(, +$;"/$,$B&&+& ;"4 # 0"$  )"$ (  /($ $/(   4#+ $ ( ;" (B&&  4 (B&& 5# 4 ((   ( $"& & %$  "  $  &$  (&& , ,  (  %    

= @

$,$B&&;"4 # 0"$ )"$

 !"#$/($%

=

5 ( $" &4 (   (%& 

 7)&"

@" ( &$ 7"$ %$"(&(($,$% 

= @

$,$B&&

=

$ )&"#   /($ $/ 4  , (%& 

   (%$)"" 9 (#/(%%& ( $"#"% $($ , C) (%%& & ( "(4 

@ ( $"/(:$%%&&7"$$)$(  , (&$ $&7"$+(&"%(& ,(  $" ;"  $,$ (, ()4 %$)/4"$)$(  ,

($&7"$(,  )& "

 ( (($+&  $  #    3("/  (  "  &  4  #   0"$   #3((+(+%%&+$%$ $$ / 

(%%& 

#"% $ &($ , (7"$ #(%%&*+)$/* 64&("%$#7"$)$$

$# (40(7"$ A$ "

& $(%%&& (%$%( &&+ , "4 &8"  &+ ( * # 

 

 ;   

 

   

          #  



 

 ;  # "

   

   < (

* # 

         

;#   

     

  

  ;  



   < (

* =

   

  

    

         

   

   



     

  



   

  

 

     



   





  

< ( * =  

 

 







    



= 

 

 



      

   







< (* #  !    

 

 

      

        <& 3(7"$(($(&$ "

& $(%$ & ,( +(($4& , ($",((",# %4 4((7"$4&+ ($$ 3(,   

(3$ $ -$%$ /

($  $4$ $$D(

E+($#

$ +(((, 4

(4 %$)  < 

9(%$)  (

$;$"

$     



 >?

>            

   

 



  

  

 

  



 

   

     

     

@$  

     



                

 

    

    

A  "

    

       

 

   

    

   

 A  "

  

           

       

   

 



 $

 

       

> 

& A$  $7"

&%%$ , $(%%&&  4(( %%&("4#((;" (,  $,$ B&& (#  <

 )"$    ( $ "     $$   /  ($ $/  &4&    4      *  "$($ "4#((, +$$"& $"* "$($"4#( (,  #%&($ ) ((4 %4 $ 4(&  * "$($"4#( "$&($/) 

4  % /(4 , $!"&% ,($ +$ #%$)& && $&( (  * "$($"4#( # 0"$+%$ ,"&&4&++ /($ $/(   ;$($"

"

&"   )$(4& 0("#4#$0%%$ $,$,  $,$B&&B(&$," ,

/(("4#($,$% "& 4      (  %%&      

 

  )&)  &&+ , "4 &8" &+ (

* % 

 % )

    '00  

% )



$  01  %  8   % 

    



 

  

  %& (($( /&$ "

& $($%  ( "4#( ($ "$$   ,(

(%& 

# 0"$ &%$)(,  <

+$$"& $"/( $# + $ /($ $/("& % %$%$  )"$ ($&&,%  * "$($"4#

($#  % ( 4 %$) (% + & +()+,$4(%$%$  # 0"$ 3(7"$(, ($",(($,$,  $#( $$+(((&% (&$ "

& $(%$5%%$ ( &  $(%"$% $# ,(#%" % 4&/)&" %$%$ (4 #  ($+, ;"4 #  0"$ )"$    ( $"* /( & ,$"



+((($&7"$((, , ($$ :$   (&$ "

&((;" ,  $,$B&& (##"

 $  "4  $3($",((, /(%$%$ + ##& $ $$/(+)$/ $40"%/(B&&+&;"  $,$/(& (+(# 0"$+ ,)( %$%$  )"$ (  * /($  $ $,$($,"# ((, 4 ,4 $"/ 4((7"$() "

((%& 

( && )  :$"4%$)4  $ 4&"45 (%$ /( ) &4 (%& 

 %$) $" $,$(, 4 , #%&/# 4 ( %$"&$ $# %  (, (4 %$$43(,  ($",(($$,$"#  (%$  (4  $, /%$%$ (4 #" )"$ (  3(   () )$0  ((,  %4&5 ( $"# /(%  (,  4

$$ $#&&(  3(, +;" ( $

##&  (;"

(, /(%$%$ +$ $$ ($) "$$ )"$ (   &&/(  () )$#%&& $ ;%$& ((  %(,  ;  $,"#     (  &$    $  7"

&  (  #  0"$, (%$%$  $&)$($( (& $&)/&+(" "4 3(,   $"# ($",( +(( $$ $(%$%$  )"$  5  $ ( $  #"4&& $&5% "% (+(

( $ ;$,"#  (&$ "

&(# 0"$+ %$  ,"&&4& ++  /($ $/(   ;$($ "

"

&" /& () "4 4" )  (

(4 &A(#A&/($("4  ( $

> ("$)) (+$&&&&  $  $5( "$($#

)   (  +(  (  ,     +$  ;"/  ($  4$($  + #% ,(# +&" +$(8"  &+%$%4 (&$  "

& $(%%&&  $% ( $8" /+&&&(( 3# ?B&& & %$ $(( (3$$C;"  3($

4 "44"(# B($,$8"  </# 4 ((   $ &0&$ )%& (+$ # / (+)$/"(%&

4$$")(($5 %$ /(   ("4 0 ,%&((, 

()4 ;"*+)$/ (&$ )/(  "$($0 %& () ,%$ &4 +  )$% * /

"

 ($%& () ,4#+ $4 +  )$% /

$ 0 (4 ,  ,)$& 

 $,$8" /# 4 (4((7"$ ()(&((, ()4 )&& ;" %$)4 $ (7"$A$ $&7"$+&&:$%%&&7"$()  (($4+&&( ,+  (, /(4

;# %$)(";" (, 3(#"

($

$ & $,)$ "  3(#" $   &  $ &%"$%  $"% ,($$3( "#  & , +(((4 %$) & F" @8"  (&$ "

& $ (  %%&&   "&    4&(  $  %   "    %$)$    ( ",# %4 4((7"$4&+ ( %%&/(8"  &++((+ $# +(&# ,(%%&/()4 ;$4)5%%$  $# ($ ,   = (* "%     /

@=($  $4$ $$D( @=E(($,$ % (%$"#% ((% (4 #

$ +((%$)  (# 0"$+( &(

$"/(&& ,(, /#(;" (%

 &%  && "$($/ "$&#($  ($

 ()%%$ )  ( %4"()&% B   /B$$(&4 ;# +((%

  ((% ++$ 4 (# ( $" ,) 4 A # 0"$($++ ()4 ;# +(()& ((% (0 %&* /($ ,) 4 ( &$ 7"$4&+$ ,()&% (,$"

((      ( @=/() 4 #%&+($ ($# % ( 4 %$)/$ )&3(:$ %%&&7"$(+$ ,& (&(  %$)( (    #   0"$/    (  %$ $#  ($  &  $/  ($ $/ %  %$)/&$$ " %$( @=/ %$"&$ $# % (4

%$$43(%  4 #%& 4 %" ,(& (&%

% ,%$ 4 ( "$&%$ A$ :$%%&&7"$(

% "(+((     ( @=/

 "& && (%$    ( @=$ "

$       

            

  

  

   

 B@ ( *

          

 

    C      C  C    (   

      

 * 

 D (

*

           

 

   C   (    

    

 *    D (

*

  

 

         @ 

 



 

D ( *

   

 

        @

 



 

D (*     

  



  D ( *  

    

"

     

 

 



                 



    "      

     '



    

  

 &  )+    (   $  " / (  8"     &+

$# 

/$ +$ )"$ (%%&&  * /      

/    #  +($   

&&+ &&(#&& "%%& / /$% /

)+ (4)",# 

 !





'   "#$%#$&'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$01 $'./ "#$%#$&&$(/&%)23$1 $'./