← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3313/2022dismissed

Sukhdev Singh v. Mulkh Raj

2023-08-10Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal9 pages

      

        !"  # $%&"!'$( )& !*(*(

+!

,, -.%& /0  !,1 "!

*  

 

 

    

 

   





       !    "#     $% $& $ '()%* +, " '

-*./0 +1+, 02 0  0  )3

)3   4 1 +6+ 77 8%8' 9 7:*;  )12+2   < /  = ./"

 '

   *  0  ,0+,<2 7  0 +>,

 +, )3 0  2     $!

$$8 )12+0   

   

2  2  0 02 0    +  )  0 5   ) ,2   ,

 +   2 

+ 

7" 0    ,  +   2

+  #     , 

       

+  2        7  0  2

%

2  2 " 12 $4

$

"7 & = $   ;

7 1? ;

   "    "    7 " 2      3@+( "  A  '(7) *

++, )12 +    2  0   0  0  0   ,    $= $= $ '(7) * # 2 2 ( 2+0

+10 +, )12+'() *   +1

 ,  "

2 < ./

 "     <2 7  ;

1   

   $!

$$8(+,<2

  ;

7 1  2 0     0 12   %

$ $  +, "  " '

 -*./+  0  3 "     12 $4

$ 0 3 " 

  7" +1 2+2+,0 , 2 $% $& $     

=

#

    

A  +2

  5("0 +,+1+, 02   + A +2

 )3  0  +,

20+2   +

C  

  )3 +2

  , 2 70 2   7 0 +2

 



  ,+ 0 ,20 ;  #0 +2

 )12+    2 "  22 ,  +   ,   

  +,)12 +    $4

$  ""7 & = $

+0  0 ,+, )12)+ A  +2 

    0 

+  + 3@+ (  "    +  +>,       A     0 0  0   2  )12+ +2   2   #    12 3@+ 2 "

  !"# $ % !# !&''&()*!

+ ,)!-

((.  # /   "

-0 1

1"2

4!

*!

- -05 &'(..

 2 )*!

+ ,)!-

(6( 0 +044 #

1

1"2

4 *!

- -05   $

1# #&'(7&)*!

+ ,)!-

&78 1*,44,90** !10

0+01 

+ 1,+* 2 0+01&'(:6)*!

+ ,)!-;

788 #,/)+ ! %0 03#&'(:40 %<7==  3 " # - #) #  )41

* )!1 ;

1-#!,)3## !   ,-# ! &'&&( -&8& 1 - +03# 

")03# 1,-# &'(:( -6=> &

#

2,    2  +,        +, ) 0  , 0+, 7 "   12     !

$% $ & #       12    = $ $   7"0    0 2 # "12 $4

$  "7 & = $   . "

   7"0  )12+

+ )12+   A + 3@+(" 2  (7) 0 0 +>,+, ) 3 0  +, )12 +    12 +, " '

 -* ./ %

$ $ "  %$! $ !0  (+,<2 -  )3 ;

7 1  2 0  0  A  

> 0  0  2 > 0 2   3@+(" A 0 )

 3 9&?  @ A   

                     

    





    



        !              

       "# "$ %$%"        &   '

( )( * '+, - 

./ #$0%$"01 

    '

   

     

     

  12'            

 # -# !-# ;,)!- "

4,

$) -0B0 10 44, 03#

50 0,  0-#,)-  ;, 01 !03  -#  $)13+ -  1 - (8('&'&( 1 ;

,!

;,!1C 3

      '

  '14

D

 A 0 ) 43  $

A    0 2  ) #

5



     

       

               

 

'

    

                

         '

         

       2'                 

 

&  '

( )( * '+, -  "# "$ %$%"

./ #$0%$"0  

    



'

  

$

A 0 0  0$= $= $   00  +, 3@+(" A'"* B& = $ ) 

 

 78*28 9      !

   '     

  '   

  

: 



   

   A 

 + +     3@+ (  "        2 

  +  0  0  

 2   + 0   

+   A 0   + 5("+ " 

  )12+    2 20 ,+, ")  <   $& $  +, ") <     ) ;&                   

 <.!'.

 

  5 8

    =!8  >>  

  !/ %"#?"@ $0 %$$A 



     

&             '

      8  '

 %0 $# %$"B '  '9

9 '

 

 5 %?

$% %$%"

5

'

  

8   '

$@ "% %$%"

 &    

       

    5,-  "@ $0 %$$A

'      

 

!

 

  2C

       <    /  $"

"% %$%%            

  5  

A 

++ 3@+(" #      

     )12  + 

        , 2  2 "  , 2

# 0

 0 0  2  "  0   2 "0  

 +  2    ,  , #  %# 01)1

1"2   

-#1

1"2  (..8:>= 3@+( 



0  +   

   "  + 022 ,  ,    #0 



 0

2 2        0+, ,  "   , #  0 #,!

 +!0-  - - ,B% 1,-# ! &'(=& =.:    3@+ (  "     0      0      0    )

 # ;) + ''    

  



  '  

 

   D 

  '

          

)

+    

   C             

  !    

C 

'



)

+ 

 

    



      

) '+E   

'

 

''



   ! 

       

   

     

=  



   

 ''<  

 '' 

)'+9

          

   

       

 



)'

+      

  '      ' 



 



  

    

'

)'

+ '  

 

'!C

     

  



''         

 

)'

+            .         



   '

   '                  

       ;'

4

=                  

 '   ! 

 

   <   %$"$)%+.""#%$"")?+88 ) '

+  @BF    %$"$)"+  88  ) '

+  B#%    %$"$)"+  8   9 C ( @0% 

;   0  +   

 )12+    2 "   "           

    )12  +  0  +  , "  2    #0 2  2 #

,2   2 ,2

C  

   "0  

    

  2 "(2 , $$$$$E) 2 0 

++,  3 "A  "220   0;  2   , #                  2+

 ,E  , 3 "A  "220 ; 0 -,"22./, 2      , 2 2  

++2 " 6+7 - 89:

%!,,);

1,('':&'&=  8!   

 !

G  HG/

  HG/