← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26727/2014dismissed

Birender Singh Hooda v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-01-15Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan3 pages



       

  !"##$%&%'( )  ) %*#'+#*,%'-.+!

// #"%"%'#* 0#*&1& ,"!"#!*2!'!!'".#* // #&3'+#'"&  

      

*#&#'"(/ *,1&.%4!%'5+6$!"#*".#3#"%"%'#*       .#  3#"%"%'#*5  8.  %&  $1**#'"42  &#*6%'-  !&  *"%$14"1*# #6#439#'" %$#*1'+#*".#*"%$14"1*##3!*"9#'"5,"!"#!*2!'!5 .!&%4#+".#%'&"!'"8*%"3#"%"%'3*!2%'-*".#%&&1!'$#!*%" !'+!91&*+%*#$"%'-".#*#&3'+#'"&"-*!'"".%9".#:#'#%" +##9#++!"#3*9"%'"".#3&"&&%&"!'" *;#$" %$#*8#

<#!*'#+$1'&#4*".#3#"%"%'#*.!&:##'.#!*+ ".!&-'#1'$'"*6#*"#+".!"!3*9"%'*+#*8!&%&&1#+ '

58.#*#:2".#3#"%"%'#*8!&3*9"#+!&&&%&"!'" *;#$"

%$#*.#3#"%"%'#*&1:9%""#+!8*%""#'*#=1#&"+!"#+>

$%"%'- .#!4".*#!&'&!'+!&&1$.5*#=1#&"#+*+##*9#'"&1$.:#'#%"0%+# 

53!&&#+:2".#%*#$"*#'#*!45*"%$14"1*#!" &1$.*#=1#&"&1:9%""#+:2".#3#"%"%'#*8!&+#!4"8%".!'+%" 8!&+%*#$"#+".!"".#:#'#%"3*9"%'"".#3#"%"%'#*"".#3&" &&%&"!'" *;#$" %$#*&"!'+&8%".+*!8'!'+.#814+'":#$'&%+#*#+ *3*9"%'*!3#*%+'#2#!*

      !"#  "&"*!'&3%*#&".!"13'!1*".#**#3*#&#'"!"%'.!6%'-:##' 9!+#:2".#3#"%"%'#*+!"#+

@ %'+%$!"%'-".#*#%'".!".%&.#!4".

$'+%"%'  .!+  %93*6#+5  ".#  3#"%"%'#*  8!&  3*9"#+  "  ".#  3&"   &&%&"!'" *;#$" %$#*' >  /A  .##'"%*#$!&#&#"13':#.!4".#3#"%"%'#*%&".!"&%'$# ".#*#&3'+#'"!1".*%"%#&.!6#".#9&#46#&-*!'"#+:#'#%"3*9"%'" ".#3#"%"%'#*"".#3&"&&%&"!'" *;#$" %$#*8%".%'!3#*%+'# 2#!*".#%'%"%!4*+#*3*9"%'5!&&1$.5".#$'+%"%'+##*9#'"!& *#-!*+&$'&%+#*!"%'*3*9"%'*!3#*%+'#2#!*%'".#4%-." 

!"''#?1*# 814+'"!3342!'+814+:# +##9#+".!6#8!%6#+ ,1$.&1:9%&&%'%&8.4429%&34!$#+!'+%&'"!$$#3"#+:2 ".%&1*" .#*#!*#&3#$%%$%'&"*1$"%'&%&&1#+:2".#,"!"#6"+!"#+

AA!&*#-!*+&+#!4%'-8%".!&%"1!"%'58.#*#%'!'#9342##*-#& ".#:#'#%"3*9"%' '"#*9&&1$.%'&"*1$"%'&513':#'#%" 3*9"%'.!6%'-:##'*#-'#5".##9342##%&'"":#$'&%+#*#+* 3*9"%'*!3#*%+'#2#!*"%&&"*%$"42%'"#*9&".#%'&"*1$"%'& +!"#+

AA5%&&1#+:2".#,"!"#6"".!"".#*+#*+!"#+ 

!"

''#?1*#   8!&  3!&&#+  :2  ".#  %*#$"*  #'#*!45  *"%$14"1*# 8%".+*!8%'-".#*+#*3*9"%'+!"#+

3!&&#+%'!61* ".#3#"%"%'#**".#3&"&&%&"!'" *;#$" %$#*'!$$1'"".#!$"

".!".#.!+ .%9&#4.%& 8'!$$*+'" !$$#3"#+&1$.3*9"%'!4 :#'#%"'&1$.*+#*+!"#+ 

5%".!+:##'$4#!*42&"!"#+".!"".# 3#"%"%'#*814+'":#$'&%+#*#+*3*9"%'"".#3&"&&%&"!'"

*;#$" %$#**!3#*%+'#2#!*,1$.*+#*+!"#+ 

!"

      !"# $ 8!&'#6#*31""$.!44#'-#:2".#3#"%"%'#* #*#42'!$$1'"".#!$"".!"".#*#&3'+#'"!1".*%"%#& .!6#3*9"#+".#3#"%"%'#*!&&&%&"!'" *;#$" %$#*' > %# 3*%*"".#"%9#3#*%+'#2#!*.!6%'-#4!3&#+5'6#&"#+*%-."814+ !$$*1#"".#3#"%"%'#*"$4!%93*9"%'!&&&%&"!'" *;#$" %$#* 8# @

.#:#'#%"3*9"%'-*!'"#+"".#3#"%"%'#*6%+# > !&&&%&"!'" *;#$" %$#*3*%*"4!3&#3#*%+ '#2#!*$!'!":#&":#6%#8#+!&!$'$#&&%'.!6%'-:##'-*!'"#+:2".# #9342#**%-."&".#*#*9$!'3&&%:4248%'!61*".#3#"%"%'#*5 "'8&##B!'"#+!"#+3*9"%'"".#3&"%'=1#&"%'8#

4!%9*!%&#+%'".#%'&"!'"3#"%"%'&##B%'-+##9#++!"# 3*9"%'!&&&%&"!'" *;#$" %$#*8#

%&1'+":# 8%".1"9#*%"!'+".#&!9#%&5!$$*+%'-425+%&9%&&#+

#"%"%'+%&9%&&#+ !     #  %&'%()*+ * 41$B2