High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5995/2010allowed

Bhawna Sharma And ORS. v. Ram Davan And ORS.

2019-09-27Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

! "

##$$ % & '"(

'# )

*&$ & +,( ##$$

!" !

- ,( #.

/#$ $,( #.

$2,# ( $"

$ / 3$3 "#$2!& 4 5 $ & 3 4 ".6 4 3

3 . 7'08.

- 09, 43 (42:$! " 2 & 3 / - ', &;4 3

3 . 7'08/89

3 ($ 43 (42 #. <'"( 3$3" 3 # & 4$ 3 , " "

4 $ 23( ; , &;3

=$$&# &+& = "$6'

3 $3 :$! "

$ / 3 &&"4+&

- # !"

$ / 3, "$2, !

!3<

!& +* $" 4 &3 $"#4 3 %. 8 3 # '"(< ,':$/2$< >6 6& 5"#2: & 3($,$"3 "#&' $;

- $3$ # ( :$ ! "

! "< , 42'2,34& $2 < " &3 , (! ",34& 2 <"

!" >! "<" $4 &3$"# 4 3 . '

-? 90 0 8 3 4(

#,$"3"#&' $;

!4$"# &", $ 3 42 5$" - 4&$, 4

- 4&$

6&" "# @&## &$(

$& $, 4 $" # "42- 4&$( - $" 5$" ) . '

-? 90 0 8(## 5& 42 2$3##$# 23 "#&3 #42- 4&$4

$"#4#"#4 "

0 , #. 0(## &3 &$

6( $ &$ # 433 &3 -# (@&;#$&

3$3 (33 &;42 #. < '"(,$"A"75") ;)B, 4 &3&"" # (3#26'CA )

)BD '; *&" # ( 2 & !&## $"&$$2, 3$ $ # (& " CA )D )B !& 4 5 $ ( CA )B? # (2 &&## 3 $" " $ # 6 $3 6' CA )

3 3 )B8 !3,$"4 &3 &""$'"( 3 $($ 4 ; &# : &$ $" #2 # & ! 05

) CA )

6 4&$, #. 3" 'B&4"3(CA 'B?233 ##$#$& $$2"#$42#$$$& $"

7 ( ," 3 $ -3- 4&$&. 4(&$2

& 4&# 3 # $ "## $ ( : - 4&$# & $3 "$# "#&

! DD %$ - # "$( 2 $$4 2# ($(, &# & @& # ( 33& 42 4$&4# # #$ "$ +& # &# ($& & 2,& 3&$2# "23 4&(&$4#& B$$3 ($& ,2 ;4&# # # 44$ & " ,! DD %$ # $ $3$ 6 # ( # "# "## , &+& 2 # # 2 "3 $3$ # (# , 3;$$ 72# $ ## 4 # $ +&3&2## -- 4&$ $&42($ &"4 " "6'

& 6'&4(#($2#& # "$" 2" 6'$3&

2"2 "&# $ -6'43

3 42# , "242 " 6 $2& 3(3#$"; 4& &$# "$, "" "

- " # . 4;

&3" (&$ 42 3$3 (33" 2$ -(3332 &(3", &# $, "$ 34 "3",# & &( -+&3" "$5& 43&# 5($5& - 4&$& " (&$ -- 4&$ $&4(&4 , & #& 42 $ &$ ##$$<& "#2 &$3&$ ( 3(42- 4&$ ""#&3

, 4 ( & (3$# "$&&

& 3$3 (3

> &",( 42- 4&$ &. &4$$3 # . & 42 3$3 (3 3 &; :$! "& +& &&"4

B 3 @&&""##24$$3$

# ( :$ ! ", - 4&$ "4' 9,?3 ;40 2 7 ( , && # # "

6( 3&$$+&3"

D !

$ % &'() * ((42#A5& ,;#3( 3 40 2 , 9E "& 4 && # # 3"$2"; ' 9,F ,DG' ,D?

6 " & 2 &

+ , # # & '((- * ))427H4$!&# "5& & ?94" # $ A# 3 #2 $" "&' 9,?# ",&$#2"& ' 9,A G' ,9?

# 3&$$ +&3"&

+ , # # & &# "&$#$ D &$ 4 ## # 3 "# #24$"&' D,A DG8,D,9?

6 ( & 2 !

$ % & &# ,$" $3"#& ($ ' ,? &$,' 9,? $ &" ' ,?& $A#,$' ,? -$"# "&' 8,D,9F,G8,D,9? -$" &$4 $3 I E# &" "$3 $"#$$&$ $J

"# ,$4$2$$4+ ( $4 # -"&$$4##

) . <!"

9E ) . 0<'2 ( " <E ) . 9<!" >! " "

E 6 " # ?$" $$ 4 ;# # " A # " $J4; # $$2"+ 2

- ,##$$$ 3$2

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#