M/S Sanjeev Kumar Goyal Contractor v. State Of Punjab And ORS

I N THE HI GH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDI GARH Ci vi l Wr i t Pet i t i on No. 20747 of 2019 ( O&M) DATE OF DECI SI ON: 19. 08. 2019 M/ s Sanj eev Kumar Goyal Cont r act or .... . Pet i t i oner ver sus St at e of Punj ab and ot her s . . . . . Respondent s CORAM: - HON' BLE MR. JUSTI CE KRI SHNA MURARI , CHI EF JUSTI CE HON' BLE MR. JUSTI CE ARUN PALLI , JUDGE Pr esent :

Shr i Puneet Gupt a, Advocat e f or t he pet i t i oner . .

KRI SHNA MURARI , CHI EF JUSTI CE: ( Or al ) The t echni cal bi d of f er ed by t he pet i t i oner was r ej ect ed by t he Techni cal Eval uat i on Commi t t ee on t he gr ound t hat t he f i r m does not f ul f i l l t he eval uat i on cr i t er i a as per t he not i ce i nvi t i ng t ender s. Admi t t edl y, t her eaf t er t hr ee r epr esent at i ons wer e made agai nst t he sai d deci si on whi ch wer e r ej ect ed. I t i s al so not bei ng di sput ed t hat subsequent l y t he f i nanci al bi ds wer e opened and t he bi d of t he pet i t i oner was hi gher t han t hat of t he t ender er who was L- 1 and was al l ot t ed t he wor k. I n such vi ew of t he mat t er , t he quest i ons bei ng r ai sed ar e onl y of academi c i nt er est and ar e not r equi r ed t o be gone i nt o i n t hi s pet i t i on, whi ch i s vi r t ual l y r ender ed i nf r uct uous and accor di ngl y st ands di smi ssed. ( KRI SHNA MURARI ) CHI EF JUSTI CE ( ARUN PALLI ) JUDGE

19. 08. 2019 par kash NOTE:

Whet her speaki ng/ non- speaki ng: Speaki ng Whet her r epor t abl e: YES/ NO PARKASH CHAND 2019.08.22 11:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

PARKASH CHAND 2019.08.22 11:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document