High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19877/2021disposed of

Baldev Raj And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others

2022-10-27Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill,Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger11 pages

!"#!$%&%"'(

)* +

*!,&-& + +

( /)

+. +)+)) /)

. + +

# !$ !

% " & '

"( ) **** )+))0. "

, " + "

" ! - & "

+"! "!

+."

/!01 "2

+ !

+++" ! +!!+"! "!"

3 + "" %456

0!" % & 2%"" , "%+

%+!" "2 8 "! " +++ 2% ""

! & + !! "" 0

0 " & , " 2 ! !2" "!2!

+ !

""2

" "

"2 "

"2 !+% 4 22++

" !% ! " %"2"- 422%

+ " 2 0

0 " "0)

0 !5 9 4+ % 2 2!$"

:5"" - 422%+%

:5 !% !

2 " - 422 + + " " "2 %

- ;/! ;+ " & 2 &2"8+ "" "!& ;+

% ! 2+"

""2 < < << " << +

+ %

, !2 " "2"2%;/! ;+

""2+% ;/! ;+ ! " 2!=+4!+% +%" "

> " ?

/! 01 !!5 9 3"!$ 2 "=< ! !+

+! ?5

%4!

2 , " " @+ + % !2+ " !

% 2 ! .0

"1 8 2%" + " "!0

7" ""! 7A 7?" ". " (

1 "! 0

B " 3 % 2%"

"2 !+

82 " %0

B" 2%"

+"2 !+

"! !+

, "%" +"! 7A 7? "+!

! "!

77 ?) " 77 BB " , " % !

" " !

)A " 0

6? " 8 2% !2!

!!+ " " +!

% ." 8 " 2"" !++%2" +"%

+++! "

"" 07

" ;/! ;+ & @&4 2" "

+!++5 9 ?

, " + "! %A!2"!

+ ,

++"2

+ ,"2$!"

+!"

8 !25 1 822 + " C! % " "!

, 8

2 " C! 2 "22 " + % 1 :, 2%

+ 1D +! 2 "

+C! !" ":% 1D2 !" 2 $$ 2% % 3 ! % &2 % $ &2 &+ &2 4 &2 !$ 18 !++/:% 2% "" ' & .

/2 %6'"2

+! 1%+ % !2+ + % > 3 +"!++ 07

/C! !%

2 " / !!! "&!%422 2 & & 2 % "" 2 2 ! #2 % + "":

! 0: 6

% % " "" " &!% 422 & 2 !$ " 4!

++5 9 8 2 % 4!

!%%""" "&!% 422 & 2 !$ 0: 6

" 4! 8 !!%4! &2 !+#2% $

%E;(%$ 2

+"2 , +$2 8 $ !2%;/! ;+ %$ , 5+ " .

1 % 22 /5 +" ! " !+ 8?) "

8+ +$ + 2 +"2, !

2 " " 2

= $2 %2 222 % "

+ ".

1! % ! " + !+ %!A <D0

2 %!+! ! "2 /"

+ + " "2 !!+ .1 " " + "

! ! "

" !%

!+2"

$%!+ " D!2

%2 2" .1"

"! "

" " &!+ ! !+ ! 2 % %+ $+ % ! % + !

% ! ! !"" F ! G!2 % 2 !+! "

," "2 %"

" " %

!+!!2 !".

1 "

.1$+" ) "$

!+ !+! , ! 2+!"%+!" 2 , 2 #(;#

0BD422 "! " % ' % H$ >

"-'&!1 #", 2! 3, %!& 24! '" "56!$ %"' " 2! &-77!& %"'&8,!$"99!': %"' 9:! & 2! :-! 3,"6!$ 2& 5!!'#%'1%;!:':%&1%<!1= "5!7%4!'!##!$ "..2 1 8 + " ! ! ! $ 2 " % "2 -! "! " /!5B:0 +"" 0

0 " % & 2 % "" , 5 ( B %"2.

I2 "2I +.1 % ! I %2 +! +++"""!" 4! " #2 % !++ 2%"2I .1 ! % #2 % !

+++ " ""!" , /!" -"!2"!:+% &!%422

> 8/+ !++:22 ! 0: 6

," "!!%%"""

" &!% 422 & 2 "

82 ""2I ! % !

2 " 2 % ! 2 3 "2 I " " ! " % 2%

+++""J! 8"! " ! " 2:! "2I!

2 8 +% ! " !2!

" " " ! " "

-!"!+ " % % " ""

" = + ! &!% 422 & 2 00

!5 9 ,2 "A

43 ( 07A

" 0 " =< !$ K =% =+ 4! !2 % & 2 K % "" ,

))

/! 1 ! .

01 #2 % ! + "2 I2 "! ""2 !"

" "2 " 2+2 " ! " +!%% , +""

+!% 85 2 "! ""

+ 2!+ /2 % " " +%% 8++ 2

!+! 2

,#2%+"2

!2!" +" "! %" "+#2 % "2 +!! % 2 $

#2%! +"2 I2 "! ""2 !"

" "2 " 2+2 " ! " +!%#2% ""

+! % ,

+2!+/2 % " " +% #2% &2

!+ ++! 2

#2 %+"2

!2 !" +"" ! %" "+ #2% "2 +!! %2 $ ,2%2! > - ! " " "" 2 !++2 "2 "$ ,% ! " "+ 22! )

"2 & 2% "" , #

!$!2 C! !

2 2 2 22! )

!5 , + 2" <,

2 " " 2 "2 % % "+ +2

,!"2! ""2<I< <<

2 %6

,2 2"<<" ""2

%"%6 2"?" 65B5

" 2 " 2 " < < ! " ! "2 <I< << " % C!2 " !++ ++ 2 "

5." 422! )

!$ $!/ -! "%$ 2 !+!2 % % $ "522 !?

%+ 2% '+ "!2 "%"!++ ( % 2 " 4! % D!2 " %C!2"2 "

+ " 2" !"! "2I !/! %" %""!2 "

!2"

:5""- 422% 2 " 0)

0 - 422 !2"

:5!%2"

! !2 " C! ""%% 3 + % " 2

(LISA GILL) JUDGE October 27, 2022 (HARSH BUNGER) Rts JUDGE 3 +:H:( 3 H:(