High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19699/2018dismissed

Ami Chand Sihag v. Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd And ORS

2018-09-11Mr. Justice Amit Rawal9 pages

!" "#$%$&'

($) &*$) + "!$!$&", -%

.%)$& ,/ & $01$-$!, &$+ (2!* &*!)",% "%3&*"&!% 4'5 24664 4'5 24664 4'5 24664 4'5 24664 ,"%"&!' 4,7%)$167( ,-",( 8*9# !"8

,!)"3"!$!$&", 6648 6648 6648 6648 )"3"!$!$&",) %#) 11"&+"*!)"07*+("&! &**"#,""3 %%"* :/!)"3"#$ 17,!8$,% * !"*;;

:/<)$#)!)"%7$! $1"*:/)$( < %*$%($%%"* & :,$"

8 !)" 3"!$!$&", $1"* %7$! , *"#1 , !$& !) ! !)" #)"#.$&+ ,"3,! = 8 . >; * !"*

3,"3 ,"* :/ !)"

$#$ 1% !)","%3&*"&!% &*("(% ?

? = &* ?

* !"*

3",! $&$&+ ! !)" "1"#!,$#$!/ #&&"#!$& :" ,$&+ @=?

= ,"$11"+ 1 &* ,:$!, ,/ &* ," 1$ :1"!:"%"! %$*" &* 1% , #&%"A7"&!$ 1 ,"1$"

3",( &"&! $&07&#!$& ,"%!, $&$&+ !)" ,"%3&*"&!% ,("

"#!$&+,"#9",/ & (7&! @8 =? %1%%! $+ ( &* %7(

? % #(37&*$&+ "" ,( !)" 3"!$!$&",% $11"+ 11/ &* ,#$:1/ & %),!8 <$ " !)" 3"!$!$&", / < &!$ 37,#) %"* )7%" :" ,$&+@ %$!7 !"* !"#!,

8 ,!8 8$,% ,( +%$,$&+) 9$*","+$%!","*% 1"*""*

@* !"*

1&+<$!) :9"% $*

"1"#!,$#$!/ #&&"#!$& <)$#) < % $& !)" & (" +%$, $&+) )" &"< ##7&! &7(:", !)" "1"#!,$#$!/ #&&"#!$& !)" 3"!$!$&", $%

)" 3"!$!$&", ,"#"$9"* 1 %! :$11 #&%7(3!$& #) ,+"% "1"#!,$#$!/* !"*>

= ,!)"3",$* ,( ;

=!;

=<$!) 1* ," *$&+ % @;> @ &* &"< ," *$&+ % @;> @ $" , > 7&$!% :7! !)" ,"%3&*"&!%#1 $("*#&%7(3!$&#) ,+"% ,(!)"3"!$!$&", ,= 7&$!% !!)"!7&" >8@?)"3"!$!$&",) * 11"+"*1/&"9",,"#"$9"*%7#) & "B,:$! &!:$11 !",!)"37,#) %" !)")7%"8!)","

,"8)"9$%$!"*!)"

$#" !)","%3&*"&!% &*< %!1*!) !!)"("!",) *:"#("*" "#!$9" &*!)" 3"!$!$&",3 $* %7( =

?!< ,*%!)"% $*:$11 &*1*+"* #(31 $&! :7!!)","31 #"("&! *"

"#!$9"("!",:7!!)","%3&*"&!%*$*&!! ." &/ #!$& &*&;

=8!)"3"!$!$&",%"&! &"( $1#(31 $&!!!)" ,"%3&*"&!%:7! & 9 $1" 1%%"&! ,"($&*",&

=:7!& #!$&< %! ."&)"&!)"<$ " !)"3"!$!$&", $1"* & 331$# !$&7&*", "#!$&

!)"2"+ 1",9$#"%7!),$!$"%#!8 ;C ,%),!D!)"#!5E :"

,"!)"",( &"&!2.* 1 !C ,%),!D!)"25E&

=)" ,"%3&*"&!%#) &+"*!)"1**"

"#!$9"("!",&

&*&;

3"!$!$&",< %%",9"*<$!)#)"#.$&+,"3,!* !"*

&*("(%* !"*

$&!$( !$&+)$(!) !!)"3,"($%"%< %$&%3"#!"*:/!)" 7!),$F"* $&%3"#!$&+

$#",&

&**7,$&+!)"$&%3"#!$&!)"/) * 7&*!)" #! !)"

!?7& 7!),$F"* 7%" "1"#!,$#$!/ )" ("!", < % ,"(9"* &* <)$1" #)"#.$&+8 !)" %" 1 < % 7&* $&! #! :7! :*/ < % 7&* ! (3","* :"# 7%"1#.% !)"("!",<",":,."& &* !",3"&$&+!)":*/ ("!",8$!< % 7&*!) !!),""&7(:",% ,"%$%! &#"%<","3,9$*"*:"!<""& ! ! *$%!7,: !)" <,.$&+ !)" ("!", )" %7$! $1"* :/ !)" 3"!$!$&",< %#&!"%!"*:/!)","%3&*"&!%:/ $1$&+!)"$,,"31/$&<)$#)$! < % 9",,"*!) !!)""1"#!,$##&&"#!$&@=?

= < %$&!)"& ("

> +%$,$&+)!< %*"&$"*!) !:$11* !"*>

=< %%",9"*<$!)!)"1* ," *$&+@;> @ &*&"<," *$&+@;> @, !)",!)"1* &*&"<," *$&+<"," @;> @ %!)"("!",< %*" *%$&#"9"(:",8

@ &*!)"," *$&+ ("!",< %%! :1" !@;> @ &*!)"#&%7(3!$&#) ,+"%<"," %%"%%"*&!)" 9", +": %$% %3",!)",71"% !)","%3&*"&!%!< % *($!!"*!) !!)" ("!",< %,"31 #"*&

<)"&!)"

$#$ 1% !)","%3&*"&!%9$%$!"* !)"3,"($%"% !)"3"!$!$&", ,,"31 #"("&! !)"1**"

"#!$9"("!",8!)" ("!",< %,"(9"* &*3 #."*$& # ,*: ,*<$!)%$+& !7," #&%7(", &*#)"#.$&+!" ( &* &"<("!",:" ,$&+

@ < %$&%! 11"* &* !)"1*("!",< %%"&!!4G2 :8$,% ,#)"#.$&+!< % 1% 9",,"* !) !!)"3"!$!$&",< %3,"%"&! !!)"%3! &*< % %."*!%$+&!)"#)"#.$&+ ,"3,!:7!)","

7%"*!%$+&!)"% (")"3"!$!$&",< % 1% %."*!:" 3,"%"&!*7,$&+!"%!$&+ !)"("!",$&!)"1 :)"%& !)"3"!$!$&",< % 3,"%"&!$&!)"4G2 :8$,% !< %:%",9"*:/!)"

$#",% !)"4G 1 :!) !:*/ !)"("!",< %! (3","* %$!%1#.%<",":,."&!< % 1% 7&*!) !!),""&7(:",,"%$%! &#"% ,"3,9$*"*:"!<""&! ! *$%!7,:!)"<,.$&+ !)"("!", &!)"%"31" *$&+%8!)"$%%7"%<"," , ("*:/!)",$ 17,! $&<)$#)$%%7"< %&(",$!%&<)$#):!)!)"3 ,!$"%1"*!)"$,, 1 % <"11 %*#7("&! ,/"9$*"&#" &* # !"+,$# $&*$&+) %:""&,"#,*"*:/ !)"1" ,&"*!,$ 17,!&$%%7"<)$1"*$%#7%%$&+!)""&!$,""9$*"&#"1"* :/:!)!)"3 ,!$"% &*!)"%7$!< %*$%($%%"* 2" ,&"*#7&%"1 ,!)"3"!$!$&",8<)$1" %% $1$&+!)"07*+("&! &**"#,"" !)"3"#$ 17,!8) %%7:($!!"*!) !!)"("!",< %,"(9"* &*3 #."*$&)$%3,"%"&#" !!)"!$("$!< %%"&!!4G2 : ,$&%3"#!$& <)$#)$%#&!, ,/!,"#,*:"# 7%"$!) %:""&%3"#$ $# 11/("&!$&"*$&!)" #)"#.$&+,"3,!!) !!)"3"!$!$&",) %,"

7%"*!%$+&!)"#)"#.$&+,"3,!

@ !)",<$%"8!)"("!",< %#)"#."*$&!)"1 :$&!)"3,"%"&#" !)"%& 3"!$!$&", )" 1" ,&"* 7,! :"1< ) % ,"#,*"* # !"+,$# $&*$&+8 <)$#)$%,"3,*7#"*)","7&*", ,!)"37,3%" ," */,"

","&#"' H )"31 $&!$

($) &*$) +<)$1" 33" ,$&+ % ) % ,"$!", !"* !)" #!% ("&!$&"* $& !)" 31 $&! & !) $& )$%

$* 9$! B? +$9"& :/ )$( $& )$% "B ($& !$&$&#)$"

0"%) ) ,( 8 24 I J ) % 3,9"* !)" # 1#71 !$& B> &* ) % *($!!"* !) ! #.&<1"*+" B < %$%%7"*:/)$%*"3 ,!("&!

-",( 8 B"#7!$9" &+$&"", <)$1" 33" ,$&+ % ) % ,"$!", !"* !)"

#!% ("&!$&"* $& !)" <,$!!"& %! !"("&! & !)$&)$%

$* 9$!B ?+$9"&:/)$( $& )$% "B ($& !$&$&#)$"

7,"&*", 67( ,8 I J &* F$, ) &*8 I >J8<)$1"#,,:, !$&+!)"%! !"("&!

8 ) 9" 1% ,"$!", !"* !)"

#!% ("&!$&"*$&!)"<,$!!"&%! !"("&!& !)$& !)"$,

$* 9$!% B ? &* B >? ,"%3"#!$9"1/ +$9"& :/ !)"( $& !)"$, ,"%3"#!$9""B ($& !$&$&#)$"

)"#.$&+ ,"3,! * !"*

B ?B> %)<% !) ! !)" #&%7(", ,"

7%"*!%$+&!)"% (" &*!)$% #! &*!)"

= #)"#.$&+,"3,!B ?B>) 9":""&*71/ 3,9"* :/ !)" <$!&"%%"% !)" *"

"&* &!% % 3", #)"#.$&+ ,"3,! B ?B>8 1* ("!", < % ,"(9"* &* &"< ("!", < % $&%! 11"*)"*"

"&* &!%+ 9" 1"!!",> * !"*

! / < &!$8!)"<$ " !)"31 $&!$

8 %.$&+)",!#("!4G1 : & ;

4!+"!!)"("!", #)"#."* $& )", 3,"%"&#" )" *"

"&* &!%

7,!)",+ 9" 1"!!", * !"*

! +%$,$&+)8$&<)%"& ("8!)","(9"* ("!", < %8 %.$&+ )$( ! #(" 3,"%"&! $& 4G1 :&

4!+"! !)"("!",#)"#."*$&)$%3,"%"&#"-$*"0$&! #)"#.$&+ ,"3,! B @?B * !"*#

8 !)" ,"(9"* ("!", !)" 31 $&!$

< % #)"#."* &* !)" %" 1% <","

7&* $&! #! :7! :*/ < % 7&* ! (3","* :"# 7%" 1#.% <"," :,."& ! < % 1% : %",9"*$&0$&!#)"#.$&+,"3,!B @?B * !"*

!) ! !)"," < % & &""*! #)"#. !)" ##7, #/ !)" ("!", :"# 7%" :*/ !)" ("!", < % 7&*! (3","* &* !)","

,"8 &/( &$371 !$&#71*) 9":""& *&" ! &/!$(" &* !",3"&$&+!)":*/ !)"("!",8$!< % 7&*!) !!),""&7(:",% ,"%$%! &#"%<","3,9$*"*:"!<""&!

!*$%!7,:!)"<,.$&+ !)"("!",)" % $* 0$&! #)"#.$&+ ,"3,! ) % :""& %$+&"* &* 3,9"* :/ F$, ) &* I >J &* 7,"&*", 67( , I J &* !)" % (" ) % :""&%$+&"*:/($!67( ,8!)"%& 31 $&!$

!) %:""& *($!!"*:/!)"31 $&!$

($ ) &* $) + $& )$% #,%%"B ($& !$& !) ! 7&*", "#!$&

2"+ 1 ",9$#"% 7!),$!/ #!8 & 331$# !$& < % +$9"& :/ )$( :"

," ",( &"&! 2. * 1 ! &* !) ! !)" *"

"&* &!% ) * 33" ,"* !)"," &* ) *

$1"* <,$!!"& %! !"("&! )$% <$!&"%% + $& % $* !) ! !)" 331$# !$& < % +$9"& :/ )$% <$ " / < &!$8 <) $% !)" <&", !)" )7%" )$% <$!&"%% ) % *($!!"* $& )$% #,%%"B ($& !$& !) ! $& !) ! 9",/ 331$# !$&8 !)" *"

"&* &!% ) * +$9"& & 331$# !$&!!)"",( &"&!2.* 1 !!) ! !)"/ < &!"* ! +"! !)" ("!", #)"#."* ,( !)"1 :, !,/ &*!) !,*",:"+$9"&!!)" 31 $&!$

!:"3,"%"&!<)$1"#)"#.$&+ ("!",)$%<$!&"%%) % 7,!)",%! !"*$&)$% #,%%"B ($& !$& !) ! )" *$* &! 33" , ! !)"!$(" #)"#.$&+)"31 $&!$

*($!!"* $& )$% #,%%"B ($& !$& !) ! )$% %& ($! 67( ,) * 33" ,"**7,$&+!)"#)"#.$&+ !)"("!", &*!)$%<$!&"%%) % *($!!"*!)"

; %$+& !7," )$%%&($!67( ,&!)"0$&! #)"#.$&+,"3,!B @?B :0"#!$& &/.$&*< %, $%"* !!) !!$(":/($! 67( ,8 !)" %& !)" 31 $&!$

/ < &!$ )","

,"8 & !)" : %$% # 1#71 !$& B ;8 ("( ?

? = * !"*

B =?B < % $%%7"* :/!)"*"

"&* &!% %,*", %%"%%("&!:/ 1$#"&%"" !)"

! 7&*", "#!$& >= !)" 1"#!,$#$!/ #!8

> &* ("( ?

* !"*

?B < % $%%7"* :/ !)" *"

"&* &!% % &!$#" ! #&%7(", :/ 1$#"&%"" , #(37&*$&+ !)"

"&#" !)"

! "1"#!,$#$!/7&*","#!$&%>= &*= 1"#!,$#$!/#!8

>)","

,"8$!*"%&! 1$"$&!)"(7!) !)"31 $&!$

!% /!) !!)" ("!", B < % &! !)" % (" <)$#) < % ,"(9"*&

<)$#)) %:""&*71/ 3 #."* & !)" %3! :/ 7,"&*", 67( , I J2" ,&"*#7&%"1 ,!)"31 $&!$

) % ,"1$"* 73& !)" 1 < 1 $* *<& $& ,: &% $&+) -",%7% 7&0 : ! !" <", ,3, !$& 2$($!"* &* !)",%

; I@J 2 <", 1*IGJ> <)","$&$!) %:""& :%",9"* :/ !)" &5:1" 7&0 : &* ,/ & $+) 7,! !) ! 3,"%"&#"

#&%7(", $% ,"A7$,"* ! !)" !$(" ("!", $% ,"(9"* &*%7#)("!",%) 11:"3 #."* &* %" 1"* $& !)" 3,"%"&#" #&%7(", ,

7,!)", #)"#.$&+$&4 1 :%& !)"3,"%"&! # %"8 ! !)" !$(" #)"#.$&+8 !)" 31 $&!$

7%"* ! %$+& !)" #)"#.$&+ ,"3,! B ?B> &* !!)"!$(" #)"#.$&+ !)" ("!",8 !)" %& !)" 31 $&!$

< % 3,"%"&! )","

,"8 !)" ,"A7$,"("&!% ,: &% $&+)5% # %" I%73, J ) 9" :""&

$11"* :/ !)" *"

"&* &!% 7,!)",8 !)" )7%"8$&<)$#)8!)"("!",< %$&%! 11"*8$%$& !)" & (" / < &!$8 !)" <$ " !)" 31 $&!$

<) $1"* & 331#$!$& :"

," ",( &"&! 2. * 1 ! )" "1"#!,$#$!/ #&&"#!$& $% $& !)" & (" +%$, $&+)8

,( <)(8 !)" )7%" < % 37,#) %"* :/

/ < &!$ )" 3,"%"&! %7$! ) % :""& $1"* :/ ($ ) &* $) +8 !)" )7%: &*

/ < &!$ &* !)"$, %& ($! 67( , < % 3,"%"&! !!)"!$(" #)"#.$&+ !)"("!", $&4G1 : )" 31 $&!$

) % ($%", :1/ $1"* ! 3,9" !) ! !)" $(37+&"* &!$#"% B =?B &*B

?B &*#)"#.$&+ ,"3,! B ?B> ," <,&+8 $11"+ 18 &711 &* 9$* &* ," 1$ :1" ! :" %"! %$*"

<)"," % !)" *"

"&* &!% ) 9"

711/ "%! :1$%)"*!)"$,# %":/1" *$&+, 1 %<"11 %*#7("&! ,/"9$*"&#"!$% %"!!1"*1 < !) ! , 1 "9$*"&#" $% "B#17*"* :/ *#7("&! ,/ "9$*"&#" $" <)"& !)"," $% *#7("&! ,/ "9$*"&#" & ,"#,*8 !)"& , 1 "9$*"&#" ) % & 9 17" ##,*$&+1/8 $%%7" $% *"#$*"* + $&%! !)" 31 $&!$

&* $&

97, !)"*"

"&* &!%K &9$"< ,"% $*8*&! $&* &/," %&!$&!", ","$& !)$%3"!$!$& &*!)"% ("$%)",":/*$%($%%"*!)7+)<$!)7! &/,*", %! #%!% I664J I664J I664J I664J

)"!)",%3" .$&+?," %&"* '

"%? )"!)","3,! :1" '

"%?