Bishan Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others




   
  

 !""#$%$&'(

$%) &*$&+)!)",% -- "!$!$&",% .",%/% *! !" /&0 1 &2!)",% -- "%3&2"&!%  4 

"5 0!)",% -- "!$!$&",% .",%/% *! !" /&0 1 &2!)",% -- "%3&2"&!% 6 (

7 ,0""!*$&+)!)",% -- "!$!$&",% .",%/% *! !" /&0 1 &2!)",% -- "%3&2"&!%
 


     

,"%"&!'-

, 8+, 925# !",!)"3"!$!$&",% :::

      )$%,2",%) ;;2$%3%" $%) & *$&+)!)",%.%*! !" /&0 1!)",%9 4  "5

0!)",%.%*! !" /&0 1!)",% &2 (

7 ,0""!*$&+)!)",%.%*! !" /&0 1 &2!)",% %$2"&!$# ;$%%/"

$%$&5;5"2$&!)"%"!),""<,$!3"!$!$&% %  3",  5",7"&!%  &  ,"#,2  !)"  3"!$!$&",%  $&  !)"%"  !),"" 3"!$!$&%<","$&$!$ ;;="&+ +"2&<,>#) ,+"1 %$% %";2 ,%<$!)!)"

&0""!* + , 7 ,0"#!&2$","&!2 !"%1"!<""&!)"=" ,%(?! (?

 /&%";  %/17$!%  !) !  !)"  <,>$&+  #&2$!$&%  1"$&+  , !)", )%!$;" &2!)"3"!$!$&",% % ;%!)","73;=""%%$7$; ,;=%$!/ !"21"$&+ ,#"2!<,>$&) @ ,2/% &22$$#/;!#&2$!$&%9%3"#$ ;$&#,"7"&!%

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

$&*D $5$;6  2"#$2"2&A  &&"C/," -( /,!)",#&!"&2"2!)  ,2$& !"

-6- "&#)    !)$%  /,!  $&    4((    4  &2  !)",  #&&"#!"2 3"!$!$&%2"#$2"2&?A &&"C/," -) %$%%/"22$,"#!$&%1= ;;<$&+!)"0/2+"7"&!% !&&"C/,"% -? &2 -(93 %%"21=!)"D  "&#) &2!)"&E1;"3"C/,! &2) %! >"& 5$"<!) !!)"1"&"$!) % !1"+"&", ;$@"2 &2!1",";" %"2$& 5/, ;;"73;=""%9<) ," $2"&!$# ;;=%$!/ !"2
&!)";$+)!!)"%/17$%%$&%, $%"21=#/&%";9
2""7$! 33,3,$ !"!2$%3%"!)"%"!),""3"!$!$&%1=2$,"#!$&+,"%3&2"&!& $"  !)"  )$"  &+$&"",9  &0""!  * + ,   79  *) )3/,  8 &2$9  $%!,$#!

!) &>!!#&%$2",!)"#; $7!)"3"!$!$&",%$&!)";$+)!!)" ,"- &!$#"20/2+"7"&!% &2!! >" $& ;2"#$%$&&!)","3,"%"&! !$&%2 !"2  (A &&"C/," -$& 92 !"2? $&  4     &&"C/,"  -  &2  ,"3,"%"&! !$&  2 !"2 A$& ( &&"C/," -9<$!)$& 3",$2 /,7&!)%,7!)"2 !","#"$3! #",!$$"2#3=!)$%,2",

"!$!$&%2$%3%"2        

;/#>= )"!)",%3" >$&+F," %&"2'

"%F )"!)", "3,! 1;"'

"%F